Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

F1 = Murray Walker

30 posts by 17 people · 01 Oct 2001 15:06 UTC - 05 Oct 2001 02:21 UTC

Murray Walker retires after the US Grand Prix

Alan Coates paid tribute to Murray Walker, whose commentary at the 2001 US Grand Prix was his last. Opinion was split: redTed and GraDee called him an inept babbler, while many others praised his passion and ability to make dull races exciting. The thread drifted into wordplay over the word coruscating.

real motorsport

Automated summary.

Alan Coates 01 Oct 2001 15:06 UTC#160417
You guys (and gals) across the pond may not know Murray Walker. His commentary at the F1 Indianapolis race was his last, and for me he will be truly missed. Some would say that he was the enthusiastic amateur but, he added a great deal of colour and a unique human touch to his commentating. I think I speak for most F1 fans in the UK when I say.. GOOD LUCK AND BEST WISHES FOR THE FUTURE, MURRAY!! lets hope MW make a few cameo appearances at future F1 venues, It's gonna be a tough job for the person who replaces him. One remembered gaff amongst all those he made: "The Williams car in front is totally unique except for the one behind!" Alan
"Alan Coates" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:3B%t7.10016$[email hidden]... > You guys (and gals) across the pond may not know Murray Walker. > His commentary at the F1 Indianapolis race was his last, and for me hewill > be truly missed. Some would say that he was the enthusiastic amateur but,he > added a great deal of colour and a unique human touch to his commentating. > I think I speak for most F1 fans in the UK when I say.. >Thanks, but you don't speak for me. IMO, Murray Walker was living proof of someone who miraculously got to the top of their profession with absolutely no talent at all. His constant gibbering and emotional breakdowns on BBC and ITV were annoying in the extreme. Personally I will be glad to see the back of him, and I speak for no one but myself..
We knew Murray Walker here in Canada. For me he is the ONLY F1 commentator. It won';t be the same without him. Alan Coates wrote:
Quoted text (19 lines)>You guys (and gals) across the pond may not know Murray Walker. >His commentary at the F1 Indianapolis race was his last, and for me he will >be truly missed. Some would say that he was the enthusiastic amateur but, he >added a great deal of colour and a unique human touch to his commentating. >I think I speak for most F1 fans in the UK when I say.. > >GOOD LUCK AND BEST WISHES FOR THE FUTURE, MURRAY!! > >lets hope MW make a few cameo appearances at future F1 venues, > >It's gonna be a tough job for the person who replaces him. > >One remembered gaff amongst all those he made: > >"The Williams car in front is totally unique except for the one behind!" > >Alan > >
Every once in a while, I install F1 '99, and run a few laps, just to hear him! curtis PS - we all know that could be the only reason for EVER installing let alone actually playing F1 '99.... "Brad Larocque" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]...
Quoted text (7 lines)> We knew Murray Walker here in Canada. For me he is the ONLY F1 > commentator. It won';t be the same without him. > > Alan Coates wrote: > > >You guys (and gals) across the pond may not know Murray Walker. > >His commentary at the F1 Indianapolis race was his last, and for me he
will > >be truly missed. Some would say that he was the enthusiastic amateur but,he > >added a great deal of colour and a unique human touch to hiscommentating.
Quoted text (16 lines)> >I think I speak for most F1 fans in the UK when I say.. > > > >GOOD LUCK AND BEST WISHES FOR THE FUTURE, MURRAY!! > > > >lets hope MW make a few cameo appearances at future F1 venues, > > > >It's gonna be a tough job for the person who replaces him. > > > >One remembered gaff amongst all those he made: > > > >"The Williams car in front is totally unique except for the one behind!" > > > >Alan > > > > >
GraDee 01 Oct 2001 18:06 UTC↳ reply to redTed#160437
redTed <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:9pa4tr$gqi57$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (7 lines)> > "Alan Coates" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:3B%t7.10016$[email hidden]... > > You guys (and gals) across the pond may not know Murray Walker. > > His commentary at the F1 Indianapolis race was his last, and for me he > will > > be truly missed. Some would say that he was the enthusiastic amateur
but, > he > > added a great deal of colour and a unique human touch to hiscommentating. > > I think I speak for most F1 fans in the UK when I say.. > > > Thanks, but you don't speak for me. > IMO, Murray Walker was living proof of someone who miraculously got tothe > top of their profession with absolutely no talent at all. > His constant gibbering and emotional breakdowns on BBC and ITV wereannoying > in the extreme. Personally I will be glad to see the back of him, and I > speak for no one but myself.. > Not trying to provoke anthing but Ted is spot on.... F1 will survive and prosper with Murray.... Brits fail to realise that there ever country has it's Murray Walker only they usually know a bit about the sport.
Well.. I DID say that Murray gave a unique human touch to the sport. This comment was obviously wasted on computer nerdy robotic types like redTed and 9Wright7. Lack of passion is NOT recommended for sports of any kind and F1 in particular. And despite Murray's 'on the spot' gaffs he almost certainly knows more about F1 and its history than anyone else. Some commentators lack of passion and constant droning technical drivel does not encourage people to follow that particular sport. The rapid success over the years of F1 is down to people like Murray and the viewing figures are living proof that his style was much appreciated. He was the Patrick Moore of F1 Oh, go on... and Patrick Moore knows nothing about his subject too. DOH Alan "9Wright7" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:9pabei$eku$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (31 lines)> > redTed <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:9pa4tr$gqi57$[email hidden]... > > > > "Alan Coates" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > > news:3B%t7.10016$[email hidden]... > > > You guys (and gals) across the pond may not know Murray Walker. > > > His commentary at the F1 Indianapolis race was his last, and for me he > > will > > > be truly missed. Some would say that he was the enthusiastic amateur > but, > > he > > > added a great deal of colour and a unique human touch to his > commentating. > > > I think I speak for most F1 fans in the UK when I say.. > > > > > Thanks, but you don't speak for me. > > IMO, Murray Walker was living proof of someone who miraculously got to > the > > top of their profession with absolutely no talent at all. > > His constant gibbering and emotional breakdowns on BBC and ITV were > annoying > > in the extreme. Personally I will be glad to see the back of him, and I > > speak for no one but myself.. > > > > Not trying to provoke anthing but Ted is spot on.... F1 will survive and > prosper with Murray.... Brits fail to realise that there ever country has > it's Murray Walker only they usually know a bit about the sport. > >
"Alan Coates" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:YM3u7.11925$[email hidden]... > Well.. I DID say that Murray gave a unique human touch to the sport. This > comment was obviously wasted on computer nerdy robotic types like redTedand > 9Wright7. Lack of passion is NOT recommended for sports of any kind and F1 > in particular. And despite Murray's 'on the spot' gaffs he almostcertainly > knows more about F1 and its history than anyone else. I see you have resorted to name calling because we don't share your opinion. Sad.
I agree with everything Alan says, MW was a great enthusiast over 52 (yes 52) years. We need more like him. Iain "Alan Coates" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:YM3u7.11925$[email hidden]... > Well.. I DID say that Murray gave a unique human touch to the sport. This > comment was obviously wasted on computer nerdy robotic types like redTedand > 9Wright7. Lack of passion is NOT recommended for sports of any kind and F1 > in particular. And despite Murray's 'on the spot' gaffs he almostcertainly > knows more about F1 and its history than anyone else. > > Some commentators lack of passion and constant droning technical driveldoes > not encourage people to follow that particular sport. The rapid successover
Quoted text (22 lines)> the years of F1 is down to people like Murray and the viewing figures are > living proof that his style was much appreciated. > > He was the Patrick Moore of F1 > > Oh, go on... and Patrick Moore knows nothing about his subject too. > > DOH > > Alan > > > "9Wright7" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:9pabei$eku$[email hidden]... > > > > redTed <[email hidden]> wrote in message > > news:9pa4tr$gqi57$[email hidden]... > > > > > > "Alan Coates" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > > > news:3B%t7.10016$[email hidden]... > > > > You guys (and gals) across the pond may not know Murray Walker. > > > > His commentary at the F1 Indianapolis race was his last, and for me
he
Quoted text (10 lines)> > > will > > > > be truly missed. Some would say that he was the enthusiastic amateur > > but, > > > he > > > > added a great deal of colour and a unique human touch to his > > commentating. > > > > I think I speak for most F1 fans in the UK when I say.. > > > > > > > Thanks, but you don't speak for me. > > > IMO, Murray Walker was living proof of someone who miraculously got
to > > the > > > top of their profession with absolutely no talent at all. > > > His constant gibbering and emotional breakdowns on BBC and ITV were > > annoying > > > in the extreme. Personally I will be glad to see the back of him, andI > > > speak for no one but myself.. > > > > > > > Not trying to provoke anthing but Ted is spot on.... F1 will survive and > > prosper with Murray.... Brits fail to realise that there ever countryhas > > it's Murray Walker only they usually know a bit about the sport. > > > > > >
"Iain Mackenzie" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:dW3u7.11972$[email hidden]... > I agree with everything Alan says, MW was a great enthusiast over 52 (yes > 52) years. We need more like him. Great. More commentators with no sense of humour who babble on ineptly for a couple of hours about something they know very little about, given the fact he has been at it 50 odd years !
redTed <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:9paili$h9thj$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (9 lines)> > "Iain Mackenzie" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:dW3u7.11972$[email hidden]... > > I agree with everything Alan says, MW was a great enthusiast over 52 (yes > > 52) years. We need more like him. > > Great. More commentators with no sense of humour who babble on ineptly for a > couple of hours about something they know very little about, given the fact > he has been at it 50 odd years !
One skill he did have was in making sure that some of the more obvious stuff was pointed out - great for those who don't follow the sport as passionately as many here certainly do. Jonny
On Mon, 1 Oct 2001 20:59:03 +0100, "Iain Mackenzie" <[email hidden]> wrote: >I agree with everything Alan says, MW was a great enthusiast over 52 (yes >52) years. We need more like him. >Iain I'm with you Iain and Alan, go Murray! No one is more passionate, or makes more mistakes :D If you're after a technically detailed and correct discussion, you'd hate Murray. But he always made every (dull) race interesting and exciting, and Martin alwalys correcting him is a laugh. Each one to their own...I thought he was great. Read the Murrayisms I posted earlier :D Rafe Mc
"Alan Coates" <[email hidden]> wrote: >GOOD LUCK AND BEST WISHES FOR THE FUTURE, MURRAY!! Yes, definitely. I would say that I Murray's commentary was one of the good aspects of F1. What was the name of that (stop-go animation) movie with small animals (rodents, hedgehogs etc) that entered in a car race? Anyway, Murray did the commentary and really made it come alive. --Morton Correct email: telson @ ameritech.net
[email hidden] (Alan Coates) wrote: > I DID say that Murray gave a unique human touch to the sport. Ok, we'll let you off. He's a nice bloke, and a national institution... a bit like Margaret Thatcher (ie someone who sounded like they knew what they were doing if you didn't listen to the words ;-) Andrew McP
"Andrew MacPherson" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]...
Quoted text (9 lines)> [email hidden] (Alan Coates) wrote: > > > I DID say that Murray gave a unique human touch to the sport. > > Ok, we'll let you off. He's a nice bloke, and a national institution... a > bit like Margaret Thatcher (ie someone who sounded like they knew what > they were doing if you didn't listen to the words ;-) > > Andrew McP
Maggie? Now they just don't build'em like that over here....:) dh >
Andrew MacPherson wrote:
Quoted text (8 lines)> > [email hidden] (Alan Coates) wrote: > > > I DID say that Murray gave a unique human touch to the sport. > > Ok, we'll let you off. He's a nice bloke, and a national institution... a > bit like Margaret Thatcher (ie someone who sounded like they knew what > they were doing if you didn't listen to the words ;-)
I don't know about Murray, but if someone had compared me to Maggie Thatcher, I'd take it as a personal insult....:-) I've only briefly experienced MW, so for me F1 commentary hit it's high on Eurosport some years ago with Allard Kalff and John Watson, although Ben Edwrds did a pretty good job when Allard Kalff left, then Eurosport lost F1 and I almost lost interest, you wouldn't believe how bad Swedish commentary are......I'm not even going to mention the Norwegians or I'll be needing a bucket here soon Beers and cheers (uncle) Goy "The Pits" http://www.theuspits.com/ * Spam is for losers who can't get business any other way * "Spamkiller" http://www.spamkiller.com
Alan Coates <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:YM3u7.11925$[email hidden]... > Well.. I DID say that Murray gave a unique human touch to the sport. This > comment was obviously wasted on computer nerdy robotic types like redTedand > 9Wright7. Lack of passion is NOT recommended for sports of any kind and F1 > in particular. And despite Murray's 'on the spot' gaffs he almostcertainly > knows more about F1 and its history than anyone else. More than who? A real F1 driver like most other channels? (Don't give me Martin Brundle. I said "real"!!) > Some commentators lack of passion and constant droning technical driveldoes > not encourage people to follow that particular sport. The rapid successover > the years of F1 is down to people like Murray and the viewing figures are > living proof that his style was much appreciated. Yeah but you like F1 or you don't....if you get ITV in your area then you have to listen to him.... Otherwise...like most, you listen to your own knowledgable commentary crew. Murray is jsut another example of Brits over-glorifying everything about themselves...
Iain Mackenzie <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:dW3u7.11972$[email hidden]... > I agree with everything Alan says, MW was a great enthusiast over 52 (yes > 52) years. We need more like him. Yeah but I'm an enthusiast.... you're an enthusiast..it doesn't mean we're Gods gift to F1.... if Murray does know as much as some say..why does it fail to shine through... With a choice of Brundle/Murray or Kennedy/Collins I for once have no hesitation in opting for the Irish presentation.
Yeah, sure, Muddly Talker was a great guy and all that, corrsuscatingly gauche Spoonerisms, etc.; but you don't realize how far off base he was most of the time until you hear his blithering commentary on "Lap of the Gods," which was on Speedvision last nite. Sometimes, of course, he was spot on, but most of the time he sounded like he was from the Planet Mugwump. --Steve Smith "Alan Coates" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:3B%t7.10016$[email hidden]... > You guys (and gals) across the pond may not know Murray Walker. > His commentary at the F1 Indianapolis race was his last, and for me hewill > be truly missed. Some would say that he was the enthusiastic amateur but,he
Quoted text (16 lines)> added a great deal of colour and a unique human touch to his commentating. > I think I speak for most F1 fans in the UK when I say.. > > GOOD LUCK AND BEST WISHES FOR THE FUTURE, MURRAY!! > > lets hope MW make a few cameo appearances at future F1 venues, > > It's gonna be a tough job for the person who replaces him. > > One remembered gaff amongst all those he made: > > "The Williams car in front is totally unique except for the one behind!" > > Alan > >
In article <Fvpu7.590843$[email hidden]>, [email hidden] says... > corrsuscatingly gauche Spoonerisms That's going to take years for me to decipher. ;/ Cheers, Rod.
Rod, All the more so since I misspelled "corruscatingly," which was one of JFK's fav words. It means "brilliant." He called somebody "corruscatingly stupid" once. He also favored "suppurating" which comes from the same root as "suppository" and is generally applied to the same place. --Steve "Rod Prince" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]...
Quoted text (9 lines)> In article <Fvpu7.590843$[email hidden]>, > [email hidden] says... > > > corrsuscatingly gauche Spoonerisms > > That's going to take years for me to decipher. ;/ > > Cheers, > Rod.
Hugh 03 Oct 2001 14:37 UTC↳ reply to GraDee#160072
Here in Thailand we get Star Sports and the commentary team is abysmal; wrong due to stupidity rather than silly Murray-style mistakes. Occasionally someone brings out a tape from the UK and we watch the whole race again, and Murray makes it come alive. If I were younger I would wish him as my grandfather! 9Wright7 <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:9pcvl1$e2b$[email hidden]... > > Alan Coates <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:YM3u7.11925$[email hidden]... > > Well.. I DID say that Murray gave a unique human touch to the sport.This > > comment was obviously wasted on computer nerdy robotic types like redTed > and > > 9Wright7. Lack of passion is NOT recommended for sports of any kind andF1
Quoted text (13 lines)> > in particular. And despite Murray's 'on the spot' gaffs he almost > certainly > > knows more about F1 and its history than anyone else. > > More than who? A real F1 driver like most other channels? (Don't give me > Martin Brundle. I said "real"!!) > > > > Some commentators lack of passion and constant droning technical drivel > does > > not encourage people to follow that particular sport. The rapid success > over > > the years of F1 is down to people like Murray and the viewing figures
are > > living proof that his style was much appreciated. > > Yeah but you like F1 or you don't....if you get ITV in your area then you > have to listen to him.... > Otherwise...like most, you listen to your own knowledgable commentarycrew.
Quoted text (8 lines)> > Murray is jsut another example of Brits over-glorifying everything about > themselves... > > > > >
In article <%KCu7.602034$[email hidden]>, [email hidden] says... > All the more so since I misspelled "corruscatingly," which was one of JFK's > fav words. It means "brilliant." He called somebody "corruscatingly > stupid" once. He also favored "suppurating" which comes from the same root > as "suppository" and is generally applied to the same place. Even spelt correctly it rings no bells ;) Seen alot of strange words, but that one is completely new to me. Cheers, Rod.
Rod Prince <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]...
Quoted text (11 lines)> In article <%KCu7.602034$[email hidden]>, > [email hidden] says... > > > All the more so since I misspelled "corruscatingly," which was one of JFK's > > fav words. It means "brilliant." He called somebody "corruscatingly > > stupid" once. He also favored "suppurating" which comes from the same root > > as "suppository" and is generally applied to the same place. > > Even spelt correctly it rings no bells ;) > > Seen alot of strange words, but that one is completely new to me.
IIRC Terry Pratchett uses "coruscating" in one of the Discworld novels, which I took to be made up - though alt.fan.pratchett or a.f.p.books would be a better place to discuss this ;-) Jonny
Dyslexia rears its ugly head again! Yer rite--coruscate *is* spelt w. one 'r'. My OED sez it indeed means 'brilliant'. At least I got that part right...the rest was a sound byte lodged in my mnemonic mnetherworld since 1962 or thereabouts. Picky, picky, picky.... --Steve "Jonny Hodgson" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:gsKu7.30178$[email hidden]... > > Rod Prince <[email hidden]> wrote in messagenews:[email hidden]... > > In article <%KCu7.602034$[email hidden]>, > > [email hidden] says... > > > > > All the more so since I misspelled "corruscatingly," which was one ofJFK's > > > fav words. It means "brilliant." He called somebody "corruscatingly > > > stupid" once. He also favored "suppurating" which comes from the sameroot
Quoted text (13 lines)> > > as "suppository" and is generally applied to the same place. > > > > Even spelt correctly it rings no bells ;) > > > > Seen alot of strange words, but that one is completely new to me. > > IIRC Terry Pratchett uses "coruscating" in one of the Discworld > novels, which I took to be made up - though alt.fan.pratchett > or a.f.p.books would be a better place to discuss this ;-) > > Jonny > >
If people have to resort to flinging obscure words around in an attempt to 'sound' brilliant, then methinks even the attempt would be a failure before it begins. (doncha just love sentence run-ons...my English teachers could never break me of the habit.) dave henrie "Stephen Smith" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:BVLu7.598065$[email hidden]... > Dyslexia rears its ugly head again! Yer rite--coruscate *is* spelt w. one > 'r'. My OED sez it indeed means 'brilliant'. At least I got that part > right...the rest was a sound byte lodged in my mnemonic mnetherworld since > 1962 or thereabouts. Picky, picky, picky....
Obscure? Not to the President of these United States. Am I being too harsh? I used a word that *means* brilliant, not to *sound* brilliant. For the latter I would resort to effluvia like obfuscate or hebephrene. Quad erat demonstrandum...or something. "Dave Henrie" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:Z3Pu7.74965$[email hidden]... > If people have to resort to flinging obscure words around in an attemptto > 'sound' brilliant, then methinks even the attempt would be a failurebefore
Quoted text (7 lines)> it begins. > (doncha just love sentence run-ons...my English teachers could never break > me of the habit.) > dave henrie > "Stephen Smith" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:BVLu7.598065$[email hidden]... > > Dyslexia rears its ugly head again! Yer rite--coruscate *is* spelt w.
one > > 'r'. My OED sez it indeed means 'brilliant'. At least I got that part > > right...the rest was a sound byte lodged in my mnemonic mnetherworldsince > > 1962 or thereabouts. Picky, picky, picky.... > > >
"Stephen Smith" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:zn%u7.607302$[email hidden]... > Obscure? Not to the President of these United States. Am I being too > harsh? I used a word that *means* brilliant, not to *sound* brilliant.For > the latter I would resort to effluvia like obfuscate or hebephrene. Quad > erat demonstrandum...or something. Didn't your Mama teach you to say "excuse me" after belching out like that? :) dh
In article <zn%u7.607302$[email hidden]>, "Stephen Smith" <[email hidden]> writes: >Obscure? Not to the President of these United States. Am I being too >harsh? I used a word that *means* brilliant, not to *sound* brilliant. For >the latter I would resort to effluvia like obfuscate or hebephrene. Quad >erat demonstrandum...or something. Writers...sheesh...<g> Eldred - needing to look up "hebephrene"...damn -- Dale Earnhardt, Sr. R.I.P. 1951-2001 Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett F1 hcp. +16.36...Monster +360.54... Never argue with an idiot. He brings you down to his level, then beats you with experience... Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.
In article <[email hidden]>, Morton Chalom <[email hidden]> writes: >What was the name of that (stop-go animation) movie with small animals >(rodents, hedgehogs etc) that entered in a car race? Anyway, Murray >did the commentary and really made it come alive. I wish you could remember the name. It sounds like a good laugh... Eldred -- Dale Earnhardt, Sr. R.I.P. 1951-2001 Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett F1 hcp. +16.36...Monster +360.54... Never argue with an idiot. He brings you down to his level, then beats you with experience... Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy