Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

All a bit tragic?

111 posts by 41 people · 25 Jun 2002 12:36 UTC - 03 Jul 2002 17:27 UTC

No modern F1 sim gets everything right

Douglas Ellison lamented that none of the three leading F1 titles got everything right, leaving realism to GPL's 1967 cars or NASCAR. Posters argued over F1 versus NASCAR audiences, track accuracy in F1 2002, GPL's tyre model and team orders. The thread later turned into a heated argument about whether US 'World Series' titles deserve the name.

game comparisonphysics/realism debatereal motorsportF1 2002Grand Prix 4Grand Prix Legends

Automated summary.

Douglas Ellison 25 Jun 2002 12:36 UTC#112520
I remember a few months ago - someone said "we've never had it so good" Well - hows this out of 3 leading F1 titles - not one has got it right - they all lack in one department or the other. If you want realism - you have to like 1967, or 2 tonnes of pig iron. It's a f**king joke isnt it? Doug
There is no one to "blame". The simple fact is a company makes what sells. NASCAR sells and is their key market. WE as simmers are in the minority. IMO if it wasn't for the NASCAR titles Papy wouldn't even be in business anymore. So be glad that you actually have those 2 ton pigs. If it wasn't for those two ton pigs we'd be all be taking about what moves we could pull off and how many bonus points we get for them on some X box game. MadDAWG
> You don't think a Papy F1 sim would sell? And I'm not talking about > 1967. If they did a really good current F1 season I think it would > sell very well. Nascar has poor sales in Europe so F1 would probably > do even better on the market than Nascar. A LOT more people watch F1 than Nascar - so one can presume that despite 1 average and 2 crap offerings of F1 titles already - a properly done one would sell well Doug
> You don't think a Papy F1 sim would sell? And I'm not talking about > 1967. If they did a really good current F1 season I think it would > sell very well. Nascar has poor sales in Europe so F1 would probably > do even better on the market than Nascar. Compared to a NASCAR title no I don't. The amount of Americans into F1 is very small. I think a CART sim would do better, and we all know the chances of that happening. I know I wouldn't buy it because F1 doesn't do any thing for me. At least a CART title I would buy to support them even if I didn't play it much. I don't like the lack of god titles any better than anyone else, but software is a business just like any other and they are here to make money. If they weren't we wouldn't have to deal with this shitty Secure Rom crap. MadDAWG
On Tue, 25 Jun 2002 13:36:44 +0100, "Douglas Ellison" <[email hidden]> wrote: >If you want realism - you have to like 1967, or 2 tonnes of pig iron. > >It's a f**king joke isnt it? Nope. I'd rather race 1967 or 1957 or 1977 or 1987 era Grand Prix cars on the tracks in those eras than what we have today. Now, I'd be excited about a modern or historical CART sim, but that's also because the cars/tracks have a lot more variety and there are still a few personalities in that sport. Grand Prix since shortly after Senna's death has been a bunch of bland personalities driving boring cars on boring circuits. It really is nothing more than high-tech go-kart racing. Seriously, the tracks in F1 2002 completely suck and it's not entirely the fault of ISI's poor design. I can't wait until some of the original tracks from GPL are ported over. Until then I'm basically running Monaco over and over. In Nascar 2002 at least there are 3-4 tracks I can enjoy (the roadies, Pocono, and Darlington). It is sad that NASCAR races on more real road courses than F1 does nowadays. Jason
jason moyer wrote:
Quoted text (25 lines)> On Tue, 25 Jun 2002 13:36:44 +0100, "Douglas Ellison" > <[email hidden]> wrote: > > >If you want realism - you have to like 1967, or 2 tonnes of pig iron. > > > >It's a f**king joke isnt it? > > Nope. I'd rather race 1967 or 1957 or 1977 or 1987 era Grand Prix > cars on the tracks in those eras than what we have today. Now, I'd be > excited about a modern or historical CART sim, but that's also because > the cars/tracks have a lot more variety and there are still a few > personalities in that sport. Grand Prix since shortly after Senna's > death has been a bunch of bland personalities driving boring cars on > boring circuits. It really is nothing more than high-tech go-kart > racing. > > Seriously, the tracks in F1 2002 completely suck and it's not entirely > the fault of ISI's poor design. I can't wait until some of the > original tracks from GPL are ported over. Until then I'm basically > running Monaco over and over. In Nascar 2002 at least there are 3-4 > tracks I can enjoy (the roadies, Pocono, and Darlington). > > It is sad that NASCAR races on more real road courses than F1 does > nowadays. >
How do the tracks suck exactly? I'm not disagreeing with you (down with chicanes!), but I'd like to hear specifics. John DiFool
I would like to see numbers backing THAT up... -Larry "Douglas Ellison" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:afa902$cu1n8$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (14 lines)> > > You don't think a Papy F1 sim would sell? And I'm not talking about > > 1967. If they did a really good current F1 season I think it would > > sell very well. Nascar has poor sales in Europe so F1 would probably > > do even better on the market than Nascar. > > A LOT more people watch F1 than Nascar - so one can presume that despite 1 > average and 2 crap offerings of F1 titles already - a properly done one > would sell well > > Doug > > >
"Douglas Ellison" wrote... > I remember a few months ago - someone said "we've never > had it so good" It's been more than a few months Doug... that was before Rally Trophy. > Well - hows this > > out of 3 leading F1 titles - not one has got it right - > they all lack in one department or the other. I will admit modern F1 afficionados have had a tough time of it. However the EA F1 series shows signs of incremental improvement, so there's light at the end of the tunnel. > If you want realism - you have to like 1967, or 2 tonnes > of pig iron. > > It's a f**king joke isnt it? If you don't want to run the best sims on a matter of principle, then you only have yourself to blame. I didn't know the first thing about the classic F1 era before GPL. It was before my time, I had never seen an F1 car that didn't have wings on it and I had no real desire to find about them. What drew me to GPL was the advanced simulation technology. Since then I own books about the era, about vehicle dynamics, about driving technique, subscribe to Motorsport, hold the drivers of the time in very high regard indeed and regularly get myself sunburnt watching some no-name enthousiasts driving these vintage cars at classic races. I was blessed with an interest in NASCAR to start with, so I'm very happy Papyrus has continued that line of development to a point where their most advanced technology is applied to the series. Jan. =---
Larry 25 Jun 2002 18:23 UTC↳ reply to MadDAWG#112428
We Americans have this funny thing about wanting to let the drivers win based on skill, the car, and of course luck. Team 'orders' can go to hell. Even the announcing crew at this weekends F1 race on Speed were betting back and forth, down to the very last lap, whether Schumaker's team mate would pull over and let him by, even afer leading every single lap of the race. If he had, it would have been the last F1 race I would have ever watched. I kind of like watching F1, and just started to recently. However, the politics are mind boggling! -Larry "MadDAWG" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]...
Quoted text (7 lines)> > You don't think a Papy F1 sim would sell? And I'm not talking about > > 1967. If they did a really good current F1 season I think it would > > sell very well. Nascar has poor sales in Europe so F1 would probably > > do even better on the market than Nascar. > > Compared to a NASCAR title no I don't. The amount of Americans into F1 is > very small. I think a CART sim would do better, and we all know the
chances > of that happening. I know I wouldn't buy it because F1 doesn't do anything > for me. At least a CART title I would buy to support them even if I didn't > play it much. I don't like the lack of god titles any better than anyone > else, but software is a business just like any other and they are here to > make money. If they weren't we wouldn't have to deal with this shittySecure > Rom crap. > > MadDAWG > >
John DiFool wrote: > How do the tracks suck exactly? I'm not disagreeing with you (down > with chicanes!), but I'd like to hear specifics. Compare old Spa to new Spa, and all should become clear. Gerry
"Douglas Ellison" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:af9o4r$cfukc$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (11 lines)> I remember a few months ago - someone said "we've never had it so good" > > Well - hows this > > out of 3 leading F1 titles - not one has got it right - they all lack in one > department or the other. > > If you want realism - you have to like 1967, or 2 tonnes of pig iron. > > It's a f**king joke isnt it? >
I'd love to see Papyrus make a modern F1 sim because, no matter how good GPL and the Nascar series' are, the dynamics of an F1 car are so different to the "2 tonnes of pig iron" that they have managed to accurately represent so far, it would be very surprising if they did something as good as F1 2002 straight away.
redTed 25 Jun 2002 19:10 UTC↳ reply to redTed#112437
Quoted text (9 lines)> > > > If you want realism - you have to like 1967, or 2 tonnes of pig iron. > > > > It's a f**king joke isnt it? > > > I'd love to see Papyrus make a modern F1 sim because, no matter how good GPL and the > Nascar series' are, the dynamics of an F1 car are so different to the "2 tonnes of pig > iron" that they have managed to accurately represent so far, it would be very surprising > if they did something as good as F1 2002 straight away.
(edit) And as for the poor track modelling in F1 2002, how accurate are the Nascar 2002 tracks ? Or those portrayed in GPL ? Nascar tracks may bear a semblance to their real life counterparts, but that wouldn't be hard with ovals. As for GPL tracks, well who's to say they are remotely similar ? I think you're being unfair on F1 2002.
"MadDAWG" <[email hidden]> wrote on 25 Jun 2002: <snip> > The amount of Americans into F1 is very small.<snip> There are other markets, you know. OKay, so the US is much bigger, but Europe as a whole must be close, and the Japanese follow F1 too. >If they weren't we wouldn't have to deal with this > shitty Secure Rom crap. Never heard of it - is it some kind of copy-protection thing? -- Cricket: England 2 Sri Lanka 0 Athletics: Gt Britain & NI European Cup winners Keep those flags up! The GPL Scrapyard: http://www.btinternet.com/~gplscrapyard
On Tue, 25 Jun 2002 17:49:11 GMT, John DiFool <[email hidden]> wrote: > How do the tracks suck exactly? I'm not disagreeing with you (down >with chicanes!), but I'd like to hear specifics. Well, some are obvious just via comparison. Spa vs. Old Spa. Nurburgring vs. the Nordschleife. Monza vs pre-chicane Monza. A1-Ring vs the Osterreich Ring. Silverstone vs Old Silverstone. Those IMHO are pretty obvious without getting into details. They took a bunch of tracks and removed all of the challenging corners for safety reasons (oh my God, someone may be risking their life by driving a car at 200mph!) by either shortening the courses, adding chicanes, or destroying the tracks and creating a new one that fits modern spec. Monaco is the only original track that still has most of its original layout, and to be fair Suzuka is still a really nice course (not sure why I ommitted it in my post). Malaysia isn't a bad track, altho by 1960-1990 standards it's pretty tame. Most of the newer and redesigned F1 courses consist of slow corners connected by short or medium length straights, hence the constant referral to them as "point and squirt". You hammer the throttle, reach top speed, brake, take a slow turn, hammer the throttle, etc and repeat this until you fall asleep. Most ovals and go-kart tracks are more interesting/challenging. By comparison, the classic tracks, like Spa, the Ring, Osterreichring, Brands Hatch, the old Silverstone, etc had lots of high speed and compound turns. There is no modern equivalents to the Curva Grande or Vialone at Monza, turns that you reached nearly flat out and took very very fast if not flat out. Most tracks don't even have a decent set of esses nowadays, like the old Glen or even NASCAR's Watkins Glen or Sears Point. I think that Mosley overreacted to the deaths at Imola in 94 to the point of turning F1's circuits into utter crap. The 80's, after Villeneuve's freak accident, were an incredibly safe period in GP history, and there were still a lot of good tracks to race on. Sure, it's understandable that the old haybale chicane at Monaco, or the Masta kink at Spa were too dangerous. Maybe a chicane or two at Hockenheim and Monza aren't a bad idea, just to keep the cars from running full-out for an entire lap. The 80's had a bunch of circuits that are no longer deemed suitable for F1 racing (for one reason or another), in addition to a much better incarnation of Hockenheim. Brands Hatch and Donington were great short circuits. Mexico was always a real challenging track. Bernie's mishandling of the Long Beach GP is possibly the #1 reason F1 no longer has a real following in the US. I'd love to see F1 cars go back to places like Paul Ricard, Watkins Glen, Long Beach, Argentina, Mexico, the old Hockenheim layout, a longer version of Spa, etc. I'd love to see modifications made to the Nordschleife so that a 4 or 5 mile section could be cordoned off, fitted with Armco and runoff areas, and linked via a connecting route (so that it formed a circuit) iin order to allow at least part of the old circuit to be used, instead of that parking-lot style track they ran this past weekend. I'd like to see a return to Adelaide. A rotating British GP between Brands and Donnington. They could keep Monaco, Suzuka, and Malaysia on the calendar. Bring back Mosport. That would be a good variety of tracks that would have perfectly acceptable safety standards if properly modified. I'm not saying we should make modern drivers deal with Masta or Flugplatz, but it's ridiculous the way FIA attempts to remove all reasonable risk from the sport and takes the defining characteristics of most of the tracks along with it. I still can't believe they tried a chicane at Eau Rouge... Jason
On Tue, 25 Jun 2002 18:23:17 GMT, "Larry" <[email hidden]> wrote: >We Americans have this funny thing about wanting to let the drivers win >based on skill, the car, and of course luck. Team 'orders' can go to hell. Aren't you a DEI fan? Jason
Rob 25 Jun 2002 20:23 UTC↳ reply to Larry#112357
Umm, you must be thinking with a US mindset. FAR more people watch F1 across the world than NASCAR. NASCAR can only dream about F1 numbers--remember, this is the WORLD we are talking about and not just the NASCAR-crazed US. I'm sure that Google could probably point you to some actual numbers. -- --------------------- Rob Berryhill "Larry" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:Ev2S8.80553$[email hidden]... > I would like to see numbers backing THAT up... > > -Larry > > "Douglas Ellison" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:afa902$cu1n8$[email hidden]... > > > > > You don't think a Papy F1 sim would sell? And I'm not talking about > > > 1967. If they did a really good current F1 season I think it would > > > sell very well. Nascar has poor sales in Europe so F1 would probably > > > do even better on the market than Nascar. > > > > A LOT more people watch F1 than Nascar - so one can presume that despite 1 > > average and 2 crap offerings of F1 titles already - a properly done one > > would sell well > > > > Doug > > > > > > > > >
"Larry" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:Ev2S8.80553$[email hidden]... > I would like to see numbers backing THAT up... > > -Larry > I'd wager that you could quite easily quadruple the number of people who watch nascar and you still wouldnt reach the viewing figures of F1. Just because Amerian Baseball is called the 'world series' doesnt mean that the world doesnt exist west of LA or East of NY Doug
> And as for the poor track modelling in F1 2002, how accurate are theNascar 2002 tracks ? Aparantly exceedingly so. I appologise for not knowing the exact details but a drive was quoted as laughing outloud for the first ever lap he did at a Nascar oval - when questioned why by his spotter - he said it was because the track was identical to how he'd seen it in N2k2 or N4. > Or those portrayed in GPL ?They're not bad. Some are way off. But it's a bit difficult to model a track that a) Hasnt existed for 20+ years, or b) Has been butchered and rebuilt a dozen times. the 'ring is outstandingly accurate - and that would make sense being as it is the only GPL track that exists in pretty much the same layout as it did 40 years ago. > Nascar tracks may bear a semblance to their real life counterparts, butthat wouldn't be > hard with ovals. As for GPL tracks, well who's to say they are remotelysimilar ? I think > you're being unfair on F1 2002. If F1RC can get them perfect ( they are a little smooth - but layout wise - accurate to a T) then why cant F12k2? Some parts of Silverstone in F12k2 make me laugh out loud each time I see them they're so innacurate. However - I dont know exactly why you presumed it was for the inaccuracy of tracks that I was slating F12k2 - because I never mentioned it. Innacurate though they are - they can be considered perfection itself when compared to the Internet code. Papy brought out mature net code 4 years ago - and just about perfected it with N2k2 - yet we have to deal with half-an-effort-that-doesnt-really-work with F12k2. And the next person who says "you need broadband to race online nowadays" - NO YOU BLOODY DONT - I can race N2k2 down a 56k perfectly well thank you. It's lazy and bad programming that means one can not do the same in F12k2 - NOTHING else. Doug
> If you don't want to run the best sims on a matter of principle, then you > only have yourself to blame. I spent 3 years playing GPL on and off. But I dont want to play it anymore. I know a LOT of GPL regulars who have outgrown GPL. The lack of a proper tyre model is one reason ( it feels dead compared to N2k2 imho) and more advance graphics and net code being another. If thats a crime - I hate to see what you'd say to a murderer > I was blessed with an interest in NASCAR to start with, so I'm very happy > Papyrus has continued that line of development to a point where their most > advanced technology is applied to the series. I now drive N2k2. Not because I like nascar's - infact I LOATH them, I HATE them, i deteste EVERYTHING ABOUT THEM. They're fat, ugly, unrefined, the handle like shit on road courses. All the tracks are crap, left ,left, left. And when you do get a road course -it's a waste of time when you're driving a tank. Despite all of that - I drive N2k2 because it's the best racing simulator out there. I think that's a pretty shit situation to be in - dont you? Doug
Quoted text (11 lines)>And as for the poor track modelling in F1 2002, how accurate are the Nascar >2002 tracks ? >Or those portrayed in GPL ? >Nascar tracks may bear a semblance to their real life counterparts, but that >wouldn't be >hard with ovals. As for GPL tracks, well who's to say they are remotely >similar ? I think >you're being unfair on F1 2002. > > >
Have you actually driven F1 2002? I am not an F1 fanatic and therefore don't know all the little ins and outs of the tracks, but I do know a few things. The elevation change after the banking bridge at Monza heading into Ascari is not a sharp change and not incredibly uneven and bumpy. Also, since when does the bend just before Spoon at Suzuka cause the car to nearly crash from bottoming out that hard over bumps? And I never realized that there were bumps so large in the braking zone for Les Combes at Spa that you could see them like speed bumps from TV cameras... F1 2002 has a great physics model, but the tracks just look sloppy. ----------------------------------------- Dan Belcher Webmaster, http://www.gplworld.racesim.net/simcrash
"Douglas Ellison" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:afaka2$cv1tr$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (12 lines)> > "Larry" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:Ev2S8.80553$[email hidden]... > > I would like to see numbers backing THAT up... > > > > -Larry > > > > I'd wager that you could quite easily quadruple the number of people who > watch nascar and you still wouldnt reach the viewing figures of F1. > > Just because Amerian Baseball is called the 'world series' doesnt mean
that > the world doesnt exist west of LA or East of NY > > Doug The only figures I seem to be able to find are thus.... http://jayski.thatsracin.com/pages/tvratings.htm Nascar seems to get between 4.5 and 6.5 million viewers. It's impossible to guage how many people watch overseas - but I REALLY dont expect it to be very many at all. Perhaps as many again - so call it 12 million per race world wide. ( The 'Tona 500 was a one off at 10.9 million viewers) For formula one - you can usually only find the total number of people who watch an F1 race thru the year - which was 54 billion for 2001. ( http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport/hi/english/motorsport/formula_one/newsid_1842000 /1842217.stm ) If we take that on a per-race basis of watching the race, qualifing and highlights, and 5 news bulletins including race news - thats 144 viewings per person in a year. 54 billion / 144 = 375 Million viewers. 375 Million viewers for F1. 12 Million for Nascar. Even if both are out by 50% - in Nascars favour - lets call it 187 for F1 and 24 Nascar. F1 has a viewership of 779% that of Nascar. And thats making the figures about as nascar biased as I can possibly make them. Taking my first figures - it's more like and F1 viewership 3125% that of Nascar. So there you go - some figure to back THAT up Doug
Quoted text (12 lines)> However - I dont know exactly why you presumed it was for the inaccuracy of > tracks that I was slating F12k2 - because I never mentioned it. Innacurate > though they are - they can be considered perfection itself when compared to > the Internet code. Papy brought out mature net code 4 years ago - and just > about perfected it with N2k2 - yet we have to deal with > half-an-effort-that-doesnt-really-work with F12k2. > > And the next person who says "you need broadband to race online nowadays" - > NO YOU BLOODY DONT - I can race N2k2 down a 56k perfectly well thank you. > It's lazy and bad programming that means one can not do the same in F12k2 - > NOTHING else. >
As you didn't state why you found F1 2002 so poor, I assumed that it was the track modelling. That seems to be the worst aspect amongst this community, although it doesn't exactly ruin a fantastic game, IMO. Net code doesn't match Papyrus games, but, again, it doesn't matter so much to a lot of people.
Quoted text (12 lines)> > > > Have you actually driven F1 2002? I am not an F1 fanatic and therefore don't > know all the little ins and outs of the tracks, but I do know a few things. > The elevation change after the banking bridge at Monza heading into Ascari is > not a sharp change and not incredibly uneven and bumpy. Also, since when does > the bend just before Spoon at Suzuka cause the car to nearly crash from > bottoming out that hard over bumps? And I never realized that there were bumps > so large in the braking zone for Les Combes at Spa that you could see them like > speed bumps from TV cameras... F1 2002 has a great physics model, but the > tracks just look sloppy. >
Of course I've played it and there are thousands of others who have as well , but there is only a small minority whining that the elevation changes are not spot on at Monza ! You really must have an intimate knowledge of all these tracks, and for that I admire you. But, why don't you respond the part of my post that suggest the GPL tracks are completely unrealistic due to the age and lack of information about most of them. Does that ruin any enjoyment you may have had while playing GPL ? I think not. And as I have no idea if these modern tracks are realistically detailed or not, except the Nurburgring first bend:-( , I won't let minor details stop me enjoying what is the best driving sim currently available.
> Net code doesn't match Papyrus games, but, again, it doesn't matter somuch to a lot of > people. WHAT THE FUCK Straw pole for RAS of features in the perfect sim 1) Physics 2) Net code. WITHOUT DOUBT Doug
Douglas Ellison 25 Jun 2002 21:30 UTC#529497
WHAT THE *** Straw pole for RAS of features in the perfect sim 1) Physics 2) Net code. WITHOUT DOUBT Doug
Scott 25 Jun 2002 21:36 UTC↳ reply to redTed#112375
> Nascar tracks may bear a semblance to their real life counterparts, butthat wouldn't be > hard with ovals. As for GPL tracks, well who's to say they are remotelysimilar ?I think > you're being unfair on F1 2002. F12002's tracks are generally poorly modelled. There is very little in the way of camber, there are bumps where there are none on thier real-life counterparts, and no bumps where there should be in certain places. Some tracks are much wider than the real thing, some too narrow, the grass is extremely grippy...and some of the corners are just plain wrong...and badly so at that...I could go on but it's bumming me out just thinking about it. What offsets this for me though is that the driving model is a lot of fun, though I don't believe entirely accurate either. It's the closest anyone has come to GPL so far (personal opinion, YMMV). The tracks in GP4 are really well done, they seem to have captured a lot of the subtle details (ie camber changes, slight elevation changes)...unfortunately the driving model is about as exciting to drive as watching a wet plank warp in the sun. I'd hate to think that GPL will be the high water mark of open wheel racing simulations, but lately that's what it looks like from my perspective. TJ
Quoted text (10 lines)> WHAT THE FUCK > > > Straw pole for RAS of features in the perfect sim > > 1) Physics > 2) Net code. > > WITHOUT DOUBT >
GET A LIFE, OUTSIDE OF RAS, PERHAPS ! SEE , I HAVE A CAPS LOCK TOO. VERY CLEVER. Do you seriously think that only people who subscribe to this NG are the one's who are playing racing sims ?????
> Do you seriously think that only people who subscribe to this NG are theone's who are > playing racing sims ????? Of course I dont. But I'd guarentee you the same results in serious sim racers world wide DOug
> F12002's tracks are generally poorly modelled. ... > ...<snip>... > the grass is > extremely grippy...and some of the corners are just plain wrong...and badly > ...<snip>... Maybe the grass seems grippy because of the traction control.
> A LOT more people watch F1 than Nascar - so one can presume that despite 1 > average and 2 crap offerings of F1 titles already - a properly done one > would sell well > > Doug Watching and attending are two different things. I wouldn't be surpised that NASCAR events get more bodies thru the turnstiles than F1. Remember, oval racing is more spectator friendly. At the typical F1 event, you're watching a fraction of the action. F1 is probably BETTER on TV than live. NASCAR just the opposite.
> Watching and attending are two different things. I wouldn't be surpisedthat > NASCAR events get more bodies thru the turnstiles than F1. Remember, oval > racing is more spectator friendly. At the typical F1 event, you'rewatching > a fraction of the action. F1 is probably BETTER on TV than live. NASCARjust > the opposite. Average 200,000 people over 3 days to a GP over 18 races = 3.6 million. About 1% of the total F1-on-TV watching public Doug
Bryon Lape 26 Jun 2002 00:15 UTC↳ reply to Rob#112201
More people watch the World Cup than the Super Bowl, yet it is the football "World Championship". More people watch the World Cup than the Stanley Cup, yet it is the hockey "World Championship". More people watch the World Cup than the World Series, yet it is the baseball "World Championship". More people watch the World Cup than the NBA playoffs, yet it is the basketball "World Championship". See a pattern here yet? Rob wrote:
Quoted text (35 lines)> Umm, you must be thinking with a US mindset. FAR more people watch F1 across > the world than NASCAR. NASCAR can only dream about F1 numbers--remember, > this is the WORLD we are talking about and not just the NASCAR-crazed US. > I'm sure that Google could probably point you to some actual numbers. > > -- > --------------------- > Rob Berryhill > > "Larry" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:Ev2S8.80553$[email hidden]... > > I would like to see numbers backing THAT up... > > > > -Larry > > > > "Douglas Ellison" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > > news:afa902$cu1n8$[email hidden]... > > > > > > > You don't think a Papy F1 sim would sell? And I'm not talking about > > > > 1967. If they did a really good current F1 season I think it would > > > > sell very well. Nascar has poor sales in Europe so F1 would probably > > > > do even better on the market than Nascar. > > > > > > A LOT more people watch F1 than Nascar - so one can presume that despite > 1 > > > average and 2 crap offerings of F1 titles already - a properly done one > > > would sell well > > > > > > Doug > > > > > > > > > > > > > > >
"Douglas Ellison" wrote... > I spent 3 years playing GPL on and off. But I > dont want to play it anymore. Blasphemy!! ;-)) > I know a LOT of GPL regulars who have outgrown > GPL. The lack of a proper tyre model is one > reason (it feels dead compared to N2k2 imho) > and more advance graphics and net code being > another. If thats a crime - I hate to see what > you'd say to a murderer I see your point, GPL is showing it's age. However, the tyre/grip model was under question as soon as people started being able to go absurdly quickly by using yaw/drift angles which were unquestionably too large/wrong. Which was quite soon after official release, IIRC. As an offline game I think it's basically dead. Online, however, there's a lot people clinging on because of the comraderie or because they dislike the alternative. Which leads us to...
Quoted text (8 lines)> > <snip> > I now drive N2k2. Not because I like nascar's - infact > I LOATH them, I HATE them, i deteste EVERYTHING ABOUT > THEM. They're fat, ugly, unrefined, they handle like > shit on road courses. All the tracks are crap, left, > left, left. > And when you do get a road course -it's a waste of > time when you're driving a tank.
I move to disagree. There's subtleties on every level. Adjusting the car to your particular style is one (have to really educate myself on this level), adjusting your driving technique to maximize the benifits of a certain setup and get the most out of your tyres. Each oval track is subtely different and while driving it on your own might not pose a challenge, having 20 people around who can get around it nearly as well or slightly quicker opens up a whole can of tactical possibilities. Chess/bluff poker on wheels. Call me weird, but I get a great sense of acchievement turning smooth, effortless laps on the road courses with these cars (haven't tried the converted tracks yet). Whoever made the default setups for these is obviously taking the piss, but think about the particulars for a bit and it's easy to see where things went wrong. Once you reach the point where the weight shift in the cars matches the rythm of the track these cars basically drive themselves. You find yourself no longer driving it, but conducting an eight cylinder orchestra instead. Anyhow, I'm happy to agree to disagree on this one. There's no arguing about what rings people's bell. > Despite all of that - I drive N2k2 because it's the > best racing simulator out there. I think that's a > pretty shit situation to be in - dont you? I don't know... it hard for me to judge how much of the situation is down to you. Don't get me wrong, I understand your plight and I would like more diversity in Papyrus simulations myself. -Or, better said, I'd like the average level of sims to be higher regardless of particular developers.- It's just I find it hard to understand why you're not challenged to look beyond your prejudice. Jan. =---
Not quite so detestful of the roundy-round boys as you Doug, but I too think it's a shame the best technology in the sim business *by far* is ONLY to be found in an oval-laden Nascar sim. Fine, but just not my thing. And F1 2002 has some nice bits, but it's really just not on the same level, product-wise, as NR2002. Every time I take one of those lumbering stockers around the Osterreichring or Silverstone I can't help imagining what GPL2 might have been. Or what a great Trans Am or ALMS sim the Papy engine would make. I love ALMS for the variety of cars and the constant traffic. Wouldn't mixed-class online racing be a hoot? Guess there's always....well, you know. ;-) SB "Douglas Ellison" <[email hidden]> wrote ... <snip> > I now drive N2k2. Not because I like nascar's - infact I LOATH them, IHATE > them, i deteste EVERYTHING ABOUT THEM. They're fat, ugly, unrefined, the > handle like shit on road courses. All the tracks are crap, left ,left,left. > And when you do get a road course -it's a waste of time when you'redriving
Quoted text (8 lines)> a tank. > > Despite all of that - I drive N2k2 because it's the best racing simulator > out there. I think that's a pretty shit situation to be in - dont you? > > Doug > >
As a matter of fact, I am. But I know what you are getting at, and it is not even near the same thing. There is teamwork, yes. Of course there is. That's why there are multi-car teams (or part of it). But it's the team against the OTHER teams, not team orders dictating what driver of a particular team is going to win. I'm not saying it has never happened, and I'm not saying it never will happen. But I can bet it'll be a hell of a lot more subtle than what we've seen in F1 :) But there is NOTHING like what went down in Austria. -Larry "jason moyer" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > On Tue, 25 Jun 2002 18:23:17 GMT, "Larry" <[email hidden]> wrote: > > >We Americans have this funny thing about wanting to let the drivers win > >based on skill, the car, and of course luck. Team 'orders' can go tohell. > > Aren't you a DEI fan? > > Jason
Hehe! Well, I asked :) Thanks for the info! -Larry "Douglas Ellison" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:afalpp$coma8$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (25 lines)> > "Douglas Ellison" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:afaka2$cv1tr$[email hidden]... > > > > "Larry" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > > news:Ev2S8.80553$[email hidden]... > > > I would like to see numbers backing THAT up... > > > > > > -Larry > > > > > > > I'd wager that you could quite easily quadruple the number of people who > > watch nascar and you still wouldnt reach the viewing figures of F1. > > > > Just because Amerian Baseball is called the 'world series' doesnt mean > that > > the world doesnt exist west of LA or East of NY > > > > Doug > > The only figures I seem to be able to find are thus.... > > http://jayski.thatsracin.com/pages/tvratings.htm > > Nascar seems to get between 4.5 and 6.5 million viewers. It's impossible
to
Quoted text (8 lines)> guage how many people watch overseas - but I REALLY dont expect it to be > very many at all. Perhaps as many again - so call it 12 million per race > world wide. ( The 'Tona 500 was a one off at 10.9 million viewers) > > > For formula one - you can usually only find the total number of people who > watch an F1 race thru the year - which was 54 billion for 2001. ( >
http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport/hi/english/motorsport/formula_one/newsid_1842000
Quoted text (27 lines)> /1842217.stm ) > > If we take that on a per-race basis of watching the race, qualifing and > highlights, and 5 news bulletins including race news - thats 144 viewings > per person in a year. 54 billion / 144 = 375 Million viewers. > > 375 Million viewers for F1. 12 Million for Nascar. > > Even if both are out by 50% - in Nascars favour - lets call it 187 for F1 > and 24 Nascar. > > F1 has a viewership of 779% that of Nascar. And thats making the figures > about as nascar biased as I can possibly make them. Taking my first > figures - it's more like and F1 viewership 3125% that of Nascar. > > > So there you go - some figure to back THAT up > > Doug > > > > > > > >
Reasonable points, me thinks. -Larry "Peter Oxford" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:nb7S8.151629$nZ3.65870@rwcrnsc53... > > > > A LOT more people watch F1 than Nascar - so one can presume that despite1 > > average and 2 crap offerings of F1 titles already - a properly done one > > would sell well > > > > Doug > > Watching and attending are two different things. I wouldn't be surpisedthat > NASCAR events get more bodies thru the turnstiles than F1. Remember, oval > racing is more spectator friendly. At the typical F1 event, you'rewatching > a fraction of the action. F1 is probably BETTER on TV than live. NASCARjust > the opposite. > > >
Ok, theoretical situation. Last race of the season. Dale Earnhardt Jr can win the championship by placing 5th or better, regardless of what the 2nd place driver does (Sterling Marlin). With 5 laps to go, Sterling Marlin is leading, Michael Waltrip is running 5th, and Dale Earnhardt Jr is running 6th. Do you think that Waltrip is going to try and hold onto a top 5 or let little E by? I don't think there's any question what would happen, and there's no question in my mind that it would be the right call. A good real life example would be Jeff Gordon's championship a few years ago (1995 I think?) when he needed to finish anywhere but last in the final race to win. Hendrick entered a 4th team car and had it retire when the race started so that Gordon couldn't lose. Is that cheating? Jason On Wed, 26 Jun 2002 01:00:14 GMT, "Larry" <[email hidden]> wrote:
Quoted text (30 lines)>As a matter of fact, I am. > >But I know what you are getting at, and it is not even near the same thing. > >There is teamwork, yes. Of course there is. That's why there are multi-car >teams (or part of it). But it's the team against the OTHER teams, not team >orders dictating what driver of a particular team is going to win. > >I'm not saying it has never happened, and I'm not saying it never will >happen. But I can bet it'll be a hell of a lot more subtle than what we've >seen in F1 :) > >But there is NOTHING like what went down in Austria. > >-Larry > > >"jason moyer" <[email hidden]> wrote in message >news:[email hidden]... >> On Tue, 25 Jun 2002 18:23:17 GMT, "Larry" <[email hidden]> wrote: >> >> >We Americans have this funny thing about wanting to let the drivers win >> >based on skill, the car, and of course luck. Team 'orders' can go to >hell. >> >> Aren't you a DEI fan? >> >> Jason > >
One other thing I need to add. The reason you don't what happened in Austria happening in NASCAR is because the point system in NASCAR rewards consistency more than podium finishes. If Formula One used a system where last place was given 5 points and each place you finished higher gave you an additional 5 points, you wouldn't see situations like happened in Austria because there would be minimal benefit to doing such a thing. On the other hand, if NASCAR used the F1 point system I think you'd see it happening fairly frequently. Jason On Wed, 26 Jun 2002 01:21:00 GMT, [email hidden] (jason moyer) wrote:
Quoted text (54 lines)>Ok, theoretical situation. > >Last race of the season. Dale Earnhardt Jr can win the championship >by placing 5th or better, regardless of what the 2nd place driver does >(Sterling Marlin). > >With 5 laps to go, Sterling Marlin is leading, Michael Waltrip is >running 5th, and Dale Earnhardt Jr is running 6th. Do you think that >Waltrip is going to try and hold onto a top 5 or let little E by? > >I don't think there's any question what would happen, and there's no >question in my mind that it would be the right call. > >A good real life example would be Jeff Gordon's championship a few >years ago (1995 I think?) when he needed to finish anywhere but last >in the final race to win. Hendrick entered a 4th team car and had it >retire when the race started so that Gordon couldn't lose. Is that >cheating? > >Jason > >On Wed, 26 Jun 2002 01:00:14 GMT, "Larry" <[email hidden]> wrote: > >>As a matter of fact, I am. >> >>But I know what you are getting at, and it is not even near the same thing. >> >>There is teamwork, yes. Of course there is. That's why there are multi-car >>teams (or part of it). But it's the team against the OTHER teams, not team >>orders dictating what driver of a particular team is going to win. >> >>I'm not saying it has never happened, and I'm not saying it never will >>happen. But I can bet it'll be a hell of a lot more subtle than what we've >>seen in F1 :) >> >>But there is NOTHING like what went down in Austria. >> >>-Larry >> >> >>"jason moyer" <[email hidden]> wrote in message >>news:[email hidden]... >>> On Tue, 25 Jun 2002 18:23:17 GMT, "Larry" <[email hidden]> wrote: >>> >>> >We Americans have this funny thing about wanting to let the drivers win >>> >based on skill, the car, and of course luck. Team 'orders' can go to >>hell. >>> >>> Aren't you a DEI fan? >>> >>> Jason >> >> >
And I would agree with Nascar's use of it either, if it did happen. I don't have anything against F1 racing. I've rather enjoyed watching these mad-men. I just don't like the politics behind the scene's. That's all. -Larry "jason moyer" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]...
Quoted text (43 lines)> One other thing I need to add. > > The reason you don't what happened in Austria happening in NASCAR is > because the point system in NASCAR rewards consistency more than > podium finishes. If Formula One used a system where last place was > given 5 points and each place you finished higher gave you an > additional 5 points, you wouldn't see situations like happened in > Austria because there would be minimal benefit to doing such a thing. > > On the other hand, if NASCAR used the F1 point system I think you'd > see it happening fairly frequently. > > Jason > > On Wed, 26 Jun 2002 01:21:00 GMT, [email hidden] (jason moyer) > wrote: > > >Ok, theoretical situation. > > > >Last race of the season. Dale Earnhardt Jr can win the championship > >by placing 5th or better, regardless of what the 2nd place driver does > >(Sterling Marlin). > > > >With 5 laps to go, Sterling Marlin is leading, Michael Waltrip is > >running 5th, and Dale Earnhardt Jr is running 6th. Do you think that > >Waltrip is going to try and hold onto a top 5 or let little E by? > > > >I don't think there's any question what would happen, and there's no > >question in my mind that it would be the right call. > > > >A good real life example would be Jeff Gordon's championship a few > >years ago (1995 I think?) when he needed to finish anywhere but last > >in the final race to win. Hendrick entered a 4th team car and had it > >retire when the race started so that Gordon couldn't lose. Is that > >cheating? > > > >Jason > > > >On Wed, 26 Jun 2002 01:00:14 GMT, "Larry" <[email hidden]> wrote: > > > >>As a matter of fact, I am. > >> > >>But I know what you are getting at, and it is not even near the same
thing. > >> > >>There is teamwork, yes. Of course there is. That's why there aremulti-car > >>teams (or part of it). But it's the team against the OTHER teams, notteam > >>orders dictating what driver of a particular team is going to win. > >> > >>I'm not saying it has never happened, and I'm not saying it never will > >>happen. But I can bet it'll be a hell of a lot more subtle than whatwe've
Quoted text (12 lines)> >>seen in F1 :) > >> > >>But there is NOTHING like what went down in Austria. > >> > >>-Larry > >> > >> > >>"jason moyer" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > >>news:[email hidden]... > >>> On Tue, 25 Jun 2002 18:23:17 GMT, "Larry" <[email hidden]> wrote: > >>> > >>> >We Americans have this funny thing about wanting to let the drivers
win
Quoted text (10 lines)> >>> >based on skill, the car, and of course luck. Team 'orders' can go to > >>hell. > >>> > >>> Aren't you a DEI fan? > >>> > >>> Jason > >> > >> > > >
That should read "Would NOT" agree... -Larry "Larry" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:7I9S8.81961$[email hidden]... > And I would agree with Nascar's use of it either, if it did happen. > > I don't have anything against F1 racing. I've rather enjoyed watchingthese
Quoted text (76 lines)> mad-men. I just don't like the politics behind the scene's. > > That's all. > > -Larry > > "jason moyer" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:[email hidden]... > > One other thing I need to add. > > > > The reason you don't what happened in Austria happening in NASCAR is > > because the point system in NASCAR rewards consistency more than > > podium finishes. If Formula One used a system where last place was > > given 5 points and each place you finished higher gave you an > > additional 5 points, you wouldn't see situations like happened in > > Austria because there would be minimal benefit to doing such a thing. > > > > On the other hand, if NASCAR used the F1 point system I think you'd > > see it happening fairly frequently. > > > > Jason > > > > On Wed, 26 Jun 2002 01:21:00 GMT, [email hidden] (jason moyer) > > wrote: > > > > >Ok, theoretical situation. > > > > > >Last race of the season. Dale Earnhardt Jr can win the championship > > >by placing 5th or better, regardless of what the 2nd place driver does > > >(Sterling Marlin). > > > > > >With 5 laps to go, Sterling Marlin is leading, Michael Waltrip is > > >running 5th, and Dale Earnhardt Jr is running 6th. Do you think that > > >Waltrip is going to try and hold onto a top 5 or let little E by? > > > > > >I don't think there's any question what would happen, and there's no > > >question in my mind that it would be the right call. > > > > > >A good real life example would be Jeff Gordon's championship a few > > >years ago (1995 I think?) when he needed to finish anywhere but last > > >in the final race to win. Hendrick entered a 4th team car and had it > > >retire when the race started so that Gordon couldn't lose. Is that > > >cheating? > > > > > >Jason > > > > > >On Wed, 26 Jun 2002 01:00:14 GMT, "Larry" <[email hidden]> wrote: > > > > > >>As a matter of fact, I am. > > >> > > >>But I know what you are getting at, and it is not even near the same > thing. > > >> > > >>There is teamwork, yes. Of course there is. That's why there are > multi-car > > >>teams (or part of it). But it's the team against the OTHER teams, not > team > > >>orders dictating what driver of a particular team is going to win. > > >> > > >>I'm not saying it has never happened, and I'm not saying it never will > > >>happen. But I can bet it'll be a hell of a lot more subtle than what > we've > > >>seen in F1 :) > > >> > > >>But there is NOTHING like what went down in Austria. > > >> > > >>-Larry > > >> > > >> > > >>"jason moyer" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > > >>news:[email hidden]... > > >>> On Tue, 25 Jun 2002 18:23:17 GMT, "Larry" <[email hidden]> wrote: > > >>> > > >>> >We Americans have this funny thing about wanting to let the drivers > win > > >>> >based on skill, the car, and of course luck. Team 'orders' can go
to
Quoted text (11 lines)> > >>hell. > > >>> > > >>> Aren't you a DEI fan? > > >>> > > >>> Jason > > >> > > >> > > > > > > >
> Either with or without TC it's a bit too grippy. Agreed. You can actually brake hard with half the car on the grass and not suffer any real consequences. They've done quite a good job of Magny-Cours in F1 2002 - They've improved it considerably over last year's effort. In fact, they seem to have spent more time there than any other track... -- Damien Smith [email hidden] ICQ: 77028579 F1 2001 rank: -11.512
Actually to get a bit off topic the Stanley cup Champion in never referred to as hockey's world champion. That honor is reserved for the country that wins the IIHF World Hockey Championship tournament each April. Just a nitpick as a hockey crazed canuck (who still loves his racing on equal ground I might add) Bryon Lape wrote:
Quoted text (49 lines)> More people watch the World Cup than the Super Bowl, yet it is the football > "World Championship". More people watch the World Cup than the Stanley Cup, yet > it is the hockey "World Championship". More people watch the World Cup than the > World Series, yet it is the baseball "World Championship". More people watch > the World Cup than the NBA playoffs, yet it is the basketball "World > Championship". See a pattern here yet? > > Rob wrote: > > >>Umm, you must be thinking with a US mindset. FAR more people watch F1 across >>the world than NASCAR. NASCAR can only dream about F1 numbers--remember, >>this is the WORLD we are talking about and not just the NASCAR-crazed US. >>I'm sure that Google could probably point you to some actual numbers. >> >>-- >>--------------------- >>Rob Berryhill >> >>"Larry" <[email hidden]> wrote in message >>news:Ev2S8.80553$[email hidden]... >> >>>I would like to see numbers backing THAT up... >>> >>>-Larry >>> >>>"Douglas Ellison" <[email hidden]> wrote in message >>>news:afa902$cu1n8$[email hidden]... >>> >>>>>You don't think a Papy F1 sim would sell? And I'm not talking about >>>>>1967. If they did a really good current F1 season I think it would >>>>>sell very well. Nascar has poor sales in Europe so F1 would probably >>>>>do even better on the market than Nascar. >>>>> >>>>A LOT more people watch F1 than Nascar - so one can presume that despite >>>> >>1 >> >>>>average and 2 crap offerings of F1 titles already - a properly done one >>>>would sell well >>>> >>>>Doug >>>> >>>> >>>> >>>> >>> >>> >
Rob 26 Jun 2002 04:58 UTC↳ reply to Peter Ford#112254
"Peter Oxford" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:nb7S8.151629$nZ3.65870@rwcrnsc53... > Watching and attending are two different things. I wouldn't be surprisedthat > NASCAR events get more bodies thru the turnstiles than F1. Remember, oval > racing is more spectator friendly. At the typical F1 event, you'rewatching > a fraction of the action. F1 is probably BETTER on TV than live. NASCARjust > the opposite. Except that this discussion isn't about attendance at races, it's about potential market for a product. F1 has a far bigger market. BTW, I think the attendance issue is debatable, especially if you only go by the per race average since F1 has fewer races. -- --------------------- Rob Berryhill
"David Buttery" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]...
Quoted text (8 lines)> "MadDAWG" <[email hidden]> wrote on 25 Jun 2002: > > <snip> > > The amount of Americans into F1 is very small. > <snip> > > There are other markets, you know. OKay, so the US is much bigger, but > Europe as a whole must be close, and the Japanese follow F1 too.
Europe as a whole is 300 million + and will probably have say 20 million F1 viewers out of that lot. I believe the USA is 250 million people - of which 6 million watch Nascar Doug
"Damien Smith" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:afbb23$d441t$[email hidden]... > > Either with or without TC it's a bit too grippy. > > they seem to have spent > more time there than any other track... They spent loads of time on Melbourne - but only because it went into the demo Doug
"Larry" <[email hidden]> writes: >Reasonable points, me thinks.... >> Watching and attending are two different things. I wouldn't be surpised that >> NASCAR events get more bodies thru the turnstiles than F1. Remember, oval >> racing is more spectator friendly. At the typical F1 event, you're watching >> a fraction of the action. F1 is probably BETTER on TV than live. NASCAR >> just the opposite. Well, and then there is the question: Is it SIM FRIENDLY ? I think, it was a wise decision to go for pre wing F1 age for a sim like GPL. Why? These cars dont make abrupt moves. No high accelerations. No sharp turns, low speeds when turning. No sudden slowdowns. Why is this important for a good modern sim? Well, IMHO: 1) The paths of the cars are more predictable in case of net lag/glitches. 2) The driver has more time to react. The whole sim doesnt feel too �arcade like�. (modern F1 is �arcadish� - just watch driver actions from cockpit cameras...) And of course, this means it is more network friendly again. Network latency doesnt have too much influence when reaction times are not that important. But I agree, playability is not a marketing factor :( To sell a game, you just have to have a huge number of potential customers, the graphics have to be top notch, and you need to put some millions in advertising. That�s the downside of capitalism and democracy. Everybody wants something special, but they just produce things they can sell to the masses ;) Calis
I stand corrected. Brad Larocque wrote:
Quoted text (57 lines)> Actually to get a bit off topic the Stanley cup Champion in never > referred to as hockey's world champion. That honor is reserved for the > country that wins the IIHF World Hockey Championship tournament each > April. Just a nitpick as a hockey crazed canuck (who still loves his > racing on equal ground I might add) > > Bryon Lape wrote: > > > More people watch the World Cup than the Super Bowl, yet it is the football > > "World Championship". More people watch the World Cup than the Stanley Cup, yet > > it is the hockey "World Championship". More people watch the World Cup than the > > World Series, yet it is the baseball "World Championship". More people watch > > the World Cup than the NBA playoffs, yet it is the basketball "World > > Championship". See a pattern here yet? > > > > Rob wrote: > > > > > >>Umm, you must be thinking with a US mindset. FAR more people watch F1 across > >>the world than NASCAR. NASCAR can only dream about F1 numbers--remember, > >>this is the WORLD we are talking about and not just the NASCAR-crazed US. > >>I'm sure that Google could probably point you to some actual numbers. > >> > >>-- > >>--------------------- > >>Rob Berryhill > >> > >>"Larry" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > >>news:Ev2S8.80553$[email hidden]... > >> > >>>I would like to see numbers backing THAT up... > >>> > >>>-Larry > >>> > >>>"Douglas Ellison" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > >>>news:afa902$cu1n8$[email hidden]... > >>> > >>>>>You don't think a Papy F1 sim would sell? And I'm not talking about > >>>>>1967. If they did a really good current F1 season I think it would > >>>>>sell very well. Nascar has poor sales in Europe so F1 would probably > >>>>>do even better on the market than Nascar. > >>>>> > >>>>A LOT more people watch F1 than Nascar - so one can presume that despite > >>>> > >>1 > >> > >>>>average and 2 crap offerings of F1 titles already - a properly done one > >>>>would sell well > >>>> > >>>>Doug > >>>> > >>>> > >>>> > >>>> > >>> > >>> > >
Bryon Lape 26 Jun 2002 10:38 UTC#529502
I stand corrected.
Quoted text (53 lines)> Actually to get a bit off topic the Stanley cup Champion in never > referred to as hockey's world champion. That honor is reserved for the > country that wins the IIHF World Hockey Championship tournament each > April. Just a nitpick as a hockey crazed canuck (who still loves his > racing on equal ground I might add) > > More people watch the World Cup than the Super Bowl, yet it is the football > > "World Championship". More people watch the World Cup than the Stanley Cup, yet > > it is the hockey "World Championship". More people watch the World Cup than the > > World Series, yet it is the baseball "World Championship". More people watch > > the World Cup than the NBA playoffs, yet it is the basketball "World > > Championship". See a pattern here yet? > >>Umm, you must be thinking with a US mindset. FAR more people watch F1 across > >>the world than NASCAR. NASCAR can only dream about F1 numbers--remember, > >>this is the WORLD we are talking about and not just the NASCAR-crazed US. > >>I'm sure that Google could probably point you to some actual numbers. > >>-- > >>--------------------- > >>Rob Berryhill > >>>I would like to see numbers backing THAT up... > >>>-Larry > >>>>>You don't think a Papy F1 sim would sell? And I'm not talking about > >>>>>1967. If they did a really good current F1 season I think it would > >>>>>sell very well. Nascar has poor sales in Europe so F1 would probably > >>>>>do even better on the market than Nascar. > >>>>A LOT more people watch F1 than Nascar - so one can presume that despite > >>1 > >>>>average and 2 ***offerings of F1 titles already - a properly done one > >>>>would sell well > >>>>Doug
"Sebastion Melmoth" > > Yes, but this is in reference to my comment that if Papy did an F1 sim > it would sell better than their Nascar sim and not about how may > people go to the track. > If Papy did an F1 sim, it probably would sell better, at least in Europe. But the number of F1 fans in the STATES is quite small compared to Nascar fans. Dang near everyone in country has heard of Richard Petty and Dale Earnhardt. Most casual fans know of Jeff Gordon and the guy who won't drive the Brown truck. But ask them about Luciano Burti and even Michael Schumacher and you will only get puzzled stares.. Same goes for CART unfortunately. I talk with a few Nascar fans at my workplace about the great race at XXX and they go wha?????? Here in the states...which is Papyrus' main market...Nascar is King...it doesn't matter how many world wide viewers there are, it doesn't matter how many countries take part. It doesn't matter that the drivers, cars, etc etc are all Uber-proffessional(well excepting Arrows & Minardi, Jordan & BAR &&...) If it doesn't have that Nascar decal on the box, it just doesn't sell in America regardless of who codes it. dave henrie
> On the other hand, if NASCAR used the F1 point system I think you'd > see it happening fairly frequently. Funny you should bring this up. I just saw a post in another newsgroup where someone figured up the NASCAR standings based on the F1 system Points Kenseth 47 Stewart 38 Johnson 31 Marlin 31 Martin 30 Busch 26 Rudd 24 Earnhardt Jr 24 Jarrett 23 Newman 18 Gordon 16 B Labonte 16 E Sadler 13 Waltrip 11 W Burton 10 J Burton 10 Elliott 9 Craven 8 Mayfield 8 Spencer 6 T Labonte 5 G Bodine 4 Harvick 4 Green 2 Benson 1 R Wallace 1 MadDAWG
Yes I know their is other markets, but it simply comes down to economics. If they thought they could make money at it they would. Since they don't ....well I'm sure you can figure it out. Keep in mind titles like GPL were financial flops. I would dare to say that the GPL community is hurting its chances of getting a GPL2. With all the new stuff that keeps rolling out why would most people upgrade? These companies are in it to make a living not to please us. I'll us the damage model in NR2002 as an example. Could they fix it so its more realistic? Sure and pretty easily I would bet. Will they? No because they don't want to make the game getting a bad rap for being to hard like GPL did. Groups like this again hurt this because they look down on anyone that races in lesser modes as being a "lamer gamer". Now don't get me wrong I'd love to see another true sim come out, but I'm not betting on it. I'd say GPL is the last one. IMO NR2002 is close but the weak damage model keeps it below GPL. MadDAWG
On Tue, 25 Jun 2002 22:01:58 +0100, "Douglas Ellison" <[email hidden]> wrote: >For formula one - you can usually only find the total number of people who >watch an F1 race thru the year - which was 54 billion for 2001. ( >http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport/hi/english/motorsport/formula_one/newsid_1842000 >/1842217.stm ) I've always wondered what other planets watch Bernie's F1 circus?... (ie: we've only got 6+ billion potential viewers on this one) :) And even if you say that's over 18 different races, do you really believe that *one half of the world's population* watches *every* F1 race (54b / 18 = 3b)? Does one half of the world's population even have access to TV on a regular basis? Always sounded like bogus numbers to me... >If we take that on a per-race basis of watching the race, qualifing and >highlights, and 5 news bulletins including race news - thats 144 viewings >per person in a year. 54 billion / 144 = 375 Million viewers. And, by Bernie's accounting, if you change the channel and come back again, you're probably one more viewer... "But in a way, fear is a big part of racing, because if there was nothing to be frightened of, and no limit, any fool could get into a motor car and racing would not exist as a sport." -- Jim Clark
> Europe as a whole is 300 million + and will probably have say 20 millionF1 > viewers out of that lot. > > I believe the USA is 250 million people - of which 6 million watch Nascar > > Doug I agree F1 has a bigger fan base world wide than NASCAR, but those 20 million F1 fan have a computer and a F1 sim vs. the NASCAR fans with the same. I would bet the percent is alot higher than F1. If only for the simple fact Americans throw money around alot more than other countries. I'm not trying to piss anyone off here I'm just trying to point out that if a company has a product that sells why mess with something else. Why do a F1 sim when there is already three other major players in the market? Even if you make the best product for us sim racers that is still only a small segment of the market overall. Its looks to me that Papy has decided to go the yearly release route like EA is doing with most of its titles. This probably doesn't leave them much time to do anything else. This could leave the door open for someone else to make a run at another type of racing. ISI with F1 is a good example of this. I really hope they prove me wrong on this, but I'm not holding my breath. MadDAWG
> Everybody wants something special, but they just > produce things they can sell to the masses ;) > > Calis Ding, ding, ding, we have a winner! MadDAWG
>If it doesn't have that Nascar decal on the box, it just doesn't sell in > America regardless of who codes it. > dave henrie > > Take that one step further. things that have NASCAR on the box sell when they shouldn't! aka NASCAR Revolution :) MadDAWG
"MadDAWG" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > > Europe as a whole is 300 million + and will probably have say 20million > F1 > > viewers out of that lot. > > > > I believe the USA is 250 million people - of which 6 million watchNascar > > > > Doug > > I agree F1 has a bigger fan base world wide than NASCAR, but those 20 > million F1 fan have a computer and a F1 sim vs. the NASCAR fans with the > same. I would bet the percent is alot higher than F1. If only for thesimple > fact Americans throw money around alot more than other countries. I'm not > trying to piss anyone off here I'm just trying to point out that if a > company has a product that sells why mess with something else. Because it would sell more than Nascar Doug
I think we are all DAMN lucky to get something like NR2k2 and should be thankfaul anyone caters to our likes, the hardcore market. Which btw is pretty small in the big scheme of things. "Douglas Ellison" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:afct90$djibg$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (18 lines)> > "MadDAWG" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:[email hidden]... > > > Europe as a whole is 300 million + and will probably have say 20 > million > > F1 > > > viewers out of that lot. > > > > > > I believe the USA is 250 million people - of which 6 million watch > Nascar > > > > > > Doug > > > > I agree F1 has a bigger fan base world wide than NASCAR, but those 20 > > million F1 fan have a computer and a F1 sim vs. the NASCAR fans with the > > same. I would bet the percent is alot higher than F1. If only for the > simple > > fact Americans throw money around alot more than other countries. I'm
not
Quoted text (8 lines)> > trying to piss anyone off here I'm just trying to point out that if a > > company has a product that sells why mess with something else. > > Because it would sell more than Nascar > > Doug > >
> Because it would sell more than Nascar > > Doug I really doubt it. If it would I think they'd do it, if nothing more than simple greed. We have all seen the hints dropped by Krammer that he wants to do another open wheel title. So the desire is there, but the market is not. MadDAWG
> Does one half of the world's population even > have access to TV on a regular basis? Or a computer, and of those that do have a computer what percent play race sims? MadDAWG.
The drafting model is also totally screwed up and I for one wont race again because of it. Having more fun in Medal of Honor than N2002. Bill / Amish on Team Brickyard www.iracingfx.com "MadDAWG" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > Yes I know their is other markets, but it simply comes down to economics.If > they thought they could make money at it they would. Since they don't > ....well I'm sure you can figure it out. Keep in mind titles like GPLwere > financial flops. I would dare to say that the GPL community is hurting its > chances of getting a GPL2. With all the new stuff that keeps rolling outwhy > would most people upgrade? These companies are in it to make a living notto > please us. I'll us the damage model in NR2002 as an example. Could theyfix > it so its more realistic? Sure and pretty easily I would bet. Will they?No > because they don't want to make the game getting a bad rap for being tohard > like GPL did. Groups like this again hurt this because they look down on > anyone that races in lesser modes as being a "lamer gamer". Now don't getme > wrong I'd love to see another true sim come out, but I'm not betting onit. > I'd say GPL is the last one. IMO NR2002 is close but the weak damage model > keeps it below GPL. > > MadDAWG > >
Never really got into shooter type games. I have been messing around with Dungeon Siege as a break from racing. If I ever finish it I might give Neverwinter Nights a try. The best part is by the time I'm ready to play it It should be in the discount bin :) MadDAWG
Medal of Honor is fantastic IMHO... "MadDAWG" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > Never really got into shooter type games. I have been messing around with > Dungeon Siege as a break from racing. If I ever finish it I might give > Neverwinter Nights a try. The best part is by the time I'm ready to playit > It should be in the discount bin :) > > MadDAWG > >
Medal of Honor is fun if you don't mind the arcade damage model. It's also very short. After installing one of the patches, all of my saved games were unusable, and I managed to start over from the beginning and beat the entire game in about 5-6 hours. Personally, I think Op Flashpoint is the only really worthwhile FPS at the moment, if you're a fan of realism. Shame the vehicle models suck. Jason On Wed, 26 Jun 2002 15:16:57 -0400, "John Poutr�" <[email hidden]> wrote:
Quoted text (15 lines)>Medal of Honor is fantastic IMHO... > >"MadDAWG" <[email hidden]> wrote in message >news:[email hidden]... >> Never really got into shooter type games. I have been messing around with >> Dungeon Siege as a break from racing. If I ever finish it I might give >> Neverwinter Nights a try. The best part is by the time I'm ready to play >it >> It should be in the discount bin :) >> >> MadDAWG >> >> > >
I don't know what you guys are talking about. There's only two things N2002 does better than F12002. Replays (big deal) and multiplay. David G Fisher "Steve Blankenship" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:z18S8.126466$[email hidden]... > Not quite so detestful of the roundy-round boys as you Doug, but I toothink > it's a shame the best technology in the sim business *by far* is ONLY tobe > found in an oval-laden Nascar sim. Fine, but just not my thing. And F1 > 2002 has some nice bits, but it's really just not on the same level, > product-wise, as NR2002. Every time I take one of those lumberingstockers > around the Osterreichring or Silverstone I can't help imagining what GPL2 > might have been. Or what a great Trans Am or ALMS sim the Papy enginewould
Quoted text (19 lines)> make. I love ALMS for the variety of cars and the constant traffic. > Wouldn't mixed-class online racing be a hoot? > > Guess there's always....well, you know. ;-) > > SB > > "Douglas Ellison" <[email hidden]> wrote ... > <snip> > > I now drive N2k2. Not because I like nascar's - infact I LOATH them, I > HATE > > them, i deteste EVERYTHING ABOUT THEM. They're fat, ugly, unrefined, the > > handle like shit on road courses. All the tracks are crap, left ,left, > left. > > And when you do get a road course -it's a waste of time when you're > driving > > a tank. > > > > Despite all of that - I drive N2k2 because it's the best racing
simulator
Quoted text (7 lines)> > out there. I think that's a pretty shit situation to be in - dont you? > > > > Doug > > > > > >
doubleu 26 Jun 2002 19:55 UTC↳ reply to Scott#112168
Let me initially say that i'm not disagreeing with you Scott. Would you mind providing me with some examples of poorly done corners and sections? Not that I know any better, but I'm just curious. -w "Scott" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:kn5S8.150894$nZ3.64568@rwcrnsc53... > > F12002's tracks are generally poorly modelled. There is very little in the > way of camber, there are bumps where there are none on thier real-life > counterparts, and no bumps where there should be in certain places. Some > tracks are much wider than the real thing, some too narrow, the grass is > extremely grippy...and some of the corners are just plain wrong...andbadly > so at that...I could go on but it's bumming me out just thinking about it. > What offsets this for me though is that the driving model is a lot of fun, > though I don't believe entirely accurate either. It's the closest anyonehas > come to GPL so far (personal opinion, YMMV).
On Wed, 26 Jun 2002 19:44:57 GMT, "David G Fisher" <[email hidden]> wrote: >I don't know what you guys are talking about. There's only two things N2002 >does better than F12002. Replays (big deal) and multiplay. > >David G Fisher It's the multiplay we're talking about, THAT's the big deal Andre
The post I replied to had comments by Doug and Steve which slagged F12002. Steve said, "And F1 2002 has some nice bits, but it's really just not on the same level, product-wise, as NR2002. " Doug says in many posts that F12002 is not that good of a sim. David G Fisher "Andre Warringa" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > On Wed, 26 Jun 2002 19:44:57 GMT, "David G Fisher" > <[email hidden]> wrote: > > >I don't know what you guys are talking about. There's only two thingsN2002
Quoted text (7 lines)> >does better than F12002. Replays (big deal) and multiplay. > > > >David G Fisher > > It's the multiplay we're talking about, THAT's the big deal > > Andre
"Andre Warringa" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > On Wed, 26 Jun 2002 19:44:57 GMT, "David G Fisher" > <[email hidden]> wrote: > > >I don't know what you guys are talking about. There's only two thingsN2002
Quoted text (7 lines)> >does better than F12002. Replays (big deal) and multiplay. > > > >David G Fisher > > It's the multiplay we're talking about, THAT's the big deal > > Andre
The post I replied to had comments by Doug and Steve which slagged F12002. Steve said, "And F1 2002 has some nice bits, but it's really just not on the same level, product-wise, as NR2002. " Doug says in many posts that F12002 is not that good of a sim. David G Fisher
On Wed, 26 Jun 2002 20:21:10 GMT, "David G Fisher" <[email hidden]> wrote:
Quoted text (7 lines)>The post I replied to had comments by Doug and Steve which slagged F12002. >Steve said, "And F1 >2002 has some nice bits, but it's really just not on the same level, >product-wise, as NR2002. " Doug says in many posts that F12002 is not that >good of a sim. > >David G Fisher
I had/have a lot of fun with F1 2002, but allready play it less and less. The more I race against the AI, the more I think they suck, and well, the multiplayer isn't exactly multiplayer heaven. Such a damn shame, F1 2002 is such a bloody good and fun sim, but without good AI and multiplayer it's getting boring rather quickly :-/ Andre
"David G Fisher" wrote: > I don't know what you guys are talking about. There's only two thingsN2002 > does better than F12002. Replays (big deal) and multiplay. Mmmm.. My wishlist for the best sim from combined from the current crop would be: Graphics: N2002 Sound: N2002 AI: GP4 (F1RC Qualifying) Weather: GP4 Rules implementation: N2002 Replays: N2002 Physics: N2002 (parameters for an open wheeler or touring/sports car) Menu/Navigation: N2002 Controller Config: N2002 Capability for Mods: F12002 Multiplayer: N2002 Force Feedback: F12002/N2002 ?? So a Cart sim from Papy, with a weather system & AI to rival GP4 and an open capability for mods, whilst retaining a controlled cheat proof multiplayer system will do me nicely :-) Tony
On Wed, 26 Jun 2002 22:38:19 +0200, Andre Warringa <[email hidden]> wrote: >I had/have a lot of fun with F1 2002, but allready play it less and >less. The more I race against the AI, the more I think they suck, and >well, the multiplayer isn't exactly multiplayer heaven. >Such a damn shame, F1 2002 is such a bloody good and fun sim, but >without good AI and multiplayer it's getting boring rather quickly :-/ I've been tempted to record the audio from a race at Monaco. Before lap 1: Michael Schumacher has lost his rear wing. Schumacher has lost his front wing. Fisichella is unable to continue. David Coulthard has lost his rear wing. Heinz Harold Frentzen is unable to continue. After a 50% race at Monaco there's normally 1 car on the lead lap. and half the field has dropped out after accidents in the first 2 laps. That's ridiculous. Jason
If the demo is anything to go by I'd say there's a whole bunch of things N2002 does miles better than F2002. (as for the final product i wouldn't know - I've not tested it. Nor do I plan to for that matter, until "someone" realises (sp?) what sim racing is really about.) -- ed_ "David G Fisher" said: > I don't know what you guys are talking about. There's only two things N2002 > does better than F12002. Replays (big deal) and multiplay. > > David G Fisher
> Controller Config: N2002 Why can't anybody but Papy seem to get controller config right. It worked great in GPL, and it's just as good if not better in N2002. Other than a few people who lose calibration occasionally, it's virtually flawless. Seems like every other game out there requires hacking around in INI files to even get a wheel to work (GPL requires that for FF, but that's because FF came out in a patch).
On Wed, 26 Jun 2002 21:32:06 GMT, "Rob Adams" <[email hidden]> wrote: >Why can't anybody but Papy seem to get controller config right. It worked >great in GPL, and it's just as good if not better in N2002. Other than a few >people who lose calibration occasionally, it's virtually flawless. Seems >like every other game out there requires hacking around in INI files to even >get a wheel to work (GPL requires that for FF, but that's because FF came >out in a patch). Controller problems severely limited my enjoyment of F1 2001. I can say wholeheartedly, that I have not had similar problem in F1 2002. The half-travel split-axis problem is history (and it now works correctly by default!), the problems I had with the controls not working in training mode are gone (I never really understood that) and without messing about much with controller rates, I've managed to get a very Papyrus-like feel by setting everything as low as it will go with axis sensitivity at 25% for all axes. Seriously, ISI sims have never felt this good before. That said, I lose my controller calibration constantly in N2002, but I still prefer that to the ISI style setup. Jason
YMMV, of course, but to my mind NR 2002 does just about everything better than F1 2002. Better overall game design, menus, tracks, AI, sounds, aural and visual car feedback (just look at how much focus they put into modeling changes in tire sounds based on grip, for instance, and look at how the density of the skid marks follows suit - very nice.) The replay system IS important to me, and multiplayer is, well, IT. Add being less demanding on a cpu/graphics card and less buggy, not to mention the controller issues and it's no contest; just a far deeper and more complete product. Not to (re)start any fires, but even good old GPL is better in most of these respects as well, and the latest 3rd-party 16bit car/track graphics are simply gorgeous. Its 4-yr-old tire model's a bit lacking relative to the state of the art, yes; but we all know that. Not to say I haven't enjoyed F1 2002; the sense of speed is superb and the physics modeling is easily the best for modern F1's yet. With the high physics rate enabled, there are some really nice nuances in high speed cornering grip. Congrats to ISI for sure, and bonus points for mod-ability and especially for being in touch with this community, but I'd say they've still got some catching up to do. Here's wishing them luck in the chase... Cheers, SB PS - really looking forward to the upcoming Papy track conversions and to getting out at the RING in a spankin' new F1. Hey, I don't need no stinkin' gravel trap... ;-) "David G Fisher" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:YQoS8.135986$[email hidden]... > I don't know what you guys are talking about. There's only two thingsN2002 > does better than F12002. Replays (big deal) and multiplay. > > David G Fisher
"MadDAWG" > Take that one step further. things that have NASCAR on the box sell when > they shouldn't! aka NASCAR Revolution :) > > > MadDAWG > yup! dh
>"doubleu" <[email hidden]> wrote > Let me initially say that i'm not disagreeing with you Scott. Would you > mind providing me with some examples of poorly done corners and sections? > Not that I know any better, but I'm just curious. Pick any track! Don't even get me started on Montr�al, per example. -- -- Fran�ois M�nard <ymenard> -- http://www.ymenard.8m.com/ -- This announcement is brought to you by the Shimago-Dominguez Corporation - helping America into the New World...
that bad eh? "ymenard" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:MUsS8.7805$[email hidden]... > >"doubleu" <[email hidden]> wrote > > Let me initially say that i'm not disagreeing with you Scott. Would you > > mind providing me with some examples of poorly done corners andsections?
Quoted text (16 lines)> > Not that I know any better, but I'm just curious. > > Pick any track! > > Don't even get me started on Montr�al, per example. > > > > -- > -- Fran�ois M�nard <ymenard> > -- http://www.ymenard.8m.com/ > -- This announcement is brought to you by the Shimago-Dominguez > Corporation - helping America into the New World... > > >
In article <[email hidden]>, [email hidden] (jason moyer) writes: >A good real life example would be Jeff Gordon's championship a few >years ago (1995 I think?) when he needed to finish anywhere but last >in the final race to win. Hendrick entered a 4th team car and had it >retire when the race started so that Gordon couldn't lose. Is that >cheating? Wow, I'd never heard(or don't remember) that... That's pretty slick...<g> Eldred -- Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett Never argue with an idiot. He brings you down to his level, then beats you with experience... Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.
In article <[email hidden]>, Brad Larocque <[email hidden]> writes: >Actually to get a bit off topic the Stanley cup Champion in never >referred to as hockey's world champion. That's ok, we'll TAKE it! Yayy, WINGS! :-) Eldred p.s. I actually got to hold the Stanley Cup yesterday...whew! -- Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett Never argue with an idiot. He brings you down to his level, then beats you with experience... Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.
In article <[email hidden]>, "MadDAWG" <[email hidden]> writes: >Yes I know their is other markets, but it simply comes down to economics. If >they thought they could make money at it they would. Since they don't >....well I'm sure you can figure it out. Keep in mind titles like GPL were >financial flops. I would dare to say that the GPL community is hurting its >chances of getting a GPL2. With all the new stuff that keeps rolling out why >would most people upgrade? I assume you're talking about mods, tracks, etc. for GPL, right? So if we *ignored* GPL, they'd make another one? I think that all the enhancements provided by the community shows that people still enjoy the sim. That should have more of an effect than if everyone just dropped GPL. Now, there aren't *enough* fans of it to make a GPL2 viable, but that's a totally different issue. Eldred -- Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett Never argue with an idiot. He brings you down to his level, then beats you with experience... Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.
[email hidden] (jason moyer) wrote:
Quoted text (7 lines)>A good real life example would be Jeff Gordon's championship a few >years ago (1995 I think?) when he needed to finish anywhere but last >in the final race to win. Hendrick entered a 4th team car and had it >retire when the race started so that Gordon couldn't lose. Is that >cheating? > >Jason
Simplisticly speaking, why the heck would it be considered cheating? Theoretically, if a particular owner could somehow cobble together 42 cars and hire 42 drivers and manage to qualify all of them, how could you stop him? Realistically speaking, it's a bit more complicated than that. NASCAR DOES have a rule restricting the number of entries that a particular owner may enter in a race (I think it's 2, but it could be 3 now, I'm not sure). Multi-car teams like Roush and Hendrick that want to enter, say, 5 cars in a race simple put a different owner's name on the entry blank and they are completely legal. Now, you may say that this is "cheating" or circumventing the spirit of the rule, but consider the issue of owner points. This is a REAL big deal as far as the end-of-season money payouts and provisionals are concerned, so even though in reality Jack Roush Racing owns the car, if it's entered under someone else's name, Roush doesn't get the points. So, to go back to the theoretical example, if I owned 42 cars and wanted to enter them all, I just find 40 buddies and enter 40 cars in their names. But I only get the points for the two cars that are entered in my name. Clear as mud? So, in the example mentioned above, sure it was a car "owned" by Rick Hendrick, but it was actually entered in the name of his dad, Papa Joe Hendrick. Absolutely nothing illegal about that, completely within the rules. What the heck, if you've got an extra car sitting around the shop, why not enter it just to make sure that all your bases are covered. If they hadn't and Gordon had blown an engine on the pace lap and finished dead last and lost the championship, they would've looked pretty stupid. This isn't the first time it's happened, BTW. Richard Childress entered an extra car for Neil Bonnett at Atlanta in the early 90s to guarantee Earnhardt's championship in exactly the same way. Now, at that time Childress was only a one-car team, so Childress didn't even have to enter it under someone else's name, there was absolutely nothing to stop him entering a second car under his own name.
elrikk 27 Jun 2002 03:59 UTC↳ reply to EldredP#112129
"EldredP" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]...
Quoted text (12 lines)> In article <[email hidden]>, Brad Larocque <[email hidden]> > writes: > > >Actually to get a bit off topic the Stanley cup Champion in never > >referred to as hockey's world champion. > > That's ok, we'll TAKE it! > Yayy, WINGS! :-) > > Eldred > p.s. I actually got to hold the Stanley Cup yesterday...whew! > --
It's been a while, but as a life long Montrealer I have had my tired old mitts on it many, many times. I used to think it was just an award you were entitled to if you played for "Les Habs". ;o) Elrikk
"EldredP" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > In article <[email hidden]>, [email hidden](jason
Quoted text (13 lines)> moyer) writes: > > >A good real life example would be Jeff Gordon's championship a few > >years ago (1995 I think?) when he needed to finish anywhere but last > >in the final race to win. Hendrick entered a 4th team car and had it > >retire when the race started so that Gordon couldn't lose. Is that > >cheating? > > Wow, I'd never heard(or don't remember) that... That's pretty slick...<g> > > Eldred > -- > It's an old trick used for years. Earnhardt did it too, or something
similiar, in the early nineties with Bonnett driving for RCR IIRC. John
> I assume you're talking about mods, tracks, etc. for GPL, right? Correct >So if we *ignored* GPL, they'd make another one? I think that all theenhancements > provided by the community shows that people still enjoy the sim. Thatshould > have more of an effect than if everyone just dropped GPL. Now, therearen't > *enough* fans of it to make a GPL2 viable, but that's a totally different > issue. > > Eldred It is a double edged sword. Yes the mods show interest, but at the same time they keep people from needing to upgrade. I'm all for mods and addons for any game title, but they can keep people happy with what they have, and decrease the desire to upgrade. But since their isn't gonna be another GPL keep them coming guys. :). With all this GPL talk I'm feeling a reinstall coming on. MadDAWG MadDAWG
In article <[email hidden]>, "MadDAWG" <[email hidden]> writes:
Quoted text (7 lines)>There is no one to "blame". The simple fact is a company makes what sells. >NASCAR sells and is their key market. WE as simmers are in the minority. IMO >if it wasn't for the NASCAR titles Papy wouldn't even be in business >anymore. So be glad that you actually have those 2 ton pigs. If it wasn't >for those two ton pigs we'd be all be taking about what moves we could pull >off and how many bonus points we get for them on some X box game. >
But if you don't *like* those 2-ton pigs, you're screwed... I think that's the point he was trying to make. Eldred -- Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett Never argue with an idiot. He brings you down to his level, then beats you with experience... Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.
"Jeff Vincent" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > On Tue, 25 Jun 2002 22:01:58 +0100, "Douglas Ellison" > <[email hidden]> wrote: > > >For formula one - you can usually only find the total number of peoplewho > >watch an F1 race thru the year - which was 54 billion for 2001. ( > >http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport/hi/english/motorsport/formula_one/newsid_1842000
Quoted text (10 lines)> >/1842217.stm ) > > I've always wondered what other planets watch Bernie's F1 > circus?... (ie: we've only got 6+ billion potential viewers on this > one) :) > > And even if you say that's over 18 different races, do you really > believe that *one half of the world's population* watches *every* F1 > race (54b / 18 = 3b)? Does one half of the world's population even > have access to TV on a regular basis?
I think it's the total number of times a person sees F1 in a year. i.e. if someone sees the race, qualifying, and 5 news storys for each race in a season - thats 126 viewings - thus 54 b = 428 million viewers - which I dont think is unreasonable Doug
"David G Fisher" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:rlpS8.412035$%[email hidden]... > Doug says in many posts that F12002 is not that good of a sim. I dunno which Doug you mean - but this Doug will slag off the track accuracy, the replays, the net code and the clunky menus. As a Sim -it's good - but it needs tarting up Doug
"Steve Lane" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]...
Quoted text (8 lines)> On Wed, 26 Jun 2002 21:27:48 -0500, "doubleu" <[email hidden]> > posted: > > >that bad eh? > > Take his comments with a grain of salt. He's harped on the > innacuracies of the EA /ISI tracks series since day one. It's not a > perfect sim but it's the best we got.
So the best of a bad bunch isnt open to criticism? Doug
EldredP 27 Jun 2002 16:20 UTC↳ reply to elrikk#111999
In article <N4wS8.26821$[email hidden]>, "elrikk" <[email hidden]> writes:
Quoted text (7 lines)>> Eldred >> p.s. I actually got to hold the Stanley Cup yesterday...whew! >> -- > >It's been a while, but as a life long Montrealer I have had my tired old >mitts on it many, many times. I used to think it was just an award you were >entitled to if you played for "Les Habs". ;o)
Booo...hisssss....<g> Eldred -- Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett Never argue with an idiot. He brings you down to his level, then beats you with experience... Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.
>"Steve Lane" <[email hidden]> wrote > Take his comments with a grain of salt. Facts are fact, coming from anybody's mouth. Note that I spewed about track innacuracies for years and not just about ISI's simulations. I did the same for the two first Ubisoft titles, GP2, even Papyrus titles. > It's not a perfect sim but it's the best we got. So you are stating that the "best of the worst" has to be worshipped and it is illegal to even criticise it? -- -- Fran�ois M�nard <ymenard> -- http://www.ymenard.8m.com/ -- This announcement is brought to you by the Shimago-Dominguez Corporation - helping America into the New World...
On Wed, 26 Jun 2002 20:40:26 GMT, Tony Rickard <[email hidden]> wrote: > "David G Fisher" wrote: > > Multiplayer: N2002 I'd rather see a vroc type plugin for N2002. Scrolling through the endless racelist without any sort of filtering capability is quite tedious. Cheers, uwe -- Uwe Schuerkamp //////////////////////////// http://www.schuerkamp.de/ Herford, Germany \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\ (52.0N/8.5E) PGP Fingerprint: 2E 13 20 22 9A 3F 63 7F 67 6F E9 B1 A8 36 A4 61
In article <[email hidden]>, Uwe Schuerkamp <[email hidden]> writes:
Quoted text (9 lines)>On Wed, 26 Jun 2002 20:40:26 GMT, Tony Rickard <[email hidden]> >wrote: >> "David G Fisher" wrote: >> >> Multiplayer: N2002 > >I'd rather see a vroc type plugin for N2002. Scrolling through >the endless racelist without any sort of filtering capability >is quite tedious.
You can't filter in VROC, can you? The only difference is that there are many MORE servers in N2002... Eldred -- Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett Never argue with an idiot. He brings you down to his level, then beats you with experience... Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.
In article <[email hidden]>, Bryon Lape wrote: >More people watch the World Cup than the Super Bowl, yet it is the football >"World Championship". More people watch the World Cup than the Stanley Cup, yet >it is the hockey "World Championship". More people watch the World Cup than the >World Series, yet it is the baseball "World Championship". More people watch >the World Cup than the NBA playoffs, yet it is the basketball "World >Championship". See a pattern here yet? Actually.. You're wrong on all counts. None of them are refered to as World Championship. Atleast nowhere else in the world. Maybe in the States, where the world is bordered by two oceans, and Canada and Mexico.. ;-) -Jari Please remove SPAMLESS before replying via email. Thank you. -- {~._.~} o Jari Ketola - if.iki@alotek - GPLRank: -7.91 ( Y ) : ``I'm not blipping the throttle. ()~*~() : It's... traction control :)�� (_)-(_) . --Greger Huttu
(snippage) . Atleast nowhere else in the world. Maybe in the > States, where the world is bordered by two oceans, and Canada and Mexico.. > ;-) > > -Jari You mean the Vast Barren Wasteland and the More Southern Southern America right?
On 30 Jun 2002 22:59:24 GMT, [email hidden] (Jari Ketola) wrote: >Actually.. You're wrong on all counts. None of them are refered to as >World Championship. Atleast nowhere else in the world. Maybe in the >States, where the world is bordered by two oceans, and Canada and Mexico.. The "World Series" is a world championship. Players from other countries come to the united states to play baseball. The only players who leave the united states to play baseball are those who aren't good enough to play in the major leagues here. It might not seem like one since North America and the Far East are seemingly the only places in the world where the only real sport is played. The NBA playoffs are a world championship. The best players in the world come to the United States to play in the NBA. The Super Bowl is a world championship. The best players in the world come to the United States to play in the NFL. The only sport I can think of that bills itself as a "world championship" and isn't is F1. It's a world championship in western Europe, Japan, and Brazil. It's as much a world championship as CART. Jason
In article <[email hidden]>, jason moyer wrote:
Quoted text (11 lines)>On 30 Jun 2002 22:59:24 GMT, [email hidden] (Jari >Ketola) wrote: > >>Actually.. You're wrong on all counts. None of them are refered to as >>World Championship. Atleast nowhere else in the world. Maybe in the >>States, where the world is bordered by two oceans, and Canada and Mexico.. > >The "World Series" is a world championship. Players from other >countries come to the united states to play baseball. The only players >who leave the united states to play baseball are those who aren't good >enough to play in the major leagues here.
I think you've misundestood the term "world championship". It's an event, or a series of event, where either teams or individuals compete against each other, each representing a single nation. Hence "world". The fact that the best players are bought from all over the world doesn't give the status of world championship to any league or event. Eg. NBA isn't the basketball world championship. http://www.2002worldbasketball.com/ That is. -Jari Please remove SPAMLESS before replying via email. Thank you. -- {~._.~} o Jari Ketola - if.iki@alotek - GPLRank: -7.91 ( Y ) : ``I'm not blipping the throttle. ()~*~() : It's... traction control :)�� (_)-(_) . --Greger Huttu
Baseball and Americian football are American, noone outside gives a rats arse and therefor doesnt send a team....I think we have yanks confusing themselves and their self importance on the globe as usual here.... Its not a global sport therefor cannot be a World Champ.. NBA playoffs, are National Blah Association but then all yanks think the world just consists of the US huh :) Carts just a series for spics and is in no-way a WDC.... For me anything contained in the US is just a national series, just theres so many spics in the US you can run your own WC signed NC's....anything that doesnt have teams, competitors, and doesnt travel the globe or change place of playing everytime, or on a cycle all over the globe is an NC.....ie: tennis tour, golf tour, F1, snooker, Atheletics, Olympics, Football WC, F3000, sailing, rugby theses are World Sports with rounds played all over the globe with different host nations for each years final. Fuck off NBA, Superbowl are just US crap, and in noway have the right to be called World sports...there are North American Sports with very little interest anywhere else...I mean we play football with our feet, hense "foot" and Rugby with our feet and hands, like the other 90% of countries playing rugby. You dont see masters in rugby like NZ, Samoa, Austrialia sending teams to the NFL do you, why, cause its just a US series and noone gives a shit, this isnt a global WC sport.... jason moyer <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > On 30 Jun 2002 22:59:24 GMT, [email hidden] (Jari > Ketola) wrote: > > >Actually.. You're wrong on all counts. None of them are refered to as > >World Championship. Atleast nowhere else in the world. Maybe in the > >States, where the world is bordered by two oceans, and Canada andMexico..
Quoted text (21 lines)> > The "World Series" is a world championship. Players from other > countries come to the united states to play baseball. The only players > who leave the united states to play baseball are those who aren't good > enough to play in the major leagues here. > > It might not seem like one since North America and the Far East are > seemingly the only places in the world where the only real sport is > played. > > The NBA playoffs are a world championship. The best players in the > world come to the United States to play in the NBA. > > The Super Bowl is a world championship. The best players in the world > come to the United States to play in the NFL. > > The only sport I can think of that bills itself as a "world > championship" and isn't is F1. It's a world championship in western > Europe, Japan, and Brazil. It's as much a world championship as CART. > > Jason
correct, bloody yanks think they own everything.... Jari Ketola <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:afpbpl$jur$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (7 lines)> In article <[email hidden]>, jason moyer wrote: > >On 30 Jun 2002 22:59:24 GMT, [email hidden] (Jari > >Ketola) wrote: > > > >>Actually.. You're wrong on all counts. None of them are refered to as > >>World Championship. Atleast nowhere else in the world. Maybe in the > >>States, where the world is bordered by two oceans, and Canada and
Mexico..
Quoted text (26 lines)> > > >The "World Series" is a world championship. Players from other > >countries come to the united states to play baseball. The only players > >who leave the united states to play baseball are those who aren't good > >enough to play in the major leagues here. > > I think you've misundestood the term "world championship". It's an event, > or a series of event, where either teams or individuals compete against > each other, each representing a single nation. Hence "world". The fact > that the best players are bought from all over the world doesn't > give the status of world championship to any league or event. > > Eg. NBA isn't the basketball world championship. > > http://www.2002worldbasketball.com/ > > That is. > > -Jari > > Please remove SPAMLESS before replying via email. Thank you. > -- > {~._.~} o Jari Ketola - if.iki@alotek - GPLRank: -7.91 > ( Y ) : ``I'm not blipping the throttle. > ()~*~() : It's... traction control :)�� > (_)-(_) . --Greger Huttu
On Mon, 1 Jul 2002 15:26:22 +0100, "David Powell" <[email hidden]> wrote: >Baseball and Americian football are American, noone outside gives a rats >arse and therefor doesnt send a team.... Odd. Tell all of the non-American players that they don't give a shit then. Again, baseball is the only sport other than motorsport that is remotely worth participating in as an athlete or spectator. >I think we have yanks confusing >themselves and their self importance on the globe as usual here.... Self-importance? Fuck America. I'm stating the simple fact that 3 major sports are fully centered around the United States. People come to the United States to play baseball, basketball, and American football. These are sports that have huge fanbases outside of the united states. Even hockey is primarily a US sport now. >Its not a global sport therefor cannot be a World Champ.. Uh. Last time I checked, baseball/basketball/hockey were all Olympic events. I'm not sure what more you need as a qualifier for something to be a "global sport". >NBA playoffs, are National Blah Association but then all yanks think the >world just consists of the US huh :) Again, the best players from the European professional leagues come here to play, not the other way around. That makes the NBA a world championship in my book. >Carts just a series for spics and is in no-way a WDC.... Using the word "spic" in a serious discussion invalidates every other point you have to make. I'm not responding to the rest of this fucking bullshit. Jason
On 1 Jul 2002 10:44:05 GMT, [email hidden] (Jari Ketola) wrote: >I think you've misundestood the term "world championship". It's an event, >or a series of event, where either teams or individuals compete against >each other, each representing a single nation. Hence "world". The fact >that the best players are bought from all over the world doesn't >give the status of world championship to any league or event. Ahh. Gotcha. Thanks for the clarification. :) Jason
lol jason moyer <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]...
Quoted text (41 lines)> On Mon, 1 Jul 2002 15:26:22 +0100, "David Powell" > <[email hidden]> wrote: > > >Baseball and Americian football are American, noone outside gives a rats > >arse and therefor doesnt send a team.... > > Odd. Tell all of the non-American players that they don't give a shit > then. > > Again, baseball is the only sport other than motorsport that is > remotely worth participating in as an athlete or spectator. > > >I think we have yanks confusing > >themselves and their self importance on the globe as usual here.... > > Self-importance? Fuck America. I'm stating the simple fact that 3 > major sports are fully centered around the United States. People come > to the United States to play baseball, basketball, and American > football. These are sports that have huge fanbases outside of the > united states. Even hockey is primarily a US sport now. > > >Its not a global sport therefor cannot be a World Champ.. > > Uh. Last time I checked, baseball/basketball/hockey were all Olympic > events. I'm not sure what more you need as a qualifier for something > to be a "global sport". > > >NBA playoffs, are National Blah Association but then all yanks think the > >world just consists of the US huh :) > > Again, the best players from the European professional leagues come > here to play, not the other way around. That makes the NBA a world > championship in my book. > > >Carts just a series for spics and is in no-way a WDC.... > > Using the word "spic" in a serious discussion invalidates every other > point you have to make. I'm not responding to the rest of this > fucking bullshit. > > Jason
Yeah, man. Racial epithets are funny - ha ha. Jason On Mon, 1 Jul 2002 18:34:35 +0100, "David Powell" <[email hidden]> wrote:
Quoted text (47 lines)>lol > >jason moyer <[email hidden]> wrote in message >news:[email hidden]... >> On Mon, 1 Jul 2002 15:26:22 +0100, "David Powell" >> <[email hidden]> wrote: >> >> >Baseball and Americian football are American, noone outside gives a rats >> >arse and therefor doesnt send a team.... >> >> Odd. Tell all of the non-American players that they don't give a shit >> then. >> >> Again, baseball is the only sport other than motorsport that is >> remotely worth participating in as an athlete or spectator. >> >> >I think we have yanks confusing >> >themselves and their self importance on the globe as usual here.... >> >> Self-importance? Fuck America. I'm stating the simple fact that 3 >> major sports are fully centered around the United States. People come >> to the United States to play baseball, basketball, and American >> football. These are sports that have huge fanbases outside of the >> united states. Even hockey is primarily a US sport now. >> >> >Its not a global sport therefor cannot be a World Champ.. >> >> Uh. Last time I checked, baseball/basketball/hockey were all Olympic >> events. I'm not sure what more you need as a qualifier for something >> to be a "global sport". >> >> >NBA playoffs, are National Blah Association but then all yanks think the >> >world just consists of the US huh :) >> >> Again, the best players from the European professional leagues come >> here to play, not the other way around. That makes the NBA a world >> championship in my book. >> >> >Carts just a series for spics and is in no-way a WDC.... >> >> Using the word "spic" in a serious discussion invalidates every other >> point you have to make. I'm not responding to the rest of this >> fucking bullshit. >> >> Jason > >
On Mon, 1 Jul 2002 15:26:22 +0100, "David Powell" <[email hidden]> wrote: >Baseball and Americian football are American, noone outside gives a rats >arse and therefor doesnt send a team....I think we have yanks confusing >themselves and their self importance on the globe as usual here.... >Have you seen this, BTW? http://209.133.73.64/TPC/Funny_Pictures/0001-1000/0001-0100/0073/TPC_0073.htm -- __________ ____---____ Marco Antonio Checa Funcke \_________D /-/---_----' Santiago de Surco, Lima, Peru _H__/_/ http://machf.tripod.com '-_____|( remove the "no_me_j." and "sons.of." parts before replying
saw that before months ago...very stereotypical but so very true.... machf <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > On Mon, 1 Jul 2002 15:26:22 +0100, "David Powell"<[email hidden]>
Quoted text (8 lines)> wrote: > > >Baseball and Americian football are American, noone outside gives a rats > >arse and therefor doesnt send a team....I think we have yanks confusing > >themselves and their self importance on the globe as usual here.... > > > Have you seen this, BTW? >
http://209.133.73.64/TPC/Funny_Pictures/0001-1000/0001-0100/0073/TPC_0073.ht m
Quoted text (10 lines)> > > -- > __________ ____---____ Marco Antonio Checa Funcke > \_________D /-/---_----' Santiago de Surco, Lima, Peru > _H__/_/ http://machf.tripod.com > |( > > remove the "no_me_j." and "sons.of." parts before replying
"David Powell" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > saw that before months ago...very stereotypical but so very true.... > OF COURSE IT'S TRUE!!! We spent several gazillion dollars putting very expensive stuff up into outter space just so they could draw this map. I'm telling ya the best minds went into that work. Somebody wanted to paint it on a Basketball but he was laughed at. So they put in on a proper serving tray. Just remember we are 8th best in the world at some kickball game we don't even know the name of......that should scare the bejeezus outta all youse. dave henrie
On Wed, 03 Jul 2002 01:49:48 GMT, "Dave Henrie" <[email hidden]> wrote:
Quoted text (15 lines)> >"David Powell" <[email hidden]> wrote in message >news:[email hidden]... >> saw that before months ago...very stereotypical but so very true.... >> > > OF COURSE IT'S TRUE!!! We spent several gazillion dollars putting very >expensive stuff up into outter space just so they could draw this map. I'm >telling ya the best minds went into that work. Somebody wanted to paint it >on a Basketball but he was laughed at. So they put in on a proper serving >tray. Just remember we are 8th best in the world at some kickball game we >don't even know the name of......that should scare the bejeezus outta all >youse. >dave henrie >
LOL! It's good to see someone with the ability to laugh at himself... -- __________ ____---____ Marco Antonio Checa Funcke \_________D /-/---_----' Santiago de Surco, Lima, Peru _H__/_/ http://machf.tripod.com '-_____|( remove the "no_me_j." and "sons.of." parts before replying
machf wrote:
Quoted text (20 lines)> > On Wed, 03 Jul 2002 01:49:48 GMT, "Dave Henrie" <[email hidden]> wrote: > > > > >"David Powell" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > >news:[email hidden]... > >> saw that before months ago...very stereotypical but so very true.... > >> > > > > OF COURSE IT'S TRUE!!! We spent several gazillion dollars putting very > >expensive stuff up into outter space just so they could draw this map. I'm > >telling ya the best minds went into that work. Somebody wanted to paint it > >on a Basketball but he was laughed at. So they put in on a proper serving > >tray. Just remember we are 8th best in the world at some kickball game we > >don't even know the name of......that should scare the bejeezus outta all > >youse. > >dave henrie > > > LOL! > It's good to see someone with the ability to laugh at himself...
Sometimes you have no choice .... :-) Beers and cheers (uncle) Goy "The Pits" http://www.theuspits.com/ "A man is only as old as the woman he feels" --Groucho Marx--

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy