Hi all,
After introducing camber to my tire force system, the standard Ferrari
Pacejka parameter set from Genta's book makes it slide sideways
severely.
The camber is very much near 0, but even a little degree of camber
makes things go haywire). I was wondering if anybody knew the exact
units that 'camber' uses in Pacejka's Fx formula?
I now use radians, but with a5/a8/a111/a112 set as they're specified,
I get LARGE forces developing quickly.
Thanks,
Ruud van Gaal
Free car sim: http://www.racer.nl/
Pencil art : http://www.marketgraph.nl/gallery/
"Ruud van Gaal" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
Ruud,
The short answer, I just dont know. Even with zero camber a side force is
produced. I dont understand it. How can that be true at rest? It must be
a result of the formula being empirical, it tries to fit the curve for most
situations, but fails a little. I can understand that a force would be
produced due to conicity and camber at higher speed.
Ash
http://www.siroccoracing.com
Quoted text (12 lines)
> Hi all, > > After introducing camber to my tire force system, the standard Ferrari > Pacejka parameter set from Genta's book makes it slide sideways > severely. > The camber is very much near 0, but even a little degree of camber > makes things go haywire). I was wondering if anybody knew the exact > units that 'camber' uses in Pacejka's Fx formula? > > I now use radians, but with a5/a8/a111/a112 set as they're specified, > I get LARGE forces developing quickly. >On Tue, 5 Mar 2002 11:10:56 -0000, "Ashley McConnell"
<[email hidden]> wrote:
In that case, you'd expect slip angle to get back to 0, but indeed, it
looks like Pacejka's Fx formula doesn't work nicely at 0 speed
(because with the same conicity/camber at speeds>0 a force would be
developed, where speed isn't an input even).
Perhaps nearing 0 speed some cutoff must be done to get Sv and Sh down
to 0. Just for some better low-speed behavior.
Ruud van Gaal
Free car sim: http://www.racer.nl/
Pencil art : http://www.marketgraph.nl/gallery/
Quoted text (10 lines)
>"Ruud van Gaal" <[email hidden]> wrote in message >news:[email hidden]... >> I was wondering if anybody knew the exact >> units that 'camber' uses in Pacejka's Fx formula? >> >> I now use radians, but with a5/a8/a111/a112 set as they're specified, >> I get LARGE forces developing quickly. > >The short answer, I just dont know. Even with zero camber a side force is >produced. I dont understand it. How can that be true at rest?Im using degrees here to pass into pacejka...I guess the information
was on Genta's...wansnt it? And Im not getting a lot of lateral
force...the force Im getting is so low that Im still guessing if my
signs are right or not...
The Ferrari on the book as a "static" camber force applied to the
constants...maybe some kind of non-symmetry in the tires? I dont trust
those values anyway...
"Ashley McConnell" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:<a629cd$ie7$[email hidden]>...
Quoted text (26 lines)
> "Ruud van Gaal" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:[email hidden]... > > Hi all, > > > > After introducing camber to my tire force system, the standard Ferrari > > Pacejka parameter set from Genta's book makes it slide sideways > > severely. > > The camber is very much near 0, but even a little degree of camber > > makes things go haywire). I was wondering if anybody knew the exact > > units that 'camber' uses in Pacejka's Fx formula? > > > > I now use radians, but with a5/a8/a111/a112 set as they're specified, > > I get LARGE forces developing quickly. > > > > > Ruud, > > The short answer, I just dont know. Even with zero camber a side force is > produced. I dont understand it. How can that be true at rest? It must be > a result of the formula being empirical, it tries to fit the curve for most > situations, but fails a little. I can understand that a force would be > produced due to conicity and camber at higher speed. > > Ash > http://www.siroccoracing.com
"Stefano Casillo" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
Hi Stefano,
Yep its Genta we are talking about. Are you sure you are setting the Fz
value to the correct amount. I discovered last night that I was using mass
/ 4000 (instead of (mass * g)/4000). This created Fy values of around 300N
max. Remember Fz is in KN. Also, make sure your slipangle is in degrees
rather than radians.
What I found was helpful was to create a "graphing" application to produce
graphs using the code you have used for Pacekja. Have a look at "physics"
on my website for an example of a graph. Once you have it working in the
graph application, you can move it over to your sim (something I have done
recently).
The tyres produce a lateral force with no slipangle or slipratio, my feeling
is that this should be linked to speed a little (but I am only learning too,
so dont take my word for it :)). This force is produced by conicity (i.e.
one side of the tyre is slightly larger in diameter than the other) or
plysteer (due to the construction of the tyre).
You probably know this stuff already, but I hope it helps
All the best,
Ash
http://www.siroccoracing.com
Quoted text (10 lines)
> Im using degrees here to pass into pacejka...I guess the information > was on Genta's...wansnt it? And Im not getting a lot of lateral > force...the force Im getting is so low that Im still guessing if my > signs are right or not... > > The Ferrari on the book as a "static" camber force applied to the > constants...maybe some kind of non-symmetry in the tires? I dont trust > those values anyway... > >Ruud,
I thought u were using a correction at low speed for tire force due to
relaxation... shouldnt that bring everthing to 0 when your speed is 0?
Ashley??? What's 4000 in your code???? Magic numbers or what???
[email hidden] (Ruud van Gaal) wrote in message news:<[email hidden]>...
Quoted text (25 lines)
> On Tue, 5 Mar 2002 11:10:56 -0000, "Ashley McConnell" > <[email hidden]> wrote: > > >"Ruud van Gaal" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > >news:[email hidden]... > >> I was wondering if anybody knew the exact > >> units that 'camber' uses in Pacejka's Fx formula? > >> > >> I now use radians, but with a5/a8/a111/a112 set as they're specified, > >> I get LARGE forces developing quickly. > > > >The short answer, I just dont know. Even with zero camber a side force is > >produced. I dont understand it. How can that be true at rest? > > In that case, you'd expect slip angle to get back to 0, but indeed, it > looks like Pacejka's Fx formula doesn't work nicely at 0 speed > (because with the same conicity/camber at speeds>0 a force would be > developed, where speed isn't an input even). > Perhaps nearing 0 speed some cutoff must be done to get Sv and Sh down > to 0. Just for some better low-speed behavior. > > > Ruud van Gaal > Free car sim: http://www.racer.nl/ > Pencil art : http://www.marketgraph.nl/gallery/
"Stefano Casillo" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
Nope, not quite magic ;)
I havent got any weight distribution or suspension yet, so I just divide the
weight by 4 to get the weight on each wheel. But the Pacekja formula needs
Fz in kiloNewtons (kN) so you need to divide that AGAIN by 1000, so I just
combined the 2 divisions. Nothing mystical at all ;)
All the best,
Ash
http://www.siroccoracing.com
Quoted text (7 lines)
> Ruud, > > I thought u were using a correction at low speed for tire force due to > relaxation... shouldnt that bring everthing to 0 when your speed is 0? > > Ashley??? What's 4000 in your code???? Magic numbers or what??? >On 5 Mar 2002 09:10:27 -0800, [email hidden] (Stefano Casillo) wrote:
>Ruud,
>
>I thought u were using a correction at low speed for tire force due to
>relaxation... shouldnt that bring everthing to 0 when your speed is 0?
I use relaxation currently only longitudinally. Laterally the car at
low speed gets very jittery lateral forces, which if integrated at
high enough frequency, make the car seem stable, even sideways at
hills and such.
So I guess maybe with the camber forces, left & right tires will
balance eachother out. But nearing 0, it's just the slipangle and
slipratio that get 'relaxed' and stabilize. They may stabilize at
non-zero values though when a static camber force creeps in, I don't
know.
The problem I had was with Genta numbers the lateral forces with a bit
of camber became really large, and my car moved over to the side very
unrealistically, to make an understatement. :)
Ruud van Gaal
Free car sim: http://www.racer.nl/
Pencil art : http://www.marketgraph.nl/gallery/
Left and right wont balance at all...cause if u are using a non-zero
value for a9 in pacejka lateral formula u'll get a constant lateral
accelleration...
U could try to invert a9 on the left tires...but that doesnt make much
sense...I think that a9 means that that tire tends to steer somewhere
left or right...and that's possible...but, that'll work only if the
tire is rolling...dont u think?
In Gillespie there's a graph of lateral force "building" up while the
tire is rolling...I still didnt code my low-speed behavior, but I
think I'll start from that graph to come up with something...
Anyway...if u are getting a lot of camber thrust there's something
wrong somewhere cause I think in Milliken I've read that camber thrust
isnt very relevant over the total force...
Meanwhile...I know u have this figured out so: any suggestion for
papers, books, links about differentials? Nothing in Genta, nothing in
Gillespie, something in Milliken, and not enough on the internet...
I've ordered a Carroll Smith book on amazon and it should have
something about differentials...but it's going to be a 1-2 week
waiting...and Im locked with a LOCKED differential...
[email hidden] (Ruud van Gaal) wrote in message news:<[email hidden]>...
Quoted text (25 lines)
> On 5 Mar 2002 09:10:27 -0800, [email hidden] (Stefano Casillo) wrote: > > >Ruud, > > > >I thought u were using a correction at low speed for tire force due to > >relaxation... shouldnt that bring everthing to 0 when your speed is 0? > > I use relaxation currently only longitudinally. Laterally the car at > low speed gets very jittery lateral forces, which if integrated at > high enough frequency, make the car seem stable, even sideways at > hills and such. > So I guess maybe with the camber forces, left & right tires will > balance eachother out. But nearing 0, it's just the slipangle and > slipratio that get 'relaxed' and stabilize. They may stabilize at > non-zero values though when a static camber force creeps in, I don't > know. > > The problem I had was with Genta numbers the lateral forces with a bit > of camber became really large, and my car moved over to the side very > unrealistically, to make an understatement. :) > > > Ruud van Gaal > Free car sim: http://www.racer.nl/ > Pencil art : http://www.marketgraph.nl/gallery/On 6 Mar 2002 07:39:53 -0800, [email hidden] (Stefano Casillo) wrote:
>In Gillespie there's a graph of lateral force "building" up while the
>tire is rolling...I still didnt code my low-speed behavior, but I
>think I'll start from that graph to come up with something...
i think you 've got a point here, the tire act like a rubber's block
when not rolling, i.e. you should compute a friction force instead of
using pacejka formula
if v=0 then f = k0 else f = -k1.v
Sebastien TIXIER - Game Developer
Dynamics and Car Physics
http://www.eden-studios.fr
GPLRank Normal:-44.24 Monster:-124.44
>if v=0 then f = k0 else f = -k1.v
BIG mistake,in fact its
if v=0 then f=k0.tire_load else f= -k1.tire_load.v/||v||
when v is not null the friction force is proportional
to the load on the tire and opposite to the velocity direction.
when v is null it's the minimun force to apply on the solid to start
it to move.
>> The camber is very much near 0, but even a little degree of camber
>> makes things go haywire). I was wondering if anybody knew the exact
>> units that 'camber' uses in Pacejka's Fx formula?
>>
Ruud, I tested the latest alpha release on my game box, and the car
would not even start at Carrera, just slid sideways to the left all
the way into the pit wall.... is this "bug" related to the above
problem?
uwe


































