How come no one is bitching about MS letting RB have the win with 10 laps to
go?
Ferrari did the same thing as in Austria (as has been done thousands of
times in all series) except a little less obviously. More like how Waltrip
let Earnhardt have Talladega.
I guess it's ok in racing to do this as long as Michael Schumacher isn't the
one who benefits. Just like I thought. Pure jealousy was the motivation for
the hysterics after Austria.
MS and RS tought JPM a few lessons today. Beautiful passes. JPM then caused
yet another accident when he hit DC. He has great car control?? Funny how
people will bitch at and try to blame MS for an incident like T1 at Malaysia
or Brazil which involve JPM, even though they were both clearly JPM's fault.
When JPM does the same type of thing to DC today though, no one says a word
because it's not MS who was the other driver, and therefor no bogus
opportunity to attack MS.
David G Fisher
Ferrari team orders at the 2002 European GP
David G Fisher asked why nobody criticised Schumacher handing Barrichello the European GP win, given the Austria outrage. Others said it was just as staged, while the thread moved into long arguments over Montoya's driving, his incidents with Coulthard and Ralf Schumacher, and the FIA's US$1 million fine on Ferrari for breaching podium protocol in Austria.
real motorsport
Automated summary.
"David G Fisher" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:G9vR8.412539$[email hidden]...
> How come no one is bitching about MS letting RB have the win with 10 lapsto
the
> one who benefits. Just like I thought. Pure jealousy was the motivationfor
> the hysterics after Austria.
>
> MS and RS tought JPM a few lessons today. Beautiful passes. JPM thencaused
> yet another accident when he hit DC. He has great car control?? Funny how
> people will bitch at and try to blame MS for an incident like T1 atMalaysia
> or Brazil which involve JPM, even though they were both clearly JPM'sfault.
> When JPM does the same type of thing to DC today though, no one says aword
> because it's not MS who was the other driver, and therefor no bogus
> opportunity to attack MS.
>
> David G Fisher
I didn't watch the race, if that helps answer the question <G> Haven't
watched one since Austria for that matter; to busy.
John
>
>
Quoted text (7 lines)
> go? > > Ferrari did the same thing as in Austria (as has been done thousands of > times in all series) except a little less obviously. More like how Waltrip > let Earnhardt have Talladega. > > I guess it's ok in racing to do this as long as Michael Schumacher isn't
"David G Fisher" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:G9vR8.412539$[email hidden]...
> How come no one is bitching about MS letting RB have the win with 10 lapsto
the
> one who benefits. Just like I thought. Pure jealousy was the motivationfor
> the hysterics after Austria.
>
> MS and RS tought JPM a few lessons today. Beautiful passes. JPM thencaused
> yet another accident when he hit DC. He has great car control?? Funny how
> people will bitch at and try to blame MS for an incident like T1 atMalaysia
> or Brazil which involve JPM, even though they were both clearly JPM'sfault.
> When JPM does the same type of thing to DC today though, no one says aword
> because it's not MS who was the other driver, and therefor no bogus
> opportunity to attack MS.
>
> David G Fisher
> All I saw were two very slow Williams... I was howling with laughter at
the SpeedChannel announcers. Hobb's fake bravado with his recap of MS
heroically racing through the field was hilarious...I even got my wife to
watch and she HATES any racing... I do recall something that 'seemed' like
a race but only two cars took part.(and they weren't RED!)
It was nice to see DC racing again....he pinched JPM nicely to the curb.
If JPM had been a bad racer, he would have not moved into the curb and both
would have been wrecked anyway. I did see Ralfie cause a near-wreck also,
running so slowly at the same turn 1 (where JPM hit DC) he forced (fishie?)
to spin rather than hit Ralf as Fishie passed JV.
This was a fairly embarrassing race. The Ferrari's are sooooooooo far
ahead of the other marques that they could get away with staging the end
result. Until the other brands level the playing field some, there is
nothing to complain about.
dave henrie
Quoted text (7 lines)
> go? > > Ferrari did the same thing as in Austria (as has been done thousands of > times in all series) except a little less obviously. More like how Waltrip > let Earnhardt have Talladega. > > I guess it's ok in racing to do this as long as Michael Schumacher isn't"David G Fisher" said:
> How come no one is bitching about MS letting RB have the win with 10 lapsto
> go?
I quit watching F1 some races ago Dave, so I wouldnt know what to comment
on.
Having said that - isn't this the wrong newsgroup to discuss stuff like
this?
--
ed_
(O.T. P.D)
"David G Fisher" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:G9vR8.412539$[email hidden]...
> How come no one is bitching about MS letting RB have the win with 10 lapsto
> go?
I have done so on other forums. Another engineered result = a race juat as
bad as Austria.
> MS and RS tought JPM a few lessons today. Beautiful passes. JPM thencaused
> yet another accident when he hit DC.
I believe MS spun today as well. He was lucky enough to get away with it.
Funny how the guy can always fall in a bucket of shit and come out smelling
of roses aint it?
MS
Too me, it looked like they were gonna hold Rubens a bit longer in the 2nd
pitstop, so MS could pass, but
he run into traffic, which slowed him down, and Rubens got out inhead of
him.
Then there was just a staged ending. I thought this was just as bad as in
Austria.
I just ignore the Ferraris in the front. Couldnt care less!.
If it was a good team you could like, and if you could think MS is a nice
guy, then I would love MS and
Ferrari, but to me they are just doing everything for a win at all costs.
*sigh*.
Thank god we have MotoGP instead :)
"David G Fisher" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:G9vR8.412539$[email hidden]...
> How come no one is bitching about MS letting RB have the win with 10 lapsto
the
> one who benefits. Just like I thought. Pure jealousy was the motivationfor
> the hysterics after Austria.
>
> MS and RS tought JPM a few lessons today. Beautiful passes. JPM thencaused
> yet another accident when he hit DC. He has great car control?? Funny how
> people will bitch at and try to blame MS for an incident like T1 atMalaysia
> or Brazil which involve JPM, even though they were both clearly JPM'sfault.
> When JPM does the same type of thing to DC today though, no one says aword
Quoted text (7 lines)
> go? > > Ferrari did the same thing as in Austria (as has been done thousands of > times in all series) except a little less obviously. More like how Waltrip > let Earnhardt have Talladega. > > I guess it's ok in racing to do this as long as Michael Schumacher isn'tQuoted text (7 lines)
> because it's not MS who was the other driver, and therefor no bogus > opportunity to attack MS. > > David G Fisher > > >
"David G Fisher" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:G9vR8.412539$[email hidden]...
> How come no one is bitching about MS letting RB have the win with 10 lapsto
> go?
Had MS not been held up by traffic - Ferrari would have got the 1-2 they
wanted - instead of the 1-2 they got.
I'm suprised no one dropped a wheelnut at RB's 2nd pitstop.
After that though - any move on the track would have looked too shocking.
But - lets face it - asking them not to race after the 2nd pit stop -whilst
it might seem sensible - would NOT Have been done if Wednesday wasnt at
stake
Doug
With Ferrari coming before the FIA this week it would be stupid to do
something on track, like in Austria.
I did read where Todt told Mike to not pass, because he was worried they
might collide.
--
Richard "ZZ" Busch
Member:
Screamers Racing League
GPL Rank + 21.54
MoGPL Rank + 365.57
RASCAR
----------------
Busch Motorsports:
Remember racecar is racecar spelled backward
-----------------
Busch Carpentry:
A good carpenter can nail anything
-----------------
With Ferrari coming before the FIA this week it would be stupid to do
something on track, like in Austria.
I did read where Todt told Mike to not pass, because he was worried they
might collide.
--
Richard "ZZ" Busch
Member:
Screamers Racing League
GPL Rank + 21.54
MoGPL Rank + 365.57
RASCAR
----------------
Busch Motorsports:
Remember racecar is racecar spelled backward
-----------------
Busch Carpentry:
A good carpenter can nail anything
-----------------
"David G Fisher" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:G9vR8.412539$[email hidden]...
> How come no one is bitching about MS letting RB have the win with 10 lapsto
> go?
>
I thought it was just as bad as austria. MS could and should have taken RB
as he was the faster man on race day (and the whole weekend really). Its an
even bigger insult to RB as he got a win handed to him as if he was a child
and couldnt do it for himself. I wish they would just race - obviously
being careful not to take out your teammate.
Ash
http://www.siroccoracing.com
Joachim Trensz wrote:
>
> I think RB's 2nd pitstop standstill-time was 2 tenths shorter than MS's, 7.6
> vs. 7.8 - but this is from memory, I may be wrong
You're not wrong
Beers and cheers
(uncle) Goy
"The Pits" http://www.theuspits.com/
"A man is only as old as the woman he feels"
--Groucho Marx--
No you are right that the clock showed rubens pit faster.
I just ment that i thought they would screw up in the pits.
"Joachim Trensz" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:af6u60$c2odh$[email hidden]...
> I think RB's 2nd pitstop standstill-time was 2 tenths shorter than MS's,7.6
2nd
> > pitstop, so MS could pass, but
> > he run into traffic, which slowed him down, and Rubens got out inhead of
> > him.
> > Then there was just a staged ending. I thought this was just as bad asin
> > Austria.
> > I just ignore the Ferraris in the front. Couldnt care less!.
> > If it was a good team you could like, and if you could think MS is anice
> > guy, then I would love MS and
> > Ferrari, but to me they are just doing everything for a win at allcosts.
Quoted text (9 lines)
> vs. 7.8 - but this is from memory, I may be wrong > > Achim > > > "Andreas Nystr�m" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:xGBR8.44863$[email hidden]... > > > > Too me, it looked like they were gonna hold Rubens a bit longer in theQuoted text (7 lines)
> > *sigh*. > > > > Thank god we have MotoGP instead :) > > > >Todt told them to get the cars into finish, thats why the Ferraris were
doing 1:36laps, while raikkonen was doing 33's.
"Richard "ZZ" Busch" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:nNCR8.83605$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (27 lines)
> With Ferrari coming before the FIA this week it would be stupid to do > something on track, like in Austria. > I did read where Todt told Mike to not pass, because he was worried they > might collide. > > > -- > Richard "ZZ" Busch > > Member: > Screamers Racing League > GPL Rank + 21.54 > MoGPL Rank + 365.57 > RASCAR > ---------------- > Busch Motorsports: > Remember racecar is racecar spelled backward > ----------------- > Busch Carpentry: > A good carpenter can nail anything > ----------------- > > > > > >Why would you think it looked like they were going to hold RB in the pits
when his stop was shorter than MS's? If I understand how time works, RB's
stop would have had to have been longer than MS's for that to work. It
wasn't.
Todd
"Andreas Nystr�m" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:xGBR8.44863$[email hidden]...
laps
> to
> > go?
> >
> > Ferrari did the same thing as in Austria (as has been done thousands of
> > times in all series) except a little less obviously. More like howWaltrip
how
Quoted text (18 lines)
> > Too me, it looked like they were gonna hold Rubens a bit longer in the 2nd > pitstop, so MS could pass, but > he run into traffic, which slowed him down, and Rubens got out inhead of > him. > Then there was just a staged ending. I thought this was just as bad as in > Austria. > I just ignore the Ferraris in the front. Couldnt care less!. > If it was a good team you could like, and if you could think MS is a nice > guy, then I would love MS and > Ferrari, but to me they are just doing everything for a win at all costs. > *sigh*. > > Thank god we have MotoGP instead :) > > "David G Fisher" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:G9vR8.412539$[email hidden]... > > How come no one is bitching about MS letting RB have the win with 10Quoted text (11 lines)
> > let Earnhardt have Talladega. > > > > I guess it's ok in racing to do this as long as Michael Schumacher isn't > the > > one who benefits. Just like I thought. Pure jealousy was the motivation > for > > the hysterics after Austria. > > > > MS and RS tought JPM a few lessons today. Beautiful passes. JPM then > caused > > yet another accident when he hit DC. He has great car control?? FunnyQuoted text (15 lines)
> > people will bitch at and try to blame MS for an incident like T1 at > Malaysia > > or Brazil which involve JPM, even though they were both clearly JPM's > fault. > > When JPM does the same type of thing to DC today though, no one says a > word > > because it's not MS who was the other driver, and therefor no bogus > > opportunity to attack MS. > > > > David G Fisher > > > > > > > >
"Dave Henrie" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:%NvR8.155481$[email hidden]...
>
> "David G Fisher" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
> news:G9vR8.412539$[email hidden]...
> > How come no one is bitching about MS letting RB have the win with 10laps
> to
> > go?
> >
> > Ferrari did the same thing as in Austria (as has been done thousands of
> > times in all series) except a little less obviously. More like howWaltrip
how
like
> a race but only two cars took part.(and they weren't RED!)
> It was nice to see DC racing again....he pinched JPM nicely to the curb.
> If JPM had been a bad racer, he would have not moved into the curb andboth
> would have been wrecked anyway. I did see Ralfie cause a near-wreck also,
> running so slowly at the same turn 1 (where JPM hit DC) he forced(fishie?)
Dave - I think your last point is right on the mark. Moreover, until some
other teams become competitive with Ferrari, F1 is going to suck. You just
aren't going to get great racing when the top two cars are on the same team.
Todd
Quoted text (11 lines)
> > let Earnhardt have Talladega. > > > > I guess it's ok in racing to do this as long as Michael Schumacher isn't > the > > one who benefits. Just like I thought. Pure jealousy was the motivation > for > > the hysterics after Austria. > > > > MS and RS tought JPM a few lessons today. Beautiful passes. JPM then > caused > > yet another accident when he hit DC. He has great car control?? FunnyQuoted text (15 lines)
> > people will bitch at and try to blame MS for an incident like T1 at > Malaysia > > or Brazil which involve JPM, even though they were both clearly JPM's > fault. > > When JPM does the same type of thing to DC today though, no one says a > word > > because it's not MS who was the other driver, and therefor no bogus > > opportunity to attack MS. > > > > David G Fisher > > > All I saw were two very slow Williams... I was howling with laughter at > the SpeedChannel announcers. Hobb's fake bravado with his recap of MS > heroically racing through the field was hilarious...I even got my wife to > watch and she HATES any racing... I do recall something that 'seemed'Quoted text (8 lines)
> to spin rather than hit Ralf as Fishie passed JV. > This was a fairly embarrassing race. The Ferrari's are sooooooooo far > ahead of the other marques that they could get away with staging the end > result. Until the other brands level the playing field some, there is > nothing to complain about. > dave henrie > >
"Ashley McConnell" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:af6u9d$c6s$[email hidden]...
>
> "David G Fisher" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
> news:G9vR8.412539$[email hidden]...
> > How come no one is bitching about MS letting RB have the win with 10laps
> to
> > go?
> >
>
> I thought it was just as bad as austria. MS could and should have taken RB
> as he was the faster man on race day (and the whole weekend really). Itsan
> even bigger insult to RB as he got a win handed to him as if he was achild
> and couldnt do it for himself. I wish they would just race - obviously
> being careful not to take out your teammate.
Not as bad as the wins RB will get gifted once MS is DWC
Doug
Sorry, i ment that i thought they would have problems filling his car with
fuel, or struggle
with a tire. Thats what i ment.
"JTBurn" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:qADR8.367609$%[email hidden]...
2nd
> > pitstop, so MS could pass, but
> > he run into traffic, which slowed him down, and Rubens got out inhead of
> > him.
> > Then there was just a staged ending. I thought this was just as bad asin
> > Austria.
> > I just ignore the Ferraris in the front. Couldnt care less!.
> > If it was a good team you could like, and if you could think MS is anice
> > guy, then I would love MS and
> > Ferrari, but to me they are just doing everything for a win at allcosts.
of
> > > times in all series) except a little less obviously. More like how
> Waltrip
> > > let Earnhardt have Talladega.
> > >
> > > I guess it's ok in racing to do this as long as Michael Schumacherisn't
> > the
> > > one who benefits. Just like I thought. Pure jealousy was themotivation
Quoted text (11 lines)
> Why would you think it looked like they were going to hold RB in the pits > when his stop was shorter than MS's? If I understand how time works, RB's > stop would have had to have been longer than MS's for that to work. It > wasn't. > > Todd > > "Andreas Nystr�m" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:xGBR8.44863$[email hidden]... > > > > Too me, it looked like they were gonna hold Rubens a bit longer in theQuoted text (12 lines)
> > *sigh*. > > > > Thank god we have MotoGP instead :) > > > > "David G Fisher" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > > news:G9vR8.412539$[email hidden]... > > > How come no one is bitching about MS letting RB have the win with 10 > laps > > to > > > go? > > > > > > Ferrari did the same thing as in Austria (as has been done thousandsQuoted text (24 lines)
> > for > > > the hysterics after Austria. > > > > > > MS and RS tought JPM a few lessons today. Beautiful passes. JPM then > > caused > > > yet another accident when he hit DC. He has great car control?? Funny > how > > > people will bitch at and try to blame MS for an incident like T1 at > > Malaysia > > > or Brazil which involve JPM, even though they were both clearly JPM's > > fault. > > > When JPM does the same type of thing to DC today though, no one says a > > word > > > because it's not MS who was the other driver, and therefor no bogus > > > opportunity to attack MS. > > > > > > David G Fisher > > > > > > > > > > > > > > >
"David G Fisher" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:G9vR8.412539$[email hidden]...
1 - "JPM then caused yet another accident when he hit DC. He has great car
control??"
2- "Funny how people will bitch at and try to blame MS for an incident like
T1 at Malaysia or Brazil which involve JPM, even though they were both
clearly JPM's fault."
> David G Fisher
Enlighten us with your pearls of wisdom and explain how that was Juan's
fault at Malaysia? Going off your logic we should blame MS for the incident
at Malaysia too - afterall it was the guy on the inside who lost control NOT
the person on the outside who gave room (DC yesterday and Juan at Malaysia).
Try to give posts without with your views on the incident rather than the
driver behind the wheel.
Rick
> Try to give posts without with your views on the incident rather than the
> driver behind the wheel.
>
Err -without :D
Rick
That's what distinguishes champions from the rest of the world :-)
Achim
"Mark Seery" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:af6fis$72g$[email hidden]...
...
> Funny how the guy can always fall in a bucket of shit
> and come out smelling of roses aint it?
Hi Doug,
> ...lets face it - asking them not to race after the 2nd pit stop
> ...would NOT Have been done if Wednesday wasnt at stake
That may be true, but it is irrelevant for the point David
is trying to make ;-)
Achim
Hi Doug,
That may be true, but it is irrelevant for the point David
is trying to make ;-)
Achim
I think RB's 2nd pitstop standstill-time was 2 tenths shorter than MS's, 7.6
vs. 7.8 - but this is from memory, I may be wrong
Achim
"Andreas Nystr�m" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:xGBR8.44863$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (14 lines)
> > Too me, it looked like they were gonna hold Rubens a bit longer in the 2nd > pitstop, so MS could pass, but > he run into traffic, which slowed him down, and Rubens got out inhead of > him. > Then there was just a staged ending. I thought this was just as bad as in > Austria. > I just ignore the Ferraris in the front. Couldnt care less!. > If it was a good team you could like, and if you could think MS is a nice > guy, then I would love MS and > Ferrari, but to me they are just doing everything for a win at all costs. > *sigh*. > > Thank god we have MotoGP instead :)No, if that's what happened, I still think that's a BOS
"David G Fisher" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:G9vR8.412539$[email hidden]...
> How come no one is bitching about MS letting RB have the win with 10 lapsto
the
> one who benefits. Just like I thought. Pure jealousy was the motivationfor
> the hysterics after Austria.
>
> MS and RS tought JPM a few lessons today. Beautiful passes. JPM thencaused
> yet another accident when he hit DC. He has great car control?? Funny how
> people will bitch at and try to blame MS for an incident like T1 atMalaysia
> or Brazil which involve JPM, even though they were both clearly JPM'sfault.
> When JPM does the same type of thing to DC today though, no one says aword
Quoted text (7 lines)
> go? > > Ferrari did the same thing as in Austria (as has been done thousands of > times in all series) except a little less obviously. More like how Waltrip > let Earnhardt have Talladega. > > I guess it's ok in racing to do this as long as Michael Schumacher isn'tQuoted text (7 lines)
> because it's not MS who was the other driver, and therefor no bogus > opportunity to attack MS. > > David G Fisher > > >RB's joy looked very real on the rostrum - he didn't seem to care whether it
was a handed win or a real one.
Achim
"Ashley McConnell" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:af6u9d$c6s$[email hidden]...
...
> I thought it was just as bad as austria. MS could and should have taken RB
> as he was the faster man on race day (and the whole weekend really). Itsan
> even bigger insult to RB as he got a win handed to him as if he was achild
> and couldnt do it for himself. I wish they would just race - obviously
> being careful not to take out your teammate....
> I'm sorry for DC as he'd left enough room and, visible in the replay,
> clearly tries to even widen the gap once he notices JPM start spinning,but
> in vain.
If DC had used his head - he'd have realised that JPM's spin was likely -
and gone for an inside move when he could - not some ditched outside line
squeeze
Had DC not squeezes JPM - he wouldnt have clipped the curb and spun
Doug
"Joachim Trensz" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:af77p0$c6f5k$[email hidden]...
> Hi Doug,
>
> > Had DC not squeezes JPM - he wouldnt have clipped the curb and spun
>
> That's an interesting interpretation :-)
DC had 15 metres of track to play with - he chose to use the inside 5
metres - then tries to say JPM was being stupid.
Doug
Not true. Remember:
McLaren : Senna and Prost
Williams: Mansell and Piquet
They batlted a lot, having even two seasons decided with crashs (Senna on
Prost and then, Prost on Senna).
The problem here is Ferrari and Schumacher. Until they allow the two to
fight, we will have a one-man championship.
Brian
"JTBurn" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:CDDR8.367636$%[email hidden]...
of
> > > times in all series) except a little less obviously. More like how
> Waltrip
> > > let Earnhardt have Talladega.
> > >
> > > I guess it's ok in racing to do this as long as Michael Schumacherisn't
> > the
> > > one who benefits. Just like I thought. Pure jealousy was themotivation
at
> > the SpeedChannel announcers. Hobb's fake bravado with his recap of MS
> > heroically racing through the field was hilarious...I even got my wifeto
> > watch and she HATES any racing... I do recall something that 'seemed'
> like
> > a race but only two cars took part.(and they weren't RED!)
> > It was nice to see DC racing again....he pinched JPM nicely to thecurb.
> > If JPM had been a bad racer, he would have not moved into the curb and
> both
> > would have been wrecked anyway. I did see Ralfie cause a near-wreckalso,
some
> other teams become competitive with Ferrari, F1 is going to suck. Youjust
> aren't going to get great racing when the top two cars are on the sameteam.
>
> Todd
>
>
Quoted text (12 lines)
> > "Dave Henrie" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:%NvR8.155481$[email hidden]... > > > > "David G Fisher" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > > news:G9vR8.412539$[email hidden]... > > > How come no one is bitching about MS letting RB have the win with 10 > laps > > to > > > go? > > > > > > Ferrari did the same thing as in Austria (as has been done thousandsQuoted text (19 lines)
> > for > > > the hysterics after Austria. > > > > > > MS and RS tought JPM a few lessons today. Beautiful passes. JPM then > > caused > > > yet another accident when he hit DC. He has great car control?? Funny > how > > > people will bitch at and try to blame MS for an incident like T1 at > > Malaysia > > > or Brazil which involve JPM, even though they were both clearly JPM's > > fault. > > > When JPM does the same type of thing to DC today though, no one says a > > word > > > because it's not MS who was the other driver, and therefor no bogus > > > opportunity to attack MS. > > > > > > David G Fisher > > > > > All I saw were two very slow Williams... I was howling with laughterQuoted text (13 lines)
> > running so slowly at the same turn 1 (where JPM hit DC) he forced > (fishie?) > > to spin rather than hit Ralf as Fishie passed JV. > > This was a fairly embarrassing race. The Ferrari's are sooooooooo far > > ahead of the other marques that they could get away with staging the end > > result. Until the other brands level the playing field some, there is > > nothing to complain about. > > dave henrie > > > > > > > Dave - I think your last point is right on the mark. Moreover, untilJPM's Ring incident with DC (inside car spinning out) was different from the
Malaysia incident between MS and JPM (front wheel of inside car tangles with
outside car).
The Malaysia incident must be compared to the T1 incident between RS and JPM
at the Ring, where RS did the right thing and gave JPM enough room to get
around the corner.
The DC/JPM incident at the Ring was a spin of the inside car because of worn
rear tires (according to the Williams team and JPM). Too much throttle for
worn out tires.
I'm sorry for DC as he'd left enough room and, visible in the replay,
clearly tries to even widen the gap once he notices JPM start spinning, but
in vain.
Achim
"Rick Osborn" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:af7391$hml$[email hidden]...
...
> Enlighten us with your pearls of wisdom and explain how that was Juan's
> fault at Malaysia? Going off your logic we should blame MS for theincident
> at Malaysia too - afterall it was the guy on the inside who lost controlNOT
> the person on the outside who gave room (DC yesterday and Juan atMalaysia).
...
"Joachim Trensz" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:af7634$c1duo$[email hidden]...
> JPM's Ring incident with DC (inside car spinning out) was different fromthe
> Malaysia incident between MS and JPM (front wheel of inside car tangleswith
> outside car).
>
> The Malaysia incident must be compared to the T1 incident between RS andJPM
> at the Ring, where RS did the right thing and gave JPM enough room to get
> around the corner.
>
> The DC/JPM incident at the Ring was a spin of the inside car because ofworn
> rear tires (according to the Williams team and JPM). Too much throttle for
> worn out tires.
So? The malaysia incident was also down to driver error also - that of
understeer from MS not taking into account heavy fuel loads and cold tyres;
oh but it's ok it's the almighty Michael and anything goes - even past his
brother by the looks of yesterday's race. Zzzz
It has nothing to do where the contact was made, if Juan hadn't have spun
he'd have speared DC like MS did him in malaysia. I'm not defending Juan
here btw - he should have squeezed DC wide and not run onto the curb, thus
preventing DC getting into t2 ahead of him. They're both plonkers, DC would
have been better off diving down the inside, cars spin outwards, David not
inwards. And Juan should have just stayed off the curb and run DC wide. Oh
well, at least DC and Juan can race wheel to wheel and accidents do happen,
more than can be said for a certain Ralf.
Rick
Hi Doug,
> Had DC not squeezes JPM - he wouldnt have clipped the curb and spun
That's an interesting interpretation :-)
Achim
Hi Doug,
That's an interesting interpretation :-)
Achim
In article <xGBR8.44863$[email hidden]>, "Andreas Nystr�m"
<[email hidden]> writes:
>Too me, it looked like they were gonna hold Rubens a bit longer in the 2nd
>pitstop, so MS could pass, but
>he run into traffic, which slowed him down, and Rubens got out inhead of
>him.
Agreed. But it made for nice suspense near the end of the race. Will they let
Rubens win, or not?
Eldred
--
Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett
Never argue with an idiot. He brings you down to his level, then beats you
with experience...
Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.
Was the a GP this week!? Oh well, I missed it, what a sham(e)...
David G Fisher wrote:
<SNIP>
----- Original Message -----
From: "David G Fisher"
> How come no one is bitching about MS letting RB have the win
> with 10 laps to go?
It may not have been posted here, but people around me aren't very happy
about it. I heard Mark's views first hand, e.g..
MS hatred has nothing to do with it per se... the way I see it is this: if
MS had been able to simply blow RB away he would have done so. Instead,
partially due to his spin, it was a hard graft to make up the time. The old
"lap quicker while other guy is in pits"-trick didn't work, so he was more
less stuck behind. Contrary to popular myth actually passing another car
without at least a 4 sec/lap speed advantage is not a foregone conclusion
(as happened due to the different fuel/tyre strategies between Ferrari and
Williams). An attentive and skilled driver, as RB is, can keep a slightly
quicker one behind for as long as he can remain error-free.
I think if Ferrari had allowed them to race there would have been two
possible outcomes : a wreck or something which looked like a let bye. Both
would have been bad for obvious reasons. Remember, Ferrari's largest
following are F1 fans, not race fans. I can see why JT asked them to hold
station and bring it home.
As a race fan, however, I can only accept this decision from "lesser" teams.
I could, e.g., understand Jaguar wanting to ensure a points finish for one
of their drivers by asking the other one not to attack. Big teams like
Ferrari, Williams and McLaren should play the game properly, IMO, as they
have the financial clout to do so. Playing to the crowd and the organising
body like Ferrari did yesterday is demeaning. The sad part is, of course,
it's going to work. I bet one of them will come out with a sort of "we're
even, from now on we fight" statement and all will be forgiven. Simply
sickening.
As and aside, the way I imagine the DEI cars "made sure" of Talladega has
more to do with both cars being under pressure from the rest of the field.
Making sure one of the drivers gets the victory in the face of stiff
competition is something quite different from arranging an unopposed
victory.
> MS and RS tought JPM a few lessons today. Beautiful
> passes.
RS took advantage of JPM having to defend at the start, nice move indeed;
wouldn't expect anything less of him.
MS had a superior car, a weight advantage and is quite special at the wheel
too. Good pass, but "teaching a lesson"? -Come on. If anybody was teaching,
it was Ross Brown, not Michael Schumacher.
> JPM then caused yet another accident when he hit DC. He
> has great car control??
When it's gone it's gone... car control does not extend much beyond the
limit.
> Funny how people will bitch at and try to blame MS for an
> incident like T1 at Malaysia or Brazil which involve JPM,
> even though they were both clearly JPM's fault.
Bad examples. The "wrong" about Malaysia was assigning a penalty for a
racing incident and to the driver who'd suffered most from the incident to
boot. T1 Brazil they touched... so what? It's racing and both want to be the
top dog in F1.
> When JPM does the same type of thing to DC today though,
> no one says a word because it's not MS who was the other
> driver, and therefor no bogus opportunity to attack MS.
Again: wrong conclusion. Both drivers raced for position and left eachother
room to work with. JPM slowed and turned in enough, but it still went pear
shaped. An incident as is bound to happen many times more in today's F1,
dominated by aero concerns and use of "strong in one direction" materials.
That said, JPM is taking a long time to "get smart". He's got to lose the
"never say die"-attitude, IMO, especially in the current Williams.
Jan.
=---
Quoted text (9 lines)
> Ferrari did the same thing as in Austria (as has been done > thousands of times in all series) except a little less > obviously. More like how Waltrip let Earnhardt have > Talladega. > > I guess it's ok in racing to do this as long as Michael > Schumacher isn't the one who benefits. Just like I thought. > Pure jealousy was the motivation for the hysterics after > Austria.In article <af7632$c1duo$[email hidden]>, "Joachim Trensz"
<[email hidden]> writes:
>RB's joy looked very real on the rostrum - he didn't seem to care whether it
>was a handed win or a real one.
Like a kid at xmas...<g>
Eldred
--
Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett
Never argue with an idiot. He brings you down to his level, then beats you
with experience...
Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.
Hi Doug,
> DC had 15 metres of track to play with
I beg to differ, but I think we've reached the end of this now :-)
Achim
Hi Doug,
I beg to differ, but I think we've reached the end of this now :-)
Achim
The problem is that RB is miles behind MS in points due to a poor start (not
all his fault) to the season.
David G Fisher
"Brian" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:af7co0$c095s$[email hidden]...
Funny
> > how
> > > > people will bitch at and try to blame MS for an incident like T1 at
> > > Malaysia
> > > > or Brazil which involve JPM, even though they were both clearlyJPM's
> > > fault.
> > > > When JPM does the same type of thing to DC today though, no one saysa
laughter
far
> > > ahead of the other marques that they could get away with staging theend
> > > result. Until the other brands level the playing field some, thereis
Quoted text (43 lines)
> Not true. Remember: > > McLaren : Senna and Prost > Williams: Mansell and Piquet > > They batlted a lot, having even two seasons decided with crashs (Senna on > Prost and then, Prost on Senna). > > The problem here is Ferrari and Schumacher. Until they allow the two to > fight, we will have a one-man championship. > > Brian > > "JTBurn" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:CDDR8.367636$%[email hidden]... > > > > "Dave Henrie" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > > news:%NvR8.155481$[email hidden]... > > > > > > "David G Fisher" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > > > news:G9vR8.412539$[email hidden]... > > > > How come no one is bitching about MS letting RB have the win with 10 > > laps > > > to > > > > go? > > > > > > > > Ferrari did the same thing as in Austria (as has been done thousands > of > > > > times in all series) except a little less obviously. More like how > > Waltrip > > > > let Earnhardt have Talladega. > > > > > > > > I guess it's ok in racing to do this as long as Michael Schumacher > isn't > > > the > > > > one who benefits. Just like I thought. Pure jealousy was the > motivation > > > for > > > > the hysterics after Austria. > > > > > > > > MS and RS tought JPM a few lessons today. Beautiful passes. JPM then > > > caused > > > > yet another accident when he hit DC. He has great car control??Quoted text (7 lines)
> > > word > > > > because it's not MS who was the other driver, and therefor no bogus > > > > opportunity to attack MS. > > > > > > > > David G Fisher > > > > > > > All I saw were two very slow Williams... I was howling withQuoted text (17 lines)
> at > > > the SpeedChannel announcers. Hobb's fake bravado with his recap of MS > > > heroically racing through the field was hilarious...I even got my wife > to > > > watch and she HATES any racing... I do recall something that 'seemed' > > like > > > a race but only two cars took part.(and they weren't RED!) > > > It was nice to see DC racing again....he pinched JPM nicely to the > curb. > > > If JPM had been a bad racer, he would have not moved into the curb and > > both > > > would have been wrecked anyway. I did see Ralfie cause a near-wreck > also, > > > running so slowly at the same turn 1 (where JPM hit DC) he forced > > (fishie?) > > > to spin rather than hit Ralf as Fishie passed JV. > > > This was a fairly embarrassing race. The Ferrari's are soooooooooQuoted text (18 lines)
> > > nothing to complain about. > > > dave henrie > > > > > > > > > > > > Dave - I think your last point is right on the mark. Moreover, until > some > > other teams become competitive with Ferrari, F1 is going to suck. You > just > > aren't going to get great racing when the top two cars are on the same > team. > > > > Todd > > > > > >"Rick Osborn" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:af7391$hml$[email hidden]...
like
incident
> at Malaysia too - afterall it was the guy on the inside who lost controlNOT
> the person on the outside who gave room (DC yesterday and Juan atMalaysia).
> Try to give posts without with your views on the incident rather than the
> driver behind the wheel.
>
> Rick
JPM squeezed MS's car way up onto the inside curbing (3/4 of the car was on
curb) even though staying a little wide would of given him a better line
into the next turn. DC gave JPM plenty of room (just one wheel touched) into
T1 at the 'Ring.
David G Fisher
Quoted text (8 lines)
> > "David G Fisher" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:G9vR8.412539$[email hidden]... > > 1 - "JPM then caused yet another accident when he hit DC. He has great car > control??" > > 2- "Funny how people will bitch at and try to blame MS for an incidentQuoted text (7 lines)
> T1 at Malaysia or Brazil which involve JPM, even though they were both > clearly JPM's fault." > > > David G Fisher > > Enlighten us with your pearls of wisdom and explain how that was Juan's > fault at Malaysia? Going off your logic we should blame MS for the
"Rick Osborn" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:af7e0e$482$[email hidden]...
get
> > around the corner.
> >
> > The DC/JPM incident at the Ring was a spin of the inside car because of
> worn
> > rear tires (according to the Williams team and JPM). Too much throttlefor
> > worn out tires.
>
> So? The malaysia incident was also down to driver error also - that of
> understeer from MS not taking into account heavy fuel loads and coldtyres;
> oh but it's ok it's the almighty Michael and anything goes - even past his
> brother by the looks of yesterday's race. Zzzz
As I said in my other post, JPM pushed MS 3/4 of the way onto the curb at
Malaysia. DC gave JPM plenty of room at the 'Ring.
>
> It has nothing to do where the contact was made, if Juan hadn't have spun
> he'd have speared DC like MS did him in malaysia.
If he didn't think he had good control of his car then he could of backed
off long before he reached the curbing.
> I'm not defending Juan
> here btw - he should have squeezed DC wide and not run onto the curb, thus
> preventing DC getting into t2 ahead of him. They're both plonkers, DCwould
> have been better off diving down the inside, cars spin outwards, David not
> inwards. And Juan should have just stayed off the curb and run DC wide.Oh
> well, at least DC and Juan can race wheel to wheel and accidents dohappen,
> more than can be said for a certain Ralf.
> Rick
RS did race wheel to wheel with JPM in the first turn on lap 1 and made a
beautiful pass, even though JPM hit him there TOO.
Out of the six top drivers (MS, RB, RS, JPM, DC, KR) only one seems to be
having trouble avoiding incidents on the track over the past 26 races.
Excuses are getting silly.
BTW, I don't dislike JPM at all, I just get tired of hearing these myths
about him being so fast and having great car control. To this point, he
hasn't been an overall faster driver than RS in qualifying or in the races.
David G Fisher
Quoted text (12 lines)
> > "Joachim Trensz" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:af7634$c1duo$[email hidden]... > > JPM's Ring incident with DC (inside car spinning out) was different from > the > > Malaysia incident between MS and JPM (front wheel of inside car tangles > with > > outside car). > > > > The Malaysia incident must be compared to the T1 incident between RS and > JPM > > at the Ring, where RS did the right thing and gave JPM enough room toI'm working on a time machine.......just for you.
David G Fisher
"Gerry Aitken" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
> Was the a GP this week!? Oh well, I missed it, what a sham(e)...
>
> David G Fisher wrote:
>
> <SNIP>
Coulthard today said, "It sits very well with the Montoya image in F1 but
the guy is all over the place. It is hardly surprising that he hasn't won
more races because I think he is very inconsistent in the race."
I think DC's comments in this article are what some of us have been saying
about JPM since the beginning of last year. His supposed great car control
is more myth than fact. Overall, he also has not been faster in qualifying
than RS in the past 26 races.
http://www.dailyf1.com/en/news/news.php?id=1539
David G Fisher
"Joachim Trensz" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:af7sq4$cat50$[email hidden]...
> > T1 Brazil they touched... so what?
>
> I'd have wanted to hear your comments if you'd have been in MS' position;-)
>
> JPM in Brazil drove over-optimistic and needed a lot of help from MS forhis
> maneuver to work, else he'd have taken both of them out.
>
> I think what happened in the months thereafter was that JPM built up a bit
> of a history of rude driving towards MS, and at one point MS simplydecided
Quoted text (8 lines)
> that it's enough now and he'd just drive as unrelenting as JPM himself. > > If we accept the Brazil move as 'just racing', then we need to accept that > decision as well. > > Achim > >"Joachim Trensz" wrote...
> > T1 Brazil they touched... so what?
>
> I'd have wanted to hear your comments if you'd have been in
> MS' position ;-)
In MS's position I wouldn't have taken the fight passed the entry point.
Just sit behind him for a couple of laps, wait for the Michelins to lose
their edge and blow him away. MS is usually a very calculating driver, but
JPM for some reason seems to give him "red mist". It appears to me he wants
to lead JPM, whether the racing situation actually demands it or not. But
that's just my impression, of course.
> JPM in Brazil drove over-optimistic and needed a lot of help
> from MS for his maneuver to work, else he'd have taken both
> of them out.
Did I suggest otherwise? -They both desperately wanted to be 1st to the
first turn and only nearly avoided ending their race there and then. With a
bit more luck something similar would have happened at Nurnburg between DC
and JPM. I mean, people contesting positions is what we watch racing for,
right?
> I think what happened in the months thereafter was that JPM
> built up a bit of a history of rude driving towards MS, and
> at one point MS simply decided that it's enough now and he'd
> just drive as unrelenting as JPM himself.
Eh... I can't remember them coming together or having over the top passes
since Brazil. The Malaysia incident preceded the Brazil race, remember?
> If we accept the Brazil move as 'just racing', then we need
> to accept that decision as well.
Not wanting to appear like an MS basher, but, IMO, MS has always driven like
this. Before him Senna drove like that. They just have low tolerance for
people ahead of them. ;-)
Jan.
=---
"Jan Verschueren" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:c2JR8.49654$[email hidden]...
wheel
> too. Good pass, but "teaching a lesson"? -Come on. If anybody wasteaching,
He shouldn't of pushed it to the limit in a vain attempt to keep DC behind
him. JPM also hit RS in T1, lap 1. Did you rea dthese comments by DC?
http://www.dailyf1.com/en/news/news.php?id=1539 JPM's car control and
decision making apparently isn't too highly regarded by the other drivers,
at least not right now.
JPM squeezed MS's car 3/4 of the way up onto the curbing, event hough JPM
would of been better off staying a little wide so he's better set up for the
next turn. DC gave JPM a ton of room in comparision.
>T1 Brazil they touched... so what? It's racing and both want to be the
> top dog in F1.
I'm referring to where JPM hit MS from behind going into T4 (first turn
after long straight) and lost his front wing.
> > When JPM does the same type of thing to DC today though,
> > no one says a word because it's not MS who was the other
> > driver, and therefor no bogus opportunity to attack MS.
>
> Again: wrong conclusion. Both drivers raced for position and lefteachother
> room to work with. JPM slowed and turned in enough, but it still went pear
> shaped. An incident as is bound to happen many times more in today's F1,
> dominated by aero concerns and use of "strong in one direction" materials.
Read DC's comments. JPM was flat wrong to try to hold him off at that point
of the race, and didn't execute the turn as good a she should of. JPM also
hit RS at the same corner on lap 1 as RS began his pass.
> That said, JPM is taking a long time to "get smart". He's got to lose the
> "never say die"-attitude, IMO, especially in the current Williams.
>
> Jan.
> =---
It seems like it's more of a, "My d**k is bigger than yours" type of
attitude.
David G Fisher
Quoted text (9 lines)
> ----- Original Message ----- > > > MS and RS tought JPM a few lessons today. Beautiful > > passes. > > RS took advantage of JPM having to defend at the start, nice move indeed; > wouldn't expect anything less of him. > > MS had a superior car, a weight advantage and is quite special at theQuoted text (7 lines)
> it was Ross Brown, not Michael Schumacher. > > > JPM then caused yet another accident when he hit DC. He > > has great car control?? > > When it's gone it's gone... car control does not extend much beyond the > limit.Quoted text (7 lines)
> > Funny how people will bitch at and try to blame MS for an > > incident like T1 at Malaysia or Brazil which involve JPM, > > even though they were both clearly JPM's fault. > > Bad examples. The "wrong" about Malaysia was assigning a penalty for a > racing incident and to the driver who'd suffered most from the incident to > boot.Even if he was closer, Schumacher wants Fangio's record, he would never
allow Rubens to won. At least this year Rubens has found how to work with
the car, and finally is putting some pressure on MS. On Austria and
yesterday, he won on the track, he was faster and did not made errors like
the spun of MS.
Now, all we can do is wait for 2003. :-(
Brian
"David G Fisher" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:SWJR8.116459$[email hidden]...
> The problem is that RB is miles behind MS in points due to a poor start(not
on
10
> > > laps
> > > > to
> > > > > go?
> > > > >
> > > > > Ferrari did the same thing as in Austria (as has been donethousands
then
> > > > caused
> > > > > yet another accident when he hit DC. He has great car control??
> Funny
> > > how
> > > > > people will bitch at and try to blame MS for an incident like T1at
> > > > Malaysia
> > > > > or Brazil which involve JPM, even though they were both clearly
> JPM's
> > > > fault.
> > > > > When JPM does the same type of thing to DC today though, no onesays
> a
> > > > word
> > > > > because it's not MS who was the other driver, and therefor nobogus
MS
> > > > heroically racing through the field was hilarious...I even got mywife
> > to
> > > > watch and she HATES any racing... I do recall something that'seemed'
> > > like
> > > > a race but only two cars took part.(and they weren't RED!)
> > > > It was nice to see DC racing again....he pinched JPM nicely to the
> > curb.
> > > > If JPM had been a bad racer, he would have not moved into the curband
there
Quoted text (12 lines)
> all his fault) to the season. > > David G Fisher > > "Brian" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:af7co0$c095s$[email hidden]... > > Not true. Remember: > > > > McLaren : Senna and Prost > > Williams: Mansell and Piquet > > > > They batlted a lot, having even two seasons decided with crashs (SennaQuoted text (16 lines)
> > Prost and then, Prost on Senna). > > > > The problem here is Ferrari and Schumacher. Until they allow the two to > > fight, we will have a one-man championship. > > > > Brian > > > > "JTBurn" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > > news:CDDR8.367636$%[email hidden]... > > > > > > "Dave Henrie" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > > > news:%NvR8.155481$[email hidden]... > > > > > > > > "David G Fisher" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > > > > news:G9vR8.412539$[email hidden]... > > > > > How come no one is bitching about MS letting RB have the win withQuoted text (14 lines)
> > of > > > > > times in all series) except a little less obviously. More like how > > > Waltrip > > > > > let Earnhardt have Talladega. > > > > > > > > > > I guess it's ok in racing to do this as long as Michael Schumacher > > isn't > > > > the > > > > > one who benefits. Just like I thought. Pure jealousy was the > > motivation > > > > for > > > > > the hysterics after Austria. > > > > > > > > > > MS and RS tought JPM a few lessons today. Beautiful passes. JPMQuoted text (8 lines)
> > > > > opportunity to attack MS. > > > > > > > > > > David G Fisher > > > > > > > > > All I saw were two very slow Williams... I was howling with > laughter > > at > > > > the SpeedChannel announcers. Hobb's fake bravado with his recap ofQuoted text (11 lines)
> > > both > > > > would have been wrecked anyway. I did see Ralfie cause a near-wreck > > also, > > > > running so slowly at the same turn 1 (where JPM hit DC) he forced > > > (fishie?) > > > > to spin rather than hit Ralf as Fishie passed JV. > > > > This was a fairly embarrassing race. The Ferrari's are sooooooooo > far > > > > ahead of the other marques that they could get away with staging the > end > > > > result. Until the other brands level the playing field some,Quoted text (21 lines)
> is > > > > nothing to complain about. > > > > dave henrie > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Dave - I think your last point is right on the mark. Moreover, until > > some > > > other teams become competitive with Ferrari, F1 is going to suck. You > > just > > > aren't going to get great racing when the top two cars are on the same > > team. > > > > > > Todd > > > > > > > > > > > >Who said he didn't won on the track? When MS tried to catch on him, he made
a mistake and spun on the track, somethink he do not do a lot. After the
second pit, they had so many time ahead of 3rd place, that the orders were
to calm down and finish. Who knows what would have happen if they had to
battle on the track.
Brian
"EldredP" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
> In article <af7632$c1duo$[email hidden]>, "Joachim Trensz"
> <[email hidden]> writes:
>
> >RB's joy looked very real on the rostrum - he didn't seem to care whetherit
you
> with experience...
>
> Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.
Quoted text (8 lines)
> >was a handed win or a real one. > > Like a kid at xmas...<g> > > Eldred > -- > Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett > Never argue with an idiot. He brings you down to his level, then beatsBTW, I do like JPM and I don't feel comfortable criticizing professional
drivers. Overly critical fans of sport here in the U.S. are called "Monday
morning quarterbacks", which means you know what the QB/coach/team should do
the day AFTER the game. I probably wouldn't get the car out of the pits, so
I feel kind of ridiculous criticizing the real F1 drivers.
What bothers me about JPM is more his fan's hyping of him since day 1, and
the way they put down other drivers in doing so.
David G Fisher
"David G Fisher" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:AtLR8.374760$[email hidden]...
indeed;
to
> > boot.
>
> JPM squeezed MS's car 3/4 of the way up onto the curbing, event hough JPM
> would of been better off staying a little wide so he's better set up forthe
pear
> > shaped. An incident as is bound to happen many times more in today's F1,
> > dominated by aero concerns and use of "strong in one direction"materials.
>
> Read DC's comments. JPM was flat wrong to try to hold him off at thatpoint
> of the race, and didn't execute the turn as good a she should of. JPM also
> hit RS at the same corner on lap 1 as RS began his pass.
>
> > That said, JPM is taking a long time to "get smart". He's got to losethe
Quoted text (9 lines)
> > "Jan Verschueren" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:c2JR8.49654$[email hidden]... > > ----- Original Message ----- > > > > > MS and RS tought JPM a few lessons today. Beautiful > > > passes. > > > > RS took advantage of JPM having to defend at the start, nice moveQuoted text (26 lines)
> > wouldn't expect anything less of him. > > > > MS had a superior car, a weight advantage and is quite special at the > wheel > > too. Good pass, but "teaching a lesson"? -Come on. If anybody was > teaching, > > it was Ross Brown, not Michael Schumacher. > > > > > JPM then caused yet another accident when he hit DC. He > > > has great car control?? > > > > When it's gone it's gone... car control does not extend much beyond the > > limit. > > He shouldn't of pushed it to the limit in a vain attempt to keep DC behind > him. JPM also hit RS in T1, lap 1. Did you rea dthese comments by DC? > http://www.dailyf1.com/en/news/news.php?id=1539 JPM's car control and > decision making apparently isn't too highly regarded by the other drivers, > at least not right now. > > > > Funny how people will bitch at and try to blame MS for an > > > incident like T1 at Malaysia or Brazil which involve JPM, > > > even though they were both clearly JPM's fault. > > > > Bad examples. The "wrong" about Malaysia was assigning a penalty for a > > racing incident and to the driver who'd suffered most from the incidentQuoted text (15 lines)
> next turn. DC gave JPM a ton of room in comparision. > > >T1 Brazil they touched... so what? It's racing and both want to be the > > top dog in F1. > > I'm referring to where JPM hit MS from behind going into T4 (first turn > after long straight) and lost his front wing. > > > > When JPM does the same type of thing to DC today though, > > > no one says a word because it's not MS who was the other > > > driver, and therefor no bogus opportunity to attack MS. > > > > Again: wrong conclusion. Both drivers raced for position and left > eachother > > room to work with. JPM slowed and turned in enough, but it still wentQuoted text (11 lines)
> > "never say die"-attitude, IMO, especially in the current Williams. > > > > Jan. > > =--- > > It seems like it's more of a, "My d**k is bigger than yours" type of > attitude. > > David G Fisher > >I've been simply amazed with Michael since a few years ago when he was
driving for Benetton and lost several gears in a race and STILL managed to
finish in 2nd (I believe it was at Silverstone, but I don't remember for
sure) even though he had to pit and had no first gear!
--
---------------------
Rob Berryhill
"Joachim Trensz" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:af6u5u$c2odh$[email hidden]...
> That's what distinguishes champions from the rest of the world :-)
>
> Achim
>
>
> "Mark Seery" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
> news:af6fis$72g$[email hidden]...
> ...
> > Funny how the guy can always fall in a bucket of shit
> > and come out smelling of roses aint it?
>
>
>
>
Andreas Nystr�m wrote:
> No you are right that the clock showed rubens pit faster.
> I just ment that i thought they would screw up in the pits.
That's the point. You can't prove team orders if done secretly.
If that's clear, I'd actually prefer them doing it openly, so at
least we know who would have really won the race.
It's the same reason why they allowed traction control, etc.
FIA was not able to control it, as the line between TC and good
engine management is very thin, so they made it legal for all.
--
l8er
ronny
Your mouse has moved. Windows must be restarted for the change
to take effect. Reboot now?
Quoted text (9 lines)
> > "Joachim Trensz" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:af6u60$c2odh$[email hidden]... > >>I think RB's 2nd pitstop standstill-time was 2 tenths shorter than MS's, >> > 7.6 > >>vs. 7.8 - but this is from memory, I may be wrong
"David G Fisher" wrote...
> > <snip>
> He shouldn't of pushed it to the limit in a vain attempt
> to keep DC behind him.
Indeed, thought I mentioned that by saying he wasn't getting smart.
Replace "car" by "self" in that sentence and I'll agree with you. When it's
just him and the car vs the track, there's few who rival him, IMO. His
situational awareness is poor, however. In the T1 incident with Ralf I don't
think he even thought about looking that way until it was too late. Did they
actually touch? -Didn't look that way to me, but hard to say for sure.
I think DC's comments are justified... that's what I meant with the getting
smart bit. Even if we're to believe JPM's excuse it was still a mistake to
try to convince the team a stop was necessary and keep DC behind. Having to
yield to DC, would have supported his viewpoint with a tyre change was
necessary.
> > > <snip>
> JPM squeezed MS's car 3/4 of the way up onto the curbing, event
> hough JPM would of been better off staying a little wide so
> he's better set up for the next turn. DC gave JPM a ton of room
> in comparision.
Yes, and he payed the price when MS didn't back out of the move. They didn't
give eachother the light of day and came together. Would it have been murder
for the stewards to leave it at that?
> > <snip>
> I'm referring to where JPM hit MS from behind going into
> T4 (first turn after long straight) and lost his front wing.
I assumed you were still talking T1 accidents, sorry.
> > > <snip>
> It seems like it's more of a, "My d**k is bigger than yours"
> type of attitude.
There is some of that on both sides, IMO, only MS is an established
superstar and uses that to great advantage to make JPM look dumb. You see,
MS *is* smart.
Jan.
=---
Quoted text (8 lines)
> JPM also hit RS in T1, lap 1. Did you read these comments > by DC? > > http://www.dailyf1.com/en/news/news.php?id=1539 > > JPM's car control and decision making apparently isn't too > highly regarded by the other drivers, at least not right > now.I thought these comments by Burger summed up MS pretty well:
"When a car is really good it is more difficult for drivers to make a bigger
difference," said Berger. "Rubens is a good driver, no question. But Michael
is an outstanding driver.
"I remember when I joined Benetton at the end of 1995 after Michael had just
won the championship and moved to Ferrari. At the first test in Estoril I
straight away did a lap time close to Michael's best.
"I thought 'no problem, I'll just go right on the limit and I will be
quicker than him'. But when I tried that I just lost the car the whole time
and I was in the barrier.
"I destroyed two or three cars in a row because the car was very, very,
critical in the last few per cent of the performance."
Berger is able to laugh about the experience now. "After that I said to
myself 'maybe Michael is not too bad after all because he can race it like
this lap after lap after lap'," he added.
"If you have a perfect car which is quite easy to drive to the limit the gap
is going to be smaller." --Berger
David G Fisher
"Rob" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:qKLR8.2853$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (27 lines)
> I've been simply amazed with Michael since a few years ago when he was > driving for Benetton and lost several gears in a race and STILL managed to > finish in 2nd (I believe it was at Silverstone, but I don't remember for > sure) even though he had to pit and had no first gear! > > -- > --------------------- > Rob Berryhill > > "Joachim Trensz" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:af6u5u$c2odh$[email hidden]... > > That's what distinguishes champions from the rest of the world :-) > > > > Achim > > > > > > "Mark Seery" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > > news:af6fis$72g$[email hidden]... > > ... > > > Funny how the guy can always fall in a bucket of shit > > > and come out smelling of roses aint it? > > > > > > > > > >Joachim Trensz wrote:
Of course, the guy who spins is never wrong... ;)
--
l8er
ronny
Your mouse has moved. Windows must be restarted for the change
to take effect. Reboot now?
Quoted text (7 lines)
> Hi Doug, > > >>Had DC not squeezes JPM - he wouldnt have clipped the curb and spun >> > > That's an interesting interpretation :-)yes, indeed :-)
Achim
"EldredP" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
> In article <af7632$c1duo$[email hidden]>, "Joachim Trensz"
> <[email hidden]> writes:
>
> >RB's joy looked very real on the rostrum - he didn't seem to care whetherit
> >was a handed win or a real one.
>
> Like a kid at xmas...<g>....
> T1 Brazil they touched... so what?
I'd have wanted to hear your comments if you'd have been in MS' position ;-)
JPM in Brazil drove over-optimistic and needed a lot of help from MS for his
maneuver to work, else he'd have taken both of them out.
I think what happened in the months thereafter was that JPM built up a bit
of a history of rude driving towards MS, and at one point MS simply decided
that it's enough now and he'd just drive as unrelenting as JPM himself.
If we accept the Brazil move as 'just racing', then we need to accept that
decision as well.
Achim
"David G Fisher" <[email hidden]> wrote in
news:N6LR8.117175$[email hidden]:
I've been thinking recently, that you're right about JPM, Dave. However he
does compare favourably with the dull (this year) R Schumacher, in the
entertainment stakes. JPM looks more and more like a pabst "insect" every
race :oD
In answer to your original comment, I find that allowing both cars to race
without orders for 50 laps then asking them to hold position and bring the
cars home is a lot different to telling one driver to move aside for the
other after outdriving him and leading him for practically the whole race.
Rubens and Michael raced on sunday, they raced for 50 laps and the "winner"
of that race carried on ahead to the end. At austria, if there was any
racing between the two, the "winner" was told to step aside and lose his
place in the history books of formula one.
MS was catching RB, and was faster, even after the spin, but "catching is
one thing, passing is quite another" RB would have had to deliberately step
aside for MS to get past him, that's my opinion.
cheers
John
Quoted text (14 lines)
> Coulthard today said, "It sits very well with the Montoya image in F1 > but the guy is all over the place. It is hardly surprising that he > hasn't won more races because I think he is very inconsistent in the > race." > > I think DC's comments in this article are what some of us have been > saying about JPM since the beginning of last year. His supposed great > car control is more myth than fact. Overall, he also has not been > faster in qualifying than RS in the past 26 races. > > http://www.dailyf1.com/en/news/news.php?id=1539 > > David G Fisher >
"Jan Verschueren" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:wVLR8.50086$[email hidden]...
it's
> just him and the car vs the track, there's few who rival him, IMO.
Isn't self control a big part of car control? Doesn't car control come from
the thousands of rapid fire decisions you make while driving?
What I don't understand is why JPM continues to have this reputation for
great car control while his teammate who's driving the same car has been
getting the better results. RS has a better qualifying and race record since
JPM joined the team. RS has fewer accidents. He's smoother while going just
as fast, or faster.
The 'Ring race was a perfect example. RS did lose pole to JPM, but only by
.009. RS was using the hard tires though. RS was the one who had great car
control when he passed JPM (JPM actually hit him), and RS ended up with the
better race result because of JPM hitting DC.
I think people say JPM has great car control because they've seen a few in
car shots of him using opposite lock to catch the rear when in CART. Not
sliding the rear of the car in the first place, while still being fast is
what I consider to be good car control. Holding your line, being smooth, not
causing accidents, etc. All F1 drivers can go around the track with the back
end hanging out but that's not the fastest way around the track, so they
don't.
>His
> situational awareness is poor, however. In the T1 incident with Ralf Idon't
> think he even thought about looking that way until it was too late. Didthey
> actually touch? -Didn't look that way to me, but hard to say for sure.
I saw a view which showed JPM's front left hitting RS's rear right tire.
> I think DC's comments are justified... that's what I meant with thegetting
> smart bit. Even if we're to believe JPM's excuse it was still a mistake to
> try to convince the team a stop was necessary and keep DC behind. Havingto
> yield to DC, would have supported his viewpoint with a tyre change was
> necessary.
Yes.
didn't
> give eachother the light of day and came together. Would it have beenmurder
> for the stewards to leave it at that?
I don't necessarily agree that a pnealty was necessary, but I'm more
focusing on who was at fault.
David G Fisher
Quoted text (7 lines)
> > "David G Fisher" wrote... > > JPM's car control and decision making apparently isn't too > > highly regarded by the other drivers, at least not right > > now. > > Replace "car" by "self" in that sentence and I'll agree with you. WhenQuoted text (7 lines)
> > > > <snip> > > JPM squeezed MS's car 3/4 of the way up onto the curbing, event > > hough JPM would of been better off staying a little wide so > > he's better set up for the next turn. DC gave JPM a ton of room > > in comparision. > > Yes, and he payed the price when MS didn't back out of the move. TheyBoth MS and RB said they'd had team orders to keep their respective
positions.
Achim
"Brian" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:af80og$c55cb$[email hidden]...
> Who said he didn't won on the track?
Hi Jan,
we're talking about different Brazil incidents I think - mine was last year,
unless I'm getting old and confused :-) where MS had to really go onto the
grass in T1 and JPM's RF wheel had contact with MS' car.
I think this year there was a really good racing maneuver from both in T1,
where they exchanged positions and drove really intelligently. Good racing
IMO.
> MS is usually a very calculating driver, but
> JPM for some reason seems to give him "red mist".
I think it's like I said. JPM attacked MS overly hard several times since he
entered F1 and MS did hold back up to a certain point, from where he decided
to stand his ground. At least that's how I perceived it.
> Not wanting to appear like an MS basher
And I don't want to blindly support him.
Achim
Agreed, with less than optimal cars or on difficult-to-drive tracks, the
differences in capabilities between the drivers show more clearly.
Achim
"David G Fisher" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:SXLR8.117565$[email hidden]...
> I thought these comments by Burger summed up MS pretty well:
>
> "When a car is really good it is more difficult for drivers to make abigger
> difference," said Berger. "Rubens is a good driver, no question. ButMichael
> is an outstanding driver.
>
> "I remember when I joined Benetton at the end of 1995 after Michael hadjust
> won the championship and moved to Ferrari. At the first test in Estoril I
> straight away did a lap time close to Michael's best.
>
> "I thought 'no problem, I'll just go right on the limit and I will be
> quicker than him'. But when I tried that I just lost the car the wholetime
gap
> is going to be smaller." --Berger
>
> David G Fisher
Quoted text (10 lines)
> and I was in the barrier. > > "I destroyed two or three cars in a row because the car was very, very, > critical in the last few per cent of the performance." > > Berger is able to laugh about the experience now. "After that I said to > myself 'maybe Michael is not too bad after all because he can race it like > this lap after lap after lap'," he added. > > "If you have a perfect car which is quite easy to drive to the limit theThat is also true :-)
Achim
"Ronald Stoehr" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
...
> Of course, the guy who spins is never wrong... ;)
On Mon, 24 Jun 2002 14:07:34 +1200, David G Fisher wrote:
\
>
> MS and RS tought JPM a few lessons today.
RS didn't. When RS was under pressure he just let his bro on past.
Disgusting. He should have at least used the 'one move' rule.
Compare Montoya trying to protect his place vs Ralf meekly letting Michael
past.
> Beautiful passes.
Thanx to cooperation from the passing driver. Just because the car behind
you is faster doesn't mean you should let it pass easily.
> JPM then caused
> yet another accident when he hit DC.
Bah. JPM had a small slow spin which would have had no consequence if DC
wasn't trying to pass him on the outside.
> He has great car control??
Hard to argue with three poles in a row.
> When JPM does the same type of thing to DC today though, no one says a word
> because it's not MS who was the other driver, and therefor no bogus
> opportunity to attack MS.
David took a risk. Montoya's tyres were crap. Montoya tried to defend his
position at all costs.
I prefer Montoya crashing to him acting like almost every other boring F1
driver today who almost lets the fastest car past them.
Thank goodness for Montoya's attitude I say.
However - I would like him to finish a race sometime.
---
Bill (who admits to being JPM biased since FINALLY there is some life in
F1 now).
On Tue, 25 Jun 2002 07:21:48 +1200, David G Fisher wrote:
\
>
> To this point, he
> hasn't been an overall faster driver than RS in qualifying or in theraces.
What? Three poles in a row. Only started driving these courses last year
in F1 cars. You can't tell me that someone who is only onto their second
time at these tracks in a F1 car who is beating RS in qualifying is not
faster overall.
Considering how quickly Montoya has come to grips with a F1 car and road
tracks after driving turboed V8s on mix of Ovals an road tracks it is VERY
impressive.
And he is fearless, and agressive. This actually gives us something
interesting to watch rather than the usual F1 procession we have been
getting for ages. Montoya will not move over meekly to let a faster car
through. He will make anyone work to pass him.
I like this. Without Montoya the only unpredictable thing is which Ferrari
will be allowed to win the race.
What we really need now though is some WET RACES!! Where is the bloody
RAIN!
---
Bill
On Tue, 25 Jun 2002 05:55:20 +1200, Jan Verschueren wrote:
.
>
> MS had a superior car, a weight advantage and is quite special at the wheel
> too. Good pass, but "teaching a lesson"? -Come on. If anybody was teaching,
> it was Ross Brown, not Michael Schumacher.
Excellent point.
Williams should have two stopped considering the tyre problem they (and
the other four people who spun their Michelin shod cars on the pit entry)
had. But I guess they couldn't predict the tyre wear problem.
From the angles I saw Montoya's inside rear tyre seemed to hit the curbing
and bounce off which is what unsettled his car. But saying that i don't
think it was a high curb.
JPM should be used to this in tyres - but I guess in CART days his tyres
started cold and just got better. He has to get used to tyres going off
now.
> ... snip snip ..
> That said, JPM is taking a long time to "get smart". He's got to lose the
> "never say die"-attitude, IMO, especially in the current Williams.
Yes. His car does fail more often than Ralf's. But he has outqualified him
a lot recently. More experience should take care of this hopefully.
---
Bill
Quoted text (7 lines)
> >> JPM then caused yet another accident when he hit DC. He >> has great car control?? > > When it's gone it's gone... car control does not extend much beyond the > limit. >On Tue, 25 Jun 2002 08:16:45 +1200, David G Fisher wrote:
I will repeat myself here. JPM only started driving these tracks last year
in F1 cars. He is learning. I would remove the first years statistics
completely when examining his performance. Don't you find it amazing he
has been on pole three races in a row?
I vividly remember him driving in Australia last year and how he sawed at
the wheel as if it was a CHAMP car. It took him a while to learn to drive
the F1 beasties properly.
Quoted text (9 lines)
> Coulthard today said, "It sits very well with the Montoya image in F1 but > the guy is all over the place. It is hardly surprising that he hasn't won > more races because I think he is very inconsistent in the race." > > I think DC's comments in this article are what some of us have been saying > about JPM since the beginning of last year. His supposed great car control > is more myth than fact. Overall, he also has not been faster in qualifying > than RS in the past 26 races. >On Mon, 24 Jun 2002 22:59:54 -0000, "Joachim Trensz"
<[email hidden]> wrote:
>Both MS and RB said they'd had team orders to keep their respective
>positions.
I was under the impression, reading the interview with Todt, that this
was to keep them from making a stupid mistake and losing constructor
points.
He also indicated that giving MS a win at this point was not a
consideration since he already has a nearly unbeatable lead in the
driver's championship.
Finally, this isn't in direct response to you, but I think that what
Ferrari does team-order wise is completely irrelevant. F1 is a team
sport, not a sport of individuals. If the cars on your team are
running 1-2, I don't see why the team manager can't say "slow down and
let him pass" or "don't fight for position". It's one thing if a
team's cars are a lap adrift and the lapped car is blocking a
competitor, which violates a rule of the sport (correct me if I'm
wrong, didn't Coulthard do this to Irvine in 1999?).
As far as what happened at the Ring (I hate calling that crappy
go-kart track that, by the way), it's been common practice for dozens
of years to have an agreement between teammates that whomever is
leading when the competition fades will take the win without pressure.
I can think of 2 teams where this unwritten rule was violated, and one
of them ended up with a driver being killed a week later as a result
of the rivalry it created. The other ended with Prost intentionally
driving into Senna twice at Suzuka in order to selfishly win the
driver's championship. I doubt either scenario would be particularly
appealing to a team like Ferrari that has perservered on the strength
of teamwork. If they had collided, even as an accident, it would've
hurt the team. Rubens picking up a victory, however he did it, is
surely a big moral boost for him. Then again, he doesn't seem to be
bothered by playing second fiddle the way Villeneuve and Peroni did.
Jason
"David G Fisher" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:<TRMR8.424085$[email hidden]>...
God knows where this'll appear in the thread (Google delays)...
JPM is very popular at Williams and BMW (my neighbour works for BMW
and has dealings with the F1 side of things) because, regardless of
what the facts may be, he's -perceived- as a fast go-getter who's
exciting to watch - and in marketing terms that's priceless (I agree
with the perceptions, BTW).
For DC, who was in the best F1 car for years and never even came
-close- to a championship to complain that JPM should have won more
races in his short F1 career in a car that is markedly second best is
rich, to say the least.
But then I've always disliked DC. He bores me - a perfect match for
the corporate grey McLaren. And that chin... ;-)
I can't comment on this race because I didn't see it. I'm missing
quite a few these days. "Missing" is the wrong word, actually - I'm
not "missing" them at all, I'm just not seeing them...
Mark
Quoted text (11 lines)
> "Jan Verschueren" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:wVLR8.50086$[email hidden]... > > > > "David G Fisher" wrote... > > > JPM's car control and decision making apparently isn't too > > > highly regarded by the other drivers, at least not right > > > now. > > > > Replace "car" by "self" in that sentence and I'll agree with you. When > it's > > just him and the car vs the track, there's few who rival him, IMO.> MS and RS tought JPM a few lessons today.
There you go again David...
--
Cheers!
Graeme Nash
"Brian" wrote:
> Now, all we can do is wait for 2003. :-(
As if that will be *any* different ???
What you have to wait for is for Schumacher to retire. Then - and not a
second earlier - will his team fully support a second driver.
--
ed_
Bill Ryder wrote:
Amen. JPM is a flashy, fearless, aggressive *individual* is a pack of
meek, conservative, anal-retentive *robots*. Those who don't care for
him tend to be the same way. <g> F1 could use many more like him. It
would really help to liven things up & make them more interesting.
--
Fester
Quoted text (11 lines)
> Considering how quickly Montoya has come to grips with a F1 car and road > tracks after driving turboed V8s on mix of Ovals an road tracks it is VERY > impressive. > > And he is fearless, and agressive. This actually gives us something > interesting to watch rather than the usual F1 procession we have been > getting for ages. Montoya will not move over meekly to let a faster car > through. He will make anyone work to pass him. > > I like this. Without Montoya the only unpredictable thing is which Ferrari > will be allowed to win the race.
>
>Amen. JPM is a flashy, fearless, aggressive *individual* is a pack of
>meek, conservative, anal-retentive *robots*. Those who don't care for
>him tend to be the same way. <g> F1 could use many more like him. It
>would really help to liven things up & make them more interesting.
I'm hearin' ya brother, nothing like Ralf et al putting up a huge
fight to hold their position...NOT! JPM has been exactly what F1 has
needed, and even if he does make a few mistakes, at least we have seen
some action and have something to talk (or whinge) about :D
Rafe Mc
You better wipe of that last bit of MS from your chin.
"David G Fisher" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:G9vR8.412539$[email hidden]...
> How come no one is bitching about MS letting RB have the win with 10 lapsto
the
> one who benefits. Just like I thought. Pure jealousy was the motivationfor
> the hysterics after Austria.
>
> MS and RS tought JPM a few lessons today. Beautiful passes. JPM thencaused
> yet another accident when he hit DC. He has great car control?? Funny how
> people will bitch at and try to blame MS for an incident like T1 atMalaysia
> or Brazil which involve JPM, even though they were both clearly JPM'sfault.
> When JPM does the same type of thing to DC today though, no one says aword
Quoted text (7 lines)
> go? > > Ferrari did the same thing as in Austria (as has been done thousands of > times in all series) except a little less obviously. More like how Waltrip > let Earnhardt have Talladega. > > I guess it's ok in racing to do this as long as Michael Schumacher isn'tQuoted text (7 lines)
> because it's not MS who was the other driver, and therefor no bogus > opportunity to attack MS. > > David G Fisher > > >Rafe McAuliffe wrote:
Agreed. At least he's *doing* something. Can't do anything wrong when
you don't do anything at all, they always say.
--
Fester
Quoted text (13 lines)
>>Amen. JPM is a flashy, fearless, aggressive *individual* is a pack of >>meek, conservative, anal-retentive *robots*. Those who don't care for >>him tend to be the same way. <g> F1 could use many more like him. It >>would really help to liven things up & make them more interesting. > > > I'm hearin' ya brother, nothing like Ralf et al putting up a huge > fight to hold their position...NOT! JPM has been exactly what F1 has > needed, and even if he does make a few mistakes, at least we have seen > some action and have something to talk (or whinge) about :D > > Rafe Mc >Uncle Fester wrote:
Well, to win a race reaching the checkered flag is very helpfull. So doing
nothing at the right time is sometimes better than doing something at the
wrong time. Problem is, JPM still has the times mixed up slightly.
--
l8er
ronny
Your mouse has moved. Windows must be restarted for the change
to take effect. Reboot now?
Quoted text (18 lines)
> Rafe McAuliffe wrote: > >>> Amen. JPM is a flashy, fearless, aggressive *individual* is a pack >>> of meek, conservative, anal-retentive *robots*. Those who don't care >>> for him tend to be the same way. <g> F1 could use many more like >>> him. It would really help to liven things up & make them more >>> interesting. >> >> >> >> I'm hearin' ya brother, nothing like Ralf et al putting up a huge >> fight to hold their position...NOT! JPM has been exactly what F1 has >> needed, and even if he does make a few mistakes, at least we have seen >> some action and have something to talk (or whinge) about :D >> > > Agreed. At least he's *doing* something. Can't do anything wrong when > you don't do anything at all, they always say.>> He has great car control??
>Hard to argue with three poles in a row.
Hmm... try "somewhere around 62391 nonfinishes in a row".
> Thank goodness for Montoya's attitude I say.
> However - I would like him to finish a race sometime.
Isn't that a bit selfcontradictive ??
Montoya is a flashbang grenade... gets a lot of attention fast and then
disappears when the real action is going down and the points are being
decided.
To finish first, first you gotta finish... JMP never has understood this.
Funny how people say JMP just needs more experience... look at Raikkonen, he
does just fine with much fewer races. Raikkonen knows when to fight with all
he's got and when to back down and get some points in the bag.
Nahhhh JMP is the single most overrated thing in F1, he will forever be a
"talent"... but never a winner.
Mikkel
"jason moyer" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
...
> ...I don't see why the team manager can't say "slow down
> and let him pass" or "don't fight for position"
Yep, agreed.
Achim
"David G Fisher" <[email hidden]> wrote:
>What bothers me about JPM is more his fan's hyping of him since day 1, and
>the way they put down other drivers in doing so.
>
You know, David, I don't disagree with everything you say about
Montoya. The thing that gets me though is the lack of objectivity and
obvious anti-Montoya bias that infects your posts. In your eyes, the
man can do no right and others can do no wrong, and every incident
that happens on the racetrack is somehow evidence of the fact that JPM
is a second-rate hacker who has no place in Formula One. Over the
past few races (most notably Monaco and Montreal - two tracks where he
didn't exactly shine last season!), JPM acquited himself quite
admirably (in my opinion), yet you don't have anything to say about
it. But just let there be some whiff of controversy (as at the Ring),
and you're back on your soapbox with the same old "See! See! I told
you! He always makes mistakes! He's not as good as his teammate!"
And on and on.
>Out of the six top drivers (MS, RB, RS, JPM, DC, KR) only one seems to be
> having trouble avoiding incidents on the track over the past 26 races.
One of the more questionable of your comments. Granted, he's been
involved in a few over the past year and a half and some have
obviously been of his own doing, but he is far from being the only
one. Monaco and Montreal last year were two of his more obvious
unforced errors, but in an effort to be at least a bit objective,
these COULD be chalked up to being an over-exuberant rookie trying to
find his limits. But, you have argued in the past, he was NOT a
rookie, since he had already driven two seasons in CART and had spent
time as an F1 test driver. Well, CART is not F1 and driving around a
deserted Barcelona or Valencia or Estoril all by yourself in the
middle of February is hardly the same as driving in a Grand Prix. If
you're going to compare apples to apples, you have to at least
acknowledge Ralf's rookie season in the Jordan when he spent as much
time in the gravel traps as he did on the track.
Even some of the acknowledged greats of the sport (notwithstanding all
of their experience in the lower formulae) have demonstrated a
tendency to be, shall we say, "accident-prone" early in their in their
F1 career. Michael was the protagonist in perhaps the most
ill-advised and overly-ambitious passing attempts I have ever seen
when he punted Senna off the track at the Magny-Cours hairpin in 1992
(a move even dumber than Montoya's at Brazil this year, IMHO). And
Senna himself demonstrated questionable judgement at times when
passing, especially in lapped traffic. Of course, there was the
famous incident at the Suzuka chicane with Prost, but Monza 1989 (the
Schlesser incident) and Brazil (1991 or 1992? Katayama? - it was
definitely a Tyrrell) were other occasions where he could have waited
another 100 yards to make the pass and could have done so cleanly but
didn't and he ended with a bent car. And if we're going to talk about
unforced errors, there's Monaco 1996 where Michael locked his front
wheels, understeered into the curb and wrecked his suspension while
leading on the first lap, or Monaco 1989 where Senna stuffed it into
the harbourfront wall late in the race with a huge lead through loss
of concentration. And let's not even get into discussing the
adventures of guys like Gilles Villeneuve and Jean Alesi in the first
few years of their careers!
To return to this year, there was the Ralf/Rubens first corner
incident at Melbourne. Who was to blame here? You could argue that
neither was to blame, that it was a racing incident. Or you could
argue that both were equally to blame, Rubens for moving over, Ralf
for not lifting. I'm not making any judgement call on this one.
However, one thing I know for sure is that if it had been Montoya
behing the wheel of the Williams, you would have found some excuse to
blame it on him and pillory him for his impatience. How about Ralf's
unforced error at Barcelona where JPM had narrowed the gap down to
less than a second on the previous lap and Ralf folded like a cheap
tent under the pressure from his teammate, spun off and subsequently
retired? And last weekend, Michael made a mistake and spun off
at the Ring. Granted, he was able to continue, but a mistake is still
a mistake, even though in this case there were no race-ending
consequences and no-one else was involved. And one of the constants
that I've noticed about Friday practice sessions this season is that
both Sato and Coulthard will spin off at some point during the day.
Yet, you contend that Montoya is the only one of the leading six who
causes accidents? He's been involved in three this season (Sepang,
Brazil, and Nurburging). Has he been completely blameless in all of
these incidents? Nope, I would never argue that. But, has he been
100% responsible for all of these incidents? Nope, I wouldn't concede
that either.
One of the other contentions that you make is how much better and
faster Ralf is than his teammate, and what a superior season he is
having. Sorry, but I just don't see it. Although Ralf has
out-pointed JPM 30-27 thus far, this doesn't take into account the
fairly-certain 12 points JPM lost at Monaco and Montreal due to
mechanical failure. From my perspective, Ralf has been a major
disappointment, he's been strangely subdued and content to plod around
and scavenge what points he can. His aggression has been seriously
lacking, and while this may be fine in a second-tier team like Jordan
or Renault it does not seem to fit the Williams mold. Sure, he won at
Sepang, but realistically he probably would not have done so had it
not been for the MS/JPM incident at the first corner or Rubens' blown
engine. Hey, luck plays a part in Formula One and I'm not begrudging
him his victory, but let's look at it for what it really was. The
drivers of THAT race were definitely JPM and MS who stormed through
the field to finish 2nd and 3rd respectively after the early incident.
And then there was the afore-mentioned unforced error in Spain. What
was THAT all about? Maybe he was upset because of the suicide bombers
in the Middle East, or maybe his kid had diaper rash? Hey, that makes
about as much sense as the excuses for his sub-par performances at the
end of last season. You go on and on about his "brilliant" passing
move on JPM in Turn Two at the Nurburgring, yet you don't mention that
on the next lap he rolled over and played dead to let his brother go
through (at least Montoya made Micheal work for the position!), you go
on and on about he was only 0.09 seconds slower than JPM in qualifying
at the Ring on harder tires, yet you don't mention how he was over
half-a-second slower than JPM in qualifying at both Monaco and
Montreal using the same tires as his teammate. And has the guy even
TRIED to pass anybody this season? He cruises up behind his brother
at Brazil and sits there for lap after lap without even making an
attempt to take the lead. You have to know that in the same position,
Montoya would at least have made it interesting. It may have ended in
tears for one or the other, but I think most people (including Frank
Williams and including the hundreds of millions of viewers around the
world) would rather see actual racing than driving around in
formation. With Montoya they just might have got it. With Ralf, not
so much. And then there was Montreal when Ralf seemed content to
follow Kimi around for half the race without trying to get past, yet
JPM was able to force his way past both of them on a single lap. Even
without Ralf's pit problems and blown engine in Montreal, he never
looked like finishing any better than fourth in that race
(optimistically) and realistically could only have hoped for fifth
given his inability to pass Raikkonen. Montoya, on the other hand,
was miles up the road, reeling in Michael by more than half-a-second a
lap after his second stop, and looked set to challenge for the win
until his engine blew up. I suppose, however, that you'll find some
way to rationalize this by saying
that at both Monaco and Montreal Montoya was the author of his own
misfortune and that his aggressive driving caused his blown engines.
Whatever.
As I said, I don't disagree with some of the things you've said about
Montoya. Hey, I admit I like the guy. If nothing else, he's
injected a measure of excitement into what has, you must admit, been a
pretty boring season as far as racing at the front of the field is
concerned. Has he made mistakes? Definitely, no doubt about it. The
thing I take issue with is your unwillingness or inability to see past
your anti-Montoya biases. You always seem to mention the facts which
support your position, while conveniently ignoring those which don't.
You say you're upset with the hype that he's engendered since his
arrival in F1? Well, what the hell do you expect??? He arrived with
"name value" having won in F3000 (in quite spectacular fashion), won
the CART championship (as a rookie) and won the Indy 500. Whatever
value you place upon the latter two accomplishments, the fact remains
that it got his name known, both in the racing world and in the
mainstream. Not much different from the way that Jacques Villeneuve
was hyped upon his arrival in F1 due to the same two accomplishments
(and with the added value of being Gilles' son). And, yes, the same
way that Ralf was hyped as the next great superstar on his arrival due
to his last name. If you recall, the feeling at the time was that
Ralf would never even have gotten a shot at F1 if his name had been
Ralph Smith, and he certainly wouldn't have lasted beyond his
incident-filled first season with Jordan. Hey, hype is to be expected
and it's gonna be heaped upon those who arrive with name-value.
Honestly, unless you're a fanatical devotee of the European
development formulae, how many people had actually heard of Takuma
Sato, Alex Yoong, or even Kimi Raikkonen before they signed for a
Formula One team and who the heck is gonna hype them apart from their
own PR flacks.
All I'm suggesting, David, is that a bit more objectivity would
greatly increase your credibility.
On Wed, 26 Jun 2002 04:34:18 +1200, Mikkel Gram-Hansen wrote:
>> Thank goodness for Montoya's attitude I say.
>> However - I would like him to finish a race sometime.
>
> Isn't that a bit selfcontradictive ??
Yep.
I admit it.
I like the excitement Montoya generates by being a grenade.
I would however like him to finish races. Mainly to shut up his critics :-)
> Funny how people say JMP just needs more experience... look at Raikkonen, he
> does just fine with much fewer races. Raikkonen knows when to fight with all
> he's got and when to back down and get some points in the bag.
Yes. Well. Comparing a Finn to a Columbian. Slight difference in
temperament. Montoya has to learn to be a little calmer. His background
makes that a little hard I think. Kimi is definitely immensly talented but
I am more concerned at the moment with Ralf vs Montoya.
If you want to
talk about Kimi compare his qualifying and race performance to his
teammate this year. David beats him most of the time. He has had 5
retirements this year and has only finished in the points three times.
David had three retirements and finished in the points every other race.
Kimi has been beating him at qualifying though.
I know who I find more interesting to watch.
> Nahhhh JMP is the single most overrated thing in F1, he will forever be a
> "talent"... but never a winner.
You gonna put money on that? Or is winning one race 'not a winner'.
He won Monza last year.
Has four poles this year.
Three seconds. One 3rd. 3 retirements. Two engine one crash (IIRC)
When he finishes he always gets points this year.
(I love www.formula1.com for this stuff).
Last year of course was his learning to get through a race. Last year was
1 First
2 Seconds
One fourth, one 8th.
11(!) retirements.
So on his second year he has already improved out of mind.
Ralf is on his sixth year. Last year ralf had seven retirements. But he
did have three firsts.
Does he have to win all the races to be a winner? Does he have to win a
championship?
Montoya is the best thing to happen to F1 in ages IMHO. It adds an air of
unpredictability apart from the Rubens vs Michael finish order thing.
---
Bill
"Ian" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
> "David G Fisher" <[email hidden]> wrote:
>
> >What bothers me about JPM is more his fan's hyping of him since day 1,and
Never said anything even remotely like that. In the post you repled to I
once again said I do like him.
In case you haven't noticed, quite a lot of people seem to be critical of
him right now. I wouldn't feel the need to say anything if it weren't for
all the hype, and the criticism of RS that comes with it, which the facts
don't support.
He's been involved in more than a few over the past 26 races. Another poster
at rec.autos.sport.f1 said the following: "So, Montoya bumped into MS while
passing him in Brazil last year, ran
MS off the road when he attempted to pass in Austria last year, crashed
with MS in Sepang, ran into the back of MS in Brazil, ran into Ralf while
being passed yesterday and finally took Coulthard and himself out of
the race, rather than concede the position."
Those certainly aren't all of his incidents, but still more than a few.
Age, and experience in an open wheel race car, especially at the level of
CART, counts for a lot..
> To return to this year, there was the Ralf/Rubens first corner
> incident at Melbourne. Who was to blame here? You could argue that
> neither was to blame, that it was a racing incident. Or you could
> argue that both were equally to blame, Rubens for moving over, Ralf
> for not lifting.
I'm a Ferrari fan, but RB moved twice to defend his position, which is
supposed to be against the rules. It's also something that's even more
dangerous to do at the first corner after the race starts.
>I'm not making any judgement call on this one.
> However, one thing I know for sure is that if it had been Montoya
> behing the wheel of the Williams, you would have found some excuse to
> blame it on him and pillory him for his impatience.
If RB did it to JPM, it still would of been RB's fault.
You're right. RB was the cause of one accident which involved another car.
JPM has caused four in nine races this season.
> One of the other contentions that you make is how much better and
> faster Ralf is than his teammate, and what a superior season he is
> having. Sorry, but I just don't see it. Although Ralf has
> out-pointed JPM 30-27 thus far, this doesn't take into account the
> fairly-certain 12 points JPM lost at Monaco and Montreal due to
> mechanical failure.
RS has had mechanical problems too. Had to be rought into the pits an extra
time at Montreal due to fuel rig problems.
He didn't roll over an play dead. There was nothing he could do to stop a
much faster MS except maybe try something completely stupid like swinging
his car wildly in front of MS, and cause an accident like JPM. He's smart.
Doing something dumb may have made people with small balls happy, but that's
not the objective.
>> As I said, I don't disagree with some of the things you've said about
> Montoya. Hey, I admit I like the guy.
So do I.
The only facts that matter are qualifying and race results, and how many
crashes or unforced errors a driver makes. Race results matter the most
obviously. Last year, RS was the better qualifier and had the better race
results, with less crashes. That's a fact. Other, younger, first year
drivers manage to outperform their older, more experienced teammates in auto
racing. As for htis year, RS has the better race results so far but JPM has
a 5-4 advantage in qualifying (I'll forget about the hard tires issue). JPM
though is still causing more than his fair share of accidents. At BEST, JPM
is still a little below RS this year, which means he has not lived up to the
hype. Now you understand my point. I doubt things will change much in the
last eight races between them, unless one has bad luck with mechanical
failures. They are both about the same talent wise, with RS being the
smarter driver. Things could change in the last eight races, but it will
probably be due more to mechanical failures or bad luck.
It's the hype along with the accompanied unfair and unsupported criticism of
other drivers such as RS which bothers me. I wouldn't care if Raikkonen,
Button, or Massa receive too much hype. They deserve it IMO. If someone says
Raikkonen is superb and rips DC in an attempt to support their opinion, then
I'd object and try to disprove them with facts.
David G Fisher
Quoted text (9 lines)
> >the way they put down other drivers in doing so. > > > > You know, David, I don't disagree with everything you say about > Montoya. The thing that gets me though is the lack of objectivity and > obvious anti-Montoya bias that infects your posts. In your eyes, the > man can do no right and others can do no wrong, and every incident > that happens on the racetrack is somehow evidence of the fact that JPM > is a second-rate hacker who has no place in Formula One.Quoted text (8 lines)
> Over the > past few races (most notably Monaco and Montreal - two tracks where he > didn't exactly shine last season!), JPM acquited himself quite > admirably (in my opinion), yet you don't have anything to say about > it. But just let there be some whiff of controversy (as at the Ring), > and you're back on your soapbox with the same old "See! See! I told > you! He always makes mistakes! He's not as good as his teammate!" > And on and on.Quoted text (7 lines)
> >Out of the six top drivers (MS, RB, RS, JPM, DC, KR) only one seems to be > > having trouble avoiding incidents on the track over the past 26 races. > > One of the more questionable of your comments. Granted, he's been > involved in a few over the past year and a half and some have > obviously been of his own doing, but he is far from being the only > one.Quoted text (11 lines)
>Monaco and Montreal last year were two of his more obvious > unforced errors, but in an effort to be at least a bit objective, > these COULD be chalked up to being an over-exuberant rookie trying to > find his limits. But, you have argued in the past, he was NOT a > rookie, since he had already driven two seasons in CART and had spent > time as an F1 test driver. Well, CART is not F1 and driving around a > deserted Barcelona or Valencia or Estoril all by yourself in the > middle of February is hardly the same as driving in a Grand Prix. If > you're going to compare apples to apples, you have to at least > acknowledge Ralf's rookie season in the Jordan when he spent as much > time in the gravel traps as he did on the track.Quoted text (16 lines)
> How about Ralf's > unforced error at Barcelona where JPM had narrowed the gap down to > less than a second on the previous lap and Ralf folded like a cheap > tent under the pressure from his teammate, spun off and subsequently > retired? And last weekend, Michael made a mistake and spun off > at the Ring. Granted, he was able to continue, but a mistake is still > a mistake, even though in this case there were no race-ending > consequences and no-one else was involved. And one of the constants > that I've noticed about Friday practice sessions this season is that > both Sato and Coulthard will spin off at some point during the day. > Yet, you contend that Montoya is the only one of the leading six who > causes accidents? He's been involved in three this season (Sepang, > Brazil, and Nurburging). Has he been completely blameless in all of > these incidents? Nope, I would never argue that. But, has he been > 100% responsible for all of these incidents? Nope, I wouldn't concede > that either.Quoted text (19 lines)
> From my perspective, Ralf has been a major > disappointment, he's been strangely subdued and content to plod around > and scavenge what points he can. His aggression has been seriously > lacking, and while this may be fine in a second-tier team like Jordan > or Renault it does not seem to fit the Williams mold. Sure, he won at > Sepang, but realistically he probably would not have done so had it > not been for the MS/JPM incident at the first corner or Rubens' blown > engine. Hey, luck plays a part in Formula One and I'm not begrudging > him his victory, but let's look at it for what it really was. The > drivers of THAT race were definitely JPM and MS who stormed through > the field to finish 2nd and 3rd respectively after the early incident. > And then there was the afore-mentioned unforced error in Spain. What > was THAT all about? Maybe he was upset because of the suicide bombers > in the Middle East, or maybe his kid had diaper rash? Hey, that makes > about as much sense as the excuses for his sub-par performances at the > end of last season. You go on and on about his "brilliant" passing > move on JPM in Turn Two at the Nurburgring, yet you don't mention that > on the next lap he rolled over and played dead to let his brother go > through (at least Montoya made Micheal work for the position!),Quoted text (7 lines)
>If nothing else, he's > injected a measure of excitement into what has, you must admit, been a > pretty boring season as far as racing at the front of the field is > concerned. Has he made mistakes? Definitely, no doubt about it. The > thing I take issue with is your unwillingness or inability to see past > your anti-Montoya biases. You always seem to mention the facts which > support your position, while conveniently ignoring those which don't.Quoted text (20 lines)
> You say you're upset with the hype that he's engendered since his > arrival in F1? Well, what the hell do you expect??? He arrived with > "name value" having won in F3000 (in quite spectacular fashion), won > the CART championship (as a rookie) and won the Indy 500. Whatever > value you place upon the latter two accomplishments, the fact remains > that it got his name known, both in the racing world and in the > mainstream. Not much different from the way that Jacques Villeneuve > was hyped upon his arrival in F1 due to the same two accomplishments > (and with the added value of being Gilles' son). And, yes, the same > way that Ralf was hyped as the next great superstar on his arrival due > to his last name. If you recall, the feeling at the time was that > Ralf would never even have gotten a shot at F1 if his name had been > Ralph Smith, and he certainly wouldn't have lasted beyond his > incident-filled first season with Jordan. Hey, hype is to be expected > and it's gonna be heaped upon those who arrive with name-value. > Honestly, unless you're a fanatical devotee of the European > development formulae, how many people had actually heard of Takuma > Sato, Alex Yoong, or even Kimi Raikkonen before they signed for a > Formula One team and who the heck is gonna hype them apart from their > own PR flacks.And people say I'm critical of Montoya. :-) Agree with you on Raikkonen.
Younger, much less experience, fast and smart.
David G Fisher
"Mikkel Gram-Hansen" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:3d189c16$0$71615$[email hidden]...
he
> does just fine with much fewer races. Raikkonen knows when to fight withall
Quoted text (16 lines)
> >> He has great car control?? > >Hard to argue with three poles in a row. > > Hmm... try "somewhere around 62391 nonfinishes in a row". > > > > Thank goodness for Montoya's attitude I say. > > However - I would like him to finish a race sometime. > > Isn't that a bit selfcontradictive ?? > Montoya is a flashbang grenade... gets a lot of attention fast and then > disappears when the real action is going down and the points are being > decided. > To finish first, first you gotta finish... JMP never has understood this. > > Funny how people say JMP just needs more experience... look at Raikkonen,Quoted text (8 lines)
> he's got and when to back down and get some points in the bag. > > Nahhhh JMP is the single most overrated thing in F1, he will forever be a > "talent"... but never a winner. > > Mikkel > >On Tue, 25 Jun 2002 17:01:29 -0000, "Joachim Trensz"
<[email hidden]> wrote:
Are you agreeing with just one of the negatives or with the full
double negative? :)
I should have said "I don't see a problem with the team manager saying
'slow down and let him pass' or 'don't fight for position'.
Jason
Quoted text (7 lines)
>"jason moyer" <[email hidden]> wrote in message >news:[email hidden]... >... >> ...I don't see why the team manager can't say "slow down >> and let him pass" or "don't fight for position" > >Yep, agreed.I guess we agree that Montoya can be fun to watch, and that he has a lot of
talent ;)
We don't agree on just how good he has the potential at becoming.... only
time will tell who is right there.
In the beginning I found him a fresh breath of air in a booooooring F1
field. Now the novelty has worn off and he still drives like he did in the
beginning, much too hotheaded.
Mikkel
PS: Anyways, it's nice to be able to disagree without getting into a
flamewar... an exchange like this could never happen in the F1 newsgroup ;)
Ronald Stoehr wrote:
> So doing
> nothing at the right time is sometimes better than doing something at the
> wrong time. Problem is, JPM still has the times mixed up slightly.
To an extent I agree. But like I've always taught all my kids, It's
better to try & fail than never to try at all. Many may not catch that
though.
--
Fester
"Uncle Fester" <
> > So doing
> > nothing at the right time is sometimes better than doing something atthe
I tried to understand what you meant, but I gave up...just couldn't wrap
my mind around it...
dave henrie
Quoted text (9 lines)
> > wrong time. Problem is, JPM still has the times mixed up slightly. > > > To an extent I agree. But like I've always taught all my kids, It's > better to try & fail than never to try at all. Many may not catch that > though. > > Fester >Dave Henrie wrote:
I rest my case... :-)
--
Fester
Quoted text (20 lines)
> "Uncle Fester" < > >>>So doing >>>nothing at the right time is sometimes better than doing something at >> > the > >>>wrong time. Problem is, JPM still has the times mixed up slightly. >> >> >>To an extent I agree. But like I've always taught all my kids, It's >>better to try & fail than never to try at all. Many may not catch that >>though. >> >>Fester >> > > I tried to understand what you meant, but I gave up...just couldn't wrap > my mind around it... > dave henrie
"Joachim Trensz" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:afcllu$d92np$[email hidden]...
I would have thought that letting Rubens win is a very tactical move for
Ferrari for their case.
I.e. most people will not find it too much of a problem if 10 laps from the
end, in a 1-2 position, with a healthy lead the team boss tells the drivers
to stop racing, and make sure they get home in one piece.
I bet the argue, "But if _that's_ acceptable, what's the difference between
that and asking the drivers to swap position?"
And to be honest, there isn't much is there? Stopping racing near the end of
a race is something that _drivers_ often choose to do.
I.e. If you're 3rd, 10 seconds behind 2nd, and 30 seconds ahead of 4th, with
10 laps to go, you may decide to opt for 3rd, rather than pushing hard to
try to catch 2nd place man, and risk going off, or something breaking.
I think Ferrari will have a good case.
Still don't agree with it, though ;-)
R.
Quoted text (15 lines)
> "jason moyer" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:[email hidden]... > ... > > I should have said "I don't see a problem with the team manager > > saying 'slow down and let him pass' or 'don't fight for position'. > ... > > IMO, you can accept or disagree with the use of team tactics, but it is > questionable to agree with team tactics when their outcome is to your > liking, and to disagree with them when it's not. > > I.e., I agree to your above statement, and that's how I'd understood your > first statement as well. > > Achim"jason moyer" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
...
> I should have said "I don't see a problem with the team manager
> saying 'slow down and let him pass' or 'don't fight for position'....
IMO, you can accept or disagree with the use of team tactics, but it is
questionable to agree with team tactics when their outcome is to your
liking, and to disagree with them when it's not.
I.e., I agree to your above statement, and that's how I'd understood your
first statement as well.
Achim
But you both _do_ agree that Montoya isn't fully using his potential yet?
;-)
Achim
"Mikkel Gram-Hansen" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:3d190e01$0$71639$[email hidden]...
> I guess we agree that Montoya can be fun to watch, and that he has a lotof
;)
>
>
Quoted text (12 lines)
> talent ;) > We don't agree on just how good he has the potential at becoming.... only > time will tell who is right there. > > In the beginning I found him a fresh breath of air in a booooooring F1 > field. Now the novelty has worn off and he still drives like he did in the > beginning, much too hotheaded. > > Mikkel > > PS: Anyways, it's nice to be able to disagree without getting into a > flamewar... an exchange like this could never happen in the F1 newsgroup"Joachim Trensz" wrote...
> The FIA has decided - Ferrari has to pay a 1 million
> Euro fine, but not for what happened during the race.
> They get fined for disrespectful behaviour of both
> drivers towards the politicians that were giving them
> the trophies on the podium.
The mind boggles.
Jan.
=---
That is ridiculous.
Essentially, FIA knew they couldn't defend a fine for something that
didn't violate the rules of the sport, so they fined them because
Schui expressed his disgust over taking a win from Rubens.
Gah. And I thought the criticism Schui was taking for not hammering
on his brakes when Rubens slowed down was ridiculous.
Jason
On Wed, 26 Jun 2002 19:26:41 -0000, "Joachim Trensz"
<[email hidden]> wrote:
Quoted text (61 lines)
>The FIA has decided - Ferrari has to pay a 1 million Euro fine, but not for >what happened during the race. They get fined for disrespectful behaviour of >both drivers towards the politicians that were giving them the trophies on >the podium. > >Achim > > >"Richard S Beckett" <richardDOTbeckettATmotorolaDOTcom@spamkiller> wrote in >message news:afcnqp$[email hidden]... >> >> "Joachim Trensz" <[email hidden]> wrote in message >> news:afcllu$d92np$[email hidden]... >> > "jason moyer" <[email hidden]> wrote in message >> > news:[email hidden]... >> > ... >> > > I should have said "I don't see a problem with the team manager >> > > saying 'slow down and let him pass' or 'don't fight for position'. >> > ... >> > >> > IMO, you can accept or disagree with the use of team tactics, but it is >> > questionable to agree with team tactics when their outcome is to your >> > liking, and to disagree with them when it's not. >> > >> > I.e., I agree to your above statement, and that's how I'd understood >your >> > first statement as well. >> > >> > Achim >> >> I would have thought that letting Rubens win is a very tactical move for >> Ferrari for their case. >> >> I.e. most people will not find it too much of a problem if 10 laps from >the >> end, in a 1-2 position, with a healthy lead the team boss tells the >drivers >> to stop racing, and make sure they get home in one piece. >> >> I bet the argue, "But if _that's_ acceptable, what's the difference >between >> that and asking the drivers to swap position?" >> >> And to be honest, there isn't much is there? Stopping racing near the end >of >> a race is something that _drivers_ often choose to do. >> >> I.e. If you're 3rd, 10 seconds behind 2nd, and 30 seconds ahead of 4th, >with >> 10 laps to go, you may decide to opt for 3rd, rather than pushing hard to >> try to catch 2nd place man, and risk going off, or something breaking. >> >> I think Ferrari will have a good case. >> >> Still don't agree with it, though ;-) >> >> R. >> >> > >The FIA has decided - Ferrari has to pay a 1 million Euro fine, but not for
what happened during the race. They get fined for disrespectful behaviour of
both drivers towards the politicians that were giving them the trophies on
the podium.
Achim
"Richard S Beckett" <richardDOTbeckettATmotorolaDOTcom@spamkiller> wrote in
message news:afcnqp$[email hidden]...
your
the
> end, in a 1-2 position, with a healthy lead the team boss tells thedrivers
> to stop racing, and make sure they get home in one piece.
>
> I bet the argue, "But if _that's_ acceptable, what's the differencebetween
> that and asking the drivers to swap position?"
>
> And to be honest, there isn't much is there? Stopping racing near the endof
> a race is something that _drivers_ often choose to do.
>
> I.e. If you're 3rd, 10 seconds behind 2nd, and 30 seconds ahead of 4th,with
Quoted text (15 lines)
> > "Joachim Trensz" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:afcllu$d92np$[email hidden]... > > "jason moyer" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > > news:[email hidden]... > > ... > > > I should have said "I don't see a problem with the team manager > > > saying 'slow down and let him pass' or 'don't fight for position'. > > ... > > > > IMO, you can accept or disagree with the use of team tactics, but it is > > questionable to agree with team tactics when their outcome is to your > > liking, and to disagree with them when it's not. > > > > I.e., I agree to your above statement, and that's how I'd understoodQuoted text (8 lines)
> > first statement as well. > > > > Achim > > I would have thought that letting Rubens win is a very tactical move for > Ferrari for their case. > > I.e. most people will not find it too much of a problem if 10 laps fromQuoted text (10 lines)
> 10 laps to go, you may decide to opt for 3rd, rather than pushing hard to > try to catch 2nd place man, and risk going off, or something breaking. > > I think Ferrari will have a good case. > > Still don't agree with it, though ;-) > > R. > >Yes, indeed :-)
Achim
"jason moyer" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
Quoted text (10 lines)
> That is ridiculous. > > Essentially, FIA knew they couldn't defend a fine for something that > didn't violate the rules of the sport, so they fined them because > Schui expressed his disgust over taking a win from Rubens. > > Gah. And I thought the criticism Schui was taking for not hammering > on his brakes when Rubens slowed down was ridiculous. > > JasonIn article <afct8d$dgkk7$[email hidden]>, "Joachim Trensz"
<[email hidden]> writes:
>The FIA has decided - Ferrari has to pay a 1 million Euro fine, but not for
>what happened during the race. They get fined for disrespectful behaviour of
>both drivers towards the politicians that were giving them the trophies on
>the podium.
How the HELL did they disrespect the politicians by swapping spots?!? What a
stupid <expletive> organization the FIA is... :(
Eldred
--
Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett
Never argue with an idiot. He brings you down to his level, then beats you
with experience...
Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.
In article <AJLR8.60363$[email hidden]>, "David G
Fisher" <[email hidden]> writes:
>What bothers me about JPM is more his fan's hyping of him since day 1, and
>the way they put down other drivers in doing so.
Nothing different than any other driver's fans...
Eldred
--
Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett
Never argue with an idiot. He brings you down to his level, then beats you
with experience...
Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.
In article <t8LR8.49979$[email hidden]>, "Jan Verschueren"
<[email hidden]> writes:
>Not wanting to appear like an MS basher, but, IMO, MS has always driven like
>this. Before him Senna drove like that. They just have low tolerance for
>people ahead of them. ;-)
Sounds like some people in online races...<g>
Eldred
--
Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett
Never argue with an idiot. He brings you down to his level, then beats you
with experience...
Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.
In article <af80og$c55cb$[email hidden]>, "Brian"
<[email hidden]> writes:
Let's just say I have my doubts... :-)
Eldred
--
Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett
Never argue with an idiot. He brings you down to his level, then beats you
with experience...
Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.
Quoted text (17 lines)
>Who said he didn't won on the track? When MS tried to catch on him, he made >a mistake and spun on the track, somethink he do not do a lot. After the >second pit, they had so many time ahead of 3rd place, that the orders were >to calm down and finish. Who knows what would have happen if they had to >battle on the track. > >Brian >"EldredP" <[email hidden]> wrote in message >news:[email hidden]... >> In article <af7632$c1duo$[email hidden]>, "Joachim Trensz" >> <[email hidden]> writes: >> >> >RB's joy looked very real on the rostrum - he didn't seem to care whether >it >> >was a handed win or a real one. >> >> Like a kid at xmas...<g>"Joachim Trensz" wrote:
...
> The FIA has decided - Ferrari has to pay a 1 million Euro fine, but notfor
> what happened during the race. They get fined for disrespectful behaviourof
> both drivers towards the politicians that were giving them the trophies on
> the podium.
Thats not quite correct Achim,
The FIA fined them US $1 million for breaching the podium protocol (meaning
the drivers didnt take their correct spots on the forum etc.) Furthermore
to make the fine even more like a poor joke - Ferrari only have to pay half
of it now and the rest is suspended over 12 months should the same thing
occur again. Meaning the fine is essantially on $500,000 and not a million
bucks.
To quote Autosport.com on the matter:
"The fine has been levied at Ferrari, Michael Schumacher and Rubens
Barrichello for breaking the correct procedure on the podium, not for the
action on the circuit when the Brazilian slowed metres from the finish line
to allow the German to win, as ordered by the team.
In essence, the FIA has given Ferrari little more than a slap on the wrist.
Only half of the $1 million must be paid immediately, with the other half
suspended for a year. The team will only have to pay the full amount should
a similar podium offence occur within the next 12 months.
The FIA issued a release following this morning's special meeting of the
World Motor Sport Council, saying that it "deplored the manner in which team
orders were given and executed at the Austrian GP. Nevertheless the council
finds it impossible to sanction the two drivers, because they were
contractually bound to execute orders given by the team."
The council also acknowledged "the long-standing and traditional right of a
team to decree the finishing order of its drivers in what it believes to be
the best interest of its attempt to win both world championships".
With that in mind, the council decided to take no action against Ferrari,
although admitting at the same time that it did so "with some reluctance".
Schumacher and Barrichello broke Article 170 of the Formula 1 Sporting
Regulations when the four-times world champion allowed his team-mate on to
the top step of the podium, despite having actually won the race himself.
The FIA statement said: "It is the duty of each team to ensure that its
contracted drivers observe the podium procedures and do not in any way
embarras the national authorities of the country where a GP takes place."
Speculation since the A1-Ring race had been that Ferrari would lose the
constructors' championship points it gained for the one-two result. A race
ban for the team was always considered only an outside possibility. "
--
ed_
Now JPM has criticized RS for passing him on the first lap! What a joke.
http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport/hi/english/motorsport/formula_one/newsid_2069000
/2069847.stm
I guess his fans who admire his supposed bold driving style will have a new
impression of him. Apparently it's ok for him to be aggressive, but fail,
but it's not ok for his own teammate to be aggressive and succeed.
David G Fisher
"David G Fisher" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:G9vR8.412539$[email hidden]...
> How come no one is bitching about MS letting RB have the win with 10 lapsto
the
> one who benefits. Just like I thought. Pure jealousy was the motivationfor
> the hysterics after Austria.
>
> MS and RS tought JPM a few lessons today. Beautiful passes. JPM thencaused
> yet another accident when he hit DC. He has great car control?? Funny how
> people will bitch at and try to blame MS for an incident like T1 atMalaysia
> or Brazil which involve JPM, even though they were both clearly JPM'sfault.
> When JPM does the same type of thing to DC today though, no one says aword
Quoted text (7 lines)
> go? > > Ferrari did the same thing as in Austria (as has been done thousands of > times in all series) except a little less obviously. More like how Waltrip > let Earnhardt have Talladega. > > I guess it's ok in racing to do this as long as Michael Schumacher isn'tQuoted text (7 lines)
> because it's not MS who was the other driver, and therefor no bogus > opportunity to attack MS. > > David G Fisher > > >"David G Fisher" <[email hidden]> wrote:
Okay, so let me get this straight. Being "aggressive and succeeding"
is measured by completing the pass irregardless of any damage you may
cause to the car which you're passing, even if it's your own teammate?
(Or are you now calling JPM a liar for claiming that his steering was
damaged by Ralf's aggression?). By this new criteria, JPM's move
around the outside of Michael at Sepang was a success since he managed
to get past, albeit at the expense of Michael's front wing.
Quoted text (10 lines)
>Now JPM has criticized RS for passing him on the first lap! What a joke. > >http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport/hi/english/motorsport/formula_one/newsid_2069000 >/2069847.stm > >I guess his fans who admire his supposed bold driving style will have a new >impression of him. Apparently it's ok for him to be aggressive, but fail, >but it's not ok for his own teammate to be aggressive and succeed. > >David G Fisher
"Ian" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
> "David G Fisher" <[email hidden]> wrote:
>
> >Now JPM has criticized RS for passing him on the first lap! What a joke.
> >
>
>http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport/hi/english/motorsport/formula_one/newsid_2069000
> >/2069847.stm
> >
> >I guess his fans who admire his supposed bold driving style will have anew
RS didn't cause the damage to JPM. Just like with DC, JPM was the one who
screwed up and hit the outside car because he lost control. His left front
hit RS's right rear. Not one person has said that RS did anything wrong
since the race Sunday.
If JPM thinks RS did, he's an idiot. Actaully, JPM ran him off the track on
exit. Luckily there wasn't gravel.
David G Fisher
Quoted text (12 lines)
> >impression of him. Apparently it's ok for him to be aggressive, but fail, > >but it's not ok for his own teammate to be aggressive and succeed. > > > >David G Fisher > > Okay, so let me get this straight. Being "aggressive and succeeding" > is measured by completing the pass irregardless of any damage you may > cause to the car which you're passing, even if it's your own teammate? > (Or are you now calling JPM a liar for claiming that his steering was > damaged by Ralf's aggression?). By this new criteria, JPM's move > around the outside of Michael at Sepang was a success since he managed > to get past, albeit at the expense of Michael's front wing."David G Fisher" said:
> Now JPM has criticized RS for passing him on the first lap! What a joke.
Welcome to the world of F1 Dave!
:-)
.--
ed_
"David G Fisher" said:
Welcome to the world of F1 Dave!
:-)
.--
ed_
"Ed Solheim" <edwins[ REMOVE ]@[ THIS ].no> wrote in message
news:IkMS8.237$[email hidden]...
Well at least they don't complain as much as those NASCAR guys......they
even attack each other after the race. They kind of remind me of how you cry
and whine every time I pass you in RASCAR. 8-p
David G Fisher (thinks we need more trash talk in RASCAR)
Quoted text (10 lines)
> "David G Fisher" said: > > > Now JPM has criticized RS for passing him on the first lap! What a joke. > > Welcome to the world of F1 Dave! > > :-) > > .-- > ed_"David G Fisher" said:
>
> Well at least they don't complain as much as those NASCAR guys......they
> even attack each other after the race. They kind of remind me of how youcry
> and whine every time I pass you in RASCAR. 8-p
Does Spa 1998 ring a bell Dave?
;-)
--
ed_
"David G Fisher" said:
Does Spa 1998 ring a bell Dave?
;-)
--
ed_
David G Fisher wrote:
More like what DGF will condemn JPM to hell for doing, he'll condone RS
for the same without a second thought.
--
Fester
Quoted text (8 lines)
> Now JPM has criticized RS for passing him on the first lap! What a joke. > > http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport/hi/english/motorsport/formula_one/newsid_2069000 > /2069847.stm > > I guess his fans who admire his supposed bold driving style will have a new > impression of him. Apparently it's ok for him to be aggressive, but fail, > but it's not ok for his own teammate to be aggressive and succeed.On Thu, 27 Jun 2002 20:32:55 +0200, "Ed Solheim"
<[email hidden]> wrote:
>Speculation since the A1-Ring race had been that Ferrari would lose the
>constructors' championship points it gained for the one-two result. A race
>ban for the team was always considered only an outside possibility. "
Uh, I don't know why anyone thinks there was any possibility of FIA
fining them for what happened on the track. FIA will bend over
backwards to keep Ferrari happy. There is no question of that. When
Ferrari himself said that if he wasn't given certain concessions he
would move the team to the CART series, FIA (or was it FISA then?)
completely freaked out and did everything they could to keep him to
stay (the result of this actually being the rule which allows 10 and
12 cylinder engines).
FIA isn't NASCAR, where the sanctioning body means more than the
teams. NASCAR could lose Rousch, Hendrick, Yates, Childress, and
Gibbs and still be the biggest draw in the United States. Take
Ferrari or Mclaren or Williams out of F1, and you lose a huge chunk of
your fanbase. If Ferrari, for instance, left F1 and went to CART I
have a feeling they'd be taking Monza and the entire motorsport
community of Italy with them. FIA can't afford that.
Jason
"Rob" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:qKLR8.2853$[email hidden]...
> I've been simply amazed with Michael since a few years ago when he was
> driving for Benetton and lost several gears in a race and STILL managed to
> finish in 2nd (I believe it was at Silverstone, but I don't remember for
> sure) even though he had to pit and had no first gear!
Spanish GP 1994. Came in a fine 2nd to Hill
MS
Bill Ryder <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]...
He reminds me of Villeneuve, when he first came this side of the pond.
> I like this. Without Montoya the only unpredictable thing is which Ferrari
> will be allowed to win the race.
>
> What we really need now though is some WET RACES!! Where is the bloody
> RAIN!
Well, it's the British Grand Prix this weekend... :-)
Jonny


































