Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

F1 2001 yes it is garbage

22 posts by 12 people · 24 Oct 2001 16:44 UTC - 29 Oct 2001 23:29 UTC

Programmer calls F1 2001 garbage over driver problems

Alan Coates argued that EA expected customers to fix its programming because no GeForce3 driver ran F1 2001 stably. Replies were dismissive or pointed to working setups, and Coates later found it ran well on a Voodoo 5 machine. David G Fisher reminded readers that GPL and NR4 also had hardware and copy-protection troubles at release.

review/impressionstech supportF1 2001

Automated summary.

Alan Coates 24 Oct 2001 16:44 UTC#156340
As a programmer I do not think it's my customers problem to sort out my programming to get things to work. This is what EA expect. I have tried all the beta drivers for the Geforce 3 as well as all the authenticated drivers. None provide a constantly stable platform to run this poorly programmed game. Having brought games for some 15 years one knows when one has purchased crap. It's been a long time since I purchased an EA game, I should have realised! So back it goes. Back to N4 and GPL Alan
Yes in many ways F12001 is crap but it has allot of potential, think of is as more of a leaked aplha version of F12002 ;-) ISI/EA did the exact same thing with F12000 it was rushed out and full of bugs, they realised F1CS2000 about 6 months later and it had all of the bugs ironed out. Alex "Alan Coates" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:X9CB7.90971$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (7 lines)> As a programmer I do not think it's my customers problem to sort out my > programming to get things to work. > > This is what EA expect. > > I have tried all the beta drivers for the Geforce 3 as well as all the > authenticated drivers. None provide a constantly stable platform to run
this > poorly programmed game. > > Having brought games for some 15 years one knows when one has purchased > crap. > > It's been a long time since I purchased an EA game, I should haverealised!
Quoted text (8 lines)> > So back it goes. > > Back to N4 and GPL > > Alan > >
Alan Coates <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:X9CB7.90971$[email hidden]... > As a programmer I do not think it's my customers problem to sort out my > programming to get things to work. > You must be a pretty low level programmer then...... > This is what EA expect. > > I have tried all the beta drivers for the Geforce 3 as well as all the > authenticated drivers. None provide a constantly stable platform to runthis > poorly programmed game. > Ah! another programmer that can't configure a computer. > Having brought games for some 15 years one knows when one has purchased > crap. > Where did you bring them?
Those were about the dumbest responses I have seen in awhile "rik zeppelin" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:b0DB7.2823$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (29 lines)> > Alan Coates <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:X9CB7.90971$[email hidden]... > > As a programmer I do not think it's my customers problem to sort out my > > programming to get things to work. > > > > You must be a pretty low level programmer then...... > > > > This is what EA expect. > > > > I have tried all the beta drivers for the Geforce 3 as well as all the > > authenticated drivers. None provide a constantly stable platform to run > this > > poorly programmed game. > > > > Ah! another programmer that can't configure a computer. > > > Having brought games for some 15 years one knows when one has purchased > > crap. > > > > Where did you bring them? > > > >
So a game is garbage because you can't get decent framerates, which some, including myself, have gotten. I'm confused. Alanb "Alan Coates" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:X9CB7.90971$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (7 lines)> As a programmer I do not think it's my customers problem to sort out my > programming to get things to work. > > This is what EA expect. > > I have tried all the beta drivers for the Geforce 3 as well as all the > authenticated drivers. None provide a constantly stable platform to run
this > poorly programmed game. > > Having brought games for some 15 years one knows when one has purchased > crap. > > It's been a long time since I purchased an EA game, I should haverealised!
Quoted text (8 lines)> > So back it goes. > > Back to N4 and GPL > > Alan > >
There's always one, isn't there (SAD) DOH Alan "rik zeppelin" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:b0DB7.2823$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (29 lines)> > Alan Coates <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:X9CB7.90971$[email hidden]... > > As a programmer I do not think it's my customers problem to sort out my > > programming to get things to work. > > > > You must be a pretty low level programmer then...... > > > > This is what EA expect. > > > > I have tried all the beta drivers for the Geforce 3 as well as all the > > authenticated drivers. None provide a constantly stable platform to run > this > > poorly programmed game. > > > > Ah! another programmer that can't configure a computer. > > > Having brought games for some 15 years one knows when one has purchased > > crap. > > > > Where did you bring them? > > > >
"Alan Bernardo" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:fIEB7.32106$[email hidden]... > So a game is garbage because you can't get decent framerates, which some, > including myself, have gotten. I'm confused. > > Alanb > Don't remember mentioning framerates ... READ the f**king post before u reply! Alan just to remind u:
Quoted text (27 lines)> "Alan Coates" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:X9CB7.90971$[email hidden]... > > As a programmer I do not think it's my customers problem to sort out my > > programming to get things to work. > > > > This is what EA expect. > > > > I have tried all the beta drivers for the Geforce 3 as well as all the > > authenticated drivers. None provide a constantly stable platform to run > this > > poorly programmed game. > > > > Having brought games for some 15 years one knows when one has purchased > > crap. > > > > It's been a long time since I purchased an EA game, I should have > realised! > > > > So back it goes. > > > > Back to N4 and GPL > > > > Alan > > > > > >
Quoted text (8 lines)> Don't remember mentioning framerates ... READ the f**king post before u > reply! > > Alan > > just to remind u: > >None provide a constantly stable platform to run this poorly programmed
game And what is the above quote supposed to refer to? I'm guessing "stable platform" has to do with the game, which in turn can refers to "framerates", among other things. If you mean something else, then that's even LESS of a reason for saying a game is bad. It's no one's fault (I know, you a computer expert and have been one for decades) you can't get the game running. I had no problem. But then-- hmm-- I'm no GPLS (Grand Prix Legend Snob). Save your comments-- worthless, as I see them-- for your own clique. Alanb
On Wed, 24 Oct 2001 21:28:32 +0100, "Alan Coates" <[email hidden]> wrote: > >Don't remember mentioning framerates ... READ the f**king post before u >reply! > >Alan I run the game on a GF2 using 12.90 drivers in windowed mode and it runs great for me. And I'm not even a programmer.
FYI - 'stable platform' can mean several things but low framerate would be the least problem. With all G3 drivers for this product 'stable platform' means severe screen corruption. The only official drivers that work but poorly with F1 2001 is the very old 12.90 which are oh so slow. The up to date official drivers are unusable with the game. In the past EA have used the public at their expense to beta test their products and then instead of a patch have released a later version that needs to be purchased again! Your snobbery answer is just ridiculous as I would love to own a modern F1 sim, but this is not it. All Papyrus games are quite polished before they are released and if a patch is required, they respond. I admit it was my mistake to again purchase an EA product. If you prefer to own sub-standard products..well that speaks for itself! Alan "Alan Bernardo" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:lQHB7.32603$[email hidden]... > And what is the above quote supposed to refer to? I'm guessing "stable > platform" has to do with the game, which in turn can refers to"framerates",
Quoted text (7 lines)> among other things. > > If you mean something else, then that's even LESS of a reason for saying a > game is bad. It's no one's fault (I know, you a computer expert and have > been one for decades) you can't get the game running. I had no problem. > > But then-- hmm-- I'm no GPLS (Grand Prix Legend Snob). Save your
comments-- > worthless, as I see them-- for your own clique. > > Alanb > >
Cliff Roman <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > Those were about the dumbest responses I have seen in awhile > >Almost as dumb as saying "F1 2001 yes its garbage"
On Thu, 25 Oct 2001 11:33:34 +0100, "Alan Coates" >I admit it was my mistake to again purchase an EA product. > >If you prefer to own sub-standard products..well that speaks for itself! > >AlanSorry to hear of your experiences, Alan but with my old, outdated 3dfx 5500 the game is a joy. Much better than the last two offerings. My racing machine continues to use the 3dfx board as I just have a cartload of issues with the 3000 permutations of drivers that get offered for the nvidia family. I use a gf2 on the other machine and have had to switch drivers a number of times for various flight/fight games. No way will I go to a new/latest/greatest graphics card from anyone. The drivers always seem to lag way behind the hardware. Staying a generation behind seems to help both the wallet and the headaches. Jeff
Thanks Jeff and Dave for replies that arn't contemptible. I have a second computer, relegated to being a dedicated server for hosting GPL reaces and some serious work. This is a P3/800-V5500 combo. I thought I would give it a try. Not only does F1-2001 run well but gives you the option of running at greater frequency rates so preventing 'tired eyes' syndrome. It obvious that the sim has been optimised for this (I still consder great) graphics adapter. I still believe that EA should make sure that such a recent sim should run with the latest official drivers for the most popular graphics adapters. The 12.90 drivers worked moderately well but I'm loath to wasting my time constantly changing between drivers with all that's involved i.e. time to uninstall the current drivers/reboot/reinstall suitable drivers for the sim. This is really not acceptable for G3 owners especially as the difference in benchmark between the latest driver and the 12.90 is almost 2000 points. In my case a drop from 7081 to 5360 incidently F1 2001 is running on the '3DFx' computer very smoothly at 1280x1024x16 (100hz) no FSAA I think it's the first time in 15 years that I have had to revert to an 'old' computer to run a game :) Alan "Jeffrey Haas" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]...
Quoted text (17 lines)> On Thu, 25 Oct 2001 11:33:34 +0100, "Alan Coates" > >I admit it was my mistake to again purchase an EA product. > > > >If you prefer to own sub-standard products..well that speaks for itself! > > > >Alan > Sorry to hear of your experiences, Alan but with my old, outdated 3dfx > 5500 the game is a joy. Much better than the last two offerings. My > racing machine continues to use the 3dfx board as I just have a > cartload of issues with the 3000 permutations of drivers that get > offered for the nvidia family. I use a gf2 on the other machine and > have had to switch drivers a number of times for various flight/fight > games. No way will I go to a new/latest/greatest graphics card from > anyone. The drivers always seem to lag way behind the hardware. > Staying a generation behind seems to help both the wallet and the > headaches. >
"Dave Ryerson" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]...
Quoted text (12 lines)> On Wed, 24 Oct 2001 21:28:32 +0100, "Alan Coates" > <[email hidden]> wrote: > > > > > >Don't remember mentioning framerates ... READ the f**king post before u > >reply! > > > >Alan > > I run the game on a GF2 using 12.90 drivers in windowed mode and it > runs great for me. And I'm not even a programmer.> Jeff
In article <HLWB7.97882$[email hidden]>, "Alan Coates" <[email hidden]> writes: >I still believe that EA should make sure that such a recent sim should run >with the latest official drivers for the most popular graphics adapters. Wouldn't that depend on when the driver came out relative to the development cycle of the program? I actually *wouldn't* expect developers to be able to keep up, since the drivers change so often... Eldred -- Dale Earnhardt, Sr. R.I.P. 1951-2001 Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett GPLRank - under construction... Never argue with an idiot. He brings you down to his level, then beats you with experience... Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.
In article <wQRB7.96161$[email hidden]>, "Alan Coates" <[email hidden]> writes:
Quoted text (7 lines)>Your snobbery answer is just ridiculous as I would love to own a modern F1 >sim, but this is not it. All Papyrus games are quite polished before they >are released and if a patch is required, they respond. > >I admit it was my mistake to again purchase an EA product. > >If you prefer to own sub-standard products..well that speaks for itself!
I didn't think he was being snobbish. I think the point he was trying to make was just because it doesn't work on a few computers doesn't mean it's total crap. We've passed the point where programs work on all flavors of all systems. Every game is going to have a subset of people who can't run it. Witness the recent issues with N4 over the copy-protection scheme. I hope you get your problems sorted out, though. I haven't played the game yet, but it sounds like fun. Eldred -- Dale Earnhardt, Sr. R.I.P. 1951-2001 Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett GPLRank - under construction... Never argue with an idiot. He brings you down to his level, then beats you with experience... Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.
Well yeah, but in theory (!) the drivers implement D3D services (API's), so if the game developers use those API's correctly their code should be forward-compatible with any future driver release. You could blame nVidia instead of EA I suppose, if it wasn't for the fact that N4, GPL, the RT demo, and Red Faction (the games I currently have on my HD) run fine with the latest official (21.83) nVidia drivers but F1 2001 doesn't. Those other developers seem to have been able to use the API correctly. That being said, F12001 runs OK on my PC, in windowed mode, except for skeleton cars in the mirrors and a few other little glitches. It is a buggy game but not as bad as it's being made out to be. "EldredP" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > In article <HLWB7.97882$[email hidden]>, "Alan > Coates" <[email hidden]> writes: > > >I still believe that EA should make sure that such a recent sim shouldrun > >with the latest official drivers for the most popular graphics adapters. > > Wouldn't that depend on when the driver came out relative to thedevelopment > cycle of the program? I actually *wouldn't* expect developers to be ableto
Quoted text (9 lines)> keep up, since the drivers change so often... > > Eldred > -- > Dale Earnhardt, Sr. R.I.P. 1951-2001 > Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett > GPLRank - under construction... > > Never argue with an idiot. He brings you down to his level, then beats
you > with experience... > Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.
"Alan Coates" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:wQRB7.96161$[email hidden]... > All Papyrus games are quite polished before they > are released and if a patch is required, they respond. I said it the other day, and I'll say it again now since history is being re-written. GPL ran like shit on all but the absolute fastest CPU when it was released. People had to go out and buy Celeron 300's and overclock them to 366. Also, people ended up buying Rendition cards for GPL, even though the Voodoo was best for just about everything else. I'd rather install different drivers than buy a new system for one game. N4 had crappy AI (people here screamed about it) and it took Papyrus two months before a patch was released. BTW, the only games that ever had trouble with my old T2 wheel were GPL and N4. David G Fisher
Oh yea, I forgot about the copy protection issues with N4. David G Fisher "David G Fisher" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:bh_B7.156038$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (9 lines)> > "Alan Coates" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:wQRB7.96161$[email hidden]... > > All Papyrus games are quite polished before they > > are released and if a patch is required, they respond. > > I said it the other day, and I'll say it again now since history is being > re-written. GPL ran like shit on all but the absolute fastest CPU when it > was released. People had to go out and buy Celeron 300's and overclock
them
Quoted text (9 lines)> to 366. Also, people ended up buying Rendition cards for GPL, even though > the Voodoo was best for just about everything else. > > I'd rather install different drivers than buy a new system for one game. > > N4 had crappy AI (people here screamed about it) and it took Papyrus two > months before a patch was released. > > BTW, the only games that ever had trouble with my old T2 wheel were GPL
and > N4. > > David G Fisher >
Well said... There is Papyrus and then there is EVERYONE else. No one ever has or ever will compare to a Papy sim. I just wish they were working on a CART sim. Chris "Alan Coates" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:wQRB7.96161$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (29 lines)> FYI - 'stable platform' can mean several things but low framerate would be > the least problem. With all G3 drivers for this product 'stable platform' > means severe screen corruption. The only official drivers that work but > poorly with F1 2001 is the very old 12.90 which are oh so slow. The up to > date official drivers are unusable with the game. > > In the past EA have used the public at their expense to beta test their > products and then instead of a patch have released a later version that > needs to be purchased again! > > Your snobbery answer is just ridiculous as I would love to own a modern F1 > sim, but this is not it. All Papyrus games are quite polished before they > are released and if a patch is required, they respond. > > I admit it was my mistake to again purchase an EA product. > > If you prefer to own sub-standard products..well that speaks for itself! > > Alan > > "Alan Bernardo" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:lQHB7.32603$[email hidden]... > > > And what is the above quote supposed to refer to? I'm guessing "stable > > platform" has to do with the game, which in turn can refers to > "framerates", > > among other things. > > > > If you mean something else, then that's even LESS of a reason for saying
a > > game is bad. It's no one's fault (I know, you a computer expert andhave
Quoted text (11 lines)> > been one for decades) you can't get the game running. I had no problem. > > > > But then-- hmm-- I'm no GPLS (Grand Prix Legend Snob). Save your > comments-- > > worthless, as I see them-- for your own clique. > > > > Alanb > > > > > >
Contemptible? Did you not start with the "READ the f**king post before u reply!" Then you say, in another post-- "With all G3 drivers for this product 'stable platform' means severe screen corruption. The only official drivers that work but poorly with F1 2001 is the very old 12.90 which are oh so slow. The up to date official drivers are unusable with the game." Sounds like partially a frame-rate issue to me ("oh so slow"). Frame-rates or no frame rates, you're basing the worth on F1 2001 on how it runs on your machine, while with others, including myself (as I mentioned above), the game runs just fine. So I did read your initial post, and my interpretation, as you've said yourself ("oh so slo" and other references to "drivers", etc.) was pretty close to what you meant without your even realizing that you said it. I certainly have no problem with anyone not liking a game. Most of you know more about what makes a good racing sim than I do. But to say a racing sim is not a sim simply because it runs poorly on your machine, is not my problem, nor anyone else's, whose machine handles a particular game just fine. That's my point. I don't rate the safety of a car based on the fact that you have a tendency to slam it into a tree at 200 mph. Alanb "Alan Coates" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:HLWB7.97882$[email hidden]... > Thanks Jeff and Dave for replies that arn't contemptible. > I have a second computer, relegated to being a dedicated server forhosting > GPL reaces and some serious work. This is a P3/800-V5500 combo. I thoughtI > would give it a try. Not only does F1-2001 run well but gives you theoption > of running at greater frequency rates so preventing 'tired eyes' syndrome. > It obvious that the sim has been optimised for this (I still consdergreat)
Quoted text (8 lines)> graphics adapter. > > I still believe that EA should make sure that such a recent sim should run > with the latest official drivers for the most popular graphics adapters. > > The 12.90 drivers worked moderately well but I'm loath to wasting my time > constantly changing between drivers with all that's involved i.e. time to > uninstall the current drivers/reboot/reinstall suitable drivers for the
sim. > This is really not acceptable for G3 owners especially as the differencein > benchmark between the latest driver and the 12.90 is almost 2000 points.In
Quoted text (17 lines)> my case a drop from 7081 to 5360 > > incidently F1 2001 is running on the '3DFx' computer very smoothly at > 1280x1024x16 (100hz) no FSAA > > I think it's the first time in 15 years that I have had to revert to an > 'old' computer to run a game :) > > Alan > > > "Jeffrey Haas" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:[email hidden]... > > On Thu, 25 Oct 2001 11:33:34 +0100, "Alan Coates" > > >I admit it was my mistake to again purchase an EA product. > > > > > >If you prefer to own sub-standard products..well that speaks for
itself!
Quoted text (30 lines)> > > > > >Alan > > Sorry to hear of your experiences, Alan but with my old, outdated 3dfx > > 5500 the game is a joy. Much better than the last two offerings. My > > racing machine continues to use the 3dfx board as I just have a > > cartload of issues with the 3000 permutations of drivers that get > > offered for the nvidia family. I use a gf2 on the other machine and > > have had to switch drivers a number of times for various flight/fight > > games. No way will I go to a new/latest/greatest graphics card from > > anyone. The drivers always seem to lag way behind the hardware. > > Staying a generation behind seems to help both the wallet and the > > headaches. > > > "Dave Ryerson" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:[email hidden]... > > On Wed, 24 Oct 2001 21:28:32 +0100, "Alan Coates" > > <[email hidden]> wrote: > > > > > > > > > >Don't remember mentioning framerates ... READ the f**king post before u > > >reply! > > > > > >Alan > > > > I run the game on a GF2 using 12.90 drivers in windowed mode and it > > runs great for me. And I'm not even a programmer.> Jeff > > >
This IS (ala Jonah Falcon) the real issue, isn't it? A Lexus owner will always damn a lesser make, no matter if the make is better or not. Alanb "Chris Rogers" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:Vl3C7.15099$[email hidden]... > Well said... There is Papyrus and then there is EVERYONE else. No oneever > has or ever will compare to a Papy sim. I just wish they were working ona
Quoted text (7 lines)> CART sim. > > Chris > > "Alan Coates" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:wQRB7.96161$[email hidden]... > > FYI - 'stable platform' can mean several things but low framerate would
be > > the least problem. With all G3 drivers for this product 'stableplatform' > > means severe screen corruption. The only official drivers that work but > > poorly with F1 2001 is the very old 12.90 which are oh so slow. The upto
Quoted text (7 lines)> > date official drivers are unusable with the game. > > > > In the past EA have used the public at their expense to beta test their > > products and then instead of a patch have released a later version that > > needs to be purchased again! > > > > Your snobbery answer is just ridiculous as I would love to own a modern
F1 > > sim, but this is not it. All Papyrus games are quite polished beforethey
Quoted text (12 lines)> > are released and if a patch is required, they respond. > > > > I admit it was my mistake to again purchase an EA product. > > > > If you prefer to own sub-standard products..well that speaks for itself! > > > > Alan > > > > "Alan Bernardo" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > > news:lQHB7.32603$[email hidden]... > > > > > And what is the above quote supposed to refer to? I'm guessing
"stable > > > platform" has to do with the game, which in turn can refers to > > "framerates", > > > among other things. > > > > > > If you mean something else, then that's even LESS of a reason forsaying > a > > > game is bad. It's no one's fault (I know, you a computer expert and > have > > > been one for decades) you can't get the game running. I had noproblem.
Quoted text (13 lines)> > > > > > But then-- hmm-- I'm no GPLS (Grand Prix Legend Snob). Save your > > comments-- > > > worthless, as I see them-- for your own clique. > > > > > > Alanb > > > > > > > > > > > > >

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy