Mike Helton confused me today in his interview after the railing was fixed
at Pocono. Reading between the lines, and in a way almost directly, he
indicated that he wanted that guard rail taken down and replaced with
Concrete because of the extensive repair-time it took and the delay in the
race.
Excuse me Mr. Helton, but that Guard Rail, IMHO, possibly saved two drivers
lives today. One for sure. I have serious doubts whether Steve Park would
have survived that crash if it were a concrete barrier there today. Dale
Jr. might not have come out of it too good either.
Those guys deflected 100 feet of Guard Rail inwards a good 15-20 feet, and
there is NO question that it's design absorbed a great deal of the impact.
At the very least, if that wall were Concrete, I think both would have taken
a trip in the Helicopter today.
So what is it Mike. Driver safety first, or or conveniencd to the 'show'
that matters the most? I care more that both of them walked away than the
fact that the race was delayed by 2 hours because of the fence repairs.
Yeah, yeah. I know I'm probably making too much out of his statement, but
the announcers seemed to get that feeling too.
-Larry
Mike Helton's comments after Pocono guardrail repair
Larry interpreted NASCAR president Mike Helton as wanting to replace Pocono's guardrail with concrete after the long repair delay following Steve Park and Dale Earnhardt Jr's crash. Others read it differently, and Tom Pabst explained how Armco absorbs energy. Posters agreed the guardrail likely saved the drivers and discussed alternatives like tyre walls.
real motorsport
Automated summary.
>From: "Larry" [email hidden]
>Reading between the lines, and in a way almost directly, he
>indicated that he wanted that guard rail taken down and replaced with
>Concrete because of the extensive repair-time it took and the delay in the
>race.
Wow! I saw the interview, and didn't get that impression at all. He did say
that the only drawback to the guard rail was the time it took to repair, but I
felt he was indicating that Nascar would be looking for improvements, not that
they were considering going back to concrete. Given the outcome of the wreck.
only a fool would suggest that, and Helton may be a lot of things, but I doubt
he is a fool.
George Adams
"From the rockin' of the cradle to the rollin' of the hearse, the goin' up was
worth the comin' down."
___Kris Kristofferson "The Pilgrim/Chapter 33"
"George Adams" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
> >From: "Larry" [email hidden]
>
> >Reading between the lines, and in a way almost directly, he
> >indicated that he wanted that guard rail taken down and replaced with
> >Concrete because of the extensive repair-time it took and the delay inthe
> >race.
>
> Wow! I saw the interview, and didn't get that impression at all. He didsay
> that the only drawback to the guard rail was the time it took to repair,but I
> felt he was indicating that Nascar would be looking for improvements, notthat
> they were considering going back to concrete. Given the outcome of thewreck.
> only a fool would suggest that, and Helton may be a lot of things, but Idoubt
> he is a fool.
>
>
> George Adams
>
> "From the rockin' of the cradle to the rollin' of the hearse, the goin' upwas
> worth the comin' down."
> ___Kris Kristofferson "The Pilgrim/Chapter 33"
I got the same impression as Larry; concrete next year, which isn't a good
idea. On the other hand, it's been pointed out to me, and correctly, having
a guard rail come through your window isn't a good option either.
Hopefully, if it's concrete, it'll be something besides a plain wall.
John
There used to be a time when race car drivers, along with bull fighters and
mountain climbers were singled out as the "Bravest" amongst us. Now we talk
about gaurdrails :-)
Mitch
"Larry" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:3v019.160502$%%[email hidden]...
drivers
> lives today. One for sure. I have serious doubts whether Steve Parkwould
taken
Quoted text (7 lines)
> Mike Helton confused me today in his interview after the railing was fixed > at Pocono. Reading between the lines, and in a way almost directly, he > indicated that he wanted that guard rail taken down and replaced with > Concrete because of the extensive repair-time it took and the delay in the > race. > > Excuse me Mr. Helton, but that Guard Rail, IMHO, possibly saved twoQuoted text (7 lines)
> have survived that crash if it were a concrete barrier there today. Dale > Jr. might not have come out of it too good either. > > Those guys deflected 100 feet of Guard Rail inwards a good 15-20 feet, and > there is NO question that it's design absorbed a great deal of the impact. > > At the very least, if that wall were Concrete, I think both would haveQuoted text (12 lines)
> a trip in the Helicopter today. > > So what is it Mike. Driver safety first, or or conveniencd to the 'show' > that matters the most? I care more that both of them walked away than the > fact that the race was delayed by 2 hours because of the fence repairs. > > Yeah, yeah. I know I'm probably making too much out of his statement, but > the announcers seemed to get that feeling too. > > -Larry > >
"Larry" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:3v019.160502$%%[email hidden]...
drivers
> lives today. One for sure. I have serious doubts whether Steve Parkwould
taken
It is the show that is more important, just look at the series:
Cars that are big hunks of metal with very few parts that are removeable in
a crash (basically sheetmetal.)
No full time safety crews, other series with full time crews have had better
driver safety records, as well as drivers feeling better by knowing the guy
working on them.
Took a few years before they did anything related to drivers deaths, all of
their deaths very much related to another.
NASCAR makes F1 look safe IMO. The only part that I could find that is bad
with the guard rail is that if it had failed, like lets say DEjr behind SP
instead of too the side, it would have gone through, and then probably gone
through a chain link fence (not a good thing to have as a projectiale.) Now
while I don't agree with the fact that both drivers would have died (it was
bad, but not THAT bad) they need to do something to the cars to make them
more crushable.
-Stuart Becktell
Quoted text (7 lines)
> Mike Helton confused me today in his interview after the railing was fixed > at Pocono. Reading between the lines, and in a way almost directly, he > indicated that he wanted that guard rail taken down and replaced with > Concrete because of the extensive repair-time it took and the delay in the > race. > > Excuse me Mr. Helton, but that Guard Rail, IMHO, possibly saved twoQuoted text (7 lines)
> have survived that crash if it were a concrete barrier there today. Dale > Jr. might not have come out of it too good either. > > Those guys deflected 100 feet of Guard Rail inwards a good 15-20 feet, and > there is NO question that it's design absorbed a great deal of the impact. > > At the very least, if that wall were Concrete, I think both would haveQuoted text (12 lines)
> a trip in the Helicopter today. > > So what is it Mike. Driver safety first, or or conveniencd to the 'show' > that matters the most? I care more that both of them walked away than the > fact that the race was delayed by 2 hours because of the fence repairs. > > Yeah, yeah. I know I'm probably making too much out of his statement, but > the announcers seemed to get that feeling too. > > -Larry > > Nah, actually talking about a dumb statement by a moronic series head :)
John
"Mitch Alatorre" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:UK119.34883$[email hidden]...
> There used to be a time when race car drivers, along with bull fightersand
> mountain climbers were singled out as the "Bravest" amongst us. Now wetalk
fixed
> > at Pocono. Reading between the lines, and in a way almost directly, he
> > indicated that he wanted that guard rail taken down and replaced with
> > Concrete because of the extensive repair-time it took and the delay inthe
Dale
> > Jr. might not have come out of it too good either.
> >
> > Those guys deflected 100 feet of Guard Rail inwards a good 15-20 feet,and
> > there is NO question that it's design absorbed a great deal of theimpact.
> >
> > At the very least, if that wall were Concrete, I think both would have
> taken
> > a trip in the Helicopter today.
> >
> > So what is it Mike. Driver safety first, or or conveniencd to the'show'
> > that matters the most? I care more that both of them walked away thanthe
> > fact that the race was delayed by 2 hours because of the fence repairs.
> >
> > Yeah, yeah. I know I'm probably making too much out of his statement,but
Quoted text (7 lines)
> about gaurdrails :-) > > Mitch > > "Larry" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:3v019.160502$%%[email hidden]... > > Mike Helton confused me today in his interview after the railing wasQuoted text (7 lines)
> > race. > > > > Excuse me Mr. Helton, but that Guard Rail, IMHO, possibly saved two > drivers > > lives today. One for sure. I have serious doubts whether Steve Park > would > > have survived that crash if it were a concrete barrier there today.Quoted text (7 lines)
> > the announcers seemed to get that feeling too. > > > > -Larry > > > > > >I can't believe in this day and age that the inside walls at NASCAR
events are still solid concrete in most cases.
It's nice that they put water barrels at the very ends to absorb the
harshest impacts, but I'm amazed they haven't started using tire
barriers on the pit and inside walls a'la F1, since that seems to be
the most effective way of slowing a car.
Jason
On Mon, 29 Jul 2002 01:02:55 GMT, "Larry" <[email hidden]> wrote:
Quoted text (27 lines)
>Mike Helton confused me today in his interview after the railing was fixed >at Pocono. Reading between the lines, and in a way almost directly, he >indicated that he wanted that guard rail taken down and replaced with >Concrete because of the extensive repair-time it took and the delay in the >race. > >Excuse me Mr. Helton, but that Guard Rail, IMHO, possibly saved two drivers >lives today. One for sure. I have serious doubts whether Steve Park would >have survived that crash if it were a concrete barrier there today. Dale >Jr. might not have come out of it too good either. > >Those guys deflected 100 feet of Guard Rail inwards a good 15-20 feet, and >there is NO question that it's design absorbed a great deal of the impact. > >At the very least, if that wall were Concrete, I think both would have taken >a trip in the Helicopter today. > >So what is it Mike. Driver safety first, or or conveniencd to the 'show' >that matters the most? I care more that both of them walked away than the >fact that the race was delayed by 2 hours because of the fence repairs. > >Yeah, yeah. I know I'm probably making too much out of his statement, but >the announcers seemed to get that feeling too. > >-Larry > >Not that I'm necessarily a big Mike Helton fan (I'm not).....I didn't get
the impression you did from his statement today, Larry. I thought he was
trying to indicate that neither armco nor concrete barriers were wholly
adequate in his (NASCAR's) eyes.....both with advantages and disadvantages.
Armco's disadvantage (as he pointed out) was the long delay to repair it
before racing could resume. From the severity of the impact....and
remembering others I've seen in the last few years of similar velocity and
angle.....who hit concrete barriers instead of armco....flying gas tanks and
engines......the disadvantage of concrete barriers is obvious. But, they
can be repaired quickly.....which is only a fact I point out....not my
endorsement of using them.
I have to agree with the idea that it seems....until a better solution comes
around.....maybe from technology of NASA or something of that
nature.....that good old fashion tire stacks (adequately tied together)
fronting concrete barriers that are not anchored nor cabled
together.....with strategically placed water barrels.......is the best
interim solution. All tracks can afford this....and there is no
"technology" that must be acquired to install them.
Mike Helton is known for putting his foot in his mouth. I think today's
statement maybe was just "two toes!" I don't think you'll see concrete
barriers in the infield at Pocono next season.....no way, Jose'!
On a related note:
How many of you guys were thinking today.....after the crash.....that Steve
Park needs to hang it up? I mean....how many times do you have to have
season-ending wrecks to get a clue? And today's wreck....were it not for
the luck of hitting the best barrier possible that could have stopped that
type of an impact....at that angle......should have been a lot more than a
"season-ending" wreck for him! 9 out of 10....any other race track NASCAR
runs at practically.......would have killed him today. I'm not saying the
accidents were Steve's fault...or that he is necessarily a bad driver
(although he does get into a lot of wrecks...along with his bad
ones)......but heck man.....do you think somebody upstairs is maybe sending
you a clue.....get another career? If Steve doesn't quit.....I think DEI
should fire him! And if they did.....I bet you that he would not find a
ride elsewhere NASCAR. It would be tough on his ego....and tough on him
mentally.....but he'd have a good chance of living to be 30 years old. If
he keeps racing....I think his odds are low. And I really, really like
Steve Park......maybe that's why I'm saying this......it was on my mind all
day after the Pocono race.
Regards,
Tom
"Larry" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:3v019.160502$%%[email hidden]...
drivers
> lives today. One for sure. I have serious doubts whether Steve Parkwould
taken
Quoted text (7 lines)
> Mike Helton confused me today in his interview after the railing was fixed > at Pocono. Reading between the lines, and in a way almost directly, he > indicated that he wanted that guard rail taken down and replaced with > Concrete because of the extensive repair-time it took and the delay in the > race. > > Excuse me Mr. Helton, but that Guard Rail, IMHO, possibly saved twoQuoted text (7 lines)
> have survived that crash if it were a concrete barrier there today. Dale > Jr. might not have come out of it too good either. > > Those guys deflected 100 feet of Guard Rail inwards a good 15-20 feet, and > there is NO question that it's design absorbed a great deal of the impact. > > At the very least, if that wall were Concrete, I think both would haveQuoted text (12 lines)
> a trip in the Helicopter today. > > So what is it Mike. Driver safety first, or or conveniencd to the 'show' > that matters the most? I care more that both of them walked away than the > fact that the race was delayed by 2 hours because of the fence repairs. > > Yeah, yeah. I know I'm probably making too much out of his statement, but > the announcers seemed to get that feeling too. > > -Larry > >[email hidden] (jason moyer) wrote in message news:<[email hidden]>...
Depends on what you want. There is no easy solution to this one. If
the angle of impact most likely to be shallow, then concrete would be
preferable as you're just gonna glance and slide. If you have tyres
then you'd snag and the deceleration would be much higher and no fun
at all...
Agreed that there must be a better solution, but I don't know what
that would be if it's to remain a spectator friendly sport.
Mark
Reading, UK
Quoted text (7 lines)
> I can't believe in this day and age that the inside walls at NASCAR > events are still solid concrete in most cases. > > It's nice that they put water barrels at the very ends to absorb the > harshest impacts, but I'm amazed they haven't started using tire > barriers on the pit and inside walls a'la F1, since that seems to be > the most effective way of slowing a car.Why did you bring Tony George and the IRL into this? =)
--
Scott B. Husted
PA-Scott
ICQ# 4395450
http://www.Husted.cc
"John Pancoast" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
> Nah, actually talking about a dumb statement by a moronic series head :)
>
> John
Jeremy Mayfield (I think) ran into a concrete barrier later in the
race. It was that sectional sort of stuff they use for temporary
medians in highway construction. It also gave way and absorbed some
impact. I dont think Mayfield was hurt in the wreck, but I didn't
ever hear for sure.
I won't pretend to know all the plusses and minuses of one barrier
over another, but they were able to get the race restarted in a very
short period of time vs. repairing the metal guardrail.
Maybe if they had long sections of guardrail pre-assembled?
Gerald
"John Pancoast" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:<[email hidden]>...
Quoted text (36 lines)
> "George Adams" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:[email hidden]... > > >From: "Larry" [email hidden] > > > >Reading between the lines, and in a way almost directly, he > > >indicated that he wanted that guard rail taken down and replaced with > > >Concrete because of the extensive repair-time it took and the delay in > the > > >race. > > > > Wow! I saw the interview, and didn't get that impression at all. He did > say > > that the only drawback to the guard rail was the time it took to repair, > but I > > felt he was indicating that Nascar would be looking for improvements, not > that > > they were considering going back to concrete. Given the outcome of the > wreck. > > only a fool would suggest that, and Helton may be a lot of things, but I > doubt > > he is a fool. > > > > > > George Adams > > > > "From the rockin' of the cradle to the rollin' of the hearse, the goin' up > was > > worth the comin' down." > > ___Kris Kristofferson "The Pilgrim/Chapter 33" > > I got the same impression as Larry; concrete next year, which isn't a good > idea. On the other hand, it's been pointed out to me, and correctly, having > a guard rail come through your window isn't a good option either. > Hopefully, if it's concrete, it'll be something besides a plain wall. > > JohnIn article <kn619.156821$[email hidden]>, "Tom Pabst"
<[email hidden]> writes:
>On a related note:
>How many of you guys were thinking today.....after the crash.....that Steve
>Park needs to hang it up? I mean....how many times do you have to have
>season-ending wrecks to get a clue?
But he didn't start that crash - somebody got into him...
>And today's wreck....were it not for
>the luck of hitting the best barrier possible that could have stopped that
>type of an impact....at that angle......should have been a lot more than a
>"season-ending" wreck for him! 9 out of 10....any other race track NASCAR
>runs at practically.......would have killed him today.
I really don't think he would have been killed. Severley injured, maybe.
And since I'm an atheist, I can't comment on your speculation about somebody
upstairs sending him a clue...<g>
Eldred
--
Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett
My .sig file is in the shop for repairs...
Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.
Why not just bring in those portable concrete barriers to fill in the space
in the broken rail until the race ends. Odds against a crash in the same
100 foot space aren't that high and the race resumes sooner.
>
> I have to agree with the idea that it seems....until a better solutioncomes
> around.....maybe from technology of NASA or something of that
> nature.....that good old fashion tire stacks (adequately tied together)
> fronting concrete barriers that are not anchored nor cabled
> together.....with strategically placed water barrels.......is the best
> interim solution. All tracks can afford this....and there is no
> "technology" that must be acquired to install them.
cause you don't want the end of a guard rail sticking out waiting for
someone to hit it.
"John Pancoast" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
not
up
> was
> > worth the comin' down."
> > ___Kris Kristofferson "The Pilgrim/Chapter 33"
>
> I got the same impression as Larry; concrete next year, which isn't agood
> idea. On the other hand, it's been pointed out to me, and correctly,having
> a guard rail come through your window isn't a good option either.
> Hopefully, if it's concrete, it'll be something besides a plain wall.
>
> John
>
I also got the impression that the armco barrier was on the way out in lieu
of concrete or some other type of barrier too. Whatever it ends up being,
they need to take the black box from the 1 car and make sure that the
replacement barrier can displace the amount of G's that the armco did
yesterday. It turned what was going to be a certain bad crash into a series
of glancing blows which increases driver survivability IMHO.
Quoted text (16 lines)
> > "George Adams" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:[email hidden]... > > >From: "Larry" [email hidden] > > > > >Reading between the lines, and in a way almost directly, he > > >indicated that he wanted that guard rail taken down and replaced with > > >Concrete because of the extensive repair-time it took and the delay in > the > > >race. > > > > Wow! I saw the interview, and didn't get that impression at all. He did > say > > that the only drawback to the guard rail was the time it took to repair, > but I > > felt he was indicating that Nascar would be looking for improvements,Quoted text (11 lines)
> that > > they were considering going back to concrete. Given the outcome of the > wreck. > > only a fool would suggest that, and Helton may be a lot of things, but I > doubt > > he is a fool. > > > > > > George Adams > > > > "From the rockin' of the cradle to the rollin' of the hearse, the goin'The armco style guardrail system....relies in part....on the metal rails
being tied together......so the impact is absorbed or distributed throughout
several hundred feet of rail...on either side of the accident's impact zone.
Every place where you break that continuity...you lower the ability of the
guardrail to absorb impacts. While bringing in concrete barriers to the
immediate crash impact site....would fix that portion of the armco....it
would be substantially weakened for a few hundred feet either side of that
impact zone. That's not acceptable....and that's why the armco needed to be
repaired before racing could resume. While the "odds may have been low" for
an exact site duplicate crash....they would not be low....for an accident
occurring later in the race.......somewhere in that general vicinity!
TP
"Tanstaafl" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:Ubd19.10945$[email hidden]...
> Why not just bring in those portable concrete barriers to fill in thespace
Quoted text (15 lines)
> in the broken rail until the race ends. Odds against a crash in the same > 100 foot space aren't that high and the race resumes sooner. > > > > > I have to agree with the idea that it seems....until a better solution > comes > > around.....maybe from technology of NASA or something of that > > nature.....that good old fashion tire stacks (adequately tied together) > > fronting concrete barriers that are not anchored nor cabled > > together.....with strategically placed water barrels.......is the best > > interim solution. All tracks can afford this....and there is no > > "technology" that must be acquired to install them. > > >Eldred...
I didn't state that I thought Steve was at fault.......or to blame for
yesterday's accident...or any of his two previous, "season-ending"
accidents. He was, in fact....not at fault for the others either. They
were not caused by driver error or anything of the like. I think that would
be clear when I said, "I'm not saying the accidents were Steve's fault...or
that he is necessarily a bad driver (although he does get into a lot of
wrecks...along with his bad ones)...." What I was pointing out.....is that
when you are a cat....and you've just used up "life #8"....you might
reasonably conclude that you would discontinue the activity that consumed
life's #1 thru #8.....since you only have one left!
>Eldred: "And since I'm an atheist, I can't comment on your speculationabout somebody
>upstairs sending him a clue...<g>
You just did.
TP
"EldredP" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
> In article <kn619.156821$[email hidden]>, "TomPabst"
> <[email hidden]> writes:
>
> >On a related note:
> >How many of you guys were thinking today.....after the crash.....thatSteve
that
> >type of an impact....at that angle......should have been a lot more thana
> >"season-ending" wreck for him! 9 out of 10....any other race trackNASCAR
> >runs at practically.......would have killed him today.
>
> I really don't think he would have been killed. Severley injured, maybe.
> And since I'm an atheist, I can't comment on your speculation aboutsomebody
Quoted text (7 lines)
> >Park needs to hang it up? I mean....how many times do you have to have > >season-ending wrecks to get a clue? > > But he didn't start that crash - somebody got into him... > > >And today's wreck....were it not for > >the luck of hitting the best barrier possible that could have stoppedQuoted text (8 lines)
> upstairs sending him a clue...<g> > > Eldred > -- > Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett > My .sig file is in the shop for repairs... > > Remove SPAM-OFF to reply. Lol, good point; they need to get in line I guess.
John
"Scott B. Husted" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:Scb19.1398$[email hidden]...
:)
> >
> > John
>
>
>
Quoted text (11 lines)
> Why did you bring Tony George and the IRL into this? =) > > -- > Scott B. Husted > PA-Scott > ICQ# 4395450 > http://www.Husted.cc > > "John Pancoast" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:[email hidden]... > > Nah, actually talking about a dumb statement by a moronic series head
"SimRacer" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:Lsh19.32688$[email hidden]...
in
> > the
> > > >race.
> > >
> > > Wow! I saw the interview, and didn't get that impression at all. Hedid
> > say
> > > that the only drawback to the guard rail was the time it took torepair,
I
goin'
lieu
> of concrete or some other type of barrier too. Whatever it ends up being,
> they need to take the black box from the 1 car and make sure that the
> replacement barrier can displace the amount of G's that the armco did
> yesterday. It turned what was going to be a certain bad crash into aseries
> of glancing blows which increases driver survivability IMHO.
Are they using boxes now ? I know it was considered, but never followed
it after that.
John
>
>
Quoted text (11 lines)
> > "John Pancoast" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:[email hidden]... > > > > "George Adams" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > > news:[email hidden]... > > > >From: "Larry" [email hidden] > > > > > > >Reading between the lines, and in a way almost directly, he > > > >indicated that he wanted that guard rail taken down and replaced with > > > >Concrete because of the extensive repair-time it took and the delayQuoted text (7 lines)
> > but I > > > felt he was indicating that Nascar would be looking for improvements, > not > > that > > > they were considering going back to concrete. Given the outcome of the > > wreck. > > > only a fool would suggest that, and Helton may be a lot of things, butQuoted text (7 lines)
> > doubt > > > he is a fool. > > > > > > > > > George Adams > > > > > > "From the rockin' of the cradle to the rollin' of the hearse, theQuoted text (16 lines)
> up > > was > > > worth the comin' down." > > > ___Kris Kristofferson "The Pilgrim/Chapter 33" > > > > I got the same impression as Larry; concrete next year, which isn't a > good > > idea. On the other hand, it's been pointed out to me, and correctly, > having > > a guard rail come through your window isn't a good option either. > > Hopefully, if it's concrete, it'll be something besides a plain wall. > > > > John > > > > I also got the impression that the armco barrier was on the way out inOn 29 Jul 2002 15:25:55 GMT, [email hidden] (EldredP) wrote:
>And since I'm an atheist, I can't comment on your speculation about somebody
>upstairs sending him a clue...<g>
I was thinking the same thing. =)
Jason
On Mon, 29 Jul 2002 20:53:56 GMT, "Tom Pabst" <[email hidden]>
wrote:
Maybe if you're really superstitious, which I guess most racers are,
so in that sense I am somewhat surprised that he hasn't retired. On
the other hand, and don't mean this as a slap in the face of religion
or anything (do what you have to do, I say), he's probably of the mind
that "when God says it's my time to go, it's my time to go".
Personally, I would have the philosophy of "driving 200mph in unsafe
cars is increasing the odds of me being killed before I turn 50" and
go from there.
If I were him I probably would have retired after the accident at
Atlanta a few years ago. If not then, definitely after the accident
at Darlington. Then again, I doubt I would have the balls to do what
he does for a living anyway.
Jason
Quoted text (10 lines)
>I didn't state that I thought Steve was at fault.......or to blame for >yesterday's accident...or any of his two previous, "season-ending" >accidents. He was, in fact....not at fault for the others either. They >were not caused by driver error or anything of the like. I think that would >be clear when I said, "I'm not saying the accidents were Steve's fault...or >that he is necessarily a bad driver (although he does get into a lot of >wrecks...along with his bad ones)...." What I was pointing out.....is that >when you are a cat....and you've just used up "life #8"....you might >reasonably conclude that you would discontinue the activity that consumed >life's #1 thru #8.....since you only have one left!Jason....I was using the phrase more as a "figure of speech"....but I get
your point.
TP
"jason moyer" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
> On 29 Jul 2002 15:25:55 GMT, [email hidden] (EldredP) wrote:
>
> >And since I'm an atheist, I can't comment on your speculation aboutsomebody
> >upstairs sending him a clue...<g>
>
> I was thinking the same thing. =)
>
> Jason
While I agree with most of your statement, it WAS that bad. In years past I
would have agreed on that part, but after having seen Dale Earnhardt die at
Daytona in a crash with much less energy IMO, I now realize that every crash
is a Bad Crash.
"Stuart Becktell" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:fj219.35702$[email hidden]...
>
> "Larry" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
> news:3v019.160502$%%[email hidden]...
> > Mike Helton confused me today in his interview after the railing wasfixed
> > at Pocono. Reading between the lines, and in a way almost directly, he
> > indicated that he wanted that guard rail taken down and replaced with
> > Concrete because of the extensive repair-time it took and the delay inthe
Dale
> > Jr. might not have come out of it too good either.
> >
> > Those guys deflected 100 feet of Guard Rail inwards a good 15-20 feet,and
> > there is NO question that it's design absorbed a great deal of theimpact.
> >
> > At the very least, if that wall were Concrete, I think both would have
> taken
> > a trip in the Helicopter today.
> >
> > So what is it Mike. Driver safety first, or or conveniencd to the'show'
> > that matters the most? I care more that both of them walked away thanthe
> > fact that the race was delayed by 2 hours because of the fence repairs.
> >
> > Yeah, yeah. I know I'm probably making too much out of his statement,but
in
> a crash (basically sheetmetal.)
> No full time safety crews, other series with full time crews have hadbetter
> driver safety records, as well as drivers feeling better by knowing theguy
> working on them.
> Took a few years before they did anything related to drivers deaths, allof
> their deaths very much related to another.
>
> NASCAR makes F1 look safe IMO. The only part that I could find that is bad
> with the guard rail is that if it had failed, like lets say DEjr behind SP
> instead of too the side, it would have gone through, and then probablygone
> through a chain link fence (not a good thing to have as a projectiale.)Now
> while I don't agree with the fact that both drivers would have died (itwas
> bad, but not THAT bad) they need to do something to the cars to make them
> more crushable.
> -Stuart Becktell
>
>
Quoted text (7 lines)
> > race. > > > > Excuse me Mr. Helton, but that Guard Rail, IMHO, possibly saved two > drivers > > lives today. One for sure. I have serious doubts whether Steve Park > would > > have survived that crash if it were a concrete barrier there today.Quoted text (8 lines)
> > the announcers seemed to get that feeling too. > > > > -Larry > > > > > > It is the show that is more important, just look at the series: > Cars that are big hunks of metal with very few parts that are removeableI know, Tom, just ribbing ya.
No offense meant...
Jason
On Mon, 29 Jul 2002 22:55:39 GMT, "Tom Pabst" <[email hidden]>
wrote:
Quoted text (19 lines)
>Jason....I was using the phrase more as a "figure of speech"....but I get >your point. > >TP > > >"jason moyer" <[email hidden]> wrote in message >news:[email hidden]... >> On 29 Jul 2002 15:25:55 GMT, [email hidden] (EldredP) wrote: >> >> >And since I'm an atheist, I can't comment on your speculation about >somebody >> >upstairs sending him a clue...<g> >> >> I was thinking the same thing. =) >> >> Jason > >"Gerald Moore" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
How about those Tire walls that they have at Infineon (SearsPoint)?
Inexpensive, absorbs impact, and won't destroy themselves after impact. Can
the solution be any simpler?
-Tim
Quoted text (11 lines)
> Jeremy Mayfield (I think) ran into a concrete barrier later in the > race. It was that sectional sort of stuff they use for temporary > medians in highway construction. It also gave way and absorbed some > impact. I dont think Mayfield was hurt in the wreck, but I didn't > ever hear for sure. > > I won't pretend to know all the plusses and minuses of one barrier > over another, but they were able to get the race restarted in a very > short period of time vs. repairing the metal guardrail. > > Maybe if they had long sections of guardrail pre-assembled?"Tom Pabst" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:kn619.156821$[email hidden]...
> .....do you think somebody upstairs is maybe sending
> you a clue.....get another career?
I think it was Rusty Wallace that was trying to send Park a clue and it was
somebody upstairs steering Park into the energy absorbing guardrail at the
perfect angle and keeping the possible threat of fire away so Park can race
next week at the Brickyard.
It seems that somebody upstairs is a Steve Park fan in my opinion!
;)
-Tim
Well, I hope you change one day :)
Phillip
"EldredP" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
> And since I'm an atheist, I can't comment on your speculation aboutsomebody
> upstairs sending him a clue...<g>
>
> Eldred
I think that would somehow violate the sacred sexual bond that has
grown between us.
Er, crap, I promised Eldred I wouldn't mention that on here...
Jason
On Mon, 29 Jul 2002 21:25:10 -0400, "Phillip Malphrus, Jr."
<[email hidden]> wrote:
Quoted text (12 lines)
>Well, I hope you change one day :) > >Phillip > >"EldredP" <[email hidden]> wrote in message >> And since I'm an atheist, I can't comment on your speculation about >somebody >> upstairs sending him a clue...<g> >> >> Eldred > >I think that would somehow violate the sacred *** bond that has
grown between us.
Er, crap, I promised Eldred I wouldn't mention that on here...
Jason
On Mon, 29 Jul 2002 21:25:10 -0400, "Phillip Malphrus, Jr."
Quoted text (11 lines)
>Well, I hope you change one day :) >Phillip >> And since I'm an atheist, I can't comment on your speculation about >somebody >> upstairs sending him a clue...<g> >> EldredIf that was concrete, Dale's car would have squashed Steve's the thickness
of a pencil. Those guys hit at like 150mph or something like that. No roll
cage would have ever survived that.
I honestly believe that if that was a concrete wall, at a minimum Steve Park
would not be with us today.
-Larry
"Stuart Becktell" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:fj219.35702$[email hidden]...
>
> "Larry" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
> news:3v019.160502$%%[email hidden]...
> > Mike Helton confused me today in his interview after the railing wasfixed
> > at Pocono. Reading between the lines, and in a way almost directly, he
> > indicated that he wanted that guard rail taken down and replaced with
> > Concrete because of the extensive repair-time it took and the delay inthe
Dale
> > Jr. might not have come out of it too good either.
> >
> > Those guys deflected 100 feet of Guard Rail inwards a good 15-20 feet,and
> > there is NO question that it's design absorbed a great deal of theimpact.
> >
> > At the very least, if that wall were Concrete, I think both would have
> taken
> > a trip in the Helicopter today.
> >
> > So what is it Mike. Driver safety first, or or conveniencd to the'show'
> > that matters the most? I care more that both of them walked away thanthe
> > fact that the race was delayed by 2 hours because of the fence repairs.
> >
> > Yeah, yeah. I know I'm probably making too much out of his statement,but
in
> a crash (basically sheetmetal.)
> No full time safety crews, other series with full time crews have hadbetter
> driver safety records, as well as drivers feeling better by knowing theguy
> working on them.
> Took a few years before they did anything related to drivers deaths, allof
> their deaths very much related to another.
>
> NASCAR makes F1 look safe IMO. The only part that I could find that is bad
> with the guard rail is that if it had failed, like lets say DEjr behind SP
> instead of too the side, it would have gone through, and then probablygone
> through a chain link fence (not a good thing to have as a projectiale.)Now
> while I don't agree with the fact that both drivers would have died (itwas
> bad, but not THAT bad) they need to do something to the cars to make them
> more crushable.
> -Stuart Becktell
>
>
Quoted text (7 lines)
> > race. > > > > Excuse me Mr. Helton, but that Guard Rail, IMHO, possibly saved two > drivers > > lives today. One for sure. I have serious doubts whether Steve Park > would > > have survived that crash if it were a concrete barrier there today.Quoted text (8 lines)
> > the announcers seemed to get that feeling too. > > > > -Larry > > > > > > It is the show that is more important, just look at the series: > Cars that are big hunks of metal with very few parts that are removeableIt was pretty clear to me that he was far more concerned about the 2 hour
delay in the 'show' than he was about the fact that the guard-rail system
saved Steve Parks life Sunday.
I would have waited a week if it meant Steve climbing out of that car.
That bothered me. A lot.
-Larry
"Tom Pabst" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:kn619.156821$[email hidden]...
> Not that I'm necessarily a big Mike Helton fan (I'm not).....I didn't get
> the impression you did from his statement today, Larry. I thought he was
> trying to indicate that neither armco nor concrete barriers were wholly
> adequate in his (NASCAR's) eyes.....both with advantages anddisadvantages.
> Armco's disadvantage (as he pointed out) was the long delay to repair it
> before racing could resume. From the severity of the impact....and
> remembering others I've seen in the last few years of similar velocity and
> angle.....who hit concrete barriers instead of armco....flying gas tanksand
> engines......the disadvantage of concrete barriers is obvious. But, they
> can be repaired quickly.....which is only a fact I point out....not my
> endorsement of using them.
>
> I have to agree with the idea that it seems....until a better solutioncomes
Steve
sending
> you a clue.....get another career? If Steve doesn't quit.....I think DEI
> should fire him! And if they did.....I bet you that he would not find a
> ride elsewhere NASCAR. It would be tough on his ego....and tough on him
> mentally.....but he'd have a good chance of living to be 30 years old. If
> he keeps racing....I think his odds are low. And I really, really like
> Steve Park......maybe that's why I'm saying this......it was on my mindall
fixed
> > at Pocono. Reading between the lines, and in a way almost directly, he
> > indicated that he wanted that guard rail taken down and replaced with
> > Concrete because of the extensive repair-time it took and the delay inthe
Dale
> > Jr. might not have come out of it too good either.
> >
> > Those guys deflected 100 feet of Guard Rail inwards a good 15-20 feet,and
> > there is NO question that it's design absorbed a great deal of theimpact.
> >
> > At the very least, if that wall were Concrete, I think both would have
> taken
> > a trip in the Helicopter today.
> >
> > So what is it Mike. Driver safety first, or or conveniencd to the'show'
> > that matters the most? I care more that both of them walked away thanthe
> > fact that the race was delayed by 2 hours because of the fence repairs.
> >
> > Yeah, yeah. I know I'm probably making too much out of his statement,but
Quoted text (13 lines)
> around.....maybe from technology of NASA or something of that > nature.....that good old fashion tire stacks (adequately tied together) > fronting concrete barriers that are not anchored nor cabled > together.....with strategically placed water barrels.......is the best > interim solution. All tracks can afford this....and there is no > "technology" that must be acquired to install them. > > Mike Helton is known for putting his foot in his mouth. I think today's > statement maybe was just "two toes!" I don't think you'll see concrete > barriers in the infield at Pocono next season.....no way, Jose'! > > On a related note: > How many of you guys were thinking today.....after the crash.....thatQuoted text (9 lines)
> Park needs to hang it up? I mean....how many times do you have to have > season-ending wrecks to get a clue? And today's wreck....were it not for > the luck of hitting the best barrier possible that could have stopped that > type of an impact....at that angle......should have been a lot more than a > "season-ending" wreck for him! 9 out of 10....any other race track NASCAR > runs at practically.......would have killed him today. I'm not saying the > accidents were Steve's fault...or that he is necessarily a bad driver > (although he does get into a lot of wrecks...along with his bad > ones)......but heck man.....do you think somebody upstairs is maybeQuoted text (11 lines)
> day after the Pocono race. > > Regards, > > Tom > > > > "Larry" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:3v019.160502$%%[email hidden]... > > Mike Helton confused me today in his interview after the railing wasQuoted text (7 lines)
> > race. > > > > Excuse me Mr. Helton, but that Guard Rail, IMHO, possibly saved two > drivers > > lives today. One for sure. I have serious doubts whether Steve Park > would > > have survived that crash if it were a concrete barrier there today.Quoted text (7 lines)
> > the announcers seemed to get that feeling too. > > > > -Larry > > > > > >Eldred,
I've watched that impact 25 times. I am totally convinced that Dale Jr's
car would have squashed Steve's car in completely if that was a no-give
concrete wall.
That was a monstrously SAVAGE hit those guys took, and that guard rail
absorbed an enormous amount of energy.
There's no roll-cage made that would have survived the force of a 3400 pound
car, right smack in the door nose first, at 150 or so mph, hitting a solid,
stationary object like a concrete wall.
-Larry
"EldredP" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
> In article <kn619.156821$[email hidden]>, "TomPabst"
> <[email hidden]> writes:
>
> >On a related note:
> >How many of you guys were thinking today.....after the crash.....thatSteve
that
> >type of an impact....at that angle......should have been a lot more thana
> >"season-ending" wreck for him! 9 out of 10....any other race trackNASCAR
> >runs at practically.......would have killed him today.
>
> I really don't think he would have been killed. Severley injured, maybe.
> And since I'm an atheist, I can't comment on your speculation aboutsomebody
Quoted text (7 lines)
> >Park needs to hang it up? I mean....how many times do you have to have > >season-ending wrecks to get a clue? > > But he didn't start that crash - somebody got into him... > > >And today's wreck....were it not for > >the luck of hitting the best barrier possible that could have stoppedQuoted text (8 lines)
> upstairs sending him a clue...<g> > > Eldred > -- > Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett > My .sig file is in the shop for repairs... > > Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.It just seemed to me that he was more concerned about the 2 hour delay in
the 'show' than he was about the fact that the guardrail saved Steve's Life.
I could be wrong, but that's the way it came across to me.
-Larry
"George Adams" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
> >From: "Larry" [email hidden]
>
> >Reading between the lines, and in a way almost directly, he
> >indicated that he wanted that guard rail taken down and replaced with
> >Concrete because of the extensive repair-time it took and the delay inthe
> >race.
>
> Wow! I saw the interview, and didn't get that impression at all. He didsay
> that the only drawback to the guard rail was the time it took to repair,but I
> felt he was indicating that Nascar would be looking for improvements, notthat
> they were considering going back to concrete. Given the outcome of thewreck.
> only a fool would suggest that, and Helton may be a lot of things, but Idoubt
> he is a fool.
>
>
> George Adams
>
> "From the rockin' of the cradle to the rollin' of the hearse, the goin' upwas
> worth the comin' down."
> ___Kris Kristofferson "The Pilgrim/Chapter 33"
I hope it's not plain concreet. If it is, someone is gonna bite the dust,
eventually :(
-Larry
"John Pancoast" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
not
up
> was
> > worth the comin' down."
> > ___Kris Kristofferson "The Pilgrim/Chapter 33"
>
> I got the same impression as Larry; concrete next year, which isn't agood
> idea. On the other hand, it's been pointed out to me, and correctly,having
> a guard rail come through your window isn't a good option either.
> Hopefully, if it's concrete, it'll be something besides a plain wall.
>
> John
>
>
Quoted text (16 lines)
> > "George Adams" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:[email hidden]... > > >From: "Larry" [email hidden] > > > > >Reading between the lines, and in a way almost directly, he > > >indicated that he wanted that guard rail taken down and replaced with > > >Concrete because of the extensive repair-time it took and the delay in > the > > >race. > > > > Wow! I saw the interview, and didn't get that impression at all. He did > say > > that the only drawback to the guard rail was the time it took to repair, > but I > > felt he was indicating that Nascar would be looking for improvements,Quoted text (11 lines)
> that > > they were considering going back to concrete. Given the outcome of the > wreck. > > only a fool would suggest that, and Helton may be a lot of things, but I > doubt > > he is a fool. > > > > > > George Adams > > > > "From the rockin' of the cradle to the rollin' of the hearse, the goin'BTW... Seeing how that guardrail is designed, and that it stayed together in
strips in that heavy of an impact, I'd be far less worried about taking one
throught the windshield than my car ending up the thickness of a pencil.
-Larry
"John Pancoast" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
not
up
> was
> > worth the comin' down."
> > ___Kris Kristofferson "The Pilgrim/Chapter 33"
>
> I got the same impression as Larry; concrete next year, which isn't agood
> idea. On the other hand, it's been pointed out to me, and correctly,having
> a guard rail come through your window isn't a good option either.
> Hopefully, if it's concrete, it'll be something besides a plain wall.
>
> John
>
>
Quoted text (16 lines)
> > "George Adams" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:[email hidden]... > > >From: "Larry" [email hidden] > > > > >Reading between the lines, and in a way almost directly, he > > >indicated that he wanted that guard rail taken down and replaced with > > >Concrete because of the extensive repair-time it took and the delay in > the > > >race. > > > > Wow! I saw the interview, and didn't get that impression at all. He did > say > > that the only drawback to the guard rail was the time it took to repair, > but I > > felt he was indicating that Nascar would be looking for improvements,Quoted text (11 lines)
> that > > they were considering going back to concrete. Given the outcome of the > wreck. > > only a fool would suggest that, and Helton may be a lot of things, but I > doubt > > he is a fool. > > > > > > George Adams > > > > "From the rockin' of the cradle to the rollin' of the hearse, the goin'That was a different kind of concrete wall in an area not expected to
experience true high-speed hits. If I'm not mistaken, wasn't that
peripheral walling near the entry to the pits?
That would never be used in a 'primary' impact area.
He wasn't going that fast, either. It did launch his car up into the air
though. Thank goodness Dale & Steve didn't hit THAT stuff at 150mph!
-Larry
"Gerald Moore" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
news:<[email hidden]>...
in
> > the
> > > >race.
> > >
> > > Wow! I saw the interview, and didn't get that impression at all. Hedid
> > say
> > > that the only drawback to the guard rail was the time it took torepair,
> > but I
> > > felt he was indicating that Nascar would be looking for improvements,not
> > that
> > > they were considering going back to concrete. Given the outcome of the
> > wreck.
> > > only a fool would suggest that, and Helton may be a lot of things, butI
goin' up
> > was
> > > worth the comin' down."
> > > ___Kris Kristofferson "The Pilgrim/Chapter 33"
> >
> > I got the same impression as Larry; concrete next year, which isn't agood
> > idea. On the other hand, it's been pointed out to me, and correctly,having
> > a guard rail come through your window isn't a good option either.
> > Hopefully, if it's concrete, it'll be something besides a plain wall.
> >
> > John
Quoted text (16 lines)
> Jeremy Mayfield (I think) ran into a concrete barrier later in the > race. It was that sectional sort of stuff they use for temporary > medians in highway construction. It also gave way and absorbed some > impact. I dont think Mayfield was hurt in the wreck, but I didn't > ever hear for sure. > > I won't pretend to know all the plusses and minuses of one barrier > over another, but they were able to get the race restarted in a very > short period of time vs. repairing the metal guardrail. > > Maybe if they had long sections of guardrail pre-assembled? > > Gerald > > > "John Pancoast" <[email hidden]> wrote in messageQuoted text (7 lines)
> > "George Adams" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > > news:[email hidden]... > > > >From: "Larry" [email hidden] > > > > > >Reading between the lines, and in a way almost directly, he > > > >indicated that he wanted that guard rail taken down and replaced with > > > >Concrete because of the extensive repair-time it took and the delayQuoted text (7 lines)
> > doubt > > > he is a fool. > > > > > > > > > George Adams > > > > > > "From the rockin' of the cradle to the rollin' of the hearse, theyeah, it's not like they don't have a few hundred tire carcasses lying
around after a race :)
-Larry
"jason moyer" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
fixed
> >at Pocono. Reading between the lines, and in a way almost directly, he
> >indicated that he wanted that guard rail taken down and replaced with
> >Concrete because of the extensive repair-time it took and the delay inthe
> >race.
> >
> >Excuse me Mr. Helton, but that Guard Rail, IMHO, possibly saved twodrivers
> >lives today. One for sure. I have serious doubts whether Steve Parkwould
> >have survived that crash if it were a concrete barrier there today. Dale
> >Jr. might not have come out of it too good either.
> >
> >Those guys deflected 100 feet of Guard Rail inwards a good 15-20 feet,and
> >there is NO question that it's design absorbed a great deal of theimpact.
> >
> >At the very least, if that wall were Concrete, I think both would havetaken
> >a trip in the Helicopter today.
> >
> >So what is it Mike. Driver safety first, or or conveniencd to the 'show'
> >that matters the most? I care more that both of them walked away thanthe
> >fact that the race was delayed by 2 hours because of the fence repairs.
> >
> >Yeah, yeah. I know I'm probably making too much out of his statement,but
> >the announcers seemed to get that feeling too.
> >
> >-Larry
> >
> >
>
Quoted text (14 lines)
> I can't believe in this day and age that the inside walls at NASCAR > events are still solid concrete in most cases. > > It's nice that they put water barrels at the very ends to absorb the > harshest impacts, but I'm amazed they haven't started using tire > barriers on the pit and inside walls a'la F1, since that seems to be > the most effective way of slowing a car. > > Jason > > > On Mon, 29 Jul 2002 01:02:55 GMT, "Larry" <[email hidden]> wrote: > > >Mike Helton confused me today in his interview after the railing wasAnd since I believe in the God of Creation instead of "The Omnipotent
Gas" theory, I won't comment about your speculation as to the lack of
a God. <g>
Andre Ming
"Tom Pabst" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:<LJj19.164353
$[email hidden]>...
Quoted text (17 lines)
> Jason....I was using the phrase more as a "figure of speech"....but I get > your point. > > TP > > > "jason moyer" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:[email hidden]... > > On 29 Jul 2002 15:25:55 GMT, [email hidden] (EldredP) wrote: > > > > >And since I'm an atheist, I can't comment on your speculation about > somebody > > >upstairs sending him a clue...<g> > > > > I was thinking the same thing. =) > > > > Jason
"John Pancoast" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
<SNIP>
Yes John, AFAIK the black boxes were tested last season and are mandated in
every car starting every NASCAR WC event this year. Apparently they show a
lot of data like G load, speed and angle at impact, pitch, yaw, all that
good stuff. That's how they can tell that the car got loose before the
backing-in to the wall type wrecks. Crew members (at BAM especially) have
seen how bad their car was getting into yaw immediately prior to losing
control. The bad news is that I don't think they (the teams) have direct
access to the data and only get snippets of it when a wreck does occur.
Knowing exactly when your car was starting to yaw at a certain track would
be an invaluable tuning tip for the crew chiefs if they could get the data,
I would think so anyway.
After every wreck experienced by the panel on Inside Winston Cup on Speed
(Ken Schrader, Mike Waltrip, and Johnny Benson) they seem to refer to *their
black box numbers* when discussing the incident so it seems everyone does
indeed have one on board nowadays.
Quoted text (11 lines)
> > "SimRacer" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:Lsh19.32688$[email hidden]... > > > > "John Pancoast" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > > news:[email hidden]... > > > > > > "George Adams" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > > > news:[email hidden]... > > > > >From: "Larry" [email hidden] > > > >Quoted text (7 lines)
> of glancing blows which increases driver survivability IMHO. > > Are they using boxes now ? I know it was considered, but never followed > it after that. > > John >
"Larry" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:0in19.163347$%%[email hidden]...
pound
> car, right smack in the door nose first, at 150 or so mph, hitting asolid,
> stationary object like a concrete wall.
>
THIS is why I would like to see (or hear about at least) the black box data
from both Junior's and Steve's cars. We don't have a similar crash with data
available to compare it too, but this was a better test than driving cars
into softwalls or cars equuipped with the Humpy bumper into regular walls,
at 45-50 mph I'd think.
Quoted text (10 lines)
> Eldred, > > I've watched that impact 25 times. I am totally convinced that Dale Jr's > car would have squashed Steve's car in completely if that was a no-give > concrete wall. > > That was a monstrously SAVAGE hit those guys took, and that guard rail > absorbed an enormous amount of energy. > > There's no roll-cage made that would have survived the force of a 3400Actually....there doesn't need to be any degradation of the roll cage
integrity - to kill you instantly - in a high speed impact like that. The
fact that Dale's car was behind Park could have actually helped reduce the
chances of Park being killed. Like the fall from a building, "Its not the
fall that kills you. Its that sudden stop at the bottom!"
Concrete would have likely created a greater deceleration of Park's race
car. The human's internal organs can not withstand sudden stops. The
heart, suspended very loosely in its cavity by light bands of muscle, is a
heavy mass. It moves forward in the chest wall rapidly, while the aorta
(the largest artery coming directly off the top of the heart - very well
secured and tightly held) doesn't move with the heart mass. That causes a
rip of the aorta - right at the exit from the heart. You have about 10
seconds of life left, when that happens. Most autopsies of auto related
deaths, show this "rip" between the aorta and heart. While there may or may
not be other collateral damage to the body from things hitting it, the death
occurred from the aorta rip. The idea of armco....is to slow the
deceleration of something hitting it. It acts like a huge "rubber band" if
you want to think of it that way. With Dale's car behind Park's, the extra
mass would have pushed the armco back even further than Park's car would
have alone....thus spreading the deceleration over a larger
distance.....providing a more survivable impact - not a less survivable
impact.
I hope that makes sense? I know it does but it may seem contrary to what
you guys are thinking about what kills you in a high-speed crash. I've only
hit armco at a fairly high speed once during my racing career. As is the
case in all accidents, your "memory" of it is very much in slow motion. I
hit the armco coming out of T-1 at Portland International Raceway, in a GT-3
Porsche, doing about 40 mph (estimated at the time of impact). It was at an
angle about 60 degrees or so. I remember the deceleration (the "thump" as I
call it) being much slower than my mind was prepared for when I saw that
armco wall coming at me! I also was very aware that the race car then was
launched backwards and off the barrier after the initial "hit" - and that
surprised me at the time! It actually felt like I'd struck a huge rubber
band. I wasn't badly injured thank goodness. But I had pretty bad bruising
across my belly, and from the top of my shoulders to about my breast area,
on both sides. There was actually some sub-dermal hematoma's on my
shoulders where the seat belts gripped me. But the next day, all the pain
was internal. I literally could not walk or talk - any movement of my body
made an extremely painful feeling in my stomach and chest - almost like
really bad gas pains or something. Its hard to describe. I was told that
had I been going maybe 10 mph faster, and hit at an angle closer to 90
degrees or so, I might not have been so lucky. It was something I will
never forget, not ever. Its the only bad accident I had in 10 years or so
of full-season competition racing. I wasn't really fast enough to get
myself in more trouble.....lol....!!
Regards,
Tom
PS: As a side note to this accident. It occurred in an SCCA sanctioned
race. One of the rules of the SCCA (Portland Region) was that if you hit
the armco at Portland, you had to pay the race track for its subsequent
repair. Besides the damage to my Porsche GT-3 race car, I had to pay PIR
about $1,500 to fix the armco in T-1. Ouch! My checkbook sustained
internal injuries as well as my body! ....lol.....
"Larry" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:0in19.163347$%%[email hidden]...
pound
> car, right smack in the door nose first, at 150 or so mph, hitting asolid,
than
> a
> > >"season-ending" wreck for him! 9 out of 10....any other race track
> NASCAR
> > >runs at practically.......would have killed him today.
> >
> > I really don't think he would have been killed. Severley injured,maybe.
Quoted text (10 lines)
> Eldred, > > I've watched that impact 25 times. I am totally convinced that Dale Jr's > car would have squashed Steve's car in completely if that was a no-give > concrete wall. > > That was a monstrously SAVAGE hit those guys took, and that guard rail > absorbed an enormous amount of energy. > > There's no roll-cage made that would have survived the force of a 3400Quoted text (22 lines)
> stationary object like a concrete wall. > > -Larry > > "EldredP" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:[email hidden]... > > In article <kn619.156821$[email hidden]>, "Tom > Pabst" > > <[email hidden]> writes: > > > > >On a related note: > > >How many of you guys were thinking today.....after the crash.....that > Steve > > >Park needs to hang it up? I mean....how many times do you have to have > > >season-ending wrecks to get a clue? > > > > But he didn't start that crash - somebody got into him... > > > > >And today's wreck....were it not for > > >the luck of hitting the best barrier possible that could have stopped > that > > >type of an impact....at that angle......should have been a lot moreQuoted text (12 lines)
> > And since I'm an atheist, I can't comment on your speculation about > somebody > > upstairs sending him a clue...<g> > > > > Eldred > > -- > > Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett > > My .sig file is in the shop for repairs... > > > > Remove SPAM-OFF to reply. > >Tim...
Another way to look at it, using your perspective:
You are already a **fan** of "The Man" upstairs, when he sends you warnings!
If he doesn't like you - you don't get warnings! You know what I mean?
Tom
-:)
"Tim Miser" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
> "Tom Pabst" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
> news:kn619.156821$[email hidden]...
> > .....do you think somebody upstairs is maybe sending
> > you a clue.....get another career?
>
> I think it was Rusty Wallace that was trying to send Park a clue and itwas
> somebody upstairs steering Park into the energy absorbing guardrail at the
> perfect angle and keeping the possible threat of fire away so Park canrace
Quoted text (9 lines)
> next week at the Brickyard. > > It seems that somebody upstairs is a Steve Park fan in my opinion! > ;) > > -Tim > > >In article <0in19.163347$%%[email hidden]>, "Larry"
<[email hidden]> writes:
>Eldred,
>
>I've watched that impact 25 times. I am totally convinced that Dale Jr's
>car would have squashed Steve's car in completely if that was a no-give
>concrete wall.
Well, I don't have the 'luxury' of reviewing it. I didn't tape the race, and I
haven't found where to download it free yet...
Eldred
--
Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett
My .sig file is in the shop for repairs...
Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.
In article <[email hidden]>, [email hidden] (jason
moyer) writes:
>Er, crap, I promised Eldred I wouldn't mention that on here...
>
>Jason
Jason has just been removed from the invite list on my server. He won't be
playing with us anymore...<g>
Eldred
--
Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett
My .sig file is in the shop for repairs...
Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.
"SimRacer" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:POy19.35239$[email hidden]...
followed
> > it after that.
> >
> > John
> >
>
> Yes John, AFAIK the black boxes were tested last season and are mandatedin
data,
> I would think so anyway.
>
> After every wreck experienced by the panel on Inside Winston Cup on Speed
> (Ken Schrader, Mike Waltrip, and Johnny Benson) they seem to refer to*their
> black box numbers* when discussing the incident so it seems everyone does
> indeed have one on board nowadays.
Ok, thanks. Have to admit, I don't follow the daily stuff near as much as
I used to since Dale died.
John
>
>
Quoted text (19 lines)
> > "John Pancoast" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:[email hidden]... > > > > "SimRacer" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > > news:Lsh19.32688$[email hidden]... > > > > > > "John Pancoast" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > > > news:[email hidden]... > > > > > > > > "George Adams" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > > > > news:[email hidden]... > > > > > >From: "Larry" [email hidden] > > > > > > <SNIP> > > > of glancing blows which increases driver survivability IMHO. > > > > Are they using boxes now ? I know it was considered, but neverQuoted text (9 lines)
> every car starting every NASCAR WC event this year. Apparently they show a > lot of data like G load, speed and angle at impact, pitch, yaw, all that > good stuff. That's how they can tell that the car got loose before the > backing-in to the wall type wrecks. Crew members (at BAM especially) have > seen how bad their car was getting into yaw immediately prior to losing > control. The bad news is that I don't think they (the teams) have direct > access to the data and only get snippets of it when a wreck does occur. > Knowing exactly when your car was starting to yaw at a certain track would > be an invaluable tuning tip for the crew chiefs if they could get theWe really should close this thread right now, before it gets out of hand :)
-Larry
"L.A. Ming" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
get
Quoted text (9 lines)
> And since I believe in the God of Creation instead of "The Omnipotent > Gas" theory, I won't comment about your speculation as to the lack of > a God. <g> > > Andre Ming > > "Tom Pabst" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:<LJj19.164353 > $[email hidden]>... > > Jason....I was using the phrase more as a "figure of speech"....but IQuoted text (16 lines)
> > your point. > > > > TP > > > > > > "jason moyer" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > > news:[email hidden]... > > > On 29 Jul 2002 15:25:55 GMT, [email hidden] (EldredP) wrote: > > > > > > >And since I'm an atheist, I can't comment on your speculation about > > somebody > > > >upstairs sending him a clue...<g> > > > > > > I was thinking the same thing. =) > > > > > > JasonIn article <EXh19.176468$Wt3.129931@rwcrnsc53>, "Tom Pabst" <[email hidden]>
writes:
> What I was pointing out.....is that
>when you are a cat....and you've just used up "life #8"....you might
>reasonably conclude that you would discontinue the activity that consumed
>life's #1 thru #8.....since you only have one left!
But if you don't believe you're at fault, there's less incentive to quit. I'm
sure that if he felt his skills had deteriorated to the point where the danger
was enhanced, he'd quit. Otherwise, what's he gonna do? He's a race car
driver...
Eldred
--
Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett
My .sig file is in the shop for repairs...
Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.
Eldred.....
You can come to my house and watch it. Okay?
TP
-:)
"EldredP" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
and I
Quoted text (10 lines)
> In article <0in19.163347$%%[email hidden]>, "Larry" > <[email hidden]> writes: > > >Eldred, > > > >I've watched that impact 25 times. I am totally convinced that Dale Jr's > >car would have squashed Steve's car in completely if that was a no-give > >concrete wall. > > Well, I don't have the 'luxury' of reviewing it. I didn't tape the race,Quoted text (8 lines)
> haven't found where to download it free yet... > > Eldred > -- > Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett > My .sig file is in the shop for repairs... > > Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.In article <3xK19.98391$uh7.16605@sccrnsc03>, "Tom Pabst" <[email hidden]>
writes:
>Eldred.....
>
>You can come to my house and watch it. Okay?
>
Sure - I'll fly out to California tomorrow...<g>
Eldred
--
Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett
My .sig file is in the shop for repairs...
Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.
Okay...perfect! Tell me what flight you are coming in on, I'll send a limo!
Do you want a blonde or a redhead driver? And, after reading a few of your
posts, I guess I should also ask, "male or female"........lol.... Just
kidding you....honest!
Tom
-:)
"EldredP" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
> In article <3xK19.98391$uh7.16605@sccrnsc03>, "Tom Pabst"<[email hidden]>
Quoted text (15 lines)
> writes: > > >Eldred..... > > > >You can come to my house and watch it. Okay? > > > > Sure - I'll fly out to California tomorrow...<g> > > Eldred > -- > Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett > My .sig file is in the shop for repairs... > > Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.In article <c4429.742062$cQ3.115491@sccrnsc01>, "Tom Pabst" <[email hidden]>
writes:
>Okay...perfect! Tell me what flight you are coming in on, I'll send a limo!
>Do you want a blonde or a redhead driver? And, after reading a few of your
>posts, I guess I should also ask, "male or female"........lol.... Just
>kidding you....honest!
What?!? Geez...
Eldred
--
Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett
My .sig file is in the shop for repairs...
Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.


































