Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

Schumacher On Sims

136 posts by 32 people · 15 Aug 2001 21:04 UTC - 24 Aug 2001 08:54 UTC

Flame warMichael Schumacher's views on racing sims and F1

David G Fisher posted an interview in which Michael Schumacher said racing games do not teach real driving and defended driver skill in modern F1. Some agreed sims cannot replicate real feel, while others said GPL helped them in karting. The 136-post thread spiralled into arguments over whether Schumacher had a privileged upbringing, Ralf Schumacher versus Montoya, and sniping at Fisher.

real motorsportphysics/realism debate

Automated summary.

David G Fisher 15 Aug 2001 21:04 UTC#167806
For those who go on and on and on and on and on and on about which sim is so realistic compared to all others, here's a little shot of perspective. He also responds to the whiners who say F1 is all technology, and little about the actual drivers. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------ Michael Schumacher's thoughts on how technology has changed the face of F1 racing * Indian Online published the following Q & A with Michael Schumacher. Formula 1 racing is considered by many to be the most thrilling sport in the world. And few drivers have dominated it like Michael Schumacher. Ever since he made his Formula 1 debut in 1991, the German has won a staggering 47 races-a figure exceeded only by Alain Prost. A three-time world champion (he is the defending champion), the 32-year old Schumacher is considered by many to be the greatest driver of his generation and is expected to rewrite most Formula 1 records by the time he calls it a day. Currently with Ferrari, Schumacher talks about the influence technology has had on his profession. Q: Car technology has changed by leaps and bounds since you made your debut in 1991. Many fear that the car has actually become more important than the driver. Would you agree with this? MS: I don't see it that way. An example: If you think back to 1991 and 1992, in 1991 Riccardo Patrese and Nigel Mansell were nearly on the same level. One year later, with more electronics, Mansell was outpacing Patrese. Because he could go more to the limit of his car. I see it like this: You are able to be more constantly at the limit [of the car] with it [better electronics] and you don't have to take care of any power peaks of the engine. It gives us more freedom to drive a bit faster. And the ability to handle the car permanently on the limit is what makes a good driver. Q: What role has technology played in your development as a driver? MS: I am a car mechanic, this is my profession, so I have a kind of basic experience with this [racing car technology]. As concerns the electronics, I don't know all the details, I am not a specialist for sure. And I don't need to be, as we have very good specialists in that field. But I know what electronics can do for me, for my car. I think it is quite important to be able to communicate properly with my engineers, to tell them more than just a "strange feeling" I might have. Q: The accidents in Formula I give the impression that it is a dangerous sport. Would you agree? What are the safety precautions taken by drivers during a race? Do you take any additional precautions? MS: In a way it is a dangerous sport, sure. Namely, in the way that you cannot eliminate all risks to 100 per cent. But we work hard to minimise that percentage. We constantly try to improve safety on and off the tracks. I am one of the directors of the GPDA, the Grand Prix Drivers Association, which permanently is in touch with the FIA to give suggestions for improvement about track layout, special corners, enough room in case of accidents and so on. And we have been very successful in these improvements. As for the drivers themselves, there are no special things beside fireproof clothes, or, maybe, not to risk too much if you don't have to. Q: We always see a crowd of technicians in the pits during a race. How important is their role in the race? MS: Without them none of us could race. It's as simple as this - Formula 1 is a team-sport, even if sometimes people tend to forget this. As a driver you are very much dependant on your team. They have to control everything and, if needed, change something. Q: With the advance of technology, do you think that a day will come when human drivers will be replaced by robots? Will there be a "virtual Michael Schumacher" some day? MS: You have that already in computer games. But in reality, no. No way! I mean, now, with all the electronics you can use, there are people who say monkeys could drive these cars. But believe me: they could not, at least not as fast. Q: Have you played any of the computer games built around Formula 1 racing? How close do they come to the real thing? MS: I have tried a few [computer racing games] and I haven't had any real feedback out of them. They are much too far away from reality. I would even deny you could learn anything from them that has to do with real driving. Their steering is so staccato, and our cars are so sensitive to drive. Not to speak of the g-forces, but also simply the steering-impulses we give. Or the delay when we break. It is very different. Q: Does being techno-savvy help a Formula 1 driver? How do you keep in touch with technological developments in your field? MS: Yes, as I said earlier, it helps a lot to know what is possible or what is going on. You are constantly in contact with the specialists in our team (Ferrari), so you automatically keep in touch with it. Q: Right. Now for the wish list! If you had to make one technological change in Formula 1 racing, what would it be? MS: I would do something very simple: Reduce the aerodynamical grip, increase the mechanical one. That would in my eyes increase the possibility to overtake, and that is something we all would like to see. Q: Finally, you are the current Formula 1 world champion and are considered to be one of the greatest drivers of all time. So, tell us what does it take to succeed in Formula 1? MS: If I really could tell this, everyone could do so. What I want to say with this is that there is no special secret with it, which you can simply follow. I think you need a lot of talent, and a lot of discipline and work ethics to make it. The second part you can influence, the first you cannot.
> Q: Have you played any of the computer games built around Formula 1racing? > How close do they come to the real thing? > > MS: I have tried a few [computer racing games] and I haven't had any real > feedback out of them. They are much too far away from reality. I wouldeven > deny you could learn anything from them that has to do with real driving. > Their steering is so staccato, and our cars are so sensitive to drive. Not > to speak of the g-forces, but also simply the steering-impulses we give.Or > the delay when we break. It is very different. He's spot on without probably haven gone into detail on any real sim but as far as not learning "real" driving. I started with GP1 and am up to GPL and it though me pretty damn good when I came into real racing. :-)
"GraDee" <[email hidden]> writes:
Quoted text (17 lines)> > Q: Have you played any of the computer games built around Formula 1 > racing? > > How close do they come to the real thing? > > > > MS: I have tried a few [computer racing games] and I haven't had any real > > feedback out of them. They are much too far away from reality. I would > even > > deny you could learn anything from them that has to do with real driving. > > Their steering is so staccato, and our cars are so sensitive to drive. Not > > to speak of the g-forces, but also simply the steering-impulses we give. > Or > > the delay when we break. It is very different. > > He's spot on without probably haven gone into detail on any real sim but as > far as not learning "real" driving. > I started with GP1 and am up to GPL and it though me pretty damn good when I > came into real racing. :-)
Yeah, my GPL experience helped me a lot when trying a proper go-kart for the first time (Formula Yamaha 100cc). I did things to save the kart when outbraking myself that I didn't know I had in me, nor the owner :) The throttle response training is also very good, never hammer the foot down. MS talks about staccato steering. Of course a F1 game will not even remotely resemble the real thing when playing on a digital input device, say for a playstation. Are us sim fanatics the only ones using a wheel ? :) Olav
Maybe MS was using his remote control? :) "Olav K. Malmin" wrote: <znipped>
Quoted text (7 lines)| MS talks about staccato steering. Of course a F1 game will not even | remotely resemble the real thing when playing on a digital input | device, say for a playstation. | | Are us sim fanatics the only ones using a wheel ? :) | | Olav
--- Outgoing mail is certified Virus Free. Checked by AVG anti-virus system (http://www.grisoft.com). Version: 6.0.265 / Virus Database: 137 - Release Date: 7/18/2001
Soon F1 racers will have automatic butt wipes in their race cars.. :) "rrevved" wrote: <znipped> | Maybe F1 is just not about *drivers* anymore. --- Outgoing mail is certified Virus Free. Checked by AVG anti-virus system (http://www.grisoft.com). Version: 6.0.265 / Virus Database: 137 - Release Date: 7/18/2001
Thom j. 15 Aug 2001 22:09 UTC#528360
Soon F1 racers will have automatic ***wipes in their race cars.. :) <znipped> | Maybe F1 is just not about *drivers* anymore. --- Outgoing mail is certified Virus Free. Checked by AVG anti-virus system (http://www.grisoft.com Version: 6.0.265 / Virus Database: 137 - Release Date: 7/18/2001
> When we pick the greatest *DRIVERS* of all time, maybe we can't > determine who should represent the current F1 era, with the current > advanced state of technology in F1. Who can tell who's better? I can't. Hey that's easy. Schumi. He's about to beat the WR for GP's won, he'll be a 3 times WC soon with two of these titles achieved in a car that wasn't the fastest. Just remember how Benetton with Schumi usually finished on 1/2/3 and Ferrari on 5/6/7, and when the two teams switched drivers, their race finishing positions were reversed although they were pretty much still the same cars. There can be no doubt - Schumi :-) Achim
"David G Fisher" wrote... > For those who go on and on and on and on and on and on > about which sim is so realistic compared to all others, > here's a little shot of perspective. Sorry to burst your bubble and not meaning any disrespect to the soon to be quadruple (or is it quintuple already?) F1 World Champion,but without knowing which sims he's talking about, under which circumstance and how long he's played them and which equipment he used to do so, his comments are next to worthless. He *is* an F1 driver, for crying out loud!! -Of course he won't relate to a simulation on his first try. His body and mind are expecting G-loads in response to his control actions and are not getting them, alienating him from the experience. It takes time to train the brain into translating the visual and audio cues into (mock) sensations about the simulated car. Otherwise everyone would be able to drive simulated cars more or less competently from the word go. Put any non-simracer in front of your PC and it'll take him 15 minutes to complete a lap at Monza. Couple of seasons ago RTL (German satellite TV station) used to invite ex-GP drivers to watch the GP's along with a moderator and a studio audience, momentarily commenting on events in the live coverage as the race unfolded. At the end of the show they put them in a simulator (F1 chassis mock-up) and had them drive a lap of Hockenheim (using MGPRS2, I think) adding the result to a fastest lap list. Without exception, they embarassed themselves. Why? -Because it takes a lot of practise to perceive the world of the simulator as real, plain and simple. If ex-F1 drivers can't do it, what chance has your cousin got? The sensations derived from a racing simulation have only a cursory relation to what you would be experiencing in a real racing car, absolutely true. I'm not even going to deny that. What matters is they relate to distinct behaviours of the car in the sim, allowing the "driver" to pre-empt what the results of his control inputs will be. That's where immersion, "being there" comes from. When I drive GPL, GPL is "real", when I drive a real car, obviously, reality is "real" eventhough, on the sensory level, these are quite different experiences. I have no trouble switching between these realities and have no real desire to compare them as, to me, perceived realism in racing sims is not about how the sim actually looks, sounds and feels (the brain translates that stuff anyway). No, perceived realism in a sim depicting a given racing series, IMO, is about knowledge and memories of it's actual and similar real life counterparts. I have driven powerfull road cars, I have driven a race prepared Porsche, I have driven rally cars. I've watched and read about an awfull lot of motorracing. I'm also a qualified engineer, with a lifelong interest in physics. I hold I have a pretty good idea of what is possible in a car and what's not (and I do leave a generous margin in this respect to account for my own lack of driving talent). I can also identify an occurance in a sim that is physically impossible when I see one. When I say GPL is more realistic than Rally Championship that's because if I drive a car in GPL over an upset in such a way and at such a speed that, IMO, it shouldn't roll, it doesn't. Whereas in Rally Championship, it does. There is an in-car lap of Nick Heidfeld in the Sauber at Sepang I downloaded from "that F1 video site I can't remember nor find the URL of right now". As I watched it I found myself really agreeing with his approach, so I loaded up GP3 to "try it for myself". Couldn't do it, no matter how many liberties I took with setup and driving model... the car in the simulation simply wouldn't go there. Recently, using F1RC, I can do it with the standard setup. Not as quickly as Nick, of course, but I can drive around the track in the same way (same more less goes for all tracks, but this is a rather poingant example). Therefore, as a simulation, F1RC is more realistic to me than GP3. The behaviour of the cars conforms more to my notion of how these cars *should* behave. If you know what I mean. I'm willing to go along with Shu in as far as we don't have the level of control precision reality has to offer. This, of course, is a nescessary evil... if the controls had quasi infinate precision as they do in real life, there wouldn't be time to calculate the model and present the graphics on-screen. > He also responds to the whiners who say F1 is all technology, > and little about the actual drivers. He doesn't respond to it, he presents the same argument in a different way. <quote> I see it like this: You are able to be more constantly at the limit [of the car] with it [better electronics] and you don't have to take care of any power peaks of the engine. It gives us more freedom to drive a bit faster. </quote> Exactly Michael. However, in the technology whiner's (sic) point of view, the "us" part is the offensive bit. In "our" view, it should only be the Schumachers, Sennas, Prosts and Mansells of this world who are in a position to drive a given car at the very limit consistently. This allows extremely talented driver X in not so performant car A to be competitive with very talented driver Y in very performant car B and we, the viewer, actually get to see some racing. Also, I wonder if his viewpoint would be the same if he found himself in a team on the other side of the technology barrier. Jan. =--- "Pay attention when I'm talking to you boy!" -Foghorn Leghorn.
I don't know how you are able to take a "no" and turn it into a "yes". I hear people say the modern F1 sims are easier to drive, but then you find out their times and it's obvious they aren't pushing the car to it's limit. They are at 98%. That last 2% is where it becomes extremely difficult, and they can't get there because things are moving too fast, and the "edge" is something they can't approach consistently. It's 1000x more difficult in real life. As for the new aids in F1 this year, many drivers have said it's more difficult to drive because they are going even faster. There's an even finer line between being on the limit and completely losing it. By not including Schumacher on the list as one of the greatest drivers, I'm afraid to say that you MUST be living in the past just a little too much. It sure doesn't sound like this guy would describe a modern F1 car as "easy". He compares a FF to a modern F1. Imagine how difficult he would find it to compete in a full F1 race, as opposed to simply testing the car for the sake of fun. From Atlas F1: Question: Is a F1 car similar to FFRenault, etc.? Russ Brooks (Experienced racer who drove the 1991 Ligier): "Actually, that is quite an interesting question. (Thanks JayWay for the prompt, I did mean to answer it!) The answer to your first question is a definite 'No'. The F1 car felt like a totally different beast, Ross. Apart from the obvious power hike - increasing the speeds, the knock-on effects caused by the extra power took me by surprise. I (of course) knew that I had to "feel" my way around the throttle pedal for a while to get used relative speed vs. braking zones, but nothing really prepared me for the "new" driving characteristics that the massive downforce introduced. I had gotten used to throwing the FF cars around with a high degree of accuracy, and with this came a certain complacency. This allowed you to control powerslides and turn in to tight corners earlier "knowing" that the car wasn't going to "answer" your command until 5 metres later - a racing line that became 2nd knowledge as it were. The worst that could happen would be a slight running off of line - which would lose you time but could be corrected by dabbing the throttle and throwing on opposite lock - or if going too fast, just hammering the brakes and finding your way out of the run off area and back onto the track. But with the F1 car this set of rules (understandably) changed quite considerably. First off, the downforce effect was quite breathtaking. It meant that you turn the wheel 5mm into a bend and the car was responding yesterday (lol!) which was quite un-nerving but ultimately providing you with PREDICTABILITY. Something you didn't have in even the best set-up FF cars. Secondly, and as an extension to the above characteristic, it meant apexing was fantastic. Chicanes could be attacked almost with abandon - knowing that the car wouldn't argue with you. The "snap over" g-forces that drivers talk about soon become very apparent. The weight of your crash-lid and head increases to the point that when I achieved my first relatively quick direction snap - I thought my head would leave my body. My shoulders were bruised when I got out the car due to the side-g's, and my knees had taken a battering. So to conclude all the above "handling rules", I would say that you could draw to within a "millimetre" the correct racing line (text-book, you could say) of any circuit, and follow it like a railtrack. Which brings me neatly on to the final major differences. The power increase is so huge, that even with enormous grip any small mistakes would be punished severely. For example, you could be doing 30mph around a slow corner - hard lock, and where as in an FF car you would be used to giving the throttle 50% to pull you out of the corner, in an F1 car (in 1st gear - soon learnt to use 2nd!) 20% throttle for the briefest dab would spin you out of control. This applied to all corners. Even when the downforce effect is working hard around a 130mph bend, the slightest bit of, "whoops, maybe that didn't need full throttle in 4th out of there.." and you were in shit-soup! I had a few scary, "...oh dear, I'm heading into the tyre wall...help me...phew that was close..." moments... The other amazing difference, as I mentioned in the thread, was the brakes. I really couldn't comprehend how late you can brake into a corner without losing control, in an F1 car. If you slammed the middle pedal hard to the floor at top speed in an FF1600 (say 125mph) then you could expect the cars wheels to lock up and obviously, without wheels turning, you have no control over where the car is going. If you left it too late then you went straight on - past the point of no return - only to release the brakes and spin sideways off the circuit. But, and a BIG BUT, you normally at this point had slowed so much that the run-off collected you - or you only nudged the tyre wall. But late in an FF1600 means 250metres from the 1st tight corner at the end of the straight. This even gave you time to correct your line into the corner if you needed to! In an F1 car, you could brake from 190mph+ into a 30mph corner - change from 6th to 2nd - and NOT LOCK UP. All from 100metres or so. No room for, "...Shit!!! Wrong line." You had to get it right, or risk dying horribly in a tyre wall pizza. Quite a frightening learning experience, all in all. Just out of interest, I seem to remember only using full opposite lock to get out of trouble, and this was on the first few laps. After that, if you had to use 'opp. lock' then you had done it wrong! Russ Brooks "rrevved" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > On Wed, 15 Aug 2001 21:04:47 GMT, "David G Fisher" <[email hidden]>wrote: > > >Q: Car technology has changed by leaps and bounds since you made yourdebut > >in 1991. Many fear that the car has actually become more important thanthe > >driver. Would you agree with this? > > > >MS: I don't see it that way. An example: If you think back to 1991 and1992, > >in 1991 Riccardo Patrese and Nigel Mansell were nearly on the same level. > >One year later, with more electronics, Mansell was outpacing Patrese. > >Because he could go more to the limit of his car. I see it like this: You > >are able to be more constantly at the limit [of the car] with it [better > >electronics] and you don't have to take care of any power peaks of the > >engine. It gives us more freedom to drive a bit faster. And the abilityto
Quoted text (9 lines)> >handle the car permanently on the limit is what makes a good driver. > > Great find. > > Regardless of what he meant to say, I think MS just confirmed what > many of us have known for quite a while, that the 'technology' is a > MAJOR portion of a driver's success and perceived 'ability'. > >
"Jan Verschueren" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > "David G Fisher" wrote... > > For those who go on and on and on and on and on and on > > about which sim is so realistic compared to all others, > > here's a little shot of perspective. > > Sorry to burst your bubble and not meaning any disrespect to the soon tobe > quadruple (or is it quintuple already?) F1 World Champion,but without > knowing which sims he's talking about, under which circumstance and howlong > he's played them and which equipment he used to do so, his comments arenext > to worthless > > He *is* an F1 driver, for crying out loud!! -Of course he won't relate toa
Quoted text (7 lines)> simulation on his first try. His body and mind are expecting G-loads in > response to his control actions and are not getting them, alienating him > from the experience. It takes time to train the brain into translating the > visual and audio cues into (mock) sensations about the simulated car. > Otherwise everyone would be able to drive simulated cars more or less > competently from the word go. Put any non-simracer in front of your PC and > it'll take him 15 minutes to complete a lap at Monza.
You don't think that a 32 year old man who had a privileged upbringing in Germany, and loves auto racing, knows what driving sims/games are, and what it would take to evaluate them? I knew these things before I was even that interested in driving sims because they're so obvious. Racing games are hardly recent inventions. > Couple of seasons ago RTL (German satellite TV station) used to inviteex-GP > drivers to watch the GP's along with a moderator and a studio audience, > momentarily commenting on events in the live coverage as the raceunfolded. > At the end of the show they put them in a simulator (F1 chassis mock-up)and > had them drive a lap of Hockenheim (using MGPRS2, I think) adding theresult > to a fastest lap list. Without exception, they embarassed themselves. > Why? -Because it takes a lot of practise to perceive the world of the > simulator as real, plain and simple. If ex-F1 drivers can't do it, what > chance has your cousin got? I've seen kids sit down in front of driving games and drive them with ease, including GPL. Your making the same mistake a lot of adult sim racers make, which is to take these things so seriously that we "talk" ourselves into believing they are more difficult than they really are, sometimes in order to justify our (what many people would call childish) hobby to ourselves and others. All he's saying, is that without the physical effects of driving a race car, most of the simulation is gone. Driving a car (sim or real) isn't that hard. Everybody does it. Simulating a real F1 car without the physical effects is like simulating sex. Will any computer program ever come within a million miles of satisfying you in the same way real sex with Cameron Diaz would? All I'm saying is let's not take this stuff so damn seriously that we actually think we could mimic what we do on screen if we were "just given the chance". Let's not put down real life drivers because we think we know "what it takes". How about not ripping the shit out of one sim, and praising another as if it's our religion? Perspective. > When I say GPL is more realistic than Rally Championship that's becauseif I > drive a car in GPL over an upset in such a way and at such a speed that, > IMO, it shouldn't roll, it doesn't. Whereas in Rally Championship, itdoes. I rarely EVER rolled the cars in RC. It was never an issue with me or many other people who drove RC. Real rally cars actually do roll fairly easily though. You should know that. How do you explain the different experiences that some had? There is only one answer and that is that some people drove them correctly, and kept them on a part of the track which wouldn't cause the car to roll over in real life. Some people drove them at realisitic speeds, while others had no idea what their speed was as they were going around a sharp turn. I saw so many replays of people rolling or crashing their car, and blaming the game. They had no idea how fast they were going, or what they hit. They simply blamed the game. As for GPL, the reason I lost interest in it was because IT did things that the real life footage showed was not accurate. Mainly, the excess sliding and drifting. Good, practiced drivers criss-crossing the driving line all the way around the track. They looked nothing like the AI or the real life footage. > There is an in-car lap of Nick Heidfeld in the Sauber at Sepang Idownloaded > from "that F1 video site I can't remember nor find the URL of right now".As > I watched it I found myself really agreeing with his approach, so I loaded > up GP3 to "try it for myself". Couldn't do it, no matter how manyliberties > I took with setup and driving model... the car in the simulation simply > wouldn't go there. Recently, using F1RC, I can do it with the standard > setup. Not as quickly as Nick, of course, but I can drive around the track > in the same way (same more less goes for all tracks, but this is a rather > poingant example). Therefore, as a simulation, F1RC is more realistic tome > than GP3. The behaviour of the cars conforms more to my notion of howthese > cars *should* behave. If you know what I mean. I'm glad to hear you noticed this about F1RC, but unfortunately, this group which is supposedly the most knowlegeable collection of sim racers on the planet has spent little time discussing F1RC's excellent simulation of an F1 car's behavior, and more time bickering over a bunch of bullshit. > I'm willing to go along with Shu in as far as we don't have the level of > control precision reality has to offer. This, of course, is a nescessary > evil... if the controls had quasi infinate precision as they do in real > life, there wouldn't be time to calculate the model and present thegraphics
Quoted text (7 lines)> on-screen. > > > He also responds to the whiners who say F1 is all technology, > > and little about the actual drivers. > > > He doesn't respond to it, he presents the same argument in a different
way. > > <quote> > I see it like this: You are able to be more constantly at the limit [ofthe
Quoted text (7 lines)> car] with it [better electronics] and you don't have to take care of any > power peaks of the engine. It gives us more freedom to drive a bit faster. > </quote> > > Exactly Michael. However, in the technology whiner's (sic) point of view, > the "us" part is the offensive bit. In "our" view, it should only be the > Schumachers, Sennas, Prosts and Mansells of this world who are in a
position > to drive a given car at the very limit consistently. Without the electronics, no driver would be able to drive those cars near their limit. 18,000rpm. 850 hp. Advances in aerodynamics. Grooved tires. Incredible braking power. Technology has now made a car which outpaces the abilities of a human driver, and that's why the electronic aids exist. I want to see what the cars are truly capable of, and the aids make that possible. There's the limit, and then there's *the limit*. The true limit is still only reached by the best drivers, so nothing has really changed. The driver who reaches that true limit the most consistently, lap after lap and race after race is MS. MS always outperforms his teammates. RS outperforms JPM. MH is still probably a bit faster than DC. Zanardi dominated CART and his teammate, but couldn't do much in F1. Within a team, there is usually one driver who is consistently faster than another. Aids don't prevent that fact from showing through. David G Fisher
Compared to many people in this world who struggle to have enough to eat or a safe place to sleep, he was priveleged. Was his family at least lower middle-class to middle-class before he aerned his first paycheck as an F1 driver? Most kids in that position while growing up in a western country had a lot of access to video games. David G Fisher "rrevved" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > On Thu, 16 Aug 2001 01:05:35 GMT, "David G Fisher" <[email hidden]>wrote: > > >You don't think that a 32 year old man who had a privileged upbringing in > >Germany, and loves auto racing, knows what driving sims/games are, andwhat > >it would take to evaluate them? > > Privileged upbringing? Schumacher's parents owned a Go-Kart track. > >
How stupid of me to make that mistake. Uh, what's the point of listing the best drivers you've seen.......in person? You can see a hell of a lot more on TV than you can at an actual race, or a baseball game, or an NFL game, or......... David G Fisher "rrevved" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > On Wed, 15 Aug 2001 23:11:56 GMT, "David G Fisher" <[email hidden]>wrote: > > > > >By not including Schumacher on the list as one of the greatest drivers,I'm
Quoted text (7 lines)> >afraid to say that you MUST be living in the past just a little too much. > > Settle down David. I listed the drivers I thought were best of > those I had personally WATCHED race. As in --- 'In Person'. > > Sheesh. >
On Thu, 16 Aug 2001 01:05:35 GMT, "David G Fisher" <[email hidden]> wrote: > RS outperforms JPM. You watching the same F1 as me? Scott Johnson "Science suggests that beer and 98 degree heat do not enhance your swimming ability, but I think it's a really, really good idea for people to test that theory as often as possible. What are you, a pussy? You can do it, champ." -- Rev. Syd Midnight
Some facts. RS has out qualified JM in nine of the 12 races, usually by .5 to .9 seconds. In the three races JM qualified higher than RS, he did it by a COMBINED total of two tenths of a second. When it comes to qualifying, it's not even close. RS has three wins, a second, a fourth, and a fifth. JM has two seconds and a fourth. He crashed out of a few races due soley to driver error. RS has no such incidences. When it comes to race results, it's not even close. David G Fisher "Top Sirloin" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]...
Quoted text (14 lines)> On Thu, 16 Aug 2001 01:05:35 GMT, "David G Fisher" > <[email hidden]> wrote: > > > RS outperforms JPM. > > You watching the same F1 as me? > > > Scott Johnson > "Science suggests that beer and 98 degree heat do not enhance your > swimming ability, but I think it's a really, really good idea for > people to test that theory as often as possible. What are you, a > pussy? You can do it, champ." > -- Rev. Syd Midnight
"rrevved" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > On Thu, 16 Aug 2001 01:05:35 GMT, "David G Fisher" <[email hidden]>wrote: > > >You don't think that a 32 year old man who had a privileged upbringing in > >Germany, and loves auto racing, knows what driving sims/games are, andwhat > >it would take to evaluate them? > > Privileged upbringing? Schumacher's parents owned a Go-Kart track. > Good point. IIRC, his dad was actually a bricklayer. Definitely not privileged, more like "humble." They didn't get the go-kart track until the brothers were well into racing. -- Remove "688" to reply.
As I said in the other post, "Compared to many people in this world who struggle to have enough to eat or a safe place to sleep, he was privileged. Was his family at least lower middle-class to middle-class before he aeaned his first paycheck as an F1 driver? Most kids in that position while growing up in a western country had a lot of access to video games." As far as I'm concerned, almost everyone who lives in a Western country in the second half of the 20th century/beginning of the 21st century is "privileged" compared to the rest of the current world, and the 50 billion or so who have walked this planet since the beginning of mankind. Add in the all the other living creatures like cute little bunny rabbits, elephants, ants, and dinasours, and the difficulty of their lives, and I don't think a construction worker in modern day Germany is really that tough a life. That's my personal opinion. I think most people are a bunch of cry baby whiners (doesn't mean they are necessarily bad) and don't have a clue how tough life can really be. Were going off waaaaaaay off on another r.a.s. tangent. The point is, MS had access to video games while growing up. If someone is reading this post and doens't have a clue why we are talking about this "privileged" stuff, you're not alone. David G Fisher David G Fisher "rrevved" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > On Thu, 16 Aug 2001 02:41:00 GMT, "Geoff Crim" <[email hidden]>wrote: > > >"rrevved" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > >news:[email hidden]... > >> On Thu, 16 Aug 2001 01:05:35 GMT, "David G Fisher"<[email hidden]> > >wrote: > >> > >> >You don't think that a 32 year old man who had a privileged upbringingin
Quoted text (9 lines)> >> >Germany, and loves auto racing, knows what driving sims/games are, and > >what > >> >it would take to evaluate them? > >> > >> Privileged upbringing? Schumacher's parents owned a Go-Kart track. > >> > > > >Good point. IIRC, his dad was actually a bricklayer. Definitely not > >privileged, more like "humble." They didn't get the go-kart track until
the > >brothers were well into racing. > > Yep, I remember that now! His father was a construction laborer > of some kind. So much for 'privileged' .. :) >
True. But my money's on JPM winning the driver's title in 2003. Not RS. Rafe Mc On Thu, 16 Aug 2001 02:28:33 GMT, "David G Fisher" <[email hidden]> wrote:
Quoted text (30 lines)>Some facts. > >RS has out qualified JM in nine of the 12 races, usually by .5 to .9 >seconds. In the three races JM qualified higher than RS, he did it by a >COMBINED total of two tenths of a second. When it comes to qualifying, it's >not even close. > >RS has three wins, a second, a fourth, and a fifth. JM has two seconds and a >fourth. He crashed out of a few races due soley to driver error. RS has no >such incidences. When it comes to race results, it's not even close. > >David G Fisher > > >"Top Sirloin" <[email hidden]> wrote in message >news:[email hidden]... >> On Thu, 16 Aug 2001 01:05:35 GMT, "David G Fisher" >> <[email hidden]> wrote: >> >> > RS outperforms JPM. >> >> You watching the same F1 as me? >> >> >> Scott Johnson >> "Science suggests that beer and 98 degree heat do not enhance your >> swimming ability, but I think it's a really, really good idea for >> people to test that theory as often as possible. What are you, a >> pussy? You can do it, champ." >> -- Rev. Syd Midnight
MS: I would do something very simple: Reduce the aerodynamical grip, increase the mechanical one. That would in my eyes increase the possibility to overtake, and that is something we all would like to see. >>>>>>>>YES!! I agree 100%!
"David G Fisher" <[email hidden]> writes: > MS: In a way it is a dangerous sport, sure. Namely, in the way that you > cannot eliminate all risks to 100 per cent. But we work hard to minimise > that percentage. Whoa! Whats next? Oil sprinklers around the track? Rotating knives in the hubs? Rocket launchers on the sidepods? Maybe I should try to get a cable package that includes F1 after all... -- -asbjxrn
In development teams usually use second driver just for testing new ideas. We'll see in the future who is better. "David G Fisher" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:ldGe7.106903$[email hidden]... > Some facts. > > RS has out qualified JM in nine of the 12 races, usually by .5 to .9 > seconds. In the three races JM qualified higher than RS, he did it by a > COMBINED total of two tenths of a second. When it comes to qualifying,it's > not even close. > > RS has three wins, a second, a fourth, and a fifth. JM has two seconds anda > fourth. He crashed out of a few races due soley to driver error. RS has no > such incidences. When it comes to race results, it's not even close. > > David G Fisher
Do you actually think *any* of todays F1 drivers (apart from Jacques that is) would say any thing else ?? -- Does Bernie Ecclestone ring a bell?? If you want an honest oppinion on F1 - go ask someone who *used* to do it. -- ed_ DGF'ed: > For those who go on and on and on and on and on and on about which sim is so > realistic compared to all others, here's a little shot of perspective. He > also responds to the whiners who say F1 is all technology, and little about > the actual drivers.
Touche` ed_ Touche` :) "Ed Solheim" wrote: | Do you actually think *any* of todays F1 drivers (apart from Jacques that | is) would say any thing else ?? -- Does Bernie Ecclestone ring abell?? | | If you want an honest oppinion on F1 - go ask someone who *used* to do it. | | -- | ed_ --- Outgoing mail is certified Virus Free. Checked by AVG anti-virus system (http://www.grisoft.com). Version: 6.0.265 / Virus Database: 137 - Release Date: 7/18/2001
"Asbj�rn Bj�rnstad" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]...
Quoted text (10 lines)> "David G Fisher" <[email hidden]> writes: > > > MS: In a way it is a dangerous sport, sure. Namely, in the way that you > > cannot eliminate all risks to 100 per cent. But we work hard to minimise > > that percentage. > > Whoa! Whats next? Oil sprinklers around the track? Rotating knives in > the hubs? Rocket launchers on the sidepods? > > Maybe I should try to get a cable package that includes F1 after all...
Get it quick. Availability for next year is in question, at least here in the states. Todd > -- > -asbjxrn
David, you are the one that jumped the gun and pounced on the guy. He specifically stated in the original post "that I have ever personally watched were" It stated right up front for you to see.. so if in your words " Uh, what's the point of listing the best drivers you've seen", why did you even comment then? Were you just trolling? "David G Fisher" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:nPFe7.106811$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (11 lines)> How stupid of me to make that mistake. > > Uh, what's the point of listing the best drivers you've seen.......in > person? You can see a hell of a lot more on TV than you can at an actual > race, or a baseball game, or an NFL game, or......... > > David G Fisher > > "rrevved" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:[email hidden]... > > On Wed, 15 Aug 2001 23:11:56 GMT, "David G Fisher"
<[email hidden]> > wrote: > > > > > > > >By not including Schumacher on the list as one of the greatest drivers, > I'm > > >afraid to say that you MUST be living in the past just a little toomuch.
Quoted text (7 lines)> > > > Settle down David. I listed the drivers I thought were best of > > those I had personally WATCHED race. As in --- 'In Person'. > > > > Sheesh. > > >
"David G Fisher" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:ldGe7.106903$[email hidden]... > Some facts. Sorry, but this is USENET. :-) > RS has out qualified JM in nine of the 12 races, usually by .5 to .9 > seconds. In the three races JM qualified higher than RS, he did it by a > COMBINED total of two tenths of a second. When it comes to qualifying, > it's not even close. RS also has the benefit of driving a Williams several years in a row, along with all of the tracks - that JPM has managed to outqualify him despite these advantages show that he's damn fast. They're both so quick it's academic at this point to say which one is faster. _Next year_ (as another poster pointed out) we'll have a better feel as to whom is quicker. > RS has three wins, a second, a fourth, and a fifth. JM has two seconds and >a fourth. He crashed out of a few races due soley to driver error. RS has no > such incidences. When it comes to race results, it's not even close. Race results aren't a fair comparison as JPM has had horrible luck with equipment and other drivers - he only took himself out at Monaco and Canada. JPM could easily have two wins, two seconds, and a fourth at this point. -Scott Johnson Fry Mumia http://www.danielfaulkner.com
Top Sirloin wrote: > > "David G Fisher" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:ldGe7.106903$[email hidden]... > > Some facts. > > Sorry, but this is USENET. :-) LOL! We all know DGF hates JPM because he plays GPL...and that's a fact ;). Gerry
>RS has three wins, a second, a fourth, and a fifth. JM has two seconds and a >fourth. He crashed out of a few races due soley to driver error. RS has no >such incidences. When it comes to race results, it's not even close. On a semi-related note, did you see Ralf's first season in F1? -- Cheers! Graeme Nash
In article <[email hidden]>, Jan Verschueren <jan.no- [email hidden]> writes <snip>
Quoted text (25 lines)> >> He also responds to the whiners who say F1 is all technology, >> and little about the actual drivers. > > >He doesn't respond to it, he presents the same argument in a different way. > ><quote> >I see it like this: You are able to be more constantly at the limit [of the >car] with it [better electronics] and you don't have to take care of any >power peaks of the engine. It gives us more freedom to drive a bit faster. ></quote> > >Exactly Michael. However, in the technology whiner's (sic) point of view, >the "us" part is the offensive bit. In "our" view, it should only be the >Schumachers, Sennas, Prosts and Mansells of this world who are in a >position >to drive a given car at the very limit consistently. This allows extremely >talented driver X in not so performant car A to be competitive with very >talented driver Y in very performant car B and we, the viewer, actually get >to see some racing. > >Also, I wonder if his viewpoint would be the same if he found himself in a >team on the other side of the technology barrier. >
Spot on Jan. Last week I just happened to catch the first part of a racing series called 'Racing Arrows' here on tv - next part on Carlton at 12pm tonight if anyone's interested - and, I think it was the team director, was asked a very similar question. Surprisingly he reckoned it was something like 90% car and 10% driver these days. Obviously some may say it's only Arrows so what does he know <g>, but developers will more than likely err on the side of 'it's more the car', whilst drivers will be inclined to lean towards 'it's more the driver'. Why on earth would Shuey want to believe that he has very little to do with getting the car to go fast? Why would he want to sell himself short? -- Peter Ives Remove ALL_STRESS before replying via email If you know what's good for you, don't listen to me GPLRank Joystick -50.63 Wheel -21.77
I sware, I will not "say" one word! :) "Cliff Roman" wrote: | David,<znipped> | Were you just trolling? --- Outgoing mail is certified Virus Free. Checked by AVG anti-virus system (http://www.grisoft.com). Version: 6.0.265 / Virus Database: 137 - Release Date: 7/18/2001
LOL, Gerry!! This is too Funny!! :) "Gerry Aitken" wrote: | LOL! We all know DGF hates JPM because he plays GPL...and that's a fact | ;). | | Gerry --- Outgoing mail is certified Virus Free. Checked by AVG anti-virus system (http://www.grisoft.com). Version: 6.0.265 / Virus Database: 137 - Release Date: 7/18/2001
rrevved wrote:
Quoted text (7 lines)> On Thu, 16 Aug 2001 01:05:35 GMT, "David G Fisher" <[email hidden]> wrote: > > >You don't think that a 32 year old man who had a privileged upbringing in > >Germany, and loves auto racing, knows what driving sims/games are, and what > >it would take to evaluate them? > > Privileged upbringing? Schumacher's parents owned a Go-Kart track.
Maybe privileged compared to soooooooooooome people's upbringing. Marty
Good point. We should never assume car in a team are equal. Marty Mario Petrinovic wrote:
Quoted text (19 lines)> In development teams usually use second driver just for testing > new ideas. We'll see in the future who is better. > > "David G Fisher" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:ldGe7.106903$[email hidden]... > > Some facts. > > > > RS has out qualified JM in nine of the 12 races, usually by .5 to .9 > > seconds. In the three races JM qualified higher than RS, he did it by a > > COMBINED total of two tenths of a second. When it comes to qualifying, > it's > > not even close. > > > > RS has three wins, a second, a fourth, and a fifth. JM has two seconds and > a > > fourth. He crashed out of a few races due soley to driver error. RS has no > > such incidences. When it comes to race results, it's not even close. > > > > David G Fisher
Cliff Roman wrote:
Quoted text (8 lines)> David, you are the one that jumped the gun and pounced on the guy. > > He specifically stated in the original post "that I have ever personally > watched were" > > It stated right up front for you to see.. so if in your words " Uh, what's > the point of listing the best drivers you've seen", why did you even comment > then? Were you just trolling?
DF a troll? LOL
Quoted text (28 lines)> "David G Fisher" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:nPFe7.106811$[email hidden]... > > How stupid of me to make that mistake. > > > > Uh, what's the point of listing the best drivers you've seen.......in > > person? You can see a hell of a lot more on TV than you can at an actual > > race, or a baseball game, or an NFL game, or......... > > > > David G Fisher > > > > "rrevved" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > > news:[email hidden]... > > > On Wed, 15 Aug 2001 23:11:56 GMT, "David G Fisher" > <[email hidden]> > > wrote: > > > > > > > > > > >By not including Schumacher on the list as one of the greatest drivers, > > I'm > > > >afraid to say that you MUST be living in the past just a little too > much. > > > > > > Settle down David. I listed the drivers I thought were best of > > > those I had personally WATCHED race. As in --- 'In Person'. > > > > > > Sheesh. > > > > >
Nick G 16 Aug 2001 18:59 UTC↳ reply to Thom j.#167677
as any racing driver knows, the most important sense when driving a car near/on the limit is feel. you feel the rear wheels begin to lose grip long before anybody could see it visually. you correct movements imperceptible to the human eye. most racing is reacting to things which cannot be taught by a computer simulation. so don't tell me gpl is realistic. yeah sure it can help a retard on how to go round corners, but not how to adjust the car using weight distribution when the feel through the steering wheel and seat, and the slightly altering tyre noises tell you alot more than plain visuals can. one of the most obvious points is how many racing games (especially rally games) model the clutch? gpl does but using it or not makes little difference. side-stepping the clutch, double-declutching and heel-toe movements are all required to get fast times in a rally car, but does any racing sim model the clutch? does any set of steering wheel/pedals have a clutch pedal? i think not. electronics are bad, semi-auto 'boxes and suchlike should be outlawed, wings removed, and no traction control, abs, esc or any other electronical aids should be allowed. then the best driver in the world can be named.
Nick G 16 Aug 2001 19:05 UTC↳ reply to Thom j.#167681
ok. having only watched the grand prix championships for the last 10-15 years with utter fanaticism (being a younger member of the group), going to silverstone every year and monaco also, does this mean as i never actually saw the great fangio 'in person', that i can't rate him as one of the greatest racers of all time? bollox mate.
the easiest way to sum up all these posts is to say this: if you see somebody claiming that racing sims are great and a realistic driving experience, then they have never raced a car, and the only high speed cornering they have ever experienced was in a bog-standard 1.1 fiesta around the outskirst of town at 25mph. if you see somebody claiming that racing and simulating are too different to even compare them, then believe them - they know what they are talking about. things like gpl are great for the layman to see roughly what racing a car requires, but stick the world champion gpl racer in even a 996 turbo somewhere like oulton park, and they will be soooo crap it will be pathetic. take the most recent evo magazine. there is a report on two magazine journalists who raced a 24hr race in a nissan skyline in a le mans game. so nissan uk phoned them and asked if they would like to borrow a real skyline and take a trip via le mans and spa to the nurburgring. they jumped at the chance. first time down the mulsanne straight, approaching indianapolis, they lost control and took out the offside wing. they weren't even racing! so, racing games weren't even good enough to teach the gamesplayers to drive a skyline at a normal roadgoing speed! and you tell me sims are realistic. admittedly it was a v-spec, but indianapolis isn't exactly the bumpiest corner in the world, is it?
David G Fisher wrote:
Quoted text (7 lines)> <snip> > Without the electronics, no driver would be able to drive those cars near > their limit. 18,000rpm. 850 hp. Advances in aerodynamics. Grooved tires. > Incredible braking power. Technology has now made a car which outpaces the > abilities of a human driver, and that's why the electronic aids exist. I > want to see what the cars are truly capable of, and the aids make that > possible.
So you think racing is about technology of the car more than about the ability of the driver. I guess that is the only way to really enjoy F1 these days. That would be fine if we were privy to the details of the technology being used by each car. Don't kid yourself into thinking you know much about what's going on under the body work of those cars.
Quoted text (10 lines)> There's the limit, and then there's *the limit*. The true limit is > still only reached by the best drivers, so nothing has really changed. The > driver who reaches that true limit the most consistently, lap after lap and > race after race is MS. MS always outperforms his teammates. RS outperforms > JPM. MH is still probably a bit faster than DC. Zanardi dominated CART and > his teammate, but couldn't do much in F1. Within a team, there is usually > one driver who is consistently faster than another. Aids don't prevent that > fact from showing through. > > David G Fisher
For many, like myself, who think racing is primarily about driving and secondarily about technology (and I do love the technology) F1 today has become the prime example of how technology can hurt the racing by reducing the range of performance variables controlled by the driver. Thus the kind of F1 races we see today with little over taking. I could go on to comment on how I think a race fan's preference for technology over driver ability relates to the driving ability of the race fan....but I won't. :) Marty
Nick G wrote: > first time down the mulsanne straight, approaching indianapolis, If drive down the Mulsanne, the first corner you approach is, in fact, Mulsanne corner! If you don't even know the name of the corner at the end of the most famous straight in motor racing...
Thom j. 16 Aug 2001 19:59 UTC↳ reply to Nick G#167551
Sure you are Nick, Rate away! Won't be any better or any worse then anyone here.. It's all subjective anyway!! :) "Nick G" wrote: | ok. having only watched the grand prix championships for the last 10-15 | years with utter fanaticism (being a younger member of the group), goingto | silverstone every year and monaco also, does this mean as i never actually | saw the great fangio 'in person', that i can't rate him as one of the | greatest racers of all time? bollox mate. | | --- Outgoing mail is certified Virus Free. Checked by AVG anti-virus system (http://www.grisoft.com). Version: 6.0.265 / Virus Database: 137 - Release Date: 7/18/2001
"Top Sirloin" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... I had a feeling someone would say this. Here's some more facts. I know, it's r.a.s. :-) RS has six retirements due to car failure or being crashed out by another driver. JM has six retirements due to car failure or being crashed out by another driver. Two more retirements due to his own mistakes. They've both had the exact same "horrible luck". I'd say not following RS's lead and taking it a bit easy on the engine at Hockenheim was a mistake (maybe the long pit stop wouldn't of caused the engine to go), but we'll let that one slide. David G Fisher (Can't wait to see what brilliant comments Gerry and Thom can add to this discussion) > Race results aren't a fair comparison as JPM has had horrible luck with > equipment and other drivers - he only took himself out at Monaco andCanada.
Quoted text (7 lines)> > JPM could easily have two wins, two seconds, and a fourth at this point. > > > -Scott Johnson > Fry Mumia > http://www.danielfaulkner.com
Did you read any of the posts in the thread previous to the one you replied to? Yep, I really pounced on him. Probably made him cry. "By not including Schumacher on the list as one of the greatest drivers, I'm afraid to say that you MUST be living in the past just a little too much." Amazing how r.a.s. can take one fairly irrelevent comment and make WW3 out of it. David G Fisher "Cliff Roman" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:AKRe7.427$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (7 lines)> David, you are the one that jumped the gun and pounced on the guy. > > He specifically stated in the original post "that I have ever personally > watched were" > > It stated right up front for you to see.. so if in your words " Uh, what's > the point of listing the best drivers you've seen", why did you even
comment
Quoted text (21 lines)> then? Were you just trolling? > > > "David G Fisher" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:nPFe7.106811$[email hidden]... > > How stupid of me to make that mistake. > > > > Uh, what's the point of listing the best drivers you've seen.......in > > person? You can see a hell of a lot more on TV than you can at an actual > > race, or a baseball game, or an NFL game, or......... > > > > David G Fisher > > > > "rrevved" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > > news:[email hidden]... > > > On Wed, 15 Aug 2001 23:11:56 GMT, "David G Fisher" > <[email hidden]> > > wrote: > > > > > > > > > > >By not including Schumacher on the list as one of the greatest
drivers,
Quoted text (12 lines)> > I'm > > > >afraid to say that you MUST be living in the past just a little too > much. > > > > > > Settle down David. I listed the drivers I thought were best of > > > those I had personally WATCHED race. As in --- 'In Person'. > > > > > > Sheesh. > > > > > > >
Was he driving the the equivalent of the 2001 Williams? Was he an F1 test driver and CART champion before his first season in F1? They are both the same age BTW. Excuses can be made for Montoya, but the fact is RS has had significantly better results in the same car. David G Fisher "Graeme Nash" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > > >RS has three wins, a second, a fourth, and a fifth. JM has two secondsand a > >fourth. He crashed out of a few races due soley to driver error. RS hasno
Quoted text (7 lines)> >such incidences. When it comes to race results, it's not even close. > > On a semi-related note, did you see Ralf's first season in F1? > > -- > Cheers! > Graeme Nash
"David G Fisher" wrote... > > <snip> > You don't think that a 32 year old man who had a privileged > upbringing in Germany, and loves auto racing, knows what > driving sims/games are, and what it would take to evaluate > them? Quite ironic you should jump to the defense of Schum as a game reviewer. <g> > I knew these things before I was even that interested in > driving sims because they're so obvious. Racing games are > hardly recent inventions. Older racing titles were as good as they could technically get. Nowadays the computing power is there if the developers and publishers are willing to put simulation before eyecandy and with the latest systems and titles even that is no longer necessarily a pre-requisite. There can be no more excuses. Anything billed as a sim should be one.
Quoted text (8 lines)> > <snip> > I've seen kids sit down in front of driving games and > drive them with ease, including GPL. Your making the > same mistake a lot of adult sim racers make, which is > to take these things so seriously that we "talk" ourselves > into believing they are more difficult than they really are, > sometimes in order to justify our (what many people would > call childish) hobby to ourselves and others.
Kids do have the advantage of not having a pre-set idea what's possible, but nevertheless you must live around some extremely talented people and kids... of the 20 odd non-simracers (some of them experienced gamers) I sat down in front of my PC none could drive their way out of a paper bag in a simulation (even with driver aids on). > All he's saying, is that without the physical effects of > driving a race car, most of the simulation is gone. Driving > a car (sim or real) isn't that hard. Just driving around isn't. Going fast, racing and winning is bloody hard in both disciplines. > Everybody does it. Simulating a real F1 car without the > physical effects is like simulating sex. Will any computer > program ever come within a million miles of satisfying you > in the same way real sex with Cameron Diaz would? How would you know? -Did you have sex with her?<g> My guess is you had sex with her just as many times as I've driven a real '67 Grand Prix car, i.e. none. In the absense of the real thing.... > All I'm saying is let's not take this stuff so damn seriously > that we actually think we could mimic what we do on screen > if we were "just given the chance". Of course not, but let's take it seriously in it's own right. > Let's not put down real life drivers because we think we know > "what it takes". I don't know if I know what it takes (I have an opinion, though <g>), but I have sure gained a deeper appreciation of it through simming. > How about not ripping the shit out of one sim, and praising > another as if it's our religion? Perspective. That's a bit rich coming from someone admitting to not being able to watch anything but the top level any given sport has to offer. Again, I take issue with your generalisation. Name the offenders or use "some". > > <snip> > I rarely EVER rolled the cars in RC. It was never an issue > with me or many other people who drove RC. Real rally cars > actually do roll fairly easily though. You should know that. To a certain extend, yes. I never seen one go up on two wheels and then roll onto it's roof without the side ever touching the ground though. > How do you explain the different experiences that some had? For RC I used to think it was a framerate/resolution issue. Having gone back to it with a more powerfull PC, I've concluded it's not that. Perhaps a matter of viewpoint, with me using cockpit only. Actually, I never really compared my experience to others as, on the whole, it wasn't the actual driving quirks that bothered me much. > There is only one answer and that is that some people drove > them correctly, and kept them on a part of the track which > wouldn't cause the car to roll over in real life. Some people > drove them at realisitic speeds, while others had no idea > what their speed was as they were going around a sharp turn. There's no way you're ever going to get close to the AI if you drive the cars properly and at "realistic speeds", i.e. as if you don't know exactly what's coming and leave a certain margin at dangerous spots. You're back to "practising until you know what's possible and what isn't". This is not what rallying is about. Rallying is done somewhat "on the fly" and therefore I didn't really want to get to know the stages by heart by playing the game continuously, instead returning to it from time to time when the stages faded from memory a little. Then again, if one doesn't have changable track conditions the only way to put some sort of lasting challenge into one's game ('cos some people are going to practise the stages to death) is to put the AI out of "easy" reach. Can't say I agree with that decision, but: fair enough. > I saw so many replays of people rolling or crashing their car, > and blaming the game. They had no idea how fast they were > going, or what they hit. They simply blamed the game. The game is not to blame for me not getting long time enjoyment from it. Not the game's fault, I'm just the wrong player for it. The driving model on the whole is not too bad. Not as immediate and poised as I would like, but it's a lot more like rallying than CMR2, for example. Pace notes could have been better, again: not terrible. The only areas where I think Magnetic Fields really dropped the ball are on setting just the one difficulty level and making a mess of the settings/repair system. They ended up with a game where, if one respects the stages and the conditions one gets humiliated by the AI and pasted with a completely unreasonable wear-rate to boot. > As for GPL, the reason I lost interest in it was because IT did > things that the real life footage showed was not accurate. Mainly, > the excess sliding and drifting. Good, practiced drivers criss- > crossing the driving line all the way around the track. They > looked nothing like the AI or the real life footage. Yes, if one only moves in the fastest circles I can understand that sentiment.... having to destroy the illusion to keep up. Align yourself with those who mostly treat it as playable history, however and things change dramatically. Which is not to say it shouldn't have been possible to do that in the first place. I don't think even the "diehard GPL heads" would deny that. It's just, all things considered, some people still prefer GPL as a vehicle for their simracing hobby. How much of that is "comfort" is for each of those individuals to come to terms with, not for you to condemn, IMO. If I were just running off-line, I pretty sure GPL would have been deleted and I would feed my habit solely with a mix of SBK2001, MBTR, F!RC and N4. However, I happen to like the bunch that races GPL online and I derive great enjoyment from pitting myself against them using this ageing sim, while GPLRank keeps practising fun. Nice compromise as far as I'm concerned. > > <snip> > I'm glad to hear you noticed this about F1RC, but unfortunately, > this group which is supposedly the most knowlegeable collection > of sim racers on the planet has spent little time discussing > F1RC's excellent simulation of an F1 car's behavior, and more > time bickering over a bunch of bullshit. I noticed a whole bunch of stuff about F1RC... as with F1RS and MGPRS2, I really like Ubisoft's latest offering. I'm having trouble compiling all the info into a coherent report, but if the muze decides to visit I will expand on the subject. > > <snip> > Without the electronics, no driver would be able to drive those > cars near their limit. 18,000rpm. 850 hp. Advances in > aerodynamics. Grooved tires. Incredible braking power. Technology > has now made a car which outpaces the abilities of a human driver, > and that's why the electronic aids exist. The same situation occurred in Rallying in the 80's... Walter Rohrl on the Audi Quattro Turbo: "One nearly couldn't think quickly enough to keep pace with that car." The electronics probably weren't there to remedy this, but all the same the governing body simply banned the cars. Result: cars are still high-tech, but the excess is gone and drivers still take the fight to eachother. If the manufacturers build racing cars which are beyond the capability of a human to drive they are conceptually on the wrong track. I can understand dynamically unstable jet fighters beying kept aloft by computers. After all, war is a matter of life and death. Racing is not, it's supposed to be a competition between drivers, *using* cars. > I want to see what the cars are truly capable of, and the aids > make that possible. So you rather see the interests of the machines served than those of the men? > There's the limit, and then there's *the limit*. The true > limit is still only reached by the best drivers, so nothing > has really changed. The driver who reaches that true limit > the most consistently, lap after lap and race after race is > MS. MS will only go as quickly as he needs to go to win, just like any other professional racing driver in one of the best cars. > MS always outperforms his teammates. RS outperforms JPM. > MH is still probably a bit faster than DC. Zanardi > dominated CART and his teammate, but couldn't do much in > F1. Within a team, there is usually one driver who is > consistently faster than another. Aids don't prevent that > fact from showing through. True, not exactly rivetting, but true. Jan. =---
I think if anyone here at r.a.s. actually had the guts (impossible) to tell one of todays F1 drivers that modern F1 was all car and little driver, that driver would laugh in their face and then tell them to "piss off you fool". If someone here told them that what they were doing was easy compared to drivers in the past, they'd call them an old timer who's stuck in the past and doesn't have a clue. Whenever I hear someone try and put down what an F1 driver of today is doing, I'm reminded of an old time NFL star player named Chuck Bednarick. Whenever he's given the chance, he goes on and on about how the players in his era (the 60's) were better and tougher than today's players. Senile Chuck doesn't have a clue that he wouldn't even sniff a roster spot on a modern NFL team. He'd be lucky to be allowed to paint the lines on the field. Just like Chuck, I don't think many of the drivers from the past would be able to compete in today's F1. Old time brain surgeons were better than those of today because all they needed to operate was a rusty butter knife. Astronauts of today don't really do anything because of all the technology. They just sit there and drink Tang. Fred Flintstone was the greatest driver of all time. That guy could do it all in the most basic car ever created. Ed, to be honest, I think you and just about everyone else here at r.a.s. would probably shit your pants on the first lap if given the chance to drive MS's Ferrari. Your head would feel like it's being ripped off. Your body would be battered and bruised. You'd rather have your nuts cut off then even consider braking at the 100 meter mark when doing 180mph. You wouldn't get within a million miles of pushing *the limit*, and therefor still wouldn't have any idea what an F1 driver of today is doing. They are the best drivers in the world. The cars are the best in the world. That's why F1 draws 350 million viewers per race. It's an ENORMOUS success. Name another sporting event which even comes close. NASCAR draws a measly (in comparison) 8-13 million per race. To all the Fred Flintsones in this group, please stop living in the past. David G Fisher "Ed Solheim" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:_EMe7.154$[email hidden]... > Do you actually think *any* of todays F1 drivers (apart from Jacques that > is) would say any thing else ?? -- Does Bernie Ecclestone ring abell??
Quoted text (9 lines)> > If you want an honest oppinion on F1 - go ask someone who *used* to do it. > > -- > ed_ > > DGF'ed: > > > For those who go on and on and on and on and on and on about which sim
is > so > > realistic compared to all others, here's a little shot of perspective.He > > also responds to the whiners who say F1 is all technology, and little > about > > the actual drivers. > >
I am and will not "say" one word.. It's hard as hell but worthless.. As "George Jetson" would say: "Consider the source!" :o)~ "David G Fisher" wrote: | David G Fisher (Can't wait to see what brilliant comments Gerry and Thomcan | add to this discussion) --- Outgoing mail is certified Virus Free. Checked by AVG anti-virus system (http://www.grisoft.com). Version: 6.0.265 / Virus Database: 137 - Release Date: 7/18/2001
amazing how some people in this ng can take a fairly irreverent post and make WW3 out of it . . . David G Fisher <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:JYWe7.109272$[email hidden]... > I think if anyone here at r.a.s. actually had the guts (impossible) totell > one of todays F1 drivers that modern F1 was all car and little driver,that > driver would laugh in their face and then tell them to "piss off youfool".
Quoted text (17 lines)> If someone here told them that what they were doing was easy compared to > drivers in the past, they'd call them an old timer who's stuck in the past > and doesn't have a clue. > > Whenever I hear someone try and put down what an F1 driver of today is > doing, I'm reminded of an old time NFL star player named Chuck Bednarick. > Whenever he's given the chance, he goes on and on about how the players in > his era (the 60's) were better and tougher than today's players. Senile > Chuck doesn't have a clue that he wouldn't even sniff a roster spot on a > modern NFL team. He'd be lucky to be allowed to paint the lines on the > field. > > Just like Chuck, I don't think many of the drivers from the past would be > able to compete in today's F1. > > Old time brain surgeons were better than those of today because all they > needed to operate was a rusty butter knife. Astronauts of today don't
really > do anything because of all the technology. They just sit there and drink > Tang. Fred Flintstone was the greatest driver of all time. That guy coulddo > it all in the most basic car ever created. > > Ed, to be honest, I think you and just about everyone else here at r.a.s. > would probably shit your pants on the first lap if given the chance todrive > MS's Ferrari. Your head would feel like it's being ripped off. Your body > would be battered and bruised. You'd rather have your nuts cut off theneven > consider braking at the 100 meter mark when doing 180mph. You wouldn't get > within a million miles of pushing *the limit*, and therefor still wouldn't > have any idea what an F1 driver of today is doing. They are the bestdrivers
Quoted text (13 lines)> in the world. The cars are the best in the world. That's why F1 draws 350 > million viewers per race. It's an ENORMOUS success. Name another sporting > event which even comes close. NASCAR draws a measly (in comparison) 8-13 > million per race. > > To all the Fred Flintsones in this group, please stop living in the past. > > David G Fisher > > > "Ed Solheim" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:_EMe7.154$[email hidden]... > > Do you actually think *any* of todays F1 drivers (apart from Jacques
that > > is) would say any thing else ?? -- Does Bernie Ecclestone ring a > bell?? > > > > If you want an honest oppinion on F1 - go ask someone who *used* to doit.
Quoted text (17 lines)> > > > -- > > ed_ > > > > DGF'ed: > > > > > For those who go on and on and on and on and on and on about which sim > is > > so > > > realistic compared to all others, here's a little shot of perspective. > He > > > also responds to the whiners who say F1 is all technology, and little > > about > > > the actual drivers. > > > > >
OMG it's getting easier & easier.. hahaha swooosh! "David G Fisher" wrote: | I think if anyone here at r.a.s. actually had the guts (impossible) totell | one of todays F1 drivers that modern F1 was all car and little driver,that | driver would laugh in their face and then tell them to "piss off youfool".
Quoted text (17 lines)| If someone here told them that what they were doing was easy compared to | drivers in the past, they'd call them an old timer who's stuck in the past | and doesn't have a clue. | | Whenever I hear someone try and put down what an F1 driver of today is | doing, I'm reminded of an old time NFL star player named Chuck Bednarick. | Whenever he's given the chance, he goes on and on about how the players in | his era (the 60's) were better and tougher than today's players. Senile | Chuck doesn't have a clue that he wouldn't even sniff a roster spot on a | modern NFL team. He'd be lucky to be allowed to paint the lines on the | field. | | Just like Chuck, I don't think many of the drivers from the past would be | able to compete in today's F1. | | Old time brain surgeons were better than those of today because all they | needed to operate was a rusty butter knife. Astronauts of today don't
really | do anything because of all the technology. They just sit there and drink | Tang. Fred Flintstone was the greatest driver of all time. That guy coulddo | it all in the most basic car ever created. | | Ed, to be honest, I think you and just about everyone else here at r.a.s. | would probably shit your pants on the first lap if given the chance todrive | MS's Ferrari. Your head would feel like it's being ripped off. Your body | would be battered and bruised. You'd rather have your nuts cut off theneven | consider braking at the 100 meter mark when doing 180mph. You wouldn't get | within a million miles of pushing *the limit*, and therefor still wouldn't | have any idea what an F1 driver of today is doing. They are the bestdrivers
Quoted text (12 lines)| in the world. The cars are the best in the world. That's why F1 draws 350 | million viewers per race. It's an ENORMOUS success. Name another sporting | event which even comes close. NASCAR draws a measly (in comparison) 8-13 | million per race. | | To all the Fred Flintsones in this group, please stop living in the past. | | David G Fisher | | | "Ed Solheim" wrote: | > Do you actually think *any* of todays F1 drivers (apart from Jacques
that | > is) would say any thing else ?? -- Does Bernie Ecclestone ring a | bell?? | > | > If you want an honest oppinion on F1 - go ask someone who *used* to doit.
Quoted text (17 lines)| > | > -- | > ed_ | > | > DGF'ed: | > | > > For those who go on and on and on and on and on and on about which sim | is | > so | > > realistic compared to all others, here's a little shot of perspective. | He | > > also responds to the whiners who say F1 is all technology, and little | > about | > > the actual drivers. | > | > |
--- Outgoing mail is certified Virus Free. Checked by AVG anti-virus system (http://www.grisoft.com). Version: 6.0.265 / Virus Database: 137 - Release Date: 7/18/2001
We'll try and get it to pre-school level so you can finally contribute something worthwhile. David G Fisher "Thom j." <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:fDXe7.109304$[email hidden]... > OMG it's getting easier & easier.. hahaha swooosh! >
Yes, you're right. It's obvious from my Fred Flintstone and butter knife comments that I was very upset when I wrote that post. David G Fisher "David Karr" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:9lhftt$hig$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (13 lines)> amazing how some people in this ng can take a fairly irreverent post and > make WW3 out of it . . . > > David G Fisher <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:JYWe7.109272$[email hidden]... > > I think if anyone here at r.a.s. actually had the guts (impossible) to > tell > > one of todays F1 drivers that modern F1 was all car and little driver, > that > > driver would laugh in their face and then tell them to "piss off you > fool". > > If someone here told them that what they were doing was easy compared to > > drivers in the past, they'd call them an old timer who's stuck in the
past > > and doesn't have a clue. > > > > Whenever I hear someone try and put down what an F1 driver of today is > > doing, I'm reminded of an old time NFL star player named ChuckBednarick. > > Whenever he's given the chance, he goes on and on about how the playersin > > his era (the 60's) were better and tougher than today's players. Senile > > Chuck doesn't have a clue that he wouldn't even sniff a roster spot on a > > modern NFL team. He'd be lucky to be allowed to paint the lines on the > > field. > > > > Just like Chuck, I don't think many of the drivers from the past wouldbe
Quoted text (7 lines)> > able to compete in today's F1. > > > > Old time brain surgeons were better than those of today because all they > > needed to operate was a rusty butter knife. Astronauts of today don't > really > > do anything because of all the technology. They just sit there and drink > > Tang. Fred Flintstone was the greatest driver of all time. That guy
could > do > > it all in the most basic car ever created. > > > > Ed, to be honest, I think you and just about everyone else here atr.a.s. > > would probably shit your pants on the first lap if given the chance to > drive > > MS's Ferrari. Your head would feel like it's being ripped off. Your body > > would be battered and bruised. You'd rather have your nuts cut off then > even > > consider braking at the 100 meter mark when doing 180mph. You wouldn'tget > > within a million miles of pushing *the limit*, and therefor stillwouldn't > > have any idea what an F1 driver of today is doing. They are the best > drivers > > in the world. The cars are the best in the world. That's why F1 draws350 > > million viewers per race. It's an ENORMOUS success. Name anothersporting > > event which even comes close. NASCAR draws a measly (in comparison) 8-13 > > million per race. > > > > To all the Fred Flintsones in this group, please stop living in thepast.
Quoted text (20 lines)> > > > David G Fisher > > > > > > "Ed Solheim" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > > news:_EMe7.154$[email hidden]... > > > Do you actually think *any* of todays F1 drivers (apart from Jacques > that > > > is) would say any thing else ?? -- Does Bernie Ecclestone ring a > > bell?? > > > > > > If you want an honest oppinion on F1 - go ask someone who *used* to do > it. > > > > > > -- > > > ed_ > > > > > > DGF'ed: > > > > > > > For those who go on and on and on and on and on and on about which
sim > > is > > > so > > > > realistic compared to all others, here's a little shot ofperspective. > > He > > > > also responds to the whiners who say F1 is all technology, andlittle
Quoted text (7 lines)> > > about > > > > the actual drivers. > > > > > > > > > >
Its too funny isnt it David K..phew or just maybe its really sad? hmm? "David Karr" wrote: | amazing how some people in this ng can take a fairly irreverent post and | make WW3 out of it . . . --- Outgoing mail is certified Virus Free. Checked by AVG anti-virus system (http://www.grisoft.com). Version: 6.0.265 / Virus Database: 137 - Release Date: 7/18/2001
There is *nothing* to contribute as you've said it all, as usual!! :o)~ swooooooosh!! 3-pointer this time from way outsight.. :) "David G Fisher" wrote:
Quoted text (7 lines)| We'll try and get it to pre-school level so you can finally contribute | something worthwhile. | | David G Fisher | | "Thom j." wrote: | > OMG it's getting easier & easier.. hahaha swooosh!
--- Outgoing mail is certified Virus Free. Checked by AVG anti-virus system (http://www.grisoft.com). Version: 6.0.265 / Virus Database: 137 - Release Date: 7/18/2001
Go get'em Fred F.... hahaha "David G Fisher" wrote:
Quoted text (17 lines)| Yes, you're right. It's obvious from my Fred Flintstone and butter knife | comments that I was very upset when I wrote that post. | | David G Fisher | | "David Karr" wrote: | > amazing how some people in this ng can take a fairly irreverent post and | > make WW3 out of it . . . | > | > David G Fisher wrote: | > > I think if anyone here at r.a.s. actually had the guts (impossible) to | > tell | > > one of todays F1 drivers that modern F1 was all car and little driver, | > that | > > driver would laugh in their face and then tell them to "piss off you | > fool". | > > If someone here told them that what they were doing was easy compared
to
Quoted text (8 lines)| > > drivers in the past, they'd call them an old timer who's stuck in the | past | > > and doesn't have a clue. | > > | > > Whenever I hear someone try and put down what an F1 driver of today is | > > doing, I'm reminded of an old time NFL star player named Chuck | Bednarick. | > > Whenever he's given the chance, he goes on and on about how the
players | in | > > his era (the 60's) were better and tougher than today's players.Senile | > > Chuck doesn't have a clue that he wouldn't even sniff a roster spot ona
Quoted text (8 lines)| > > modern NFL team. He'd be lucky to be allowed to paint the lines on the | > > field. | > > | > > Just like Chuck, I don't think many of the drivers from the past would | be | > > able to compete in today's F1. | > > | > > Old time brain surgeons were better than those of today because all
they | > > needed to operate was a rusty butter knife. Astronauts of today don't | > really | > > do anything because of all the technology. They just sit there anddrink
Quoted text (10 lines)| > > Tang. Fred Flintstone was the greatest driver of all time. That guy | could | > do | > > it all in the most basic car ever created. | > > | > > Ed, to be honest, I think you and just about everyone else here at | r.a.s. | > > would probably shit your pants on the first lap if given the chance to | > drive | > > MS's Ferrari. Your head would feel like it's being ripped off. Your
body | > > would be battered and bruised. You'd rather have your nuts cut offthen
Quoted text (12 lines)| > even | > > consider braking at the 100 meter mark when doing 180mph. You wouldn't | get | > > within a million miles of pushing *the limit*, and therefor still | wouldn't | > > have any idea what an F1 driver of today is doing. They are the best | > drivers | > > in the world. The cars are the best in the world. That's why F1 draws | 350 | > > million viewers per race. It's an ENORMOUS success. Name another | sporting | > > event which even comes close. NASCAR draws a measly (in comparison)
8-13
Quoted text (15 lines)| > > million per race. | > > | > > To all the Fred Flintsones in this group, please stop living in the | past. | > > | > > David G Fisher | > > | > > | > > "Ed Solheim" wrote: | > > > Do you actually think *any* of todays F1 drivers (apart from Jacques | > that | > > > is) would say any thing else ?? -- Does Bernie Ecclestone ring a | > > bell?? | > > > | > > > If you want an honest oppinion on F1 - go ask someone who *used* to
do
Quoted text (24 lines)| > it. | > > > | > > > -- | > > > ed_ | > > > | > > > DGF'ed: | > > > | > > > > For those who go on and on and on and on and on and on about which | sim | > > is | > > > so | > > > > realistic compared to all others, here's a little shot of | perspective. | > > He | > > > > also responds to the whiners who say F1 is all technology, and | little | > > > about | > > > > the actual drivers. | > > > | > > > | > > | > | > |
--- Outgoing mail is certified Virus Free. Checked by AVG anti-virus system (http://www.grisoft.com). Version: 6.0.265 / Virus Database: 137 - Release Date: 7/18/2001
Now quit it Graeme! You ain't suppose to bring common sense into this :) "Graeme Nash" wrote:
Quoted text (7 lines)| On a semi-related note, did you see Ralf's first season in F1? | | -- | Cheers! | Graeme Nash | >RS has three wins, a second, a fourth, and a fifth. JM has two seconds
and a | >fourth. He crashed out of a few races due soley to driver error. RS hasno | >such incidences. When it comes to race results, it's not even close. | --- Outgoing mail is certified Virus Free. Checked by AVG anti-virus system (http://www.grisoft.com). Version: 6.0.265 / Virus Database: 137 - Release Date: 7/18/2001
The scary part is he for a fleeting second wondered whether it was valid for him to do so. Jan. =--- "Pay attention when I'm talking to you boy!" -Foghorn Leghorn. "Thom j." wrote... > Sure you are Nick, Rate away! Won't be any better or any > worse then anyone here.. It's all subjective anyway!! :)
On Thu, 16 Aug 2001 20:07:32 GMT, "David G Fisher" <[email hidden]> wrote: >They've both had the exact same "horrible luck". You're discounting the multiple failures that have plagued JPM during Friday-Saturday before the race. :-) >I'd say not following RS's lead and taking it a bit easy on the engine at >Hockenheim was a mistake (maybe the long pit stop wouldn't of caused the >engine to go), but we'll let that one slide. The whole "taking it easy"' bit was debunked by Mario Thiessen of BMW, who blamed the long pit stop. Patrick Head even said they were using the same revs. Scott Johnson "Science suggests that beer and 98 degree heat do not enhance your swimming ability, but I think it's a really, really good idea for people to test that theory as often as possible. What are you, a pussy? You can do it, champ." -- Rev. Syd Midnight
On Thu, 16 Aug 2001 11:43:37 -0700, Marty U'Ren <[email hidden]> wrote: >Good point. We should never assume car in a team are equal. At Williams they are. Frank puts the constructors championship above the drivers, and gives each driver the best equipment possible. Scott Johnson "Science suggests that beer and 98 degree heat do not enhance your swimming ability, but I think it's a really, really good idea for people to test that theory as often as possible. What are you, a pussy? You can do it, champ." -- Rev. Syd Midnight
What the hell does this got to do with telling "the thruth" or not? However, having said that.... what do you think is the easiest: A) Feel the exact correct time and place to grab the gearstick, lift the throttle just enough, engage the correct gear, match the correct rev's and get on the the throttle again at the correct time - not a 10th to early - not 10th to late. Repeat this 50 times a lap - 70 laps a race. - or - B) Push a button each time you want to gear up a gear - push another button each time you want to go down *several* gears. Repeat this 30 times a lap - 70 laps a race Seeing you're so fond of them... here's a few quotes for you: "Every time you bring in a driver aid, you're widening the area of abilities which can take part and perform" - John Surtees " I acknowledge that it's difficult for someone of my period to make an outright statement because I haven't driven one of the current F1 cars. But people with no previous experience can get up to good a speed so quickly, which suggests reaching 90 per cent in an F1 is not that difficult now." - John Surtees "I think I first tried it in September 1991, and I was amazed. The traditional way into a corner was to brake, wait a little bit, and then control the throttle with the foot, balancing between power and traction out of the corner. But with traction control you could brake then immediantly put your foot down and wait because the electronics were doing everything. You didn't have to care how to manage the power" - Ricardo Patrese "I have the impression things have been done in the last year to make it possible for more people to drive an F1 car. Some years ago it was like climbing a mountain to reach F1. You had to be good - no, you had to be *special* - to be quick in a grand prix car." - Ricardo Patrese "Over a race distance, it helps because traction control is always perfect, whereas a human will make errors." - Ricardo Patrese "Traction Control meant a driver could be much more confidentthat he wasn't going to have the back end step out unexpectedly. An even more significant aspect is that, over a period of running on a set of tyres, the rate at which they degrade is much reduced if you're running traction control" - Patrick Head Source: MotorSport magazine, March 2001 - "Farewell to crossed arms" -- ed_ DGF'ed: > I think if anyone here at r.a.s. actually had the guts (impossible) to tell > one of todays F1 drivers that modern F1 was all car and little driver, that > driver would laugh in their face and then tell them to "piss off you fool". > If someone here told them that what they were doing was easy compared to > drivers in the past, they'd call them an old timer who's stuck in the past > and doesn't have a clue. <SNIPPED THE REST>
After the 2 times Montoya lost the back end of the car putting himself out of the race, I think Mr. Head may be reconsidering the first part of his statement <G> -- Ian P <email invalid due to spammers> "Ed Solheim" <[email hidden]> wrote > "Traction Control meant a driver could be much more confidentthat he wasn't > going to have the back end step out unexpectedly. An even more significant > aspect is that, over a period of running on a set of tyres, the rate at > which they degrade is much reduced if you're running traction control" - > Patrick Head > > Source: MotorSport magazine, March 2001 - "Farewell to crossed arms" > > -- > ed_ >
No, silly wabbit--I was swayed by "to be honest" part; I assumed you meant the "honest" bit. Over-purple it was, with a bit too much machismo'd Clint Eastwood for my taste, but it read like you meant it. Seems I was wrong. leggo that ego! David G Fisher <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:RMXe7.109321$[email hidden]... > Yes, you're right. It's obvious from my Fred Flintstone and butter knife > comments that I was very upset when I wrote that post. > > David G Fisher
By the way, I agree with your sentiments regarding the skill-level necc. for current F1 driving. I just think you're a jerk. (Scant comfort, I know, but do with it what you can. In a war the size of WW3, you'll find the bunker full of strange allies indeed.) --David David G Fisher <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:RMXe7.109321$[email hidden]... > Yes, you're right. It's obvious from my Fred Flintstone and butter knife > comments that I was very upset when I wrote that post. > > David G Fisher
On 17/8/01 5:17 AM, in article [email hidden], "Nick G" <[email hidden]> wrote:
Quoted text (12 lines)> the easiest way to sum up all these posts is to say this: > > if you see somebody claiming that racing sims are great and a realistic > driving experience, then they have never raced a car, and the only high > speed cornering they have ever experienced was in a bog-standard 1.1 fiesta > around the outskirst of town at 25mph. > > if you see somebody claiming that racing and simulating are too different to > even compare them, then believe them - they know what they are talking > about. things like gpl are great for the layman to see roughly what racing a > car requires, but stick the world champion gpl racer in even a 996 turbo > somewhere like oulton park, and they will be soooo crap it will be pathetic.
Hi Nick, My name is Jon Crooke. In 1986 I won the Australian F2 Championship in one of the worlds last ground effects cars. You know, over 4 G's lateral forces and brakes that pop your eyeballs. I've also raced every thing from Sprint Karts to Superkarts to non-ground effects open wheelers to V8 Supercars. Retired from professional race driving with the all-time highest career win rate at National level racing. Know a thing or two about driving, I do. Anyway, enough about me, let's talk about you. You stated that > if you see somebody claiming that racing sims are great and a realistic > driving experience, then they have never raced a car">. Phew, big statement. I would agree with you if you said that MOST sims on the market are unrealistic, BUT I'm prepared to state that GPL IS (and I'll use your words) a great and a realistic driving experience. And your statement > but stick the world champion gpl racer in even a 996 turbo somewhere like > oulton park, and they will be soooo crap it will be pathetic.> Let me tell you that if you stuck Wolfgang or any other top GPL driver in a real car he would be a superstar. We did that exact experiment here in Australia with the 1999 Australian GPL Champion Vail Riches. Never having driven a race car or kart of any sort he went out to a race school and drove a F/Ford around Oran Park and in 24 laps set the fastest lap time ever done in a school car. For that story see www.hyperstimulator.com and click on Simulators, then under Latest News click on "Can simulator drivers cut the mustard in the real world?"
I was being honest. A person can be honest without being upset. They can even throw in a little joke here and there. David G Fisher "David Karr" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:9lhr0h$j1j$[email hidden]... > No, silly wabbit--I was swayed by "to be honest" part; I assumed you meant > the "honest" bit. Over-purple it was, with a bit too much machismo'dClint
Quoted text (14 lines)> Eastwood for my taste, but it read like you meant it. Seems I was wrong. > > leggo that ego! > > David G Fisher <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:RMXe7.109321$[email hidden]... > > Yes, you're right. It's obvious from my Fred Flintstone and butter knife > > comments that I was very upset when I wrote that post. > > > > David G Fisher > > > >
"Ed Solheim" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:vwZe7.811$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (12 lines)> What the hell does this got to do with telling "the thruth" or not? > > However, having said that.... what do you think is the easiest: > > A) Feel the exact correct time and place to grab the gearstick, lift the > throttle just enough, engage the correct gear, match the correct rev's and > get on the the throttle again at the correct time - not a 10th to early - > not 10th to late. Repeat this 50 times a lap - 70 laps a race. > > - or - > > B) Push a button each time you want to gear up a gear - push another
button > each time you want to go down *several* gears. Repeat this 30 times alap - > 70 laps a race I think it's a lot harder to manually shift a modern F1 car than an older car (from the 60's for example) because the revs are so much higher, and the cars are so much quicker and faster. The current F1 drivers proved long ago they could master that part of driving to the point where it's irrelevent as a measue of talent. That's why the automatic shifting aid this year isn't a big deal. As for the quotes, two guys (one who never drove a modern F1 car) don't like the traction control. Big deal. A lot of the current drivers said they weren't even sure if they'd use it because they weren't that impressed by it, and that it made it even harder for the driver to dance on the edge. If the back end starts to go with traction control on, there is NO chance to save it. They said that it might even slow them down on some dry circuits, but that it could help at a circuit like Monaco (ask Montoya if that's true), or if it rains. Alesi says he doesn't ever use it. Aids haven't suddenly launched the backmarkers up to the front. Barrichello still can't keep up with MS. Where are the great changes in race results due to the aids? Has the entire grid suddenly been replaced with F1 drivers who have never raced without traction control? Most of the drivers raced for years without it, so where has traction control opened up F1 to less talented drivers? Those aids will probably be taken away as soon as they find a way to reliably police their use, you'll hardly notice, and the drivers probably won't care. David G Fisher > Seeing you're so fond of them... here's a few quotes for you: > > "Every time you bring in a driver aid, you're widening the area ofabilities > which can take part and perform" - John Surtees > > " I acknowledge that it's difficult for someone of my period to make an > outright statement because I haven't driven one of the current F1 cars.But > people with no previous experience can get up to good a speed so quickly, > which suggests reaching 90 per cent in an F1 is not that difficultow." - > John Surtees > > "I think I first tried it in September 1991, and I was amazed. The > traditional way into a corner was to brake, wait a little bit, and then > control the throttle with the foot, balancing between power and tractionout
Quoted text (10 lines)> of the corner. But with traction control you could brake then immediantly > put your foot down and wait because the electronics were doing everything. > You didn't have to care how to manage the power" - Ricardo Patrese > > "I have the impression things have been done in the last year to make it > possible for more people to drive an F1 car. Some years ago it was like > climbing a mountain to reach F1. You had to be good - no, you had to be > *special* - to be quick in a grand prix car." - Ricardo Patrese > > "Over a race distance, it helps because traction control is always
perfect, > whereas a human will make errors." - Ricardo Patrese > > "Traction Control meant a driver could be much more confidentthat hewasn't
Quoted text (20 lines)> going to have the back end step out unexpectedly. An even more significant > aspect is that, over a period of running on a set of tyres, the rate at > which they degrade is much reduced if you're running traction control" - > Patrick Head > > Source: MotorSport magazine, March 2001 - "Farewell to crossed arms" > > -- > ed_ > > DGF'ed: > > > I think if anyone here at r.a.s. actually had the guts (impossible) to > tell > > one of todays F1 drivers that modern F1 was all car and little driver, > that > > driver would laugh in their face and then tell them to "piss off you > fool". > > If someone here told them that what they were doing was easy compared to > > drivers in the past, they'd call them an old timer who's stuck in the
past > > and doesn't have a clue. <SNIPPED THE REST> > >
You're an ass. David G Fisher wrote:
Quoted text (25 lines)> > As I said in the other post, "Compared to many people in this world who > struggle to have enough to eat or a safe place to sleep, he was privileged. > Was his family at least lower > middle-class to middle-class before he aeaned his first paycheck as an F1 > driver? Most kids in that position while growing up in a western country had > a lot of access to video games." > > As far as I'm concerned, almost everyone who lives in a Western country in > the second half of the 20th century/beginning of the 21st century is > "privileged" compared to the rest of the current world, and the 50 billion > or so who have walked this planet since the beginning of mankind. Add in the > all the other living creatures like cute little bunny rabbits, elephants, > ants, and dinasours, and the difficulty of their lives, and I don't think a > construction worker in modern day Germany is really that tough a life. > That's my personal opinion. I think most people are a bunch of cry baby > whiners (doesn't mean they are necessarily bad) and don't have a clue how > tough life can really be. > > Were going off waaaaaaay off on another r.a.s. tangent. The point is, MS had > access to video games while growing up. If someone is reading this post and > doens't have a clue why we are talking about this "privileged" stuff, you're > not alone. > > David G Fisher
Wow Jon C, I am impressed... No BS!! Great info too.. Thanx for sharing! -Thom_j. "Jon Crooke" wrote: Nick G" wrote: | | > the easiest way to sum up all these posts is to say this: | > | > if you see somebody claiming that racing sims are great and a realistic | > driving experience, then they have never raced a car, and the only high | > speed cornering they have ever experienced was in a bog-standard 1.1fiesta | > around the outskirst of town at 25mph. | > | > if you see somebody claiming that racing and simulating are toodifferent to | > even compare them, then believe them - they know what they are talking | > about. things like gpl are great for the layman to see roughly whatracing a | > car requires, but stick the world champion gpl racer in even a 996 turbo | > somewhere like oulton park, and they will be soooo crap it will bepathetic. | | Hi Nick, | | My name is Jon Crooke. In 1986 I won the Australian F2 Championship in one | of the worlds last ground effects cars. You know, over 4 G's lateralforces | and brakes that pop your eyeballs. I've also raced every thing from Sprint | Karts to Superkarts to non-ground effects open wheelers to V8 Supercars. | Retired from professional race driving with the all-time highest careerwin
Quoted text (12 lines)| rate at National level racing. Know a thing or two about driving, I do. | | Anyway, enough about me, let's talk about you. | | You stated that | > if you see somebody claiming that racing sims are great and a realistic | > driving experience, then they have never raced a car">. | | Phew, big statement. | | I would agree with you if you said that MOST sims on the market are | unrealistic, BUT I'm prepared to state that GPL IS (and I'll use your
words) | a great and a realistic driving experience. | | And your statement | > but stick the world champion gpl racer in even a 996 turbo somewherelike | > oulton park, and they will be soooo crap it will be pathetic.> | | Let me tell you that if you stuck Wolfgang or any other top GPL driver ina | real car he would be a superstar. We did that exact experiment here in | Australia with the 1999 Australian GPL Champion Vail Riches. Never having | driven a race car or kart of any sort he went out to a race school anddrove | a F/Ford around Oran Park and in 24 laps set the fastest lap time everdone | in a school car. For that story see www.hyperstimulator.com and click on | Simulators, then under Latest News click on "Can simulator drivers cut the | mustard in the real world?" | | --- Outgoing mail is certified Virus Free. Checked by AVG anti-virus system (http://www.grisoft.com). Version: 6.0.265 / Virus Database: 137 - Release Date: 7/18/2001
It's always possible to lose the back end if you go in too hot. Just removes power-oversteer. JPM always loves a loose car tho. Rafe Mc On Fri, 17 Aug 2001 01:56:09 +0100, "Ian P" <[email hidden]> wrote: >After the 2 times Montoya lost the back end of the car putting himself out >of the race, I think Mr. Head may be reconsidering the first part of his >statement <G>
No ones saying that there's no difficulty in driving F1 cars, just that a skill area that was once vital has been removed from the equation. Backmarker cars will stay at the back, since the car is still slow. And the bigger teams have developed more reliable and accurate systems. MS is still faster than RB because he still uses the remaining areas of the car to greater effect. But you can't deny that one skill requirement of a driver has been removed. Rafe Mc On Fri, 17 Aug 2001 01:51:32 GMT, "David G Fisher" <[email hidden]> wrote:
Quoted text (104 lines)> >"Ed Solheim" <[email hidden]> wrote in message >news:vwZe7.811$[email hidden]... >> What the hell does this got to do with telling "the thruth" or not? >> >> However, having said that.... what do you think is the easiest: >> >> A) Feel the exact correct time and place to grab the gearstick, lift the >> throttle just enough, engage the correct gear, match the correct rev's and >> get on the the throttle again at the correct time - not a 10th to early - >> not 10th to late. Repeat this 50 times a lap - 70 laps a race. >> >> - or - >> >> B) Push a button each time you want to gear up a gear - push another >button >> each time you want to go down *several* gears. Repeat this 30 times a >lap - >> 70 laps a race > >I think it's a lot harder to manually shift a modern F1 car than an older >car (from the 60's for example) because the revs are so much higher, and the >cars are so much quicker and faster. The current F1 drivers proved long ago >they could master that part of driving to the point where it's irrelevent as >a measue of talent. That's why the automatic shifting aid this year isn't a >big deal. > >As for the quotes, two guys (one who never drove a modern F1 car) don't like >the traction control. Big deal. A lot of the current drivers said they >weren't even sure if they'd use it because they weren't that impressed by >it, and that it made it even harder for the driver to dance on the edge. If >the back end starts to go with traction control on, there is NO chance to >save it. They said that it might even slow them down on some dry circuits, >but that it could help at a circuit like Monaco (ask Montoya if that's >true), or if it rains. Alesi says he doesn't ever use it. Aids haven't >suddenly launched the backmarkers up to the front. Barrichello still can't >keep up with MS. Where are the great changes in race results due to the >aids? Has the entire grid suddenly been replaced with F1 drivers who have >never raced without traction control? Most of the drivers raced for years >without it, so where has traction control opened up F1 to less talented >drivers? Those aids will probably be taken away as soon as they find a way >to reliably police their use, you'll hardly notice, and the drivers probably >won't care. > >David G Fisher > > >> Seeing you're so fond of them... here's a few quotes for you: >> >> "Every time you bring in a driver aid, you're widening the area of >abilities >> which can take part and perform" - John Surtees >> >> " I acknowledge that it's difficult for someone of my period to make an >> outright statement because I haven't driven one of the current F1 cars. >But >> people with no previous experience can get up to good a speed so quickly, >> which suggests reaching 90 per cent in an F1 is not that difficult >ow." - >> John Surtees >> >> "I think I first tried it in September 1991, and I was amazed. The >> traditional way into a corner was to brake, wait a little bit, and then >> control the throttle with the foot, balancing between power and traction >out >> of the corner. But with traction control you could brake then immediantly >> put your foot down and wait because the electronics were doing everything. >> You didn't have to care how to manage the power" - Ricardo Patrese >> >> "I have the impression things have been done in the last year to make it >> possible for more people to drive an F1 car. Some years ago it was like >> climbing a mountain to reach F1. You had to be good - no, you had to be >> *special* - to be quick in a grand prix car." - Ricardo Patrese >> >> "Over a race distance, it helps because traction control is always >perfect, >> whereas a human will make errors." - Ricardo Patrese >> >> "Traction Control meant a driver could be much more confidentthat he >wasn't >> going to have the back end step out unexpectedly. An even more significant >> aspect is that, over a period of running on a set of tyres, the rate at >> which they degrade is much reduced if you're running traction control" - >> Patrick Head >> >> Source: MotorSport magazine, March 2001 - "Farewell to crossed arms" >> >> -- >> ed_ >> >> DGF'ed: >> >> > I think if anyone here at r.a.s. actually had the guts (impossible) to >> tell >> > one of todays F1 drivers that modern F1 was all car and little driver, >> that >> > driver would laugh in their face and then tell them to "piss off you >> fool". >> > If someone here told them that what they were doing was easy compared to >> > drivers in the past, they'd call them an old timer who's stuck in the >past >> > and doesn't have a clue. <SNIPPED THE REST> >> >>
Damn impressive. Great to hear your opinion. When did you race in the V8's? We'll have to hope that this GPL Bathurst track gets properly sorted :) Rafe Mc On Fri, 17 Aug 2001 11:26:11 +1000, Jon Crooke <[email hidden]> wrote:
Quoted text (50 lines)>On 17/8/01 5:17 AM, in article [email hidden], "Nick G" ><[email hidden]> wrote: > >> the easiest way to sum up all these posts is to say this: >> >> if you see somebody claiming that racing sims are great and a realistic >> driving experience, then they have never raced a car, and the only high >> speed cornering they have ever experienced was in a bog-standard 1.1 fiesta >> around the outskirst of town at 25mph. >> >> if you see somebody claiming that racing and simulating are too different to >> even compare them, then believe them - they know what they are talking >> about. things like gpl are great for the layman to see roughly what racing a >> car requires, but stick the world champion gpl racer in even a 996 turbo >> somewhere like oulton park, and they will be soooo crap it will be pathetic. > >Hi Nick, > >My name is Jon Crooke. In 1986 I won the Australian F2 Championship in one >of the worlds last ground effects cars. You know, over 4 G's lateral forces >and brakes that pop your eyeballs. I've also raced every thing from Sprint >Karts to Superkarts to non-ground effects open wheelers to V8 Supercars. >Retired from professional race driving with the all-time highest career win >rate at National level racing. Know a thing or two about driving, I do. > >Anyway, enough about me, let's talk about you. > >You stated that >> if you see somebody claiming that racing sims are great and a realistic >> driving experience, then they have never raced a car">. > >Phew, big statement. > >I would agree with you if you said that MOST sims on the market are >unrealistic, BUT I'm prepared to state that GPL IS (and I'll use your words) >a great and a realistic driving experience. > >And your statement >> but stick the world champion gpl racer in even a 996 turbo somewhere like >> oulton park, and they will be soooo crap it will be pathetic.> > >Let me tell you that if you stuck Wolfgang or any other top GPL driver in a >real car he would be a superstar. We did that exact experiment here in >Australia with the 1999 Australian GPL Champion Vail Riches. Never having >driven a race car or kart of any sort he went out to a race school and drove >a F/Ford around Oran Park and in 24 laps set the fastest lap time ever done >in a school car. For that story see www.hyperstimulator.com and click on >Simulators, then under Latest News click on "Can simulator drivers cut the >mustard in the real world?" >
Jon, I've read that there are a fair few drivers like Russell Ingall and Greg Moore who use (and used) the hyprestimulator. What sims did they use with it? And how did it compare to their racing? Rafe Mc
Amazing! By using your brand of logic and including a bunch of animal (don't forget germs!), all posts to r.a.s. were made by some of the smartest individuals ever to walk this planet. In the top 1/1,000,000 easily. :-) /Jens P.S.: Comparing standards of living across species is a staggering concept. Ever seen a high tech rabbit? "David G Fisher" <[email hidden]> skrev i en meddelelse news:nRGe7.107050$[email hidden]... <Snip!>
Quoted text (8 lines)> Add in the > all the other living creatures like cute little bunny rabbits, elephants, > ants, and dinasours, and the difficulty of their lives, and I don't think a > construction worker in modern day Germany is really that tough a life. > That's my personal opinion. I think most people are a bunch of cry baby > whiners (doesn't mean they are necessarily bad) and don't have a clue how > tough life can really be. >
NASCAR! Dacid G Fisher "Pat Dotson" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > You're an ass. > > David G Fisher wrote: > > > > As I said in the other post, "Compared to many people in this world who > > struggle to have enough to eat or a safe place to sleep, he wasprivileged. > > Was his family at least lower > > middle-class to middle-class before he aeaned his first paycheck as anF1 > > driver? Most kids in that position while growing up in a western countryhad > > a lot of access to video games." > > > > As far as I'm concerned, almost everyone who lives in a Western countryin > > the second half of the 20th century/beginning of the 21st century is > > "privileged" compared to the rest of the current world, and the 50billion > > or so who have walked this planet since the beginning of mankind. Add inthe > > all the other living creatures like cute little bunny rabbits,elephants, > > ants, and dinasours, and the difficulty of their lives, and I don'tthink a > > construction worker in modern day Germany is really that tough a life. > > That's my personal opinion. I think most people are a bunch of cry baby > > whiners (doesn't mean they are necessarily bad) and don't have a cluehow > > tough life can really be. > > > > Were going off waaaaaaay off on another r.a.s. tangent. The point is, MShad > > access to video games while growing up. If someone is reading this postand > > doens't have a clue why we are talking about this "privileged" stuff,you're > > not alone. > > > > David G Fisher
Which pretty much disproves the theory that Traction Control is the be all and end all of driver aids. It won't magically make a crap driver into a good one ;) Before anyone starts, I'm not saying JPM is a crap driver ! I don't think he is, in fact I think he's future WC material once he gets used to F1. -- Ian P <email invalid due to spammers> "Rafe McAuliffe" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > It's always possible to lose the back end if you go in too hot. Just > removes power-oversteer. JPM always loves a loose car tho. > > Rafe Mc > > On Fri, 17 Aug 2001 01:56:09 +0100, "Ian P" <[email hidden]> wrote: > > >After the 2 times Montoya lost the back end of the car putting himself out > >of the race, I think Mr. Head may be reconsidering the first part of his > >statement <G> >
I don't think so either, but I believe it narrows the gap a bit though. Just removes another skill that separates the good from the bad. There are still a hell of a lot of skills that a driver has to use to the fullest. Rafe Mc On Fri, 17 Aug 2001 11:07:23 +0100, "Ian P" <[email hidden]> wrote: >Which pretty much disproves the theory that Traction Control is the be all >and end all of driver aids. It won't magically make a crap driver into a >good one ;) >Before anyone starts, I'm not saying JPM is a crap driver ! I don't think he >is, in fact I think he's future WC material once he gets used to F1.
>so don't tell me gpl is realistic. yeah sure it can help a retard on how to >go round corners, but not how to adjust the car using weight distribution >when the feel through the steering wheel and seat, and the slightly altering >tyre noises tell you alot more than plain visuals can. >Well then, don't bother playing computer games and get out there, start racing! GPL is the closest you're gonna get without being there, and does the best it can, given the minimal feedback able to be conveyed to the driver. Rafe Mc
See, I do not have to "say" one word! :o)~ "David G Fisher" wrote: | >I think it's a lot harder to manually shift a modern F1 car than an older | >car (from the 60's for example) because the revs are so much higher, andthe | >cars are so much quicker and faster. "rrevved" wrote: | ROFL!!!!!!!!!!! | --- Outgoing mail is certified Virus Free. Checked by AVG anti-virus system (http://www.grisoft.com). Version: 6.0.265 / Virus Database: 137 - Release Date: 7/18/2001
DGF'ed: > I think it's a lot harder to manually shift a modern F1 car than an older > car (from the 60's for example) because the revs are so much higher, andthe > cars are so much quicker and faster. The current F1 drivers proved longago > they could master that part of driving to the point where it's irreleventas > a measue of talent. That's why the automatic shifting aid this year isn'ta > big deal. Why do you always have to assume I'm comparing modern day F1 to that of the 60's? Looking for yet another oppertunity to bash GPL perhaps? I'm not talking about the 60's or 70's at all.. all I'm saying is that all these aid's have runied the sport. They have undoubtly made F1 easier... take Kimi Raikonen for instance.. his 23rd *ever* car race and he scores a point in F1??? You might think F1 is the most awesome thing on earth - I don't. Imho - F1 is dieing... and it has been doing so for the last 6-7 years. I predict that within 5-10 years - F1 as a sport - will be completely gone. All the private teams will be gone - having being taken over by the car manufacturers. You'll end up with Toyota, Ford, Mercedes, Honda, etc. who know's - perhaps Ferrari will be around to - renamed Fiat perhaps.. I could probably go on and on with this mail - but why bother, you're clearly a so called F1 "fan" - and no motorsports enthusiast. -- ed_
>Was he an F1 test driver and CART champion before his first season in F1? >They are both the same age BTW. No. But he had extensive experience in Formula Nippon and a fair amount of F1 testing. >Excuses can be made for Montoya, but the fact is RS has had significantly >better results in the same car. Not my point at all. The point is, in his first season, Ralf was all over the place. he constantly threw his car off the road, and often took others with him. Including taking his team-mate out of a race-winning position and his brother out of a title-winning one. Give JPM 3 years of F1 race experience and IMHO he'll be running the show. (What show, lol!) -- Cheers! Graeme Nash
hey - thats what the guy said - i was just being sarcastic... "Jan Verschueren" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > The scary part is he for a fleeting second wondered whether it was validfor
Quoted text (13 lines)> him to do so. > > Jan. > =--- > "Pay attention when I'm talking to you boy!" -Foghorn Leghorn. > > "Thom j." wrote... > > Sure you are Nick, Rate away! Won't be any better or any > > worse then anyone here.. It's all subjective anyway!! :) > > > >
David Karr wrote: > amazing how some people in this ng can take a fairly irreverent post and > make WW3 out of it . . . I prefer to think of it as good sport. :) Marty
Quoted text (79 lines)> > > David G Fisher <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:JYWe7.109272$[email hidden]... > > I think if anyone here at r.a.s. actually had the guts (impossible) to > tell > > one of todays F1 drivers that modern F1 was all car and little driver, > that > > driver would laugh in their face and then tell them to "piss off you > fool". > > If someone here told them that what they were doing was easy compared to > > drivers in the past, they'd call them an old timer who's stuck in the past > > and doesn't have a clue. > > > > Whenever I hear someone try and put down what an F1 driver of today is > > doing, I'm reminded of an old time NFL star player named Chuck Bednarick. > > Whenever he's given the chance, he goes on and on about how the players in > > his era (the 60's) were better and tougher than today's players. Senile > > Chuck doesn't have a clue that he wouldn't even sniff a roster spot on a > > modern NFL team. He'd be lucky to be allowed to paint the lines on the > > field. > > > > Just like Chuck, I don't think many of the drivers from the past would be > > able to compete in today's F1. > > > > Old time brain surgeons were better than those of today because all they > > needed to operate was a rusty butter knife. Astronauts of today don't > really > > do anything because of all the technology. They just sit there and drink > > Tang. Fred Flintstone was the greatest driver of all time. That guy could > do > > it all in the most basic car ever created. > > > > Ed, to be honest, I think you and just about everyone else here at r.a.s. > > would probably shit your pants on the first lap if given the chance to > drive > > MS's Ferrari. Your head would feel like it's being ripped off. Your body > > would be battered and bruised. You'd rather have your nuts cut off then > even > > consider braking at the 100 meter mark when doing 180mph. You wouldn't get > > within a million miles of pushing *the limit*, and therefor still wouldn't > > have any idea what an F1 driver of today is doing. They are the best > drivers > > in the world. The cars are the best in the world. That's why F1 draws 350 > > million viewers per race. It's an ENORMOUS success. Name another sporting > > event which even comes close. NASCAR draws a measly (in comparison) 8-13 > > million per race. > > > > To all the Fred Flintsones in this group, please stop living in the past. > > > > David G Fisher > > > > > > "Ed Solheim" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > > news:_EMe7.154$[email hidden]... > > > Do you actually think *any* of todays F1 drivers (apart from Jacques > that > > > is) would say any thing else ?? -- Does Bernie Ecclestone ring a > > bell?? > > > > > > If you want an honest oppinion on F1 - go ask someone who *used* to do > it. > > > > > > -- > > > ed_ > > > > > > DGF'ed: > > > > > > > For those who go on and on and on and on and on and on about which sim > > is > > > so > > > > realistic compared to all others, here's a little shot of perspective. > > He > > > > also responds to the whiners who say F1 is all technology, and little > > > about > > > > the actual drivers. > > > > > > > >
Top Sirloin wrote:
Quoted text (7 lines)> On Thu, 16 Aug 2001 11:43:37 -0700, Marty U'Ren > <[email hidden]> wrote: > > >Good point. We should never assume car in a team are equal. > > At Williams they are. Frank puts the constructors championship above > the drivers, and gives each driver the best equipment possible.
You know this how....?
RAS is notoriously bad at detecting sarcasm... use of sarcasm tags (<sarcasm> </sarcasm>) is advised. Jan. ;-) =--- "Pay attention when I'm talking to you boy!" -Foghorn Leghorn. "Nick G" wrote... > hey - thats what the guy said - i was just being sarcastic... > > <snip>
Does that mean that someone that WANTS to only rate the drivers that they have seen in person, Can't? One should be able to rate them however they like don't you think? Especially without having someone tell them they were wrong for doing so? It's all opinion no matter how you do it, and how can one persons opinion be wrong?
Well finally another has seen the light! :) Touche` ed_ "Ed Solheim" wrote: <znipped> | I could probably go on and on with this mail - but why bother, you're | clearly a so called F1 "fan" - and no motorsports enthusiast. | -- | ed_ --- Outgoing mail is certified Virus Free. Checked by AVG anti-virus system (http://www.grisoft.com). Version: 6.0.265 / Virus Database: 137 - Release Date: 7/18/2001
Nick G wrote: > as any racing driver knows, the most important sense when driving a car > near/on the limit is feel. you feel the rear wheels begin to lose grip long > before anybody could see it visually. you correct movements imperceptible to > the human eye. most racing is reacting to things which cannot be taught by a > computer simulation. You are wrong if not alone in not understanding how a computer driving simulation can produce a 'real' driving experience. As one with a long time fascination with the nature of competitive driving and with on track and sim racing experience I have come to understand why to two are fundamentally the same. It is, as you said, about feel...feel of the car's reactions to your inputs.. That feel comes from the driver's brain processing the inputs available to it. While computer sims do lack one important input, g-force to the driver's body, the bests sims are able to communicate well enough through visual and audible outputs that the driver's mind can learn to 'feel' the g-forces being modeled by the computer. Notice I said 'can learn'. How well this is learned is a skill like any other. Some will be better at it than others. Some will learn it quicker while other's can become as good with more practice as with any skill. Make no mistake the feeling is very real to the sim driver. The feeling of controlling a car at the limit of the car's and driver's potential is the same in a good simulation as it is in a real car, which is not to say a real car isn't more satisfying. > so don't tell me gpl is realistic. yeah sure it can help a retard on how to > go round corners, but not how to adjust the car using weight distribution > when the feel through the steering wheel and seat, and the slightly altering > tyre noises tell you alot more than plain visuals can. There are many accounts of people who didn't enjoy GPL when they first got it. After seeing how much others were getting out of it tried again and after enough practice found it to be a fantastic driving experience. It's sad you haven't been able to get to the point of enjoying the feeling of driving one of the most challenging forms of motorsport that GPL simulates so well.
Quoted text (9 lines)> one of the most obvious points is how many racing games (especially rally > games) model the clutch? gpl does but using it or not makes little > difference. side-stepping the clutch, double-declutching and heel-toe > movements are all required to get fast times in a rally car, but does any > racing sim model the clutch? does any set of steering wheel/pedals have a > clutch pedal? i think not. electronics are bad, semi-auto 'boxes and > suchlike should be outlawed, wings removed, and no traction control, abs, > esc or any other electronical aids should be allowed. then the best driver > in the world can be named.
Whether a sim models the function of the clutch pedal is irrelevant to the fundamentals of how well it models the driving experience. I tend to agree driving aids have hurt some forms of motorsport but there are plenty of others that restrict various technologies and produce some of the best racing. Marty
You're pretty old, aren't you? David G Fisher "rrevved" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > On Fri, 17 Aug 2001 01:51:32 GMT, "David G Fisher" <[email hidden]>wrote: > > >I think it's a lot harder to manually shift a modern F1 car than an older > >car (from the 60's for example) because the revs are so much higher, andthe > >cars are so much quicker and faster. > > ROFL!!!!!!!!!!! >
"Ed Solheim" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:pwaf7.446$[email hidden]... > I'm not talking about the 60's or 70's at all.. all I'm saying is thatall > these aid's have runied the sport. They have undoubtly made F1 easier... > take Kimi Raikonen for instance.. his 23rd *ever* car race and he scoresa > point in F1??? It's called young, natural talent. Guys his age and with his experience dominate in all sports. Tiger Woods puts men with 20 years more of pro experience to shame. Who's to say Raikkonen wouldn't have scored a point in F1 in '90', '80, '65? You don't know. > You might think F1 is the most awesome thing on earth - I don't. > Imho - F1 is dieing... Yep, nobody's watching it anymore. > I could probably go on and on with this mail - but why bother, you're > clearly a so called F1 "fan" - and no motorsports enthusiast. And you're clearly a guy who pines for the "old days". There are fans like you in every sport. Always talking about how it used to be better. I don't know why I bother either, especially after I read this quote from you, "Modern day F1 is just one giant yaaaaaaaawn... The cars suck, the tracks suck, the FIA sucks and the competition in general sucks." David G Fisher
Marty U'Ren <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > It is, as you said, about feel...feel of the car's reactions to yourinputs.. > That feel comes from the driver's brain processing the inputsavailable to it. > Make no mistake the feeling is very real to the sim driver. Thefeeling of Totally agree. As I've mentioned in similar threads in the past, the same applies to R/C model racing. We talk about the way the car "feels" to drive, and mean it. I've "felt" parts come loose on my model cars many times - if not in a totally specific way, at least enough to say "that's not right" and bring it in for inspection - and I can immediately "feel" the effect of setup changes, just as I can in GPL, Gran Turismo or GP2. Noticed this evening that the "feeling" of the tail of my road car starting to become light under trailbraking is very much like GPL - except that in GPL, whenever I try to trailbrake I spin it :-( Jonny
First of all, old man, you've "LOL" at something which you have now proved you didn't read carefully. I said "manually shift a modern F1 car". The cars previous to this season. So LOL. The drivers have al;ready proved they can do it, so big deal. As for your little story about shifting below...........I used to spend a lot of time on motocross motorcycles. Two wheels. No protection, except me as a buffer for the bike if I happened to hit one of those trees five feet to my right or left as I ripped down an undulating, unknown dirt road full of rocks, gulleys, fallen branches, etc. at 100mph. Throttle and front brake with one hand. Clutch with the other. One foot shifting. Other foot rear braking. Shifting my weight constantly. Big deal. With practice it all quickly becomes second nature. For you, me, and those drivers you drool over form the past. David G Fisher "rrevved" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > On Fri, 17 Aug 2001 19:48:35 GMT, "David G Fisher" <[email hidden]>wrote:
Quoted text (24 lines)> > >You're pretty old, aren't you? > > > >David G Fisher > > > > Yep, I'm ancient. > > But, in my 58 year old opinion, it's harder to drive with one hand > on the wheel with the other trying to navigate and jerk it's way > through a gated, non-synchro gearbox, with the right side of > your right foot blipping the throttle while the left side of your > right foot operates the brake and your left foot stabs at the > clutch while approaching a corner at full cry at 180 mph with > other drivers trying to overtake you. > > You might want to try to contrast this scenario with pushing a > wheel button, on a modern F1 car, while cornering all alone. > > Again, I say to you ... LOL. > > >"rrevved" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > >news:[email hidden]... > >> On Fri, 17 Aug 2001 01:51:32 GMT, "David G Fisher"
<[email hidden]> > >wrote: > >> > >> >I think it's a lot harder to manually shift a modern F1 car than anolder > >> >car (from the 60's for example) because the revs are so much higher,and > >the > >> >cars are so much quicker and faster. > >> > >> ROFL!!!!!!!!!!! > >> >
"rrevved" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > On Fri, 17 Aug 2001 20:48:29 GMT, "David G Fisher" <[email hidden]>wrote: > > >First of all, old man, you've "LOL" at something which you have nowproved > >you didn't read carefully. I said "manually shift a modern F1 car". Thecars > >previous to this season. So LOL. > > > >The drivers have al;ready proved they can do it, so big deal. As for your > >little story about shifting below...........I used to spend a lot of timeon > >motocross motorcycles. Two wheels. No protection, except me as a bufferfor > >the bike if I happened to hit one of those trees five feet to my right or > >left as I ripped down an undulating, unknown dirt road full of rocks, > >gulleys, fallen branches, etc. at 100mph. Throttle and front brake withone
Quoted text (9 lines)> >hand. Clutch with the other. One foot shifting. Other foot rear braking. > >Shifting my weight constantly. > > > > I'm glad for your bike experience, son, but I spent a lot of years > in SCCA in FV, FF, CSR, BP. I held an SCCA National and FIA license. > My last racecar was a Lotus XI Le Mans, chassis #247. > > I have done what I described in my post. A lot.
Yea, and so what? You SHOULD have the same view on shifting then as I do since you did it "a lot". It's not brain surgery. You drove cars. EVERYBODY can drive a car. You made a big deal out of the process of manual shifting, and acted like it's a concept that only guys like you and your heroes of the past can understand, and a modern F1 driver can't dream of doing. So many of a certain "type" here at r.a.s. make such a big, fat hairy, deal out of crap like that. I don't. My self-esteem doesn't get pumped up because I can MANUALLY SHIFT a motocross bike as I described above. If only revved could get the chance to drive in today's F1. He'd show 'em. David G Fisher
>"David G Fisher" <[email hidden]> wrote So, he was talking about F1RC? ;-) -- -- Fran�ois M�nard <ymenard> -- May the Downforce be with you... -- http://www.ymenard.com/ -- This announcement is brought to you by the Shimato Dominguez Corporation - helping America into the New World...
ymenard 17 Aug 2001 21:43 UTC↳ reply to Nick G#167371
>"Nick G" <[email hidden]> wrote > but stick the world champion gpl racer in even a 996 turbo > somewhere like oulton park, and they will be soooo crap it will bepathetic. That's about true, and the opposite is totally acceptable also. I always said that racing simulations are on their own, it's a new form of racing that cannot be compared to reality. Well it's reality within itself. That's why most of us admire GPL, because it's a single form of racing, even if it's not really "real-life" racing. But is it really important? There's no absolute definition of "racing". -- -- Fran�ois M�nard <ymenard> -- May the Downforce be with you... -- http://www.ymenard.com/ -- This announcement is brought to you by the Shimato Dominguez Corporation - helping America into the New World...
Hey Guys, I`ve noticed a few posts in this thread talking about how the aids being used in todays F1 cars have a negative effect on F1. It`s obvious that some people are of the opnion that true driver skill becomes harder to notice as more aids are introduced, some even think that just about anyone could drive a F1 car these days. While I don`t have a strong opnion on the subject, I just thought I`d post what Schumacher had to say about it (in case anyone missed it). Technology has evolved over the last decade in Formula One, but championship leader Michael Schumacher insists that technology has not shifted the balance from the driver. He explained why not when he said: "I see it like this: You are able to be more constantly at the limit [of the car] with it [better electronics] and you don't have to take care of any power peaks of the engine. It gives us more freedom to drive a bit faster. And the ability to handle the car permanently on the limit is what makes a good driver". Jaguar Racing's CEO of their Premier Performance Division Niki Lauda said recently that with the introduction of electronic driver aids even a monkey could drive a F1 car. Michael Schumacher refuted this when he said: "I mean, now, with all the electronics you can use, there are people who say monkeys could drive these cars. But believe me: they could not, at least not as fast" Lorne
"Jon Crooke" wrote...
Quoted text (11 lines)> <snip> > Hi Nick, > > My name is Jon Crooke. In 1986 I won the Australian F2 > Championship in one of the worlds last ground effects cars. > You know, over 4 G's lateral Forces and brakes that pop > your eyeballs. I've also raced every thing from Sprint > Karts to Superkarts to non-ground effects open wheelers > to V8 Supercars. Retired from professional race driving > with the all-time highest career win rate at National level > racing. Know a thing or two about driving, I do.
Impressive record Jon. Can I ask you something? (rethoric... I'm going to anyway!! ;-)) Would you consider simracing more a surrogate for real racing (some of the thrills and sensations for a fraction of the cost and without the risk of injury), more a hobby (like model trains) or more a sport (like golf)? Jan. =--- "Pay attention when I'm talking to you boy!" -Foghorn Leghorn.
I'm not saying Jon doesn't really believe what he wrote about sims in this thread, but, how could he say anything else when he's asking people to pay a lot of money for a hyperstim? David G Fisher "Jan Verschueren" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]...
Quoted text (26 lines)> "Jon Crooke" wrote... > > <snip> > > Hi Nick, > > > > My name is Jon Crooke. In 1986 I won the Australian F2 > > Championship in one of the worlds last ground effects cars. > > You know, over 4 G's lateral Forces and brakes that pop > > your eyeballs. I've also raced every thing from Sprint > > Karts to Superkarts to non-ground effects open wheelers > > to V8 Supercars. Retired from professional race driving > > with the all-time highest career win rate at National level > > racing. Know a thing or two about driving, I do. > > Impressive record Jon. Can I ask you something? (rethoric... I'm going to > anyway!! ;-)) > > Would you consider simracing more a surrogate for real racing (some of the > thrills and sensations for a fraction of the cost and without the risk of > injury), more a hobby (like model trains) or more a sport (like golf)? > > Jan. > =--- > "Pay attention when I'm talking to you boy!" -Foghorn Leghorn. > > >
Here`s another way to compare sim vs real, or more to the point, if sim skills can be related to any real world driving skills. If given a few months of practice in the real 996 Turbo who do you think would be faster; One of the top GPL sim racers on the planet, or someone who`s been playing GPL for years but hasn`t even got to the point where he could be considered a mid-pack GPL racer ? I tend to think that if you`re a very fast sim racer [chances are] you`d make a better real life racer than someone who can`t do very well at sims no matter how hard they try. Btw, I also believe that if they were to put the time into it, any top racer in real life would probably do very well at simulation racing. Lorne "ymenard" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:Obgf7.48897$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (10 lines)> >"Nick G" <[email hidden]> wrote > > but stick the world champion gpl racer in even a 996 turbo > > somewhere like oulton park, and they will be soooo crap it will be > pathetic. > > > That's about true, and the opposite is totally acceptable also. I always > said that racing simulations are on their own, it's a new form of racing > that cannot be compared to reality. Well it's reality within itself. > That's why most of us admire GPL, because it's a single form of racing,
even > if it's not really "real-life" racing. But is it really important? > > There's no absolute definition of "racing".
And in which way does this little gem relate to my question? I asked him a question on how he personally experiences racing sims. What makes you think he'd turn his reply into an advert? He didn't even plug Hyperstim in his original reply. To tell you the truth, I didn't notice the connection until I snipped his return address from my reply. Jan. =--- "Pay attention when I'm talking to you boy!" -Foghorn Leghorn. "David G Fisher" wrote... > I'm not saying Jon doesn't really believe what he wrote > about sims in this thread, but, how could he say anything > else when he's asking people to pay a lot of money for a > hyperstim?
David G Fisher took a deep breath and coughed up: > I'm not saying Jon doesn't really believe what he wrote about sims in this > thread, but, how could he say anything else when he's asking people to pay a > lot of money for a hyperstim? So, according to you, he's either deluded or lying? You really are pathetic! Now David, are you trolling or are you just plain stupid? Come on, you can tell us. Gerry "I have a very good life, and I made it this way by avoiding the way of thinking of "the average guy"." -- David G Fisher, talking about his life living rough on the street.
Gee rrevved, you of all people should have learned by now that any discussion made with "you know who" is wasted space.. :) "rrevved" wrote: | [sigh] | | *plonk* --- Outgoing mail is certified Virus Free. Checked by AVG anti-virus system (http://www.grisoft.com). Version: 6.0.265 / Virus Database: 137 - Release Date: 7/18/2001
DFG'ed again: > > You might think F1 is the most awesome thing on earth - I don't. > > Imho - F1 is dieing... > > Yep, nobody's watching it anymore. See! Bernie got you fooled allready. -- ed_
Ed Solheim 18 Aug 2001 00:21 UTC#528364
DFG'ed again: See! Bernie got you fooled allready. -- ed_
In article <[email hidden]>, Gerry Aitken <[email hidden]> writes:
Quoted text (10 lines)>Nick G wrote: > >> does any set of steering wheel/pedals have a clutch pedal? > >Yes. > >> i think not. > >You'd be wrong AGAIN then. >
My TSW2mod has a clutch pedal. I'm not USING it at the moment, but it's available...<g> Eldred -- Dale Earnhardt, Sr. R.I.P. 1951-2001 Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett F1 hcp. +16.36...Monster +366.59... Never argue with an idiot. He brings you down to his level, then beats you with experience... Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.
Patrick Head and Frank Williams have stated this on numerous occasions over the last decade or so. They purely concentrate on the constructors championship, the drivers is a secondary consideration. Rafe Mc On Fri, 17 Aug 2001 11:06:17 -0700, Marty U'Ren <[email hidden]> wrote:
Quoted text (13 lines)> > >Top Sirloin wrote: > >> On Thu, 16 Aug 2001 11:43:37 -0700, Marty U'Ren >> <[email hidden]> wrote: >> >> >Good point. We should never assume car in a team are equal. >> >> At Williams they are. Frank puts the constructors championship above >> the drivers, and gives each driver the best equipment possible. > >You know this how....?
Totally agree there, on the money. Rafe Mc On Fri, 17 Aug 2001 18:45:32 +0100, Graeme Nash <[email hidden]> wrote:
Quoted text (19 lines)> >>Was he an F1 test driver and CART champion before his first season in F1? >>They are both the same age BTW. > >No. But he had extensive experience in Formula Nippon and a fair amount >of F1 testing. > >>Excuses can be made for Montoya, but the fact is RS has had significantly >>better results in the same car. > >Not my point at all. > >The point is, in his first season, Ralf was all over the place. he >constantly threw his car off the road, and often took others with him. >Including taking his team-mate out of a race-winning position and his >brother out of a title-winning one. > >Give JPM 3 years of F1 race experience and IMHO he'll be running the >show. (What show, lol!)
Too true. On Sat, 18 Aug 2001 00:19:52 GMT, "Thom j." <[email hidden]> wrote:
Quoted text (15 lines)>Gee rrevved, you of all people should have learned by now that >any discussion made with "you know who" is wasted space.. :) > >"rrevved" wrote: >| [sigh] >| >| *plonk* > > > >--- >Outgoing mail is certified Virus Free. >Checked by AVG anti-virus system (http://www.grisoft.com). >Version: 6.0.265 / Virus Database: 137 - Release Date: 7/18/2001 >
>"David G Fisher" <[email hidden]> wrote > I'm not saying Jon doesn't really believe what he wrote about sims in this > thread, but, how could he say anything else when he's asking people to paya > lot of money for a hyperstim? Shut up. Now. -- -- Fran�ois M�nard <ymenard> -- May the Downforce be with you... -- http://www.ymenard.com/ -- This announcement is brought to you by the Shimato Dominguez Corporation - helping America into the New World...
I thought nobody noticed that. MS would be 4 time World Champion if his own brother didn't throw him out. BTW, I was watching German F3 with Ralf. In short, he was uncapable of better than 3rd or 4th place, but was overambitious, 'cos his brother is WC, so he drove the same way. "Graeme Nash" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]...
Quoted text (7 lines)> > The point is, in his first season, Ralf was all over the place. he > constantly threw his car off the road, and often took others with him. > Including taking his team-mate out of a race-winning position and his > brother out of a title-winning one. >
Good talk Marty. "Marty U'Ren" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > Nick G wrote: > > > as any racing driver knows, the most important sense when driving a car > > near/on the limit is feel. you feel the rear wheels begin to lose griplong > > before anybody could see it visually. you correct movementsimperceptible to > > the human eye. most racing is reacting to things which cannot be taughtby a > > computer simulation. > > You are wrong if not alone in not understanding how a computer driving > simulation can produce a 'real' driving experience. As one with a longtime > fascination with the nature of competitive driving and with on track andsim > racing experience I have come to understand why to two are fundamentallythe > same. > > It is, as you said, about feel...feel of the car's reactions to yourinputs.. > That feel comes from the driver's brain processing the inputs available toit. > While computer sims do lack one important input, g-force to the driver'sbody, > the bests sims are able to communicate well enough through visual andaudible > outputs that the driver's mind can learn to 'feel' the g-forces beingmodeled by > the computer. Notice I said 'can learn'. How well this is learned is askill > like any other. Some will be better at it than others. Some will learn it > quicker while other's can become as good with more practice as with anyskill. > Make no mistake the feeling is very real to the sim driver. The feeling of > controlling a car at the limit of the car's and driver's potential is thesame > in a good simulation as it is in a real car, which is not to say a realcar > isn't more satisfying. > > > so don't tell me gpl is realistic. yeah sure it can help a retard on howto > > go round corners, but not how to adjust the car using weightdistribution > > when the feel through the steering wheel and seat, and the slightlyaltering > > tyre noises tell you alot more than plain visuals can. > > There are many accounts of people who didn't enjoy GPL when they first gotit. > After seeing how much others were getting out of it tried again and afterenough > practice found it to be a fantastic driving experience. > > It's sad you haven't been able to get to the point of enjoying the feelingof > driving one of the most challenging forms of motorsport that GPL simulatesso > well. > > > one of the most obvious points is how many racing games (especiallyrally > > games) model the clutch? gpl does but using it or not makes little > > difference. side-stepping the clutch, double-declutching and heel-toe > > movements are all required to get fast times in a rally car, but doesany > > racing sim model the clutch? does any set of steering wheel/pedals havea > > clutch pedal? i think not. electronics are bad, semi-auto 'boxes and > > suchlike should be outlawed, wings removed, and no traction control,abs, > > esc or any other electronical aids should be allowed. then the bestdriver > > in the world can be named. > > Whether a sim models the function of the clutch pedal is irrelevant to the > fundamentals of how well it models the driving experience. > > I tend to agree driving aids have hurt some forms of motorsport but thereare > plenty of others that restrict various technologies and produce some ofthe best > racing. > > Marty >
On 17/8/01 "Rafe McAuliffe" wrote: > When did you race in the V8's? > We'll have to hope that this GPL Bathurst track gets properly > sorted :) > Jon, I've read that there are a fair few drivers like Russell > Ingall and Greg Moore who use (and used) the hyprestimulator. What sims did > they use with it? And how did it compare to their racing? Hi Rafe > When did you race in the V8's?Co-drove with Brock for HDT in the VL's for the 1987 season. > We'll have to hope that this GPL Bathurst track gets properly sorted :)Working day and night with Chris Kelly (the developer of the Bathurst track). I have enlisted the help of Owen Kelly and Russell Ingall. So between 3 Bathurst V8 Supercar drivers and Chris, we hope to get it as close to real as we can. We've made some big changes over the last week and the run over the top of the mountain is now near perfect. Really captures the "roller coaster" feel. > Jon, I've read that there are a fair few drivers like Russell > Ingall and Greg Moore who use (and used) the hyprestimulator. What sims did > they use with it?Almost all the younger V8 drivers, including Russell, and quite a few of our top F/Ford drivers own Hypers, as do many Indycar drivers. We have also many very top end and VERY famous European (German) drivers who own Hypers but wish to remain anonymous. Except for some of the American drivers, almost all drive GPL and ONLY GPL. > And how did it compare to their racing?The Austalian V8 drivers reckon GPL feels like a V8 Supercar in the wet. We have a Hyper Stimulator Race Center in Melbourne Australia where the V8 boy's get together on a regular basis and race all night on a 7 way LAN set-up. And let me tell you these guys can steer. Jason Bargwanna had never driven Milano before and after a 15 min practice, qualified with a 2.16:82. Garth Tander was only 1/10th behind. Steven Richards and Paul Dumbrell were in the low 17's. Cheers Jon.
"Lorne Glustein" wrote... <snip> > Michael Schumacher > refuted this when he said: "I mean, now, with all the electronics you > can use, there are people who say monkeys could drive these cars. > But believe me: they could not, at least not as fast" AHA! MS admits that monkeys could drive modern F1! AHA! ;-) I can see a whole new sport coming on... It combines features from some of the most popular TV shows: motor racing and vet programs (oh, and apes means we can attract WWF viewers too). Now if we can factor in makeovers for the colour schemes and styling ("Darling, all this carbon fibre is soooo 1990's. We'll throw it all out and replace it with wood.") we have a sure-fire winner. And I'll bet they would overtake. -- Tony Whitley GPLRank -0.54 MonsterRank 407 and falling... "On some laps I'd get as many as fifteen corners really right, but Moss, he gets them all right on every lap" - Von Trips after the 1961 German Grand Prix.
"David G Fisher" wrote...
Quoted text (7 lines)> > "Ed Solheim" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:pwaf7.446$[email hidden]... > > > I'm not talking about the 60's or 70's at all.. all I'm saying is that > all > > these aid's have runied the sport. They have undoubtly made F1
easier... > > take Kimi Raikonen for instance.. his 23rd *ever* car race and hescores > a > > point in F1??? > > It's called young, natural talent. Guys his age and with his experience > dominate in all sports. Tiger Woods puts men with 20 years more of pro > experience to shame.Err, Tiger Woods has been playing golf since he was three AFAIK. He's played s l i g h t l y more than 23 rounds. -- Tony Whitley
Kewl idea Tony.. Monkey F1 "Racing" hahahaha. Now if we can only get Michael Jackson's monkey aka chimp to "race" :) "Tony Whitley" wrote:
Quoted text (14 lines)| | "Lorne Glustein" wrote... | <snip> | > Michael Schumacher | > refuted this when he said: "I mean, now, with all the electronics you | > can use, there are people who say monkeys could drive these cars. | > But believe me: they could not, at least not as fast" | | AHA! MS admits that monkeys could drive modern F1! AHA! | | ;-) | | I can see a whole new sport coming on... It combines features from some of | the most popular TV shows: motor racing and vet programs (oh, and apes
means | we can attract WWF viewers too). Now if we can factor in makeovers for the | colour schemes and styling ("Darling, all this carbon fibre is soooo1990's.
Quoted text (12 lines)| We'll throw it all out and replace it with wood.") we have a sure-fire | winner. | | And I'll bet they would overtake. | | | -- | | Tony Whitley | GPLRank -0.54 | MonsterRank 407 and falling... | "On some laps I'd get as many as fifteen corners really right, but Moss,
he
Quoted text (8 lines)| gets them all right on every lap" - Von Trips after the 1961 German Grand | Prix. | | | | | |
--- Outgoing mail is certified Virus Free. Checked by AVG anti-virus system (http://www.grisoft.com). Version: 6.0.265 / Virus Database: 137 - Release Date: 7/18/2001
Gerry Aitken wrote:
Quoted text (9 lines)> David G Fisher took a deep breath and coughed up: > > > I'm not saying Jon doesn't really believe what he wrote about sims in this > > thread, but, how could he say anything else when he's asking people to pay a > > lot of money for a hyperstim? > > So, according to you, he's either deluded or lying? You really are > pathetic! Now David, are you trolling or are you just plain stupid? Come > on, you can tell us.
Worse, it's a sad need for attention.
Quoted text (7 lines)> > > Gerry > > "I have a very good life, and I made it this way by avoiding the way of > thinking of "the average guy"." -- David G Fisher, talking about his > life living rough on the street.
Please, you, Thom, Gerry, Edwin, and revved, put me in your killfile. Some of you have promised to do this in the past but keep replying to my posts. Who needs attention? A little review of the last 24 hours. Friday practice. Montoya was going every way but forward while RS was smooth and under control. RS qualified fourth, .8 higher than JM who finished eighth (typical result this season). The so called *rookie* Montoya (same age as RS-26, CART vet, F1 test driver, F3000 driver) was matched by Raikkonen (who must be a rookie rookie rookie rookie rookie compared to Montoya) in a lesser car. Which leads me to....... The Speedvision announcers (hear me revved and ED) commented that the drivers are sliding the cars even more this year because, as Coulthard said, the drivers are pushing the cars even harder due to the traction control (one of those terrible aids which makes F1 so easy for the drivers) making the cars faster. Ask Sven what he learned about the ability it takes to catch the rear end of these modern F1 cars when it breaks loose. BTW, some of the same guys who say the aids in F1 make it too easy for the drivers make excuses for Montoya coming up short against RS. As for my comments on Jon and his opinions on sims.......I'd like you sell you a $2,000 add-on to your daughters Razor scooter. A Razor scooter isn't just a toy, it's a serious piece of training equipment which will enable her to be a top motorcyclist racer someday. You need this add-on. Yep, you kids really did a great job in this thread. David G Fisher "Marty U'Ren" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > > Worse, it's a sad need for attention. >
David G Fisher wrote: > > Please, you, Thom, Gerry, Edwin, and revved, put me in your killfile. Some > of you have promised to do this in the past but keep replying to my posts. > Who needs attention? Hehe, yes indeed, DGF! But maybe I should explain, for those that don't understand, DGF is one of my 'merry men', one of my collection of trolls I keep 'safe' in my fillfile. When I get bored...last night I was very bored...I like to take one of my 'merry men' out of my killfile and have him dance for my amusement. And last night was DGF's turn. Gerry
Quoted text (12 lines)>> When did you race in the V8's? >Co-drove with Brock for HDT in the VL's for the 1987 season. > >> We'll have to hope that this GPL Bathurst track gets properly sorted :) >Working day and night with Chris Kelly (the developer of the Bathurst >track). >I have enlisted the help of Owen Kelly and Russell Ingall. So between 3 >Bathurst V8 Supercar drivers and Chris, we hope to get it as close to real >as we can. We've made some big changes over the last week and the run over >the top of the mountain is now near perfect. Really captures the "roller >coaster" feel. >
GREAT news :D Looking forward to it. To have some v8 drivers on the project is fantastic. I assumed it was only going to be a fan's perspective on how they guessed it would be like, but this is pretty cool.
Quoted text (9 lines)>> Jon, I've read that there are a fair few drivers like Russell >> Ingall and Greg Moore who use (and used) the hyprestimulator. What sims did >> they use with it? >Almost all the younger V8 drivers, including Russell, and quite a few of our >top F/Ford drivers own Hypers, as do many Indycar drivers. We have also many >very top end and VERY famous European (German) drivers who own Hypers but >wish to remain anonymous. >Except for some of the American drivers, almost all drive GPL and ONLY GPL. >
Friend of mine Paul Freestone (NASCAR and GTP Lotus driver) has a Hyperstim with GPL, I only wish I was able to drive it more. :D I'm surprised that there aren't any other sims that are generally used, but then again no others really compare, do they?
Quoted text (9 lines)>> And how did it compare to their racing? >The Austalian V8 drivers reckon GPL feels like a V8 Supercar in the wet. >We have a Hyper Stimulator Race Center in Melbourne Australia where the V8 >boy's get together on a regular basis and race all night on a 7 way LAN >set-up. And let me tell you these guys can steer. Jason Bargwanna had never >driven Milano before and after a 15 min practice, qualified with a 2.16:82. >Garth Tander was only 1/10th behind. Steven Richards and Paul Dumbrell were >in the low 17's. >
Is this in Lilydale? I guess so, but that's a hell of a trip for me from Essendon way. Still, I'll have to check it out next time you're racing. Do you have this info posted on your website, dates, times, etc.? I had a decent look, but couldn't find any info. Be great to see the v8 guns racing in gpl, even better to see it at the Bathurst track (when its done). Rafe Mc >Cheers Jon.
Quoted text (12 lines)>> We have a Hyper Stimulator Race Center in Melbourne Australia where the V8 >> boy's get together on a regular basis and race all night on a 7 way LAN >> set-up. >> > Is this in Lilydale? I guess so, but that's a hell of a trip for me > from Essendon way. Still, I'll have to check it out next time you're > racing. Do you have this info posted on your website, dates, times, > etc.? I had a decent look, but couldn't find any info. Be great to see > the v8 guns racing in gpl, even better to see it at the Bathurst track > (when its done). > > Rafe
Yes Lilydale. But it's a night off for them, so they don't like spectators. Sorry. Jon.
SODA! David G Fisher wrote:
Quoted text (47 lines)> > NASCAR! > > Dacid G Fisher > > "Pat Dotson" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:[email hidden]... > > You're an ass. > > > > David G Fisher wrote: > > > > > > As I said in the other post, "Compared to many people in this world who > > > struggle to have enough to eat or a safe place to sleep, he was > privileged. > > > Was his family at least lower > > > middle-class to middle-class before he aeaned his first paycheck as an > F1 > > > driver? Most kids in that position while growing up in a western country > had > > > a lot of access to video games." > > > > > > As far as I'm concerned, almost everyone who lives in a Western country > in > > > the second half of the 20th century/beginning of the 21st century is > > > "privileged" compared to the rest of the current world, and the 50 > billion > > > or so who have walked this planet since the beginning of mankind. Add in > the > > > all the other living creatures like cute little bunny rabbits, > elephants, > > > ants, and dinasours, and the difficulty of their lives, and I don't > think a > > > construction worker in modern day Germany is really that tough a life. > > > That's my personal opinion. I think most people are a bunch of cry baby > > > whiners (doesn't mean they are necessarily bad) and don't have a clue > how > > > tough life can really be. > > > > > > Were going off waaaaaaay off on another r.a.s. tangent. The point is, MS > had > > > access to video games while growing up. If someone is reading this post > and > > > doens't have a clue why we are talking about this "privileged" stuff, > you're > > > not alone. > > > > > > David G Fisher
In article <[email hidden]>, Pat Dotson <[email hidden]> writes:
Quoted text (14 lines)> >SODA! > >David G Fisher wrote: >> >> NASCAR! >> >> Dacid G Fisher >> >> "Pat Dotson" <[email hidden]> wrote in message >> news:[email hidden]... >> > You're an ass. >> > >> > David G Fisher wrote:
PEPSI! Eldred -- Dale Earnhardt, Sr. R.I.P. 1951-2001 Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett F1 hcp. +16.36...Monster +366.59... Never argue with an idiot. He brings you down to his level, then beats you with experience... Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.
EldredP wrote:
Quoted text (19 lines)><[email hidden]> writes: > > > > >SODA! > > > >David G Fisher wrote: > >> > >> NASCAR! > >> > >> Dacid G Fisher > >> > >> "Pat Dotson" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > >> news:[email hidden]... > >> > You're an ass. > >> > > >> > David G Fisher wrote: > > PEPSI! >
COKE! -- ed_
Ed Solheim 19 Aug 2001 20:24 UTC#528373
Quoted text (18 lines)> >SODA! > >> NASCAR! > >> Dacid G Fisher > >> > You're an ass. > PEPSI!
COKE! -- ed_
"Ed Solheim" wrote...
Quoted text (24 lines)> > EldredP wrote: > ><[email hidden]> writes: > > > > > > > >SODA! > > > > > >David G Fisher wrote: > > >> > > >> NASCAR! > > >> > > >> Dacid G Fisher > > >> > > >> "Pat Dotson" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > > >> news:[email hidden]... > > >> > You're an ass. > > >> > > > >> > David G Fisher wrote: > > > > PEPSI! > > > > COKE! >
CRACK!
Tony Whitley 19 Aug 2001 21:48 UTC#528374
"Ed Solheim" wrote...
Quoted text (20 lines)> > >SODA! > > >> NASCAR! > > >> Dacid G Fisher > > >> > You're an ass. > > PEPSI! > COKE!
CRACK!
Nce race results today for Montoya. RS finished 4th. JM finished eighth. At least 30 seconds behind RS. Nice pass by JM on Panis BTW. For some reason the rookie rookie rookie rookie rookie Raikkonen finished higher than JM. David G Fisher "David G Fisher" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:iwBf7.115579$[email hidden]... > A little review of the last 24 hours. > > Friday practice. Montoya was going every way but forward while RS wassmooth > and under control. > > RS qualified fourth, .8 higher than JM who finished eighth (typical result > this season). The so called *rookie* Montoya (same age as RS-26, CART vet, > F1 test driver, F3000 driver) was matched by Raikkonen (who must be arookie > rookie rookie rookie rookie compared to Montoya) in a lesser car.
You certainly could have a Cameron Diaz simulator! You could have VR goggles, silicon for the "fun" parts, and they could engineer something that felt like real skin and, errr, other stuff. Then they could study Cameron Diaz's behavior in bed and see what she likes, doesn't like, etc. so if you ever had the chance to, you could easily please her! LMAO.....I think it's sad that I laugh at my own jokes, but anyway, it could happen. Thanks, Alex David G Fisher <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:z%Ee7.106698$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (18 lines)> > "Jan Verschueren" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:[email hidden]... > > "David G Fisher" wrote... > > > For those who go on and on and on and on and on and on > > > about which sim is so realistic compared to all others, > > > here's a little shot of perspective. > > > > Sorry to burst your bubble and not meaning any disrespect to the soon to > be > > quadruple (or is it quintuple already?) F1 World Champion,but without > > knowing which sims he's talking about, under which circumstance and how > long > > he's played them and which equipment he used to do so, his comments are > next > > to worthless > > > > He *is* an F1 driver, for crying out loud!! -Of course he won't relate
to > a > > simulation on his first try. His body and mind are expecting G-loads in > > response to his control actions and are not getting them, alienating him > > from the experience. It takes time to train the brain into translatingthe > > visual and audio cues into (mock) sensations about the simulated car. > > Otherwise everyone would be able to drive simulated cars more or less > > competently from the word go. Put any non-simracer in front of your PCand > > it'll take him 15 minutes to complete a lap at Monza. > > You don't think that a 32 year old man who had a privileged upbringing in > Germany, and loves auto racing, knows what driving sims/games are, andwhat
Quoted text (19 lines)> it would take to evaluate them? I knew these things before I was even that > interested in driving sims because they're so obvious. Racing games are > hardly recent inventions. > > > Couple of seasons ago RTL (German satellite TV station) used to invite > ex-GP > > drivers to watch the GP's along with a moderator and a studio audience, > > momentarily commenting on events in the live coverage as the race > unfolded. > > At the end of the show they put them in a simulator (F1 chassis mock-up) > and > > had them drive a lap of Hockenheim (using MGPRS2, I think) adding the > result > > to a fastest lap list. Without exception, they embarassed themselves. > > Why? -Because it takes a lot of practise to perceive the world of the > > simulator as real, plain and simple. If ex-F1 drivers can't do it, what > > chance has your cousin got? > > I've seen kids sit down in front of driving games and drive them with
ease, > including GPL. Your making the same mistake a lot of adult sim racersmake, > which is to take these things so seriously that we "talk" ourselves into > believing they are more difficult than they really are, sometimes in order > to justify our (what many people would call childish) hobby to ourselvesand > others. > > All he's saying, is that without the physical effects of driving a racecar, > most of the simulation is gone. Driving a car (sim or real) isn't thathard. > Everybody does it. Simulating a real F1 car without the physical effectsis > like simulating sex. Will any computer program ever come within a million > miles of satisfying you in the same way real sex with Cameron Diaz would? > All I'm saying is let's not take this stuff so damn seriously that we > actually think we could mimic what we do on screen if we were "just given > the chance". Let's not put down real life drivers because we think we know > "what it takes". How about not ripping the shit out of one sim, andpraising
Quoted text (17 lines)> another as if it's our religion? Perspective. > > > When I say GPL is more realistic than Rally Championship that's because > if I > > drive a car in GPL over an upset in such a way and at such a speed that, > > IMO, it shouldn't roll, it doesn't. Whereas in Rally Championship, it > does. > > I rarely EVER rolled the cars in RC. It was never an issue with me or many > other people who drove RC. Real rally cars actually do roll fairly easily > though. You should know that. How do you explain the different experiences > that some had? There is only one answer and that is that some people drove > them correctly, and kept them on a part of the track which wouldn't cause > the car to roll over in real life. Some people drove them at realisitic > speeds, while others had no idea what their speed was as they were going > around a sharp turn. I saw so many replays of people rolling or crashing > their car, and blaming the game. They had no idea how fast they were
going, > or what they hit. They simply blamed the game. As for GPL, the reason Ilost
Quoted text (8 lines)> interest in it was because IT did things that the real life footage showed > was not accurate. Mainly, the excess sliding and drifting. Good, practiced > drivers criss-crossing the driving line all the way around the track. They > looked nothing like the AI or the real life footage. > > > There is an in-car lap of Nick Heidfeld in the Sauber at Sepang I > downloaded > > from "that F1 video site I can't remember nor find the URL of right
now". > As > > I watched it I found myself really agreeing with his approach, so Iloaded > > up GP3 to "try it for myself". Couldn't do it, no matter how many > liberties > > I took with setup and driving model... the car in the simulation simply > > wouldn't go there. Recently, using F1RC, I can do it with the standard > > setup. Not as quickly as Nick, of course, but I can drive around thetrack > > in the same way (same more less goes for all tracks, but this is arather
Quoted text (7 lines)> > poingant example). Therefore, as a simulation, F1RC is more realistic to > me > > than GP3. The behaviour of the cars conforms more to my notion of how > these > > cars *should* behave. If you know what I mean. > > I'm glad to hear you noticed this about F1RC, but unfortunately, this
group > which is supposedly the most knowlegeable collection of sim racers on the > planet has spent little time discussing F1RC's excellent simulation of anF1 > car's behavior, and more time bickering over a bunch of bullshit. > > > I'm willing to go along with Shu in as far as we don't have the levelof
Quoted text (18 lines)> > control precision reality has to offer. This, of course, is a nescessary > > evil... if the controls had quasi infinate precision as they do in real > > life, there wouldn't be time to calculate the model and present the > graphics > > on-screen. > > > > > He also responds to the whiners who say F1 is all technology, > > > and little about the actual drivers. > > > > > > He doesn't respond to it, he presents the same argument in a different > way. > > > > <quote> > > I see it like this: You are able to be more constantly at the limit [of > the > > car] with it [better electronics] and you don't have to take care of any > > power peaks of the engine. It gives us more freedom to drive a bit
faster. > > </quote> > > > > Exactly Michael. However, in the technology whiner's (sic) point ofview,
Quoted text (11 lines)> > the "us" part is the offensive bit. In "our" view, it should only be the > > Schumachers, Sennas, Prosts and Mansells of this world who are in a > position > > to drive a given car at the very limit consistently. > > Without the electronics, no driver would be able to drive those cars near > their limit. 18,000rpm. 850 hp. Advances in aerodynamics. Grooved tires. > Incredible braking power. Technology has now made a car which outpaces the > abilities of a human driver, and that's why the electronic aids exist. I > want to see what the cars are truly capable of, and the aids make that > possible. There's the limit, and then there's *the limit*. The true limit
is > still only reached by the best drivers, so nothing has really changed. The > driver who reaches that true limit the most consistently, lap after lapand > race after race is MS. MS always outperforms his teammates. RS outperforms > JPM. MH is still probably a bit faster than DC. Zanardi dominated CART and > his teammate, but couldn't do much in F1. Within a team, there is usually > one driver who is consistently faster than another. Aids don't preventthat > fact from showing through. > > David G Fisher >
You've put way too much thought itnot that. :-) BTW, how's your rally driving going with your dad? We used to chat a bit on ICQ back when I was beta testing RC2000. David G Fisher "Alex Kihurani" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:4eYf7.1509$[email hidden]... > You certainly could have a Cameron Diaz simulator! You could have VR > goggles, silicon for the "fun" parts, and they could engineer somethingthat > felt like real skin and, errr, other stuff. Then they could study Cameron > Diaz's behavior in bed and see what she likes, doesn't like, etc. so ifyou
Quoted text (16 lines)> ever had the chance to, you could easily please her! LMAO.....I think it's > sad that I laugh at my own jokes, but anyway, it could happen. > > Thanks, > Alex > David G Fisher <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:z%Ee7.106698$[email hidden]... > > > > "Jan Verschueren" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > > news:[email hidden]... > > > "David G Fisher" wrote... > > > > For those who go on and on and on and on and on and on > > > > about which sim is so realistic compared to all others, > > > > here's a little shot of perspective. > > > > > > Sorry to burst your bubble and not meaning any disrespect to the soon
to > > be > > > quadruple (or is it quintuple already?) F1 World Champion,but without > > > knowing which sims he's talking about, under which circumstance andhow > > long > > > he's played them and which equipment he used to do so, his commentsare
Quoted text (7 lines)> > next > > > to worthless > > > > > > He *is* an F1 driver, for crying out loud!! -Of course he won't relate > to > > a > > > simulation on his first try. His body and mind are expecting G-loads
in > > > response to his control actions and are not getting them, alienatinghim
Quoted text (9 lines)> > > from the experience. It takes time to train the brain into translating > the > > > visual and audio cues into (mock) sensations about the simulated car. > > > Otherwise everyone would be able to drive simulated cars more or less > > > competently from the word go. Put any non-simracer in front of your PC > and > > > it'll take him 15 minutes to complete a lap at Monza. > > > > You don't think that a 32 year old man who had a privileged upbringing
in > > Germany, and loves auto racing, knows what driving sims/games are, and > what > > it would take to evaluate them? I knew these things before I was eventhat > > interested in driving sims because they're so obvious. Racing games are > > hardly recent inventions. > > > > > Couple of seasons ago RTL (German satellite TV station) used to invite > > ex-GP > > > drivers to watch the GP's along with a moderator and a studioaudience, > > > momentarily commenting on events in the live coverage as the race > > unfolded. > > > At the end of the show they put them in a simulator (F1 chassismock-up) > > and > > > had them drive a lap of Hockenheim (using MGPRS2, I think) adding the > > result > > > to a fastest lap list. Without exception, they embarassed themselves. > > > Why? -Because it takes a lot of practise to perceive the world of the > > > simulator as real, plain and simple. If ex-F1 drivers can't do it,what
Quoted text (8 lines)> > > chance has your cousin got? > > > > I've seen kids sit down in front of driving games and drive them with > ease, > > including GPL. Your making the same mistake a lot of adult sim racers > make, > > which is to take these things so seriously that we "talk" ourselves into > > believing they are more difficult than they really are, sometimes in
order
Quoted text (11 lines)> > to justify our (what many people would call childish) hobby to ourselves > and > > others. > > > > All he's saying, is that without the physical effects of driving a race > car, > > most of the simulation is gone. Driving a car (sim or real) isn't that > hard. > > Everybody does it. Simulating a real F1 car without the physical effects > is > > like simulating sex. Will any computer program ever come within a
million > > miles of satisfying you in the same way real sex with Cameron Diazwould? > > All I'm saying is let's not take this stuff so damn seriously that we > > actually think we could mimic what we do on screen if we were "justgiven > > the chance". Let's not put down real life drivers because we think weknow > > "what it takes". How about not ripping the shit out of one sim, and > praising > > another as if it's our religion? Perspective. > > > > > When I say GPL is more realistic than Rally Championship that'sbecause > > if I > > > drive a car in GPL over an upset in such a way and at such a speedthat, > > > IMO, it shouldn't roll, it doesn't. Whereas in Rally Championship, it > > does. > > > > I rarely EVER rolled the cars in RC. It was never an issue with me ormany > > other people who drove RC. Real rally cars actually do roll fairlyeasily > > though. You should know that. How do you explain the differentexperiences > > that some had? There is only one answer and that is that some peopledrove > > them correctly, and kept them on a part of the track which wouldn'tcause
Quoted text (8 lines)> > the car to roll over in real life. Some people drove them at realisitic > > speeds, while others had no idea what their speed was as they were going > > around a sharp turn. I saw so many replays of people rolling or crashing > > their car, and blaming the game. They had no idea how fast they were > going, > > or what they hit. They simply blamed the game. As for GPL, the reason I > lost > > interest in it was because IT did things that the real life footage
showed > > was not accurate. Mainly, the excess sliding and drifting. Good,practiced > > drivers criss-crossing the driving line all the way around the track.They
Quoted text (12 lines)> > looked nothing like the AI or the real life footage. > > > > > There is an in-car lap of Nick Heidfeld in the Sauber at Sepang I > > downloaded > > > from "that F1 video site I can't remember nor find the URL of right > now". > > As > > > I watched it I found myself really agreeing with his approach, so I > loaded > > > up GP3 to "try it for myself". Couldn't do it, no matter how many > > liberties > > > I took with setup and driving model... the car in the simulation
simply > > > wouldn't go there. Recently, using F1RC, I can do it with the standard > > > setup. Not as quickly as Nick, of course, but I can drive around the > track > > > in the same way (same more less goes for all tracks, but this is a > rather > > > poingant example). Therefore, as a simulation, F1RC is more realisticto
Quoted text (8 lines)> > me > > > than GP3. The behaviour of the cars conforms more to my notion of how > > these > > > cars *should* behave. If you know what I mean. > > > > I'm glad to hear you noticed this about F1RC, but unfortunately, this > group > > which is supposedly the most knowlegeable collection of sim racers on
the > > planet has spent little time discussing F1RC's excellent simulation ofan > F1 > > car's behavior, and more time bickering over a bunch of bullshit. > > > > > I'm willing to go along with Shu in as far as we don't have the level > of > > > control precision reality has to offer. This, of course, is anescessary > > > evil... if the controls had quasi infinate precision as they do inreal
Quoted text (13 lines)> > > life, there wouldn't be time to calculate the model and present the > > graphics > > > on-screen. > > > > > > > He also responds to the whiners who say F1 is all technology, > > > > and little about the actual drivers. > > > > > > > > > He doesn't respond to it, he presents the same argument in a different > > way. > > > > > > <quote> > > > I see it like this: You are able to be more constantly at the limit
[of > > the > > > car] with it [better electronics] and you don't have to take care ofany
Quoted text (7 lines)> > > power peaks of the engine. It gives us more freedom to drive a bit > faster. > > > </quote> > > > > > > Exactly Michael. However, in the technology whiner's (sic) point of > view, > > > the "us" part is the offensive bit. In "our" view, it should only be
the > > > Schumachers, Sennas, Prosts and Mansells of this world who are in a > > position > > > to drive a given car at the very limit consistently. > > > > Without the electronics, no driver would be able to drive those carsnear > > their limit. 18,000rpm. 850 hp. Advances in aerodynamics. Grooved tires. > > Incredible braking power. Technology has now made a car which outpacesthe > > abilities of a human driver, and that's why the electronic aids exist. I > > want to see what the cars are truly capable of, and the aids make that > > possible. There's the limit, and then there's *the limit*. The truelimit > is > > still only reached by the best drivers, so nothing has really changed.The > > driver who reaches that true limit the most consistently, lap after lap > and > > race after race is MS. MS always outperforms his teammates. RSoutperforms > > JPM. MH is still probably a bit faster than DC. Zanardi dominated CARTand > > his teammate, but couldn't do much in F1. Within a team, there isusually
Quoted text (7 lines)> > one driver who is consistently faster than another. Aids don't prevent > that > > fact from showing through. > > > > David G Fisher > > >
In article <9lm0mg$ldu$[email hidden]>, Tony Whitley <[email hidden]> writes
Quoted text (22 lines)> >"David G Fisher" wrote... >> >> "Ed Solheim" <[email hidden]> wrote in message >> news:pwaf7.446$[email hidden]... >> >> > I'm not talking about the 60's or 70's at all.. all I'm saying is that >> all >> > these aid's have runied the sport. They have undoubtly made F1 >easier... >> > take Kimi Raikonen for instance.. his 23rd *ever* car race and he >scores >> a >> > point in F1??? >> >> It's called young, natural talent. Guys his age and with his experience >> dominate in all sports. Tiger Woods puts men with 20 years more of pro >> experience to shame. >Err, Tiger Woods has been playing golf since he was three AFAIK. He's >played >s l i g h t l y more than 23 rounds. >
Besides, there aren't 'different' types of golf as you progress so you don't have to learn to use a different set of clubs as your skill levels improve and you start to take on the pros. Not a very good example, David. As to the reasons behind your statement, the jury is still out on this one for me as this year is the first time I have seen KR, although he is undoubtedly talented though, to what level I'm not sure. He is already matching Heidfeld - they both seem really close times-wise and in the races - but how good IS Heidfeld? Being able to determine how good KR is really does depend on how good you rate H and although it looks as though KR has the potential to be better than H, I'm not sure of H's ability when compared to other F1 drivers. I suspect that Heidfeld will turn out to be a reasonable but not exceptional F1 racer - somewhere near but below the Frentzen level perhaps at best - though this is really just a gut instinct about him at the mo'. -- Peter Ives Remove ALL_STRESS before replying via email If you know what's good for you, don't listen to me GPLRank Joystick -50.63 Wheel -21.77
"Peter Ives" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]...
Quoted text (9 lines)> In article <9lm0mg$ldu$[email hidden]>, Tony Whitley > <[email hidden]> writes > >> It's called young, natural talent. Guys his age and with his experience > >> dominate in all sports. Tiger Woods puts men with 20 years more of pro > >> experience to shame. > >Err, Tiger Woods has been playing golf since he was three AFAIK. He's > >played > >s l i g h t l y more than 23 rounds.
Michael Schumacher received his first sponsorship at age five while racing go-karts. I'm willing to guess Raikkonen probably had some early go-kart experience as well. Woods is just one example out of thousands of young talents who not only compete, but dominate in sports. David G Fisher
"David G Fisher" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:Igzg7.123940
Quoted text (7 lines)> Michael Schumacher received his first sponsorship at age five while racing > go-karts. I'm willing to guess Raikkonen probably had some early go-kart > experience as well. Woods is just one example out of thousands of young > talents who not only compete, but dominate in sports. > > David G Fisher >
Shush David, you know that Schumacher had no privileged background, so every kid in Germany must have been racing karts at age five. Doesn't make him that special after all ;o) cheers John
EldredP 23 Aug 2001 21:47 UTC↳ reply to Ian P#166083
In article <9lhq1s$dqb$[email hidden]>, "Ian P" <[email hidden]> writes: >After the 2 times Montoya lost the back end of the car putting himself out >of the race, I think Mr. Head may be reconsidering the first part of his >statement <G> Monaco and where else? Eldred -- Dale Earnhardt, Sr. R.I.P. 1951-2001 Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett F1 hcp. +16.36...Monster +366.59... Never argue with an idiot. He brings you down to his level, then beats you with experience... Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.
EldredP 23 Aug 2001 21:47 UTC#528383
writes: Monaco and where else? Eldred -- Dale Earnhardt, Sr. R.I.P. 1951-2001 Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett F1 hcp. +16.36...Monster +366.59... Never argue with an idiot. He brings you down to his level, then beats you with experience... Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.
He also lost the rear end at Canada. I think it was a mechanical fault which caused that one, although my memory may be out :) Rafe Mc >Monaco and where else? > >Eldred

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy