Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

The future of racing sims

35 posts by 26 people · 08 Apr 2002 21:09 UTC - 11 Apr 2002 23:51 UTC

Proposal for a virtual crew chief to handle setups

Haybails suggested that future sims include a virtual crew chief who adjusts the car based on the driver's handling complaints. Many liked the idea for players without setup expertise, while Tom Pabst argued that drivers should learn setups, which drew a personal attack from another poster. Others proposed human crew chiefs or spotters online, and 'Schumi' of Relay Games said a voice-and-telemetry crew-chief system was half developed.

With Schumi (Relay Games)

setup/driving techniquerumour/speculation

Automated summary.

Haybails 08 Apr 2002 21:09 UTC#126197
A while back, might have been as much as a month and a half ago, someone submitted a post which basically stated that Racing sims really have no where else to improve. Now, I race solely in the Papyrus NASCAR Sim ... so, forgive me if this doesn't fit everyone's experience. But, I can think of one huge area where further work could be spent ... and I submit this idea not sarcastically, but, seriously; We need a dynamic intelligent interactive crew chief. I race solely Online ... and when I get to places like Bristol, I can pretty much forget about dialing in the car once the race has started. Besides ... I'm really not a set-up guru. So, what I need is a "Crew Chief" which can query me in straight forward Yes/No questions and intelligently react to my Yes/No answer. So, I should be able to hit a key (while I'm racing) to open up a "communications channel" to the "Crew Chief" and then it should start asking me questions. Like this: Too Loose? Yes. Loose entering? No. Loose exiting? Yes. Would you like us to adjust the "xyz" by "xxx"? No. Would you like us to adjust the "abc" by "aaa"? Yes. Or something like that. Understand what I'm getting at? So, there might be 25 guys racing at Bristol, all with the same game loaded, starting with the exact same setup and using the exact same "crew chief" code ... and finish the race with 25 different setups. There are a few "Quick Fix" guides which I've seen around the net ... and don't get me wrong ... they all help. But, I'm not able to consult them when I'm racing ... and I simply have gotten all the "fixes" memorized. What do you folks think? Is this a valid suggestion and a possible thing to code into the game? db
Great Idea! And probably close to what happens in real racing. You suspect that not all the NASCAR drivers are 'setup gurus' either. "Haybails" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > A while back, might have been as much as a month and a half ago, someonesubmitted a post which basically stated that Racing sims > really have no where else to improve. Now, I race solely in the PapyrusNASCAR Sim ... so, forgive me if this doesn't fit everyone's > experience. But, I can think of one huge area where further work could bespent ... and I submit this idea not sarcastically, but, > seriously; > > We need a dynamic intelligent interactive crew chief. > > I race solely Online ... and when I get to places like Bristol, I canpretty much forget about dialing in the car once the race has > started. Besides ... I'm really not a set-up guru. So, what I need is a"Crew Chief" which can query me in straight forward Yes/No > questions and intelligently react to my Yes/No answer. So, I should beable to hit a key (while I'm racing) to open up a > "communications channel" to the "Crew Chief" and then it should startasking me questions. Like this:
Quoted text (13 lines)> > Too Loose? > Yes. > Loose entering? > No. > Loose exiting? > Yes. > Would you like us to adjust the "xyz" by "xxx"? > No. > Would you like us to adjust the "abc" by "aaa"? > Yes. > > Or something like that. Understand what I'm getting at? So, there might be
25 guys racing at Bristol, all with the same game loaded, > starting with the exact same setup and using the exact same "crew chief"code ... and finish the race with 25 different setups. > There are a few "Quick Fix" guides which I've seen around the net ... anddon't get me wrong ... they all help. But, I'm not able to > consult them when I'm racing ... and I simply have gotten all the "fixes"memorized. > > What do you folks think? Is this a valid suggestion and a possible thingto code into the game? > > > db > >
BRH 09 Apr 2002 01:40 UTC↳ reply to Haybails#126238
I think that the old CART Precision Racing had a feature similar to this, but not during the race. So, it's probably something that could be done. Haybails wrote:
Quoted text (31 lines)> A while back, might have been as much as a month and a half ago, someone submitted a post which basically stated that Racing sims > really have no where else to improve. Now, I race solely in the Papyrus NASCAR Sim ... so, forgive me if this doesn't fit everyone's > experience. But, I can think of one huge area where further work could be spent ... and I submit this idea not sarcastically, but, > seriously; > > We need a dynamic intelligent interactive crew chief. > > I race solely Online ... and when I get to places like Bristol, I can pretty much forget about dialing in the car once the race has > started. Besides ... I'm really not a set-up guru. So, what I need is a "Crew Chief" which can query me in straight forward Yes/No > questions and intelligently react to my Yes/No answer. So, I should be able to hit a key (while I'm racing) to open up a > "communications channel" to the "Crew Chief" and then it should start asking me questions. Like this: > > Too Loose? > Yes. > Loose entering? > No. > Loose exiting? > Yes. > Would you like us to adjust the "xyz" by "xxx"? > No. > Would you like us to adjust the "abc" by "aaa"? > Yes. > > Or something like that. Understand what I'm getting at? So, there might be 25 guys racing at Bristol, all with the same game loaded, > starting with the exact same setup and using the exact same "crew chief" code ... and finish the race with 25 different setups. > There are a few "Quick Fix" guides which I've seen around the net ... and don't get me wrong ... they all help. But, I'm not able to > consult them when I'm racing ... and I simply have gotten all the "fixes" memorized. > > What do you folks think? Is this a valid suggestion and a possible thing to code into the game? > > db
bertr 09 Apr 2002 01:40 UTC#529125
I think that the old CART Precision Racing had a feature similar to this, but not during the race. So, it's probably something that could be done.
Quoted text (31 lines)> A while back, might have been as much as a month and a half ago, someone submitted a post which basically stated that Racing sims > really have no where else to improve. Now, I race solely in the Papyrus NASCAR Sim ... so, forgive me if this doesn't fit everyone's > experience. But, I can think of one huge area where further work could be spent ... and I submit this idea not sarcastically, but, > seriously; > We need a dynamic intelligent interactive crew chief. > I race solely Online ... and when I get to places like Bristol, I can pretty much forget about dialing in the car once the race has > started. Besides ... I'm really not a set-up guru. So, what I need is a "Crew Chief" which can query me in straight forward Yes/No > questions and intelligently react to my Yes/No answer. So, I should be able to hit a key (while I'm racing) to open up a > "communications channel" to the "Crew Chief" and then it should start asking me questions. Like this: > Too Loose? > Yes. > Loose entering? > No. > Loose exiting? > Yes. > Would you like us to adjust the "xyz" by "xxx"? > No. > Would you like us to adjust the "abc" by "aaa"? > Yes. > Or something like that. Understand what I'm getting at? So, there might be 25 guys racing at Bristol, all with the same game loaded, > starting with the exact same setup and using the exact same "crew chief" code ... and finish the race with 25 different setups. > There are a few "Quick Fix" guides which I've seen around the net ... and don't get me wrong ... they all help. But, I'm not able to > consult them when I'm racing ... and I simply have gotten all the "fixes" memorized. > What do you folks think? Is this a valid suggestion and a possible thing to code into the game? > db
SS 09 Apr 2002 05:18 UTC↳ reply to Haybails#126156
Fascinating idea. Seems that it would be easy enough to set up a relatively 'fixed' exhange where your 'crew chief' always asked the same basic questions about the car being, for instance, too loose... or having too much oversteer/understeer... pulling to the left/right... etc. But imagine if the game code actually allowed for 'intelligent' monitoring of your car's performance in real time against a set of benchmarks for a given track. Taking into account entry and exit speed through each turn, top speed through various track sections, deviation from 'ideal' line, deviation from 'ideal' apex, amount of tire spin and tire lockup and where they are occuring on the track, relative tire temperatures, etc., it seems that it would be possible for the game to make more 'intelligent' suggestions to help dial in a setup that matched up with a driver's style. Sometimes it's great to know nothing about coding.... let's me imagine that anything might be possible. :-) Itazura
In all honesty, what you are suggesting is something far more difficult than you might imagine. The person who could code that would basically put crew chiefs out of a job in real life. The problem is that for certain anomalies in handling, 6 different settings could be changed (you can get rid of oversteer by adjusting a wide number of different settings as an example). The trick is to make the right decision, which will not adversely affect other handling characteristics. In an easy world (which it is not) it would only be 1 setting you change. In real-life applications, it can be a fine balance of combination settings for multiple parameters. Of course there is no set formula to match your driving style, and this process would *still* require some trial and error. Which at the end of the day brings you right back to were we are now; Practicing, tweaking, practicing, tweaking... Even the computer would need to make quasi-drastic mistakes to learn the better solution in short periods of time. Although, I do not truly feel the idea you have is without any merit. Indeed I believe it has a lot of merit, and it is something that Relay is working on (in parallel terms). What if instead of the computer auto-configuring.... you had another "real person" on the other end of the in-game voice communications? This person would them adjust your settings based on your on-track feedback, and have those changes waiting for you the next stop. This person is your real-time virtua crew chief. That virtua crew chief on the other end of the mic might also be viewing your in-car cam over the net, and watching real-time telemetry through something like Relay TV. We have the codebase working for a large portion of the requirements to make it happen, it simply would require the developers to step up and allow official support/cooperation. Anyways... you touched on something we've been working on for a while, so I thought I'd pop in and throw out some things to chew on. Cheers, Schumi "Haybails" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > A while back, might have been as much as a month and a half ago, someonesubmitted a post which basically stated that Racing sims > really have no where else to improve. Now, I race solely in the PapyrusNASCAR Sim ... so, forgive me if this doesn't fit everyone's > experience. But, I can think of one huge area where further work could bespent ... and I submit this idea not sarcastically, but, > seriously; > > We need a dynamic intelligent interactive crew chief. > > I race solely Online ... and when I get to places like Bristol, I canpretty much forget about dialing in the car once the race has > started. Besides ... I'm really not a set-up guru. So, what I need is a"Crew Chief" which can query me in straight forward Yes/No > questions and intelligently react to my Yes/No answer. So, I should beable to hit a key (while I'm racing) to open up a > "communications channel" to the "Crew Chief" and then it should startasking me questions. Like this:
Quoted text (13 lines)> > Too Loose? > Yes. > Loose entering? > No. > Loose exiting? > Yes. > Would you like us to adjust the "xyz" by "xxx"? > No. > Would you like us to adjust the "abc" by "aaa"? > Yes. > > Or something like that. Understand what I'm getting at? So, there might be
25 guys racing at Bristol, all with the same game loaded, > starting with the exact same setup and using the exact same "crew chief"code ... and finish the race with 25 different setups. > There are a few "Quick Fix" guides which I've seen around the net ... anddon't get me wrong ... they all help. But, I'm not able to > consult them when I'm racing ... and I simply have gotten all the "fixes"memorized. > > What do you folks think? Is this a valid suggestion and a possible thingto code into the game? > > > db > >
"Haybails" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:<[email hidden]>... > > We need a dynamic intelligent interactive crew chief. Here is an area with some good possibilities. I'd especially like it if it would say from time to time: "Quit whining about the car and learn to drive, you moron!" I need that a lot. I all seriousness though, yes I think this is a good idea. Someone else mentioned it a while back in the N5 wish list thread, btw. > Is this a valid suggestion and a possible thing to code into the game? Whether or not this kind of thing can be coded in such a way as to work well without impacting the rest of the code or performance is probably only a matter of time and money. Gerald
"Schumi" < > In all honesty, what you are suggesting is something far more difficultthan > you might imagine. The person who could code that would basically put crew > chiefs out of a job in real life. The problem is that for certainanomalies > in handling, 6 different settings could be changed (you can get rid of > oversteer by adjusting a wide number of different settings as an example). > The trick is to make the right decision, which will not adversely affect > other handling characteristics. In an easy world (which it is not) itwould > only be 1 setting you change. In real-life applications, it can be a fine > balance of combination settings for multiple parameters. Well here is a possible avenue to achieve that....do not have just one crew chief, but rather a group of chief's that all have different tendancies. One might be more likely to use air pressure, another trackbar adjustments...as a driver you would have to find one of the many who SEEMS to understand you, then in the game you hire him. But yes it really would be a tough programming chore. I can already hear the possible belly aching tho... "Man I was leading a t Bristol, and called in for a small change...when I left the pits the car was so bad I wrecked and lost the ##*@# race...damn computer!!" dave henrie > > Of course there is no set formula to match your driving style, and this > process would *still* require some trial and error. Which at the end ofthe > day brings you right back to were we are now; Practicing, tweaking, > practicing, tweaking... Even the computer would need to make quasi-drastic > mistakes to learn the better solution in short periods of time. > > Although, I do not truly feel the idea you have is without any merit.Indeed
Quoted text (14 lines)> I believe it has a lot of merit, and it is something that Relay is working > on (in parallel terms). > > What if instead of the computer auto-configuring.... you had another "real > person" on the other end of the in-game voice communications? This person > would them adjust your settings based on your on-track feedback, and have > those changes waiting for you the next stop. This person is your real-time > virtua crew chief. > > That virtua crew chief on the other end of the mic might also be viewing > your in-car cam over the net, and watching real-time telemetry through > something like Relay TV. > > We have the codebase working for a large portion of the requirements to
make > it happen, it simply would require the developers to step up and allow > official support/cooperation. > > Anyways... you touched on something we've been working on for a while, soI
Quoted text (13 lines)> thought I'd pop in and throw out some things to chew on. > > Cheers, > Schumi > > > "Haybails" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:[email hidden]... > > A while back, might have been as much as a month and a half ago, someone > submitted a post which basically stated that Racing sims > > really have no where else to improve. Now, I race solely in the Papyrus > NASCAR Sim ... so, forgive me if this doesn't fit everyone's > > experience. But, I can think of one huge area where further work could
be
Quoted text (26 lines)> spent ... and I submit this idea not sarcastically, but, > > seriously; > > > > We need a dynamic intelligent interactive crew chief. > > > > I race solely Online ... and when I get to places like Bristol, I can > pretty much forget about dialing in the car once the race has > > started. Besides ... I'm really not a set-up guru. So, what I need is a > "Crew Chief" which can query me in straight forward Yes/No > > questions and intelligently react to my Yes/No answer. So, I should be > able to hit a key (while I'm racing) to open up a > > "communications channel" to the "Crew Chief" and then it should start > asking me questions. Like this: > > > > Too Loose? > > Yes. > > Loose entering? > > No. > > Loose exiting? > > Yes. > > Would you like us to adjust the "xyz" by "xxx"? > > No. > > Would you like us to adjust the "abc" by "aaa"? > > Yes. > > > > Or something like that. Understand what I'm getting at? So, there might
be > 25 guys racing at Bristol, all with the same game loaded, > > starting with the exact same setup and using the exact same "crew chief" > code ... and finish the race with 25 different setups. > > There are a few "Quick Fix" guides which I've seen around the net ...and > don't get me wrong ... they all help. But, I'm not able to > > consult them when I'm racing ... and I simply have gotten all the"fixes"
Quoted text (11 lines)> memorized. > > > > What do you folks think? Is this a valid suggestion and a possible thing > to code into the game? > > > > > > db > > > > > >
On 9 Apr 2002 06:23:44 -0700, [email hidden] (Gerald Moore) wrote:
Quoted text (7 lines)>"Haybails" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:<[email hidden]>... >> >> We need a dynamic intelligent interactive crew chief. > >Here is an area with some good possibilities. I'd especially like it >if it would say from time to time: "Quit whining about the car and >learn to drive, you moron!" I need that a lot.
OMG, "Simcopter 1 reporting heavy traffic"-trauma alert! ;-) Ruud van Gaal Free car sim: http://www.racer.nl/ Pencil art : http://www.marketgraph.nl/gallery/
I think this is not such a good idea. Why is it that we cry about "realism".....want it for our racing simulations, but then don't want to do any work to become better drivers, more knowledgeable drivers. This might be something good for "arcade mode" racing for those who just want to "play" with our good racing sims, and nothing else.....let the computer do it for me.....let the "computer" make me a Jeff Gordon! There's a very limited number of things you can change in a WC car from the pits during a race. It might take you all of two hours to practice and test them....to figure out what they do and in what way. There's literally dozens of "guides" on the topic of setups for you to reference, in addition to a very good (but not perfect) guide built into N2K2 to give the driver basic information about setup parameter changes. This is not hard. I think the term, "setup guru" is way over-used.....applied too many times to someone who has simply taken the time to learn and understand the basics of the race car setup parameters. That's an important part of the character of a "racing simulation".....should be part and parcel to its appeal. Why should the drivers who take the time to learn about racing......have that competitive edge removed from them by the computer......supporting those who don't/can't take the time to do the same? Maybe we should have the computer do the driving for you, too? If you can't/don't want to/won't learn about the basics of race car setups....run in "fixed setup" races....that's what they are for! Tom "Haybails" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > A while back, might have been as much as a month and a half ago, someonesubmitted a post which basically stated that Racing sims > really have no where else to improve. Now, I race solely in the PapyrusNASCAR Sim ... so, forgive me if this doesn't fit everyone's > experience. But, I can think of one huge area where further work could bespent ... and I submit this idea not sarcastically, but, > seriously; > > We need a dynamic intelligent interactive crew chief. > > I race solely Online ... and when I get to places like Bristol, I canpretty much forget about dialing in the car once the race has > started. Besides ... I'm really not a set-up guru. So, what I need is a"Crew Chief" which can query me in straight forward Yes/No > questions and intelligently react to my Yes/No answer. So, I should beable to hit a key (while I'm racing) to open up a > "communications channel" to the "Crew Chief" and then it should startasking me questions. Like this:
Quoted text (13 lines)> > Too Loose? > Yes. > Loose entering? > No. > Loose exiting? > Yes. > Would you like us to adjust the "xyz" by "xxx"? > No. > Would you like us to adjust the "abc" by "aaa"? > Yes. > > Or something like that. Understand what I'm getting at? So, there might be
25 guys racing at Bristol, all with the same game loaded, > starting with the exact same setup and using the exact same "crew chief"code ... and finish the race with 25 different setups. > There are a few "Quick Fix" guides which I've seen around the net ... anddon't get me wrong ... they all help. But, I'm not able to > consult them when I'm racing ... and I simply have gotten all the "fixes"memorized. > > What do you folks think? Is this a valid suggestion and a possible thingto code into the game? > > > db > >
Taking things another step, think about having one person online as the driver, and one person online as the drivers crew chief/and or spotter.The crew chief would set what would be done on the next pitstop, and that info would be relayed to the drivers computer to be done when they came in. You could make it mostly text based messaging between the driver and crew chief, and wouldnt have to have the hi graphics that the driver has, to save bandwidth.
"John Smith" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... "You could make it mostly text based messaging between the driver and crew chief, and wouldnt have to have the hi graphics that the driver has, to save bandwidth." When I am on the track I type as little as possible. No way would I want to type out all the info to a "remote" Crew chief. And IMO it sounds like it wouldn't be all that exciting for the guy that has to be the crew chief. - Isotrip�
What if the communication was done over real-time voice, and the crew chief could watch the other person drive from multiple angles in real-time, and could also view the real-time telemetry? Do you think that would make him bored? It's being developed (half done already). Cheers, Schumi "Isotrip�" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]...
Quoted text (7 lines)> > "John Smith" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:[email hidden]... > > > "You could make it mostly text based messaging between the driver and crew > chief, and wouldnt have to have the hi graphics that the driver has, to
save > bandwidth." > > When I am on the track I type as little as possible. No way would I wantto > type out all the info to a "remote" Crew chief. And IMO it sounds like it > wouldn't be all that exciting for the guy that has to be the crew chief. > > - Isotrip� > >
"Tom Pabst" wrote:
Quoted text (8 lines)> I think this is not such a good idea. > > Why is it that we cry about "realism".....want it for our racing > simulations, but then don't want to do any work to become better drivers, > more knowledgeable drivers. This might be something good for "arcade mode" > racing for those who just want to "play" with our good racing sims, and > nothing else.....let the computer do it for me.....let the "computer" make > me a Jeff Gordon!
My intepretation was that the idea was to "simulate" the dialogue between driver & race engineer. Currently our sims require both driver & engineer simulation. The suggestion was that you just simulate the driver aspect and discuss with the race engineer how to adjust the car. I am sure not all drivers are qualified race engineers are they? Tony
"Tony Rickard" wrote... > "Tom Pabst" wrote: > > > I think this is not such a good idea. > > > > Why is it that we cry about "realism".....want it for our racing > > simulations, but then don't want to do any work to become betterdrivers, > > more knowledgeable drivers. This might be something good for "arcademode" > > racing for those who just want to "play" with our good racing sims, and > > nothing else.....let the computer do it for me.....let the "computer"make > > me a Jeff Gordon! > > My intepretation was that the idea was to "simulate" the dialogue betweendriver > & race engineer. > > Currently our sims require both driver & engineer simulation. > > The suggestion was that you just simulate the driver aspect and discusswith the > race engineer how to adjust the car. I am sure not all drivers arequalified > race engineers are they? I'm definitely in favour of this. I'm reasonably good at mechanical things but I don't want to bother when I'm playing a racing game - I just want to race. I suspect the obsession with set-ups is an American thing born out of oval racing where it's more important than anything else. As for real racers, Jim Clark was notorious for just driving whatever he was given. Colin Chapman used to get really frustrated that he got no feedback about the changes he made, whatever he did to the car Jim drove it just as quickly. Today's drivers may be a little more aware but they have even more engineering support than ever. I can't see that it's that difficult to do (and I'm a software engineer by trade), but whether it can be done well I don't know. I'm sure it's no more complicated than all the wonderful work being done by the physics gurus. Tony Whitley
Quoted text (8 lines)> > Why should the drivers who take the time to learn about racing......have > that competitive edge removed from them by the computer......supporting > those who don't/can't take the time to do the same? Maybe we should have > the computer do the driving for you, too? > > If you can't/don't want to/won't learn about the basics of race car > setups....run in "fixed setup" races....that's what they are for!
This is exactly why serious game companies will never put the code in to help with the set ups. It's not about if they are able. The computer could make all the calculations and have a perfect set up for you to run. It's more about what those companies feel there customers want in a sim. But fortunatly there are very few elitist hard core simers out there, and soon it will not be profitable for companies to make sims for the select few. The majority of the population will not buy a game and compete online if they know they can't win. So you can brag all you want about having better set ups and lap times all you want, because this will be a thing of the past in a matter of a couple of years, and the rest of the majority of the public will be content with GT4 or NFS7 (or what ever they are up to).
Now there's a terrific idea for league racing. Two man teams....one crew chief...one driver. Could the driver and crew chief not be in voice com via the telephone, and the crew chief watching the race from the TV cam of a "non racing" car? Could he not also be your live and real "spotter"......?? I'd love to see an online racing league give this a trial....if the code could be hacked into a sim. TP "John Smith" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]...
Quoted text (8 lines)> Taking things another step, think about having one person online as the > driver, and one person online as the drivers crew chief/and or spotter.The > crew chief would set what would be done on the next pitstop, and that info > would be relayed to the drivers computer to be done when they came in. You > could make it mostly text based messaging between the driver and crew > chief, and wouldnt have to have the hi graphics that the driver has, to > save bandwidth. >
"jlohman" < (snip) It's not about if they are able. The computer could > make all the calculations and have a perfect set up for you to run. It's > more about what those companies feel there customers want in a sim. Isn't that what F1 teams do nowdays? They have the computer predict the car's behaivor and render a base setup. Most teams only make comfort adjustments nowdays...That's why guys like Zanardi didn't do well, he's a seat of his pants kind of driver, yet the Williams team basically said, here's the car setup to be the fastest posible at this circuit. Now learn to drive it... dave henrie
I had thought about the amount of typing needed and thought that maybe a form of shorthand would help, the crew chief could be more verbose. Here is a sample idea of how that could work: Crew Cheif types: Hows it handling? Driver: (possible responses) TI1 (tight going into turn 1) TC1 (tight in center of turn 1) TO1 ( tight out of turn 1) LI1 ( loose in turn 1) LC1 ( loose in center of turn one) LO1 ( loose out of turn one) Or the crewchief could ask questions that just needed a Y/N answer Voice comms would be great, but that entails having a good enough connection so that it works, or being able to use the regular phone system while online, so having the text option would be good for those that didnt have access to voice comms.
I think that the real time voice comunications would be MUCH better than Text based. And I am sure that there are some guys out there that would like to be a crew chief I suppose. But, I wouldn't be interested in being a crew chief at all. I would much rather drive my own car than watch someone elses. But that is just me. :o) - Isotrip� "Schumi" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:y4Hs8.829$[email hidden]... > What if the communication was done over real-time voice, and the crewchief
Quoted text (8 lines)> could watch the other person drive from multiple angles in real-time, and > could also view the real-time telemetry? > > Do you think that would make him bored? It's being developed (half done > already). > > Cheers, > Schumi
On Mon, 8 Apr 2002 16:09:18 -0500, "Haybails" <[email hidden]> wrote: >A while back, might have been as much as a month and a half ago, someone submitted a post which basically stated that Racing sims >really have no where else to improve. Now, I race solely in the Papyrus NASCAR Sim ... so, forgive me if this doesn't fit everyone's >experience. But, I can think of one huge area where further work could be spent ... and I submit this idea not sarcastically, but, >seriously; > >We need a dynamic intelligent interactive crew chief. <snip> Good idea! However, I can think of some more improvement.... What I would like is the possibility to develop your own car. The chassis, engine, tyres, gearbox, electronics, suspension do get a number of attributes, and you can adjust them, for example, between performance and reliability. Attributes like bore, stroke, exhaust length, etc. Now combine this with online play and teams....it wil not only be a matter of being the fastest driver, you can also be the best designer! <g> Remco
"Remco Moedt" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]...
Quoted text (15 lines)> > > Good idea! However, I can think of some more improvement.... > > > What I would like is the possibility to develop your own car. The > chassis, engine, tyres, gearbox, electronics, suspension do get a > number of attributes, and you can adjust them, for example, between > performance and reliability. Attributes like bore, stroke, exhaust > length, etc. > > Now combine this with online play and teams....it wil not only be a > matter of being the fastest driver, you can also be the best designer! > <g> >
So, like what "X-Car could have been..." I'm an engineer, so I would buy it in a heartbeat. Stephen
"Schumi" <[email hidden]> writes: > What if instead of the computer auto-configuring.... you had another "real > person" on the other end of the in-game voice communications? This person > would them adjust your settings based on your on-track feedback, and have > those changes waiting for you the next stop. This person is your real-time > virtua crew chief. nice idea, but do you think anyone would want to do this? being a virtual crew chief sounds unbelievably boring to me at least. -- Gunnar #31 SUCKS#015 Tupperware MC#002 DoD#0x1B DoDRT#003 DoD:CT#4,8 Kibo�: 2 gitaren er en sjingke
In article <f%Ds8.194418$[email hidden]>, [email hidden] says... >If you can't/don't want to/won't learn about the basics of race car >setups....run in "fixed setup" races....that's what they are for! You really are a fucking prick, aren't you? -Tim
"Schumi" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:<fGxs8.39013$[email hidden]>...
Quoted text (9 lines)> In all honesty, what you are suggesting is something far more difficult than > you might imagine. The person who could code that would basically put crew > chiefs out of a job in real life. The problem is that for certain anomalies > in handling, 6 different settings could be changed (you can get rid of > oversteer by adjusting a wide number of different settings as an example). > The trick is to make the right decision, which will not adversely affect > other handling characteristics. In an easy world (which it is not) it would > only be 1 setting you change. In real-life applications, it can be a fine > balance of combination settings for multiple parameters.
A driver who understood car setups would hold an advantage over one who relied on the virtual crew chief. The fixes the auto crew chief would implement for different conditions could be easily outlined. Just as in real life someone like Rusty Wallace who understands suspension changes would have an advantage by making specific requests, whereas someone who constantly relied on the crew chief would have to deal with a car that sometimes handled worse than when you started. Which also happens in real life. I think a really simplistic virtual crew chief would be extremely cool. I also think that Papy should add some realistic telemetry to the Nascar series, since teams do employ blackbox-type equipment during testing sessions. You could disable it during race weekends or something to keep it realistic. Jason
Why not both -- defaults to AI or you specify an address where the software can find the human crew chief? If the human crew chief had access to good race data (lap times on other cars, changes in weather, etc, etc.) it would not be boring--assuming that you have the right kind of mind for this job!! Just figuring fuel use (for example) depending on how much your driver has been drafting, and then deciding when to stop for gas is quite a challenge, as is the 2 vs 4 tire-change choice. On 10 Apr 2002, Gunnar Horrigmo wrote:
Quoted text (17 lines)> "Schumi" <[email hidden]> writes: > > > What if instead of the computer auto-configuring.... you had another "real > > person" on the other end of the in-game voice communications? This person > > would them adjust your settings based on your on-track feedback, and have > > those changes waiting for you the next stop. This person is your real-time > > virtua crew chief. > > nice idea, but do you think anyone would want to do this? being a > virtual crew chief sounds unbelievably boring to me at least. > > -- > Gunnar > #31 SUCKS#015 Tupperware MC#002 DoD#0x1B DoDRT#003 DoD:CT#4,8 Kibo: 2 > gitaren er en sjingke > >
If the human crew chief could spectate while communicating it wouldn't be that boring. At least for a gearhead like me. ;o) "Gunnar Horrigmo" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > "Schumi" <[email hidden]> writes: > > > What if instead of the computer auto-configuring.... you had another"real > > person" on the other end of the in-game voice communications? Thisperson > > would them adjust your settings based on your on-track feedback, andhave > > those changes waiting for you the next stop. This person is yourreal-time
Quoted text (8 lines)> > virtua crew chief. > > nice idea, but do you think anyone would want to do this? being a > virtual crew chief sounds unbelievably boring to me at least. > > -- > Gunnar > #31 SUCKS#015 Tupperware MC#002 DoD#0x1B DoDRT#003 DoD:CT#4,8
Kibo�: 2 > gitaren er en sjingke
Agreed, that would be awesome - for SOME of us. Unfortunately probably not enough of us. But anyway I wouldn't be surprised if one or more of the "do-it-yourself" sims in development around here eventually gives us that capability. "Stephen F." <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:3cb43272$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (16 lines)> > "Remco Moedt" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:[email hidden]... > > > > > > Good idea! However, I can think of some more improvement.... > > > > > > What I would like is the possibility to develop your own car. The > > chassis, engine, tyres, gearbox, electronics, suspension do get a > > number of attributes, and you can adjust them, for example, between > > performance and reliability. Attributes like bore, stroke, exhaust > > length, etc. > > > > Now combine this with online play and teams....it wil not only be a > > matter of being the fastest driver, you can also be the best
designer!
Quoted text (11 lines)> > <g> > > > > So, like what "X-Car could have been..." > > I'm an engineer, so I would buy it in a heartbeat. > > Stephen > > >
You really are determined to end up in a lot of killfiles aren't you? Some of us around here actually like Tom and appreciate his point of view. "The Enigmatic One" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:Sl%s8.2659$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (11 lines)> In article <f%Ds8.194418$[email hidden]>, > [email hidden] says... > > >If you can't/don't want to/won't learn about the basics of race car > >setups....run in "fixed setup" races....that's what they are for! > > You really are a fucking prick, aren't you? > > > -Tim >
Joe62 10 Apr 2002 23:30 UTC↳ reply to Haybails#125910
On Mon, 8 Apr 2002 16:09:18 -0500, "Haybails" <[email hidden]> wrote: >What do you folks think? Is this a valid suggestion and a possible thing to code into the game? It's a great idea. I like the flexibility of sim racing, but don't usually have the time to dedicate to master a realistic setup system.
In article <f%Ds8.194418$[email hidden]>, "Tom Pabst" <[email hidden]> writes:
Quoted text (10 lines)>There's a very limited number of things you can change in a WC car from the >pits during a race. It might take you all of two hours to practice and test >them....to figure out what they do and in what way. There's literally >dozens of "guides" on the topic of setups for you to reference, in addition >to a very good (but not perfect) guide built into N2K2 to give the driver >basic information about setup parameter changes. This is not hard. I think >the term, "setup guru" is way over-used.....applied too many times to >someone who has simply taken the time to learn and understand the basics of >the race car setup parameters. That's an important part of the character of >a "racing simulation".....should be part and parcel to its appeal.
There are people who have driven sims literally for YEARS, and we're no closer to figuring out setups now than when we started(even with the guides). Should we just be left out to dry? Since you apparently understand all the ramifications of setup subtleties, you can't see the point of view from those that don't. Just like the fast drivers can't understand what it's like at the back of the grid. It's an elitist view... >Why should the drivers who take the time to learn about racing......have >that competitive edge removed from them by the computer......supporting >those who don't/can't take the time to do the same? Maybe we should have >the computer do the driving for you, too? > Should we not be able to download others' setups, as well? First, it's possible to find someone's setups that work for you without knowing why. Second, I know of some VERY good sim drivers who don't have a CLUE about setups. They find one that works for them and kick everyone else's ass... Third, I don't think that REAL drivers know how to tweak the car for maximum benefit(um, that's why they have a crew chief). If *they* can't, why should *we* be expected to? >If you can't/don't want to/won't learn about the basics of race car >setups....run in "fixed setup" races....that's what they are for! The better drivers usually win anyway, so what's wrong with giving people who aren't good at setups a CHANCE? Eldred -- Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett GPLRank - under construction... Can the Detroit Tigers match the Detroit Lions' blazing 2001 start of 0-12??? Currently at 0-8...stay tuned... Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.
In article <a92f6e$10crhp$[email hidden]>, [email hidden] says... > > >You really are determined to end up in a lot of killfiles aren't you? >Some of us around here actually like Tom and appreciate his point of >view. When the point of view is "everyone should do it my way or not play the games" then we're talking about something completely worthless. Tom may have a point or two occasionally, but expecting everyone to want things his way is not one of them. -Tim
"Haybails" <[email hidden]> writes: <snip> Good idea, i've been saying it for years :) The one thing that put me off contemporary F1 sims is that the setup options are too overwhelming. Not even real life drivers have to cope with all that, but they have to give a lot of feedback to the engineers. Also during race situations, like N2002 and even back to the first indycar sims there are too many decisions that has to be made about fuel, tires, sway bars etc. And all this input has to be done with the keyboard while racing. I find that very unrealistic. A semi-intelligent crew chief that let me in for a splash and dash without filling up the tank completely when needed would be more like it. Hell, even a crew chief to tell me when to pit would be great. :) Of course, all the options must be avaliable manually aswell for the masochists :) -- Olav K. Malmin remove .spam when replying
Well you are entitled to your opinion, but I think that you are taking Tom the wrong way. He is just expressing his opinion, which he apparently feels very strongly about. I have a great deal of respect for people who are able to form strong opinions and are not afraid to speak their mind. In fact, I can't stand people who always agree with everybody else. Being rather opinionated myself, I will, after listening to others, still make my own decisions and still do whatever the hell I think is right. Nobody can force you to do something you don't want to do (unless you're a total doormat), but everybody still has a right to express themselves. "The Enigmatic One" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:xm8t8.2666$[email hidden]... > > When the point of view is "everyone should do it my way or not playthe > games" then we're talking about something completely worthless. Tommay > have a point or two occasionally, but expecting everyone to wantthings > his way is not one of them. > > > -Tim >

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy