I've been following the WSC/RL debate with interest and it occurs to me that
the West Brothers may have a slightly different strategy in mind to what is
indicated on their website.
I think they have already built the sim engine (4 years of WSC development)
but are attempting to find a new way to sell it without having to sign with
publishers/distributers AND without having to gain licenses. They want to
retain control of their software - which I think they should be applauded
for.
Of course by pitching it to real race teams they tap into a new specialist
market for their software. Particularly amateur and low budget racing teams
who may not have the funds for the expensive engineering/modelling software
and hardware.
More importantly however, they definitely want to tap in to the sim editing
community's ability to 'value-add' to a sim. In fact I think they hope the
sim editing community will make the majority of the expansion packs (free
mods) for the RL engine for a number of reasons:
1. It will bypass the problems and costs of obtaining licencses for tracks,
cars, championships, etc. They can concentrate on the really specialist
expansion packs like damage modelling, and pit stops, (not to mention
patches) while the community builds licence free cars and tracks.
2. As the sim community gets involved in extending RL, it will also act as
an advertising system (similar to viral marketing).
3. It will continually increase the VALUE of the RL sim engine to the end
user without the Wests doing any more work. Look at GPL, SCGT, F12001 etc. -
all the add-ons and mods certainly increased sales for those games. One
drawback of this is that those mods may actually decrease sales of
subsequent releases because the quality of the older sim has increased
dramatically. In the case of Racing Legends they intend to capitalise on
this mechanism because they will continue to sell the original sim engine.
It all sounds like it could work for the Wests, and could be great for sim
racing enthusiasts - but I'm still bugged by this thought. If the open
source concept can produce Linux, Xplane and Racer then surely we can't be
too far from producing an open source, ultimate motor racing sim similar in
concept to Racing Legends. And if both the commercial Racing Legends and an
open source 'ultimate sim' do arrive, which one will get the most support
from the sim racing/editing community?...
"Krunch" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:3d327646$[email hidden]...
<snip>
> It all sounds like it could work for the Wests, and could be great for sim
> racing enthusiasts - but I'm still bugged by this thought. If the open
> source concept can produce Linux, Xplane and Racer then surely we can't be
> too far from producing an open source, ultimate motor racing sim similarin
> concept to Racing Legends. And if both the commercial Racing Legends andan
> open source 'ultimate sim' do arrive, which one will get the most support
> from the sim racing/editing community?...
>
I just read at one of the sim racing sites that Thfella who did Xplane is
doing a car sim as well. More details to come in the next few weeks.
Elrikk
Since GranTurismo 3 features real tracks with fake names (Monaco) and real
cars with fake names,
(The F1-cars) i dont see the problem in doing cars and tracks and just call
the Ferrari, a Fararri like in
the old spectrum game Chequered flag :) MacLuren.. Coventry.. murusama.. its
been done before.
"Nigel Nichols" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:agtv53$f9n$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (11 lines)
> Hey > > I think you will find even the sim community won't be allowed to make > likenesses of tracks without licences. > I remember the issue over the Daytona track that was made to N2 I think it > was. The author was threatened legal action and had to back out of the > project. > > Nigel > >"Nigel Nichols" <[email hidden]> wrote on 16 Jul 2002:
> Hey
>
> I think you will find even the sim community won't be allowed to
> make likenesses of tracks without licences.<snip>
You mean like they haven't in GPL? ;-)
--
"After all, a mere thousand yards... such a harmless little knoll,
really" - Raymond Mays on Shelsley Walsh.
The GPL Scrapyard: http://www.btinternet.com/~gplscrapyard
> I think they have already built the sim engineIndeed. However - it's owned by Emprie - and thus RL is all new code.
> 1. It will bypass the problems and costs of obtaining licencses fortracks,
> cars, championships, etc.
Bingo.
> 2. As the sim community gets involved in extending RL, it will also act as
> an advertising system (similar to viral marketing).Yup.
> It all sounds like it could work for the Wests, and could be great for sim
> racing enthusiasts - but I'm still bugged by this thought. If the open
> source concept can produce Linux, Xplane and Racer
X-Plane isnt open source - and the only one of the above that's not free.
>then surely we can't be
> too far from producing an open source, ultimate motor racing sim similarin
> concept to Racing Legends.
Best of luck to anyone prepared to have a go - Ruud and Ash are doing bloody
well - but it take months of full time effort to get there
Doug
>
>
Indeed. However - it's owned by Emprie - and thus RL is all new code.
Bingo.
Yup.
X-Plane isnt open source - and the only one of the above that's not free.
Best of luck to anyone prepared to have a go - Ruud and Ash are doing ***y
well - but it take months of full time effort to get there
Doug
"Andreas Nystrom" <[email hidden]> wrote in
news:25yY8.16131$[email hidden]:
> call the Ferrari, a Fararri like in
> the old spectrum game Chequered flag :)
I think you'll find it was called the Feretti Turbo ;o)
Then there was the McFaster Special...
cheers
John
"Joel A. Willstein" <[email hidden]> wrote in
news:6mzY8.40838$[email hidden]:
You'd maybe be surprised at how much of the time spent in development
doesn't involve actually entering the code into the text editor :o)
Also the initial years of work may have yielded many dead ends. In
essence, with a new code base, the Wests could have "hit the ground
running" as it were.
I'm not saying that's the explanation, just that it's possible to re-do 3
years work in 6 months when you're fully up to speed.
cheers
John
Quoted text (9 lines)
> Krunch, > > I believe that the code for WSC belongs to Empire and not the > Wests. > That's why the code for RL is supposed to be new. But it sure seems > odd that it took years to write the code for WSC, then to be able to > knock out the code for RL in just 6 months or so. > > Joel Willstein
"Douglas Ellison" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:agus4r$oeeg5$[email hidden]...
>
> > I think they have already built the sim engine
> Indeed. However - it's owned by Emprie - and thus RL is all new code.
Hmmm...I seriously doubt its all new code. My guess is that Empire ended up
with a cut down 'Arcade' game ( which may still be released as WSC, who
knows) - all the juicy, realistic modelling code is most likely what Empire
wanted cut out of WSC, so I believe the Wests retained that code after the
split. Even if they didn't, they could easily rewrite the code based on the
knowledge they'd gained over those years, and Empire couldn't do a thing
about it - they only got code, not the West's knowledge. It's all
speculation of course so you may be right :)
> > It all sounds like it could work for the Wests, and could be great forsim
> > racing enthusiasts - but I'm still bugged by this thought. If the open
> > source concept can produce Linux, Xplane and Racer
>
> X-Plane isnt open source - and the only one of the above that's not free.
Oops! Yes you're right - my mistake.
> >then surely we can't be too far from producing an open source,
> >ultimate motor racing sim similar in concept to Racing Legends.
>
> Best of luck to anyone prepared to have a go - Ruud and Ash are doingbloody
> well - but it take months of full time effort to get there
Yep. But that only gives me hope :). I think open source has a much better
chance of eventually producing our 'ultimate racing sim' than a commercial
entity. Trouble is, that is probably still a couple of years off - Racing
Legends might be just around the corner. I just hope it doesn't cost too
much.
Hey
I think you will find even the sim community won't be allowed to make
likenesses of tracks without licences.
I remember the issue over the Daytona track that was made to N2 I think it
was. The author was threatened legal action and had to back out of the
project.
Nigel
Krunch <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:3d327646$[email hidden]...
> I've been following the WSC/RL debate with interest and it occurs to methat
> the West Brothers may have a slightly different strategy in mind to whatis
> indicated on their website.
>
> I think they have already built the sim engine (4 years of WSCdevelopment)
> but are attempting to find a new way to sell it without having to signwith
> publishers/distributers AND without having to gain licenses. They want to
> retain control of their software - which I think they should be applauded
> for.
>
> Of course by pitching it to real race teams they tap into a new specialist
> market for their software. Particularly amateur and low budget racingteams
> who may not have the funds for the expensive engineering/modellingsoftware
> and hardware.
>
> More importantly however, they definitely want to tap in to the simediting
> community's ability to 'value-add' to a sim. In fact I think they hope the
> sim editing community will make the majority of the expansion packs (free
> mods) for the RL engine for a number of reasons:
>
> 1. It will bypass the problems and costs of obtaining licencses fortracks,
etc. -
in
> concept to Racing Legends. And if both the commercial Racing Legends andan
> open source 'ultimate sim' do arrive, which one will get the most support
> from the sim racing/editing community?...
>
>
>
Quoted text (9 lines)
> cars, championships, etc. They can concentrate on the really specialist > expansion packs like damage modelling, and pit stops, (not to mention > patches) while the community builds licence free cars and tracks. > > 2. As the sim community gets involved in extending RL, it will also act as > an advertising system (similar to viral marketing). > > 3. It will continually increase the VALUE of the RL sim engine to the end > user without the Wests doing any more work. Look at GPL, SCGT, F12001Quoted text (10 lines)
> all the add-ons and mods certainly increased sales for those games. One > drawback of this is that those mods may actually decrease sales of > subsequent releases because the quality of the older sim has increased > dramatically. In the case of Racing Legends they intend to capitalise on > this mechanism because they will continue to sell the original sim engine. > > It all sounds like it could work for the Wests, and could be great for sim > racing enthusiasts - but I'm still bugged by this thought. If the open > source concept can produce Linux, Xplane and Racer then surely we can't be > too far from producing an open source, ultimate motor racing sim similar
"Krunch" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:3d33820e$[email hidden]...
No. Racing Legends is all new code. FACT.
> My guess is that Empire ended up with a cut down 'Arcade' game ( which maystill be released as WSC, who
> knows) - all the juicy, realistic modelling code is most likely whatEmpire wanted cut out of WSC, so I believe the Wests retained that code
after the
> split. Even if they didn't, they could easily rewrite the code based onthe knowledge they'd gained over those years, and Empire couldn't do a
thing
> about it - they only got code, not the West's knowledge. It's allspeculation of course so you may be right :)
Empire legally own all the WSC code - but they're not using it. TIR doesnt
contain any WSC code - it's entirely new,
> Yep. But that only gives me hope :). I think open source has a much better
> chance of eventually producing our 'ultimate racing sim' than a commercial
> entity. Trouble is, that is probably still a couple of years off - Racing
> Legends might be just around the corner. I just hope it doesn't cost too
> much.
It's going to be expensive. A ferrari costs more than a fiesta. I had no
problem paying $99 for X-Plane because it's the best there is imho. I'll
have no problem paying double that for Racing Legends.
Doug
Quoted text (8 lines)
> > "Douglas Ellison" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:agus4r$oeeg5$[email hidden]... > > > > > I think they have already built the sim engine > > Indeed. However - it's owned by Emprie - and thus RL is all new code. > > Hmmm...I seriously doubt its all new code.> > > I think they have already built the sim engine
> > Indeed. However - it's owned by Emprie - and thus RL is all new code.
> Hmmm...I seriously doubt its all new code.
No. Racing Legends is all new code. FACT.
still be released as WSC, who
Empire wanted cut out of WSC, so I believe the Wests retained that code
after the
the knowledge they'd gained over those years, and Empire couldn't do a
thing
speculation of course so you may be right :)
Empire legally own all the WSC code - but they're not using it. TIR doesnt
contain any WSC code - it's entirely new,
It's going to be expensive. A ferrari costs more than a fiesta. I had no
problem paying $99 for X-Plane because it's the best there is imho. I'll
have no problem paying double that for Racing Legends.
Doug
Krunch,
I believe that the code for WSC belongs to Empire and not the Wests.
That's why the code for RL is supposed to be new. But it sure seems odd
that it took years to write the code for WSC, then to be able to knock out
the code for RL in just 6 months or so.
Joel Willstein
--
"If you can leave black marks on a straight from the time you exit a corner
till the time you brake for the next turn
, then you have enough horsepower."
Mark Donohue
"Krunch" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:3d327646$[email hidden]...
> I've been following the WSC/RL debate with interest and it occurs to me
that
> the West Brothers may have a slightly different strategy in mind to what
is
> indicated on their website.
>
> I think they have already built the sim engine (4 years of WSC
development)
> but are attempting to find a new way to sell it without having to sign
with
> publishers/distributers AND without having to gain licenses. They want to
> retain control of their software - which I think they should be applauded
> for.
>
> Of course by pitching it to real race teams they tap into a new specialist
> market for their software. Particularly amateur and low budget racing
teams
> who may not have the funds for the expensive engineering/modelling
software
> and hardware.
>
> More importantly however, they definitely want to tap in to the sim
editing
> community's ability to 'value-add' to a sim. In fact I think they hope the
> sim editing community will make the majority of the expansion packs (free
> mods) for the RL engine for a number of reasons:
>
> 1. It will bypass the problems and costs of obtaining licencses for
tracks,
> cars, championships, etc. They can concentrate on the really specialist
> expansion packs like damage modelling, and pit stops, (not to mention
> patches) while the community builds licence free cars and tracks.
>
> 2. As the sim community gets involved in extending RL, it will also act as
> an advertising system (similar to viral marketing).
>
> 3. It will continually increase the VALUE of the RL sim engine to the end
> user without the Wests doing any more work. Look at GPL, SCGT, F12001
etc. -
> all the add-ons and mods certainly increased sales for those games. One
> drawback of this is that those mods may actually decrease sales of
> subsequent releases because the quality of the older sim has increased
> dramatically. In the case of Racing Legends they intend to capitalise on
> this mechanism because they will continue to sell the original sim engine.
>
> It all sounds like it could work for the Wests, and could be great for sim
> racing enthusiasts - but I'm still bugged by this thought. If the open
> source concept can produce Linux, Xplane and Racer then surely we can't be
> too far from producing an open source, ultimate motor racing sim similar
in
> concept to Racing Legends. And if both the commercial Racing Legends and
an
> open source 'ultimate sim' do arrive, which one will get the most support
> from the sim racing/editing community?...
>
>
>
Krunch,
I believe that the code for WSC belongs to Empire and not the Wests.
That's why the code for RL is supposed to be new. But it sure seems odd
that it took years to write the code for WSC, then to be able to knock out
the code for RL in just 6 months or so.
Joel Willstein
--
"If you can leave black marks on a straight from the time you exit a corner
till the time you brake for the next turn
, then you have enough horsepower."
Mark Donohue
"Krunch" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:3d327646$[email hidden]...
> I've been following the WSC/RL debate with interest and it occurs to me
that
> the West Brothers may have a slightly different strategy in mind to what
is
> indicated on their website.
>
> I think they have already built the sim engine (4 years of WSC
development)
> but are attempting to find a new way to sell it without having to sign
with
> publishers/distributers AND without having to gain licenses. They want to
> retain control of their software - which I think they should be applauded
> for.
>
> Of course by pitching it to real race teams they tap into a new specialist
> market for their software. Particularly amateur and low budget racing
teams
> who may not have the funds for the expensive engineering/modelling
software
> and hardware.
>
> More importantly however, they definitely want to tap in to the sim
editing
> community's ability to 'value-add' to a sim. In fact I think they hope the
> sim editing community will make the majority of the expansion packs (free
> mods) for the RL engine for a number of reasons:
>
> 1. It will bypass the problems and costs of obtaining licencses for
tracks,
> cars, championships, etc. They can concentrate on the really specialist
> expansion packs like damage modelling, and pit stops, (not to mention
> patches) while the community builds licence free cars and tracks.
>
> 2. As the sim community gets involved in extending RL, it will also act as
> an advertising system (similar to viral marketing).
>
> 3. It will continually increase the VALUE of the RL sim engine to the end
> user without the Wests doing any more work. Look at GPL, SCGT, F12001
etc. -
> all the add-ons and mods certainly increased sales for those games. One
> drawback of this is that those mods may actually decrease sales of
> subsequent releases because the quality of the older sim has increased
> dramatically. In the case of Racing Legends they intend to capitalise on
> this mechanism because they will continue to sell the original sim engine.
>
> It all sounds like it could work for the Wests, and could be great for sim
> racing enthusiasts - but I'm still bugged by this thought. If the open
> source concept can produce Linux, Xplane and Racer then surely we can't be
> too far from producing an open source, ultimate motor racing sim similar
in
> concept to Racing Legends. And if both the commercial Racing Legends and
an
> open source 'ultimate sim' do arrive, which one will get the most support
> from the sim racing/editing community?...
>
>
>
In article <6mzY8.40837$[email hidden]>, "Joel A.
Willstein" <[email hidden]> writes:
Thank you. That what I was wondering, too...
Eldred
--
Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett
My .sig file is in the shop for repairs...
Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.
Quoted text (7 lines)
>Krunch, > > I believe that the code for WSC belongs to Empire and not the Wests. >That's why the code for RL is supposed to be new. But it sure seems odd >that it took years to write the code for WSC, then to be able to knock out >the code for RL in just 6 months or so. >[email hidden] (EldredP) writes:
Remember, the research on how to do things is taking most of the time,
not coding. I guess Empire didn't brainwash the lads aswell ?
On another note, how does Empire check that they don't use bits of
code from the old project ? House-razzia ?
--
Olav Malmin
remove .spam when replying
Quoted text (12 lines)
> In article <6mzY8.40837$[email hidden]>, "Joel A. > Willstein" <[email hidden]> writes: > > >Krunch, > > > > I believe that the code for WSC belongs to Empire and not the Wests. > >That's why the code for RL is supposed to be new. But it sure seems odd > >that it took years to write the code for WSC, then to be able to knock out > >the code for RL in just 6 months or so. > > > > Thank you. That what I was wondering, too...On 16 Jul 2002 13:11:26 GMT, EldredP <[email hidden]> wrote:
I have to agree with John on that one. All the experience gained
in years of coding will allow you to be much more "efficient"
should you have to start from scratch again.
uwe
--
Uwe Schuerkamp //////////////////////////// http://www.schuerkamp.de/
Herford, Germany \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\ (52.0N/8.5E)
PGP Fingerprint: 2E 13 20 22 9A 3F 63 7F 67 6F E9 B1 A8 36 A4 61
Quoted text (7 lines)
>>that it took years to write the code for WSC, then to be able to knock out >>the code for RL in just 6 months or so. >> > > Thank you. That what I was wondering, too... > > Eldred
"Nigel Nichols" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:agtv53$f9n$[email hidden]...
Yeah, its a tricky subject but I don't think anyone has the right to stop
anyone else from making a 'likeness' of anything. I think making threats is
their only course of action. In the case of the Daytona track, if it went to
court they may not have won - but the threat was enough to stop the author.
My feeling is that if you build a 3D model, then you own the rights to that
model even if its a dead-ringer for someone elses real world object. And if
you call it say: "My track based on Daytona" and allow people to use it,
then nobody has any legal grounds to stop you.
If you take photography as an example it gets interesting. I could go out
and take photos of a Ferrari on the street and then put them on my web site
to share. I could allow people to download them as desktop wallpaper or
other personal use. I could call them 'Ferrari Photos' and nobody could stop
me. In fact if Ferrari put those photos on their web site I could threaten
THEM with breach of copyright. Photographers always own the copyright of
their photos no matter what the subject is - even if someone else
comissioned them.
So lets make our models. We can't let these corporate stuffed shirts spoil
our fun :)
to
> > retain control of their software - which I think they should beapplauded
> > for.
> >
> > Of course by pitching it to real race teams they tap into a newspecialist
the
> > sim editing community will make the majority of the expansion packs(free
as
> > an advertising system (similar to viral marketing).
> >
> > 3. It will continually increase the VALUE of the RL sim engine to theend
engine.
> >
> > It all sounds like it could work for the Wests, and could be great forsim
> > racing enthusiasts - but I'm still bugged by this thought. If the open
> > source concept can produce Linux, Xplane and Racer then surely we can'tbe
> > too far from producing an open source, ultimate motor racing sim similar
> in
> > concept to Racing Legends. And if both the commercial Racing Legends and
> an
> > open source 'ultimate sim' do arrive, which one will get the mostsupport
> > from the sim racing/editing community?...
> >
> >
> >
>
>
Quoted text (9 lines)
> Hey > > I think you will find even the sim community won't be allowed to make > likenesses of tracks without licences. > I remember the issue over the Daytona track that was made to N2 I think it > was. The author was threatened legal action and had to back out of the > project. > > NigelQuoted text (13 lines)
> Krunch <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:3d327646$[email hidden]... > > I've been following the WSC/RL debate with interest and it occurs to me > that > > the West Brothers may have a slightly different strategy in mind to what > is > > indicated on their website. > > > > I think they have already built the sim engine (4 years of WSC > development) > > but are attempting to find a new way to sell it without having to sign > with > > publishers/distributers AND without having to gain licenses. They wantQuoted text (9 lines)
> > market for their software. Particularly amateur and low budget racing > teams > > who may not have the funds for the expensive engineering/modelling > software > > and hardware. > > > > More importantly however, they definitely want to tap in to the sim > editing > > community's ability to 'value-add' to a sim. In fact I think they hopeQuoted text (9 lines)
> > mods) for the RL engine for a number of reasons: > > > > 1. It will bypass the problems and costs of obtaining licencses for > tracks, > > cars, championships, etc. They can concentrate on the really specialist > > expansion packs like damage modelling, and pit stops, (not to mention > > patches) while the community builds licence free cars and tracks. > > > > 2. As the sim community gets involved in extending RL, it will also actQuoted text (7 lines)
> > user without the Wests doing any more work. Look at GPL, SCGT, F12001 > etc. - > > all the add-ons and mods certainly increased sales for those games. One > > drawback of this is that those mods may actually decrease sales of > > subsequent releases because the quality of the older sim has increased > > dramatically. In the case of Racing Legends they intend to capitalise on > > this mechanism because they will continue to sell the original sim
"Douglas Ellison" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:ah0pam$p7pcm$[email hidden]...
FACT according to who? Tony and Chris? Even if they themselves walked up to
me and said "its all new code" I'd still doubt it. They are never going to
admit it with Empire looking over their shoulders :)
>
> Empire legally own all the WSC code - but they're not using it. TIRdoesnt
> contain any WSC code - it's entirely new,
Empire also legally own all the track and car models and textures from WSC
too. It looks like TIR *is* using all that so perhaps its not really
entirely new.
>
> It's going to be expensive. A ferrari costs more than a fiesta. I had no
> problem paying $99 for X-Plane because it's the best there is imho. I'll
> have no problem paying double that for Racing Legends.
Are you talking US dollars? US$200 would be nearly AUS$400. I think that's
WAY too much for its initial configuration. I'd be prepared to pay half
that.


































