Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

My opinions on GP4 and F12002

10 posts by 6 people · 23 Jun 2002 10:04 UTC - 10 Jul 2002 17:54 UTC

Len 23 Jun 2002 10:04 UTC#113030
I Have a P3 1000Mhz, GF2 GTS, 256MB. I run both games at 800x600x16 with 4FSAA (F12002 shimmers like hell without, and GP4 cockpit looks to blocky without). 32bit or higher res (with FSAA) makes my GF2 extremly slow. Thrustmaster T2 controller, with home made shifters and other small modifications. Setup: F12002 all graphics options at max (arms removed, and high physics rate in plr. file) (FPS typical between 20-40) GP4 locked at 24fps, only cars in mirrors, no reflection, no bump map, no advanced lightning, and low shadows. highest car detail, object detail object render, and pitcrew. (Hardware acc. sound OFF - and sound sample freq. slider in WInXP sound setup, moved to the left.) (PO typical between 90-120) Physics: F12002: Very good, smooth and sophisticated. GP4: Typical Crammond style: driving to the limits, it feels good , driving over the limits, it feels canned, driving slow it feels like a train. A good controller setup is extremly important (IMO set max. lock to 20deg, low sens. zone about 10%, reduce with speed about 30%, and offcourse no steering help at all) Graphics: I made some screendumps from the back of the grid from both games on 7 different tracks. Comparing those still images makes me wonder why people thinks GP4 is ugly. Try to do the same (Use PrintScreen key, and paste in a Paint program). Try back of the grid in Brazil, Monaco or Austria - try a look back view at Eau Rouge at Spa. For me(!), GP4 is clearly the most beautifull - clear colors, more objects. Its true that close to structures GP4 is often very pixelated. But thats not an issue when racing at the track. F12002 is also pixelated when close, try the first corner at Monaco hold close to the left fence and look at the spectators and close buildings. Mirrors: GP4: I select show cars only, I dont need more (neither does my CPU :) ) F12002: Very good, but doesnt show all objects - gone is Monaco's tunnel, trees, buildings ect. AI: GP4: Very good. Car behaves good - close race is a blast, outbraking, overtaking and side-by-side racing feels very realisticly. The AI fights for its line, and give up instead of ramming when defeated. (well, they should work on Schummies AI :)) F12002: I just dont like it. The racing rythm is mysterious. IMO when passing and overtaking it feels like the AI doesnt know where I am. Instant Replay GP4: Very good, outside view is actually less CPU hungry than cockpit view. Good camera-setups, looks very much like TV. You have to see a chrash debris all over, and small men running to the track pushing cars away and waving flags. F12002: Very slow and choppy. Not the best camera angles Online play: I only play flighsims online (Aces High is the best :)) My conclusion. If you PC is less powerfull than mine - go for F12002 anytime!!! If its like mine or better: Try them both - and do it thoroughly - forget others opinions, can you live with 24fps? - for me, F12002 has a more realistic driving model and I like to drive it, but the atmosphere and mood in GP4 gives me the best offline modern F1 racing experience I ever had. Len
Frode 23 Jun 2002 11:31 UTC↳ reply to Len#112942
"Len" <[email hidden]> wrote > Mirrors: > GP4: I select show cars only, I dont need more (neither does my > CPU :) ) You actually notice a difference? Whether I select show cars, show everything, or show nothing, I see exactly the same in the mirrors. And that is, everything. Advertising billboards et al. > AI: > GP4: Very good. Car behaves good - close race is a blast, > outbraking, overtaking and side-by-side racing feels very > realisticly. The AI fights for its line, and give up instead of > ramming when defeated. During the race, I agree the AI is decent. During qualifying they're absolutely horrible since they use the same AI as for the race and thus will happily destroy your flying lap by racing you on their out lap. > Online play: > I only play flighsims online (Aces High is the best :)) Good for you since GP4 doesn't have anything but LAN :) -- Frode
Hey man, I appreciate the side-by-side comparison! Looks like I'll have to check out GP4, afterall it is free right? right??? Mike http://mikebeauchamp.com "Len" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:af46e1$2c98$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (74 lines)> I Have a P3 1000Mhz, GF2 GTS, 256MB. I run both games at > 800x600x16 with 4FSAA (F12002 shimmers like hell without, and GP4 > cockpit looks to blocky without). 32bit or higher res (with FSAA) > makes my GF2 extremly slow. > Thrustmaster T2 controller, with home made shifters and other > small modifications. > > Setup: > F12002 all graphics options at max (arms removed, and high > physics rate in plr. file) (FPS typical between 20-40) > GP4 locked at 24fps, only cars in mirrors, no reflection, no bump > map, no advanced lightning, and low shadows. highest car detail, > object detail object render, and pitcrew. (Hardware acc. sound > OFF - and sound sample freq. slider in WInXP sound setup, moved > to the left.) (PO typical between 90-120) > > Physics: > F12002: Very good, smooth and sophisticated. > GP4: Typical Crammond style: driving to the limits, it feels good > , driving over the limits, it feels canned, driving slow it feels > like a train. A good controller setup is extremly important (IMO > set max. lock to 20deg, low sens. zone about 10%, reduce with > speed about 30%, and offcourse no steering help at all) > > Graphics: > I made some screendumps from the back of the grid from both games > on 7 different tracks. Comparing those still images makes me > wonder why people thinks GP4 is ugly. Try to do the same (Use > PrintScreen key, and paste in a Paint program). Try back of the > grid in Brazil, Monaco or Austria - try a look back view at Eau > Rouge at Spa. For me(!), GP4 is clearly the most beautifull - > clear colors, more objects. Its true that close to structures GP4 > is often very pixelated. But thats not an issue when racing at > the track. F12002 is also pixelated when close, try the first > corner at Monaco hold close to the left fence and look at the > spectators and close buildings. > Mirrors: > GP4: I select show cars only, I dont need more (neither does my > CPU :) ) > F12002: Very good, but doesnt show all objects - gone is Monaco's > tunnel, trees, buildings ect. > > AI: > GP4: Very good. Car behaves good - close race is a blast, > outbraking, overtaking and side-by-side racing feels very > realisticly. The AI fights for its line, and give up instead of > ramming when defeated. (well, they should work on Schummies AI > :)) > F12002: I just dont like it. The racing rythm is mysterious. IMO > when passing and overtaking it feels like the AI doesnt know > where I am. > > Instant Replay > GP4: Very good, outside view is actually less CPU hungry than > cockpit view. Good camera-setups, looks very much like TV. You > have to see a chrash debris all over, and small men running to > the track pushing cars away and waving flags. > F12002: Very slow and choppy. Not the best camera angles > > Online play: > I only play flighsims online (Aces High is the best :)) > > My conclusion. > If you PC is less powerfull than mine - go for F12002 anytime!!! > If its like mine or better: Try them both - and do it > thoroughly - forget others opinions, can you live with 24fps? - > for me, F12002 has a more realistic driving model and I like to > drive it, but the atmosphere and mood in GP4 gives me the best > offline modern F1 racing experience I ever had. > > Len > > >
Len 24 Jun 2002 16:20 UTC↳ reply to Frode#112722
"Frode" wrote: > You actually notice a difference? Whether I select show cars,show > everything, or show nothing, I see exactly the same in themirrors. And that > is, everything. Advertising billboards et al. "Cars only" gives me just that - cars only on a blue background - and less PO. > During the race, I agree the AI is decent. During qualifyingthey're > absolutely horrible since they use the same AI as for the raceand thus will > happily destroy your flying lap by racing you on their out lap. If I catch up to someone - he could be on his own flying lap or first out lap - I can't tell I'll try a clean pass - if succesfull, I'm happy - if not, I'll swear at him, and try another lap. Not a big issue for me - I do not catch up _that_ many on ace level ;) I haven't noticed how F12002 behaves in this situation? -- Len
Frode 24 Jun 2002 19:54 UTC↳ reply to Len#112666
"Len" <[email hidden]> wrote > "Cars only" gives me just that - cars only on a blue background - > and less PO. All of a sudden mine has decided to work as intended as well. Finally, I might add, helped my PO quite considerably and allowed me to up a few other settings instead. > If I catch up to someone - he could be on his own flying lap or > first out lap - I can't tell If you catch up to him just as he's coming out of the pits, it would be fairly obvious. I've had more than one occasion of a ruined flying lap due to a car coming out as I exit the first bend. Luckily the physics when it comes to damage being incurred is lame enough to allow me to pat their back and send them off track at near to no loss on my own. Unfortunately that only works if I catch them in the right corner. > I haven't noticed how F12002 behaves in this situation? No idea, I haven't played anything but the WIP and that only for about 5 minutes. I really should get off my butt and give that game a try. Anyways, Geoff brags a lot about his AI. If it was half as good as what he (and PCG) claims they should have that very basic performance trait of not driving full out on their out lap, and giving way to flyers. This pissed me off in GP2 and it still does. -- Frode
Len 25 Jun 2002 07:40 UTC↳ reply to Frode#112580
"Frode" wrote: > "Len" wrote: > > "Cars only" gives me just that - cars only on a bluebackground - > > and less PO. > > All of a sudden mine has decided to work as intended as well. Sensitive AI in GP4, reminds me of something.... HAL: "I know you and Frank were planning to disconnect me...and I'm afraid that's something I cannot allow to happen." :) > Luckily the physics when it > comes to damage being incurred is lame enough to allow me topat their back > and send them off track at near to no loss on my own. I think you can use that statement on nearly every driving sim - and in some cases it also works in real world. But it's not a nice thing to do :) > Geoff brags a lot about his AI. If it was half as good as whathe (and PCG) > claims they should have that very basic performance trait ofnot driving > full out on their out lap, and giving way to flyers. Thispissed me off in > GP2 and it still does. Yes its stupid. Still its a minor issue to me - the AI during the race is to me the most important thing. If you are on the kerbs in a corner, the AI in F12002 will happily - without loosing speed - overtake you on the grass! (Just happend to me in the RTL kurve - N�rburgring). That is a major issue to me. -- Len
Bill Ryder 25 Jun 2002 21:16 UTC↳ reply to Len#112369
On Sun, 23 Jun 2002 22:04:22 +1200, Len wrote:
Quoted text (7 lines)> Instant Replay > GP4: Very good, outside view is actually less CPU hungry than > cockpit view. Good camera-setups, looks very much like TV. You > have to see a chrash debris all over, and small men running to > the track pushing cars away and waving flags. > F12002: Very slow and choppy. Not the best camera angles >
Mmm. I had a full grid and was starting about 10th at Silverstone. I launched off with traction control but unfortunately one of the McLarens had stalled on the grid and I ran right up his backside (the stalled car was obscured by cars in front of me). I did an instant replay of this - full grid remember - and it looked fantastic! Wheels and wings bounced off and everything. Not choppy at all. Smoke from the wheel spins etc etc. I think the big trick to graphics speed in F1-2k2 is to use 16bit not 32bit and run a really high res. I run 1600x1200 at 16bit with all graphics options on and 5x for the lod multiplier in the default.cfg. My machine is XP1600+, GF3 Ti200 oced to Ti500. Win98SE. 512MB RAM. --- Bill
In article <[email hidden]>, Bill Ryder <[email hidden]> writes: >Mmm. I had a full grid and was starting about 10th at Silverstone. I >launched off with traction control but unfortunately one of the McLarens >had stalled on the grid and I ran right up his backside (the stalled car >was obscured by cars in front of me). Now THAT'S cool - you have to worry about a car in front stalling.. Did F1 2001 have this? I don't remember. Eldred -- Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett My .sig file is in the shop for repairs... Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.
Yes it had. I also wish that F1 2003 will feature waving arms for the stalled drivers, like Mika H�kkinen did last year :) And i want some raise / wave arm in F1 2003. "EldredP" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > In article <[email hidden]>,Bill
Quoted text (8 lines)> Ryder <[email hidden]> writes: > > >Mmm. I had a full grid and was starting about 10th at Silverstone. I > >launched off with traction control but unfortunately one of the McLarens > >had stalled on the grid and I ran right up his backside (the stalled car > >was obscured by cars in front of me). > > Now THAT'S cool - you have to worry about a car in front stalling.. Did
F1
Quoted text (8 lines)> 2001 have this? I don't remember. > > Eldred > -- > Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett > My .sig file is in the shop for repairs... > > Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.
EldredP 10 Jul 2002 17:54 UTC#109275
In article <aggv39$jue$[email hidden]>, "Richard S Beckett" <[email hidden]> writes: >> Now THAT'S cool - you have to worry about a car in front stalling.. Did >F1 >> 2001 have this? I don't remember. > >Yup. That just shows that I didn't spend enough time with it. I *never* saw that... Maybe I missed whatever checkbox allows that. Eldred -- Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett My .sig file is in the shop for repairs... Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy