Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

F1 2001 physics (downforce)

12 posts by 6 people · 20 Mar 2002 05:00 UTC - 22 Mar 2002 23:07 UTC

Alex Cameron 20 Mar 2002 05:00 UTC#129193
I've never really taken to F12001 since it came out, something just didn't feel right about it. I had a suspicion that they've underdone the mechanical grip and overdone the downforce. So I've been playing about with the physics a bit, I upped the tyre's grip levels a little and at the moment I'm working on lowering the downforce. But I've noticed something, looking on technical F1 sites I found that the wings should provide about 60% of the cars downforce with the front about 25% and the rear 35% (I know that would vary allot depending on settings). But as far as I can make out even at their maximum settings the wings only account for about 30% of the cars downforce in F12001. The rest is made up by the body at about 25% and the diffuser at a whopping 43% that can't be right? Also the downforce loss with lower wing settings is way too extreme imo, at the lowest wing setting the downforce is virtually zero, that's just not right the lowest wing setting on an F1 car will still produce allot of downforce. That must be why everyone uses unrealistically high wing settings everywhere because there's too much of a penalty for lowering the wings, and far too extreme a range. 50 clicks is 50x the downforce of 1 click, there can't be more than a 3-4x difference in downforce produced by the wings between the highest and lowest settings on an F1 car (I'm guessing there). Have I got totally mixed up or are the physics values (downforce at least) of F12001's cars wrong? I've convinced myself they are and I'm trying to put them right the best I can and it's starting to feel better already :-) Alex
You're completely right, I've been tinkering with them myself as well and came to the same conclusion. Furthermore I felt that the overall downforce was way too high, I went back to far lower values making the car more realistic through high speed sections. The problem however is that the AI has some sort of downforce 'trick' in there, they always have higher downforce than us. And I also found out why, when you give them very little downforce, they can't handle the tricky car. So they slowdown in the middle of a fast corner. That's probably why they decided on giving them some extra downforce over the player. It could also be to get close to real world lap times. "Alex Cameron" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:a7951s$ohp$[email hidden]... > I've never really taken to F12001 since it came out, something just didn't > feel right about it. I had a suspicion that they've underdone themechanical > grip and overdone the downforce. So I've been playing about with thephysics > a bit, I upped the tyre's grip levels a little and at the moment I'mworking
Quoted text (12 lines)> on > lowering the downforce. > > But I've noticed something, looking on technical F1 sites I found that the > wings should provide about 60% of the cars downforce with the front about > 25% and the rear 35% (I know that would vary allot depending on settings). > But as far as I can make out even at their maximum settings the wings only > account for about 30% of the cars downforce in F12001. The rest is made up > by the body at about 25% and the diffuser at a whopping 43% that can't be > right? > > Also the downforce loss with lower wing settings is way too extreme imo,
at > the lowest wing setting the downforce is virtually zero, that's just not > right the lowest wing setting on an F1 car will still produce allot of > downforce. That must be why everyone uses unrealistically high wingsettings > everywhere because there's too much of a penalty for lowering the wings,and > far too extreme a range. 50 clicks is 50x the downforce of 1 click, there > can't be more than a 3-4x difference in downforce produced by the wings > between the highest and lowest settings on an F1 car (I'm guessing there). > > Have I got totally mixed up or are the physics values (downforce at least) > of F12001's cars wrong? I've convinced myself they are and I'm trying toput > them right the best I can and it's starting to feel better already :-) > > Alex > > >
"Alex Cameron" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:a7951s$ohp$[email hidden]... > I've never really taken to F12001 since it came out, something just didn't > feel right about it. I had a suspicion that they've underdone themechanical > grip and overdone the downforce. So I've been playing about with thephysics > a bit, I upped the tyre's grip levels a little and at the moment I'mworking
Quoted text (11 lines)> on > lowering the downforce. > > But I've noticed something, looking on technical F1 sites I found that the > wings should provide about 60% of the cars downforce with the front about > 25% and the rear 35% (I know that would vary allot depending on settings). > But as far as I can make out even at their maximum settings the wings only > account for about 30% of the cars downforce in F12001. The rest is made up > by the body at about 25% and the diffuser at a whopping 43% that can't be > right? >
Alex, IIRC, those values would be pretty close. I believe in David Tremayne's book _The_Science_ of_ Speed_ quotes similar values. compiled with the help of Gary Anderson, then of Jordan, circa 1997/98. Actual %: 25, 33,42 Averaging the downforce coefficients and downforce/drag ratios calculated by Enrico Benzing for a 750bhp car in Giorgio Piola's _Formual_1_Technical_Analysis_2000_ book: 1606 kg, 2.95 respectively. HTH, j-n
"Alex Cameron" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:a7951s$ohp$[email hidden]... > I've never really taken to F12001 since it came out, something justdidn't > feel right about it. I had a suspicion that they've underdone themechanical > grip and overdone the downforce. So I've been playing about with thephysics > a bit, I upped the tyre's grip levels a little and at the moment I'mworking > on > lowering the downforce. I disagree about lowering the grip. Low speed cornering is right where it should be as far as I can tell. I believe there is a problem in that there are still an awful lot of people who think that F1 2001 works properly in split axis mode, but it doesn't. So they end up with a 50% dead spot on the throttle without realizing it, and wonder why they can't control the car at low speed. Obviously I don't know if you are having that difficulty or not, but I do know that once I went back to combined axis control, thus getting rid of the dead spot, my low speed cornering problems nearly disappeared (they didn't completely disappear, because I'm not that good a driver :o) > But I've noticed something, looking on technical F1 sites I found thatthe > wings should provide about 60% of the cars downforce with the frontabout > 25% and the rear 35% (I know that would vary allot depending onsettings). > But as far as I can make out even at their maximum settings the wingsonly > account for about 30% of the cars downforce in F12001. The rest ismade up > by the body at about 25% and the diffuser at a whopping 43% that can'tbe > right? I don't think that is correct. There is no lift value for the body in the hdv files, only for the wings and the diffuser. And I think those percentages are in reference to a race trimmed vehicle. The basic lift values in the hdv files are for zero wing setting and zero ground height. If you look at the comments in the file it is clear that in race trim the wings will have more downforce than that base value and the diffuser will have less. > Also the downforce loss with lower wing settings is way too extremeimo, at > the lowest wing setting the downforce is virtually zero, that's justnot > right the lowest wing setting on an F1 car will still produce allot of > downforce. That must be why everyone uses unrealistically high wingsettings > everywhere because there's too much of a penalty for lowering thewings, and > far too extreme a range. 50 clicks is 50x the downforce of 1 click,there > can't be more than a 3-4x difference in downforce produced by thewings > between the highest and lowest settings on an F1 car (I'm guessingthere). Again I think this is incorrect. As I read the hdv files, the lift value is given by a second order polynomial function of wing setting, plus a height factor. For example, the front wing lift for the Williams would be: CL = -0.4678 - 0.0111 * S + 0.00001 * S^2 + 1.005 * H Where S is the wing setting and H is the height off of the ground in meters. That means the difference in CL from a setting of 0 to a setting of 50 is about 0.53 (assuming I pressed the keys on the calculator correctly :). IOW the max wing setting has just over double the downforce of the minimum one. > Have I got totally mixed up or are the physics values (downforce atleast) > of F12001's cars wrong? I've convinced myself they are and I'm tryingto put > them right the best I can and it's starting to feel better already :-) While I don't have any race car tuning experience, I do have 12 years experience in automotive aerodynamics, and based on that I think the values in the hdv files, correctly understood, are quite reasonable.
"Haqsau" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:a7b7hj$k9je5$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (24 lines)> "Alex Cameron" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:a7951s$ohp$[email hidden]... > > I've never really taken to F12001 since it came out, something just > didn't > > feel right about it. I had a suspicion that they've underdone the > mechanical > > grip and overdone the downforce. So I've been playing about with the > physics > > a bit, I upped the tyre's grip levels a little and at the moment I'm > working > > on > > lowering the downforce. > > I disagree about lowering the grip. Low speed cornering is right where > it should be as far as I can tell. I believe there is a problem in that > there are still an awful lot of people who think that F1 2001 works > properly in split axis mode, but it doesn't. So they end up with a 50% > dead spot on the throttle without realizing it, and wonder why they > can't control the car at low speed. Obviously I don't know if you are > having that difficulty or not, but I do know that once I went back to > combined axis control, thus getting rid of the dead spot, my low speed > cornering problems nearly disappeared (they didn't completely disappear, > because I'm not that good a driver :o) >
I consider myself a decent driver -62 Gplrank ect and I find F12001's low speed cornering frustrating and I'm pretty sure I don't have controller problems, the very high speed cornering is just boring.
Quoted text (21 lines)> > But I've noticed something, looking on technical F1 sites I found that > the > > wings should provide about 60% of the cars downforce with the front > about > > 25% and the rear 35% (I know that would vary allot depending on > settings). > > But as far as I can make out even at their maximum settings the wings > only > > account for about 30% of the cars downforce in F12001. The rest is > made up > > by the body at about 25% and the diffuser at a whopping 43% that can't > be > > right? > > I don't think that is correct. There is no lift value for the body in > the hdv files, only for the wings and the diffuser. And I think those > percentages are in reference to a race trimmed vehicle. The basic lift > values in the hdv files are for zero wing setting and zero ground > height. If you look at the comments in the file it is clear that in > race trim the wings will have more downforce than that base value and > the diffuser will have less.
There is a lift value for the body: BodyFore=(0.0, -0.5252, 0.435) // aero forces from moving forwards (lift value important!) I had misinterpreted the settings especially the wings, I've got a better understanding of them now and a race trimmed car with 30 clicks of wing on each end the wings roughly account for 48% and the body/diffuser 52% that is still quite wrong. The wing percentages are 26% front 21% rear, remember it should be 25% front 33% rear.
Quoted text (30 lines)> > > Also the downforce loss with lower wing settings is way too extreme > imo, at > > the lowest wing setting the downforce is virtually zero, that's just > not > > right the lowest wing setting on an F1 car will still produce allot of > > downforce. That must be why everyone uses unrealistically high wing > settings > > everywhere because there's too much of a penalty for lowering the > wings, and > > far too extreme a range. 50 clicks is 50x the downforce of 1 click, > there > > can't be more than a 3-4x difference in downforce produced by the > wings > > between the highest and lowest settings on an F1 car (I'm guessing > there). > > Again I think this is incorrect. As I read the hdv files, the lift > value is given by a second order polynomial function of wing setting, > plus a height factor. For example, the front wing lift for the Williams > would be: > > CL = -0.4678 - 0.0111 * S + 0.00001 * S^2 + 1.005 * H > > Where S is the wing setting and H is the height off of the ground in > meters. That means the difference in CL from a setting of 0 to a > setting of 50 is about 0.53 (assuming I pressed the keys on the > calculator correctly :). IOW the max wing setting has just over double > the downforce of the minimum one. >
Yep I realised that shortly after I posted, from first looking at the hdv I assumed the first two values made up the boundaries of a range :-/ > > While I don't have any race car tuning experience, I do have 12 years > experience in automotive aerodynamics, and based on that I think the > values in the hdv files, correctly understood, are quite reasonable. > > They may be perfectly right, but as F12001 is I just don't enjoy it I'm doing it to get the car to feel the way I want and using the excuse that it might be more realistic ;-) Alex
"Alex Cameron" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:a7bdaf$fq0$[email hidden]... > > I consider myself a decent driver -62 Gplrank ect and I find F12001'slow > speed cornering frustrating and I'm pretty sure I don't havecontroller > problems, the very high speed cornering is just boring. > Frustrating yes, but have you checked the speeds against real world telemetry? They come out about right to me at most of the tracks that I have tried. > > There is a lift value for the body: > > BodyFore=(0.0, -0.5252, 0.435) // aero forces from moving forwards(lift > value important!) > Very strange. I believe you are correct, but it's odd that the third value in there doesn't match the drag coefficient. > > They may be perfectly right, but as F12001 is I just don't enjoy itI'm > doing it to get the car to feel the way I want and using the excusethat it > might be more realistic ;-) > Just curious, have you tried combined axis pedals? I didn't believe I had the problem either until I tried it, and I have gotten the same reaction from other people. If you haven't tried it please do, I think you will be surprised at the result.
briGuy 21 Mar 2002 03:45 UTC↳ reply to Haqsau#128996
"Haqsau" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:a7bfv7$k01ka$[email hidden]...> Just curious, have you tried combined axis pedals? I didn't believe I > had the problem either until I tried it, and I have gotten the same > reaction from other people. If you haven't tried it please do, I think > you will be surprised at the result. > OK, I have the same issue, but I don't find it to be a huge problem. In fact, before you mentioned it, everything seemed fine to me. I think the thing is, I only play F1-2001 - no other sims. Because of that, I have simply adjusted to this, to the point where I can control my car naturally. I did a test a few minutes ago, and I was able to maintain any speed I wanted to, within 5mph. And that was low-speed stuff, too - 25-75mph. Sure, there may be an argument that with the deadzone it's too easy to spin your car, due to misjudging where the throttle comes "on", but that just makes it more important to apply the throttle carefully. At least, that's what it's forced me to do. I don't see that as necessarily bad...
Haqsau 22 Mar 2002 03:20 UTC↳ reply to briGuy#128934
IF you can get used to it then keeping split axis is probably worthwhile. I just could not get used to it. Constantly coming into the throttle too hard because I was never sure where it was, but that's only part of it - it also created a longer and more abrupt brake to throttle transition on higher speed corners, which would throw me off the line. BTW, are you using throttle help? That would definitely make it easier, but I decided to be retentive and try to learn to drive without it. ;o) "briGuy" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:a7bkr7$gsn$[email hidden]... > "Haqsau" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:a7bfv7$k01ka$[email hidden]...> Just curious, haveyou > tried combined axis pedals? I didn't believe I > > had the problem either until I tried it, and I have gotten the same > > reaction from other people. If you haven't tried it please do, Ithink > > you will be surprised at the result. > > > > OK, I have the same issue, but I don't find it to be a huge problem.In > fact, before you mentioned it, everything seemed fine to me. I thinkthe > thing is, I only play F1-2001 - no other sims. Because of that, Ihave > simply adjusted to this, to the point where I can control my carnaturally. > I did a test a few minutes ago, and I was able to maintain any speed I > wanted to, within 5mph. And that was low-speed stuff, too - 25-75mph. > > Sure, there may be an argument that with the deadzone it's too easy tospin > your car, due to misjudging where the throttle comes "on", but thatjust > makes it more important to apply the throttle carefully. At least,that's > what it's forced me to do. I don't see that as necessarily bad... > > > >
I use throttle help for the Vipers in the GT mod, but I'm not sure If I have it set for F1. dave henrie "Haqsau" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:a7e7p6$k6e9d$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (45 lines)> IF you can get used to it then keeping split axis is probably > worthwhile. I just could not get used to it. Constantly coming into > the throttle too hard because I was never sure where it was, but that's > only part of it - it also created a longer and more abrupt brake to > throttle transition on higher speed corners, which would throw me off > the line. BTW, are you using throttle help? That would definitely make > it easier, but I decided to be retentive and try to learn to drive > without it. ;o) > > > "briGuy" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:a7bkr7$gsn$[email hidden]... > > "Haqsau" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > > news:a7bfv7$k01ka$[email hidden]...> Just curious, have > you > > tried combined axis pedals? I didn't believe I > > > had the problem either until I tried it, and I have gotten the same > > > reaction from other people. If you haven't tried it please do, I > think > > > you will be surprised at the result. > > > > > > > OK, I have the same issue, but I don't find it to be a huge problem. > In > > fact, before you mentioned it, everything seemed fine to me. I think > the > > thing is, I only play F1-2001 - no other sims. Because of that, I > have > > simply adjusted to this, to the point where I can control my car > naturally. > > I did a test a few minutes ago, and I was able to maintain any speed I > > wanted to, within 5mph. And that was low-speed stuff, too - 25-75mph. > > > > Sure, there may be an argument that with the deadzone it's too easy to > spin > > your car, due to misjudging where the throttle comes "on", but that > just > > makes it more important to apply the throttle carefully. At least, > that's > > what it's forced me to do. I don't see that as necessarily bad... > > > > > > > > >
briGuy 22 Mar 2002 04:07 UTC↳ reply to Haqsau#128849
"Haqsau" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:a7e7p6$k6e9d$[email hidden]... > IF you can get used to it then keeping split axis is probably > worthwhile. I just could not get used to it. Constantly coming into > the throttle too hard because I was never sure where it was, but that's > only part of it - it also created a longer and more abrupt brake to > throttle transition on higher speed corners, which would throw me off > the line. I wonder - do you brake with your right or left foot? I left-foot brake, which means both my feet are always on the pedals. That may make the difference, esp. during transition. During braking, my right foot eases off the gas, but my foot's still on the pedal, at the proper take-up point. If you right-foot brake, yeah - of course it would be difficult, as you're putting your whole foot back on the gas... BTW, are you using throttle help? That would definitely make > it easier, but I decided to be retentive and try to learn to drive > without it. ;o) Throttle assist? Well, typically no, although enough of the community is using it in the interests of "realism" (traction-control) that I have been been experimenting with running with it on low, but only lately. Before two weeks ago, I had been driving without it for two years...
briGuy 22 Mar 2002 04:18 UTC↳ reply to briGuy#128851
>I wonder - do you brake with your right or left foot? D'oh. If you wanted to use split-axis, you'd almost have to left-foot brake. My bad...
Haqsau 22 Mar 2002 23:07 UTC↳ reply to briGuy#128669
NP, but to answer your question - yes I left foot brake. Still I found that I could not get used to the dead spots. In fact, it kind of led to bad habits because I started to rest my feet on the pedals more in F1 2001, and then that really screwed me up in other games. I dunno, I'm still very much a newbie at all of this, so having to precisely take up exactly the right amount of slack in the pedal in order to just barely crack the throttle open is beyond my skill level. For now, at least, I lap much more consistently in F1 2001 with combined axis and no dead spots. "briGuy" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:a7ebbn$jni$[email hidden]... > >I wonder - do you brake with your right or left foot? > > D'oh. If you wanted to use split-axis, you'd almost have to left-foot > brake. My bad... > >

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy