Guys,
My brother has been accused of using this 'cheat' in some guys' fixed setup
league. They claim to have some patch that detects that cheat and others
that the papy server.exe cannot catch.
Anyone who knows Jeff (who is pretty average at racing online) would laugh
at the idea that Jeff's lap times in fixed setup racing are faster than some
'very experienced open setup leagues'.
Of course, this league he is in won't mention just who those leagues might
be but I was wondering if anyone else has heard about a patch that is
catching cheats Papy cannot?
Tim White
www.birds-i-view.com/intrac
NASCAR Racing 2002 memory cheat and detection tools
Tim said his brother had been falsely accused of using a known NASCAR Racing 2002 cheat that resets tyre wear by editing memory, apparently because of a hot-key utility. Posters confirmed the cheat dated back to early Papyrus titles and worked mainly on Windows 9x, and discussed detection approaches such as client programs that check running processes and randomised memory layouts. Opinions differed on whether imperfect detection does more good than harm.
Automated summary.
>"Tim" <[email hidden]> wrote
> Of course, this league he is in won't mention just who those leagues might
> be but I was wondering if anyone else has heard about a patch that is
> catching cheats Papy cannot?
It's I hope common knowledge that there is a (true) cheat for NR2002 that
permits tyre wear and other stuff to be restarted to zero, therefore giving
them an obvious advantage. It's a reason why many people have stopped
racing online. I doubt there is a software that can catch cheaters.
I also speculate (others too) that since we are more near NR2003 then the
release of NR2002 back at the start of the year, Papyrus has gave up on
NR2002. I would hope not, but remember that they only care about
profitability. Only.
Oh btw I doubt Jeff cheats ;-)
--
-- Fran�ois M�nard <ymenard>
-- http://www.ymenard.8m.com/
-- This announcement is brought to you by the Shimago-Dominguez
Corporation - helping America into the New World...
I too have heard about the cheat mentioned; haven't heard anything about a
"patch" to detect it. Sounds like Jeff's getting railroaded.
John
"ymenard" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:dq239.10472$[email hidden]...
> >"Tim" <[email hidden]> wrote
> > Of course, this league he is in won't mention just who those leaguesmight
> > be but I was wondering if anyone else has heard about a patch that is
> > catching cheats Papy cannot?
>
>
> It's I hope common knowledge that there is a (true) cheat for NR2002 that
> permits tyre wear and other stuff to be restarted to zero, thereforegiving
Quoted text (20 lines)
> them an obvious advantage. It's a reason why many people have stopped > racing online. I doubt there is a software that can catch cheaters. > > > I also speculate (others too) that since we are more near NR2003 then the > release of NR2002 back at the start of the year, Papyrus has gave up on > NR2002. I would hope not, but remember that they only care about > profitability. Only. > > Oh btw I doubt Jeff cheats ;-) > > > -- > -- Fran�ois M�nard <ymenard> > -- http://www.ymenard.8m.com/ > -- This announcement is brought to you by the Shimago-Dominguez > Corporation - helping America into the New World... > > >There's some info on the Sierra board that Mike Baker has written a patch to
detect possible cheats by somehow reviewing programs running in the
background.
I think it would probably assume that even the NR Asst option of enabling
the F11 & F12 keys would be some sort of cheat, since it is a "hot key" prog
running in the background.
"Tim" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:Sp139.44965$[email hidden]...
> Guys,
>
> My brother has been accused of using this 'cheat' in some guys' fixedsetup
> league. They claim to have some patch that detects that cheat and others
> that the papy server.exe cannot catch.
>
> Anyone who knows Jeff (who is pretty average at racing online) would laugh
> at the idea that Jeff's lap times in fixed setup racing are faster thansome
Quoted text (12 lines)
> 'very experienced open setup leagues'. > > Of course, this league he is in won't mention just who those leagues might > be but I was wondering if anyone else has heard about a patch that is > catching cheats Papy cannot? > > Tim White > www.birds-i-view.com/intrac > > > >Thats interesting...
Jeff's uses a lightpen & pad for artwork that uses those keys F11, and or
F12.
You'd think if someone was going to write a hack to detect if certain keys
are enabled they would bother to look into if any other software was using
them, and what software that was.
Man, if their only way of detecting a cheat is to see what keys are avail,
man thats lame. Hell I could do that LOL
--
Tim White
www.intracmotorsports.com
"Bob G" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:9n439.16791$[email hidden]...
> There's some info on the Sierra board that Mike Baker has written a patch
to
> detect possible cheats by somehow reviewing programs running in the
> background.
>
> I think it would probably assume that even the NR Asst option of enabling
> the F11 & F12 keys would be some sort of cheat, since it is a "hot key"
prog
> running in the background.
>
>
> "Tim" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
> news:Sp139.44965$[email hidden]...
> > Guys,
> >
> > My brother has been accused of using this 'cheat' in some guys' fixed
> setup
> > league. They claim to have some patch that detects that cheat and
others
> > that the papy server.exe cannot catch.
> >
> > Anyone who knows Jeff (who is pretty average at racing online) would
laugh
> > at the idea that Jeff's lap times in fixed setup racing are faster than
> some
> > 'very experienced open setup leagues'.
> >
> > Of course, this league he is in won't mention just who those leagues
might
> > be but I was wondering if anyone else has heard about a patch that is
> > catching cheats Papy cannot?
> >
> > Tim White
> > www.birds-i-view.com/intrac
> >
> >
> >
> >
>
>
I never heard about this until right now.
David G Fisher
"ymenard" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:dq239.10472$[email hidden]...
> >
> It's I hope common knowledge that there is a (true) cheat for NR2002 that
> permits tyre wear and other stuff to be restarted to zero, thereforegiving
Quoted text (11 lines)
> them an obvious advantage. It's a reason why many people have stopped > racing online. I doubt there is a software that can catch cheaters. > > > I also speculate (others too) that since we are more near NR2003 then the > release of NR2002 back at the start of the year, Papyrus has gave up on > NR2002. I would hope not, but remember that they only care about > profitability. Only. > > Oh btw I doubt Jeff cheats ;-) >that cheat has been around since TEN,,,,,
"John Pancoast" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]...
: I too have heard about the cheat mentioned; haven't heard anything about a
: "patch" to detect it. Sounds like Jeff's getting railroaded.
:
: John
:
:
: "ymenard" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
: news:dq239.10472$[email hidden]...
: > >"Tim" <[email hidden]> wrote
: > > Of course, this league he is in won't mention just who those leagues
: might
: > > be but I was wondering if anyone else has heard about a patch that is
: > > catching cheats Papy cannot?
: >
: >
: > It's I hope common knowledge that there is a (true) cheat for NR2002 that
: > permits tyre wear and other stuff to be restarted to zero, therefore
: giving
: > them an obvious advantage. It's a reason why many people have stopped
: > racing online. I doubt there is a software that can catch cheaters.
: >
: >
: > I also speculate (others too) that since we are more near NR2003 then the
: > release of NR2002 back at the start of the year, Papyrus has gave up on
: > NR2002. I would hope not, but remember that they only care about
: > profitability. Only.
: >
: > Oh btw I doubt Jeff cheats ;-)
: >
: >
: > --
: > -- Fran�ois M�nard <ymenard>
: > -- http://www.ymenard.8m.com/
: > -- This announcement is brought to you by the Shimago-Dominguez
: > Corporation - helping America into the New World...
: >
: >
: >
:
:
Tim, you shouldn't be so critical of this.
Of course this key detection method (if that's really what it is) isn't
optimal, but at least, it's an attempt. More than most of us have done to
help doing something against the cheat situation.
Anything that can detect cheats, and even if it doesn't work 100%, is a
welcome means of prevention against cheats. Cheaters must be left in
uncertainty as to whether they can be detected, so as to at least perhaps
prevent the more consciencious or timid ones from trying it.
Negative side effects are annoying, but these are not the fault of those who
try to write cheat detection programs, they're the fault of those who write
and use cheats.
Achim
"Tim" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:6%539.45442$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (14 lines)
> Thats interesting... > > Jeff's uses a lightpen & pad for artwork that uses those keys F11, and or > F12. > You'd think if someone was going to write a hack to detect if certain keys > are enabled they would bother to look into if any other software was using > them, and what software that was. > > Man, if their only way of detecting a cheat is to see what keys are avail, > man thats lame. Hell I could do that LOL > > -- > Tim White > www.intracmotorsports.com"David G Fisher" wrote...
> I never heard about this until right now.
I've seen it mentioned... haven't felt the urge to look into it yet. If
someone needs to cheat to beat me that's pretty lame, I think.
Jan.
=---
In article <[email hidden]>, [email hidden]
says...
How ironic. He's being railroaded because he was driving like he
was on rails.
Quoted text (41 lines)
> I too have heard about the cheat mentioned; haven't heard anything about a > "patch" to detect it. Sounds like Jeff's getting railroaded. > > John > > > "ymenard" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:dq239.10472$[email hidden]... > > >"Tim" <[email hidden]> wrote > > > Of course, this league he is in won't mention just who those leagues > might > > > be but I was wondering if anyone else has heard about a patch that is > > > catching cheats Papy cannot? > > > > > > It's I hope common knowledge that there is a (true) cheat for NR2002 that > > permits tyre wear and other stuff to be restarted to zero, therefore > giving > > them an obvious advantage. It's a reason why many people have stopped > > racing online. I doubt there is a software that can catch cheaters. > > > > > > I also speculate (others too) that since we are more near NR2003 then the > > release of NR2002 back at the start of the year, Papyrus has gave up on > > NR2002. I would hope not, but remember that they only care about > > profitability. Only. > > > > Oh btw I doubt Jeff cheats ;-) > > > > > > -- > > -- Fran�ois M�nard <ymenard> > > -- http://www.ymenard.8m.com/ > > -- This announcement is brought to you by the Shimago-Dominguez > > Corporation - helping America into the New World... > > > > > > > > >In article <dq239.10472$[email hidden]>, "ymenard"
<[email hidden]> writes:
>It's I hope common knowledge that there is a (true) cheat for NR2002 that
>permits tyre wear and other stuff to be restarted to zero, therefore giving
>them an obvious advantage.
Damn, I hadn't heard that... That sucks...
Eldred
--
Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett
GPLRank:+8.09
N2002 Rank:+22.329
Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.
I didn't mean that simply using the F11 & F12 keys could be detected as a
possible cheat. The NR Assistant program contains a KeyboardHook.dll, that
when enabled will cycle through the other keys so you don't have to hunt
for and press them individually.
I don't know that Baker's patch actually detects this particular routine. I
was just make an assumption since it is a hotkey prog running in the
background behind N2K2.
"Tim" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:6%539.45442$[email hidden]...
patch
> to
> > detect possible cheats by somehow reviewing programs running in the
> > background.
> >
> > I think it would probably assume that even the NR Asst option ofenabling
than
Quoted text (19 lines)
> Thats interesting... > > Jeff's uses a lightpen & pad for artwork that uses those keys F11, and or > F12. > You'd think if someone was going to write a hack to detect if certain keys > are enabled they would bother to look into if any other software was using > them, and what software that was. > > Man, if their only way of detecting a cheat is to see what keys are avail, > man thats lame. Hell I could do that LOL > > -- > Tim White > www.intracmotorsports.com > > > "Bob G" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:9n439.16791$[email hidden]... > > There's some info on the Sierra board that Mike Baker has written aQuoted text (18 lines)
> > the F11 & F12 keys would be some sort of cheat, since it is a "hot key" > prog > > running in the background. > > > > > > "Tim" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > > news:Sp139.44965$[email hidden]... > > > Guys, > > > > > > My brother has been accused of using this 'cheat' in some guys' fixed > > setup > > > league. They claim to have some patch that detects that cheat and > others > > > that the papy server.exe cannot catch. > > > > > > Anyone who knows Jeff (who is pretty average at racing online) would > laugh > > > at the idea that Jeff's lap times in fixed setup racing are fasterQuoted text (18 lines)
> > some > > > 'very experienced open setup leagues'. > > > > > > Of course, this league he is in won't mention just who those leagues > might > > > be but I was wondering if anyone else has heard about a patch that is > > > catching cheats Papy cannot? > > > > > > Tim White > > > www.birds-i-view.com/intrac > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > >Achim,
You know, for awhile I considered your opinions on sim issues valuable but
what you just said was almost as lame as what happen to Jeff LOL
Jeff, like I said is average at best, and was waxing their butts in their
league. Jeff asked me to join and I waxed HIS butt and they didnt call me a
cheater.
Your points about trying to do the right thing for the community is valid.
Was is not is making the assumption that decent people who play fair must
suffer. Jeff isn't bent out of shape over this. It was (IN MY OPNION) a
lame league, 25% moderate damage, 1/3 of all their racing was under caution.
But, I'm glad to see that the innocent need to suffer for the greater good,
EVEN IN AMERICA LOL !!!
--
Tim White
www.intracmotorsports.com
"Joachim Trensz" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:aiirc1$14m4r3$[email hidden]...
> Tim, you shouldn't be so critical of this.
>
> Of course this key detection method (if that's really what it is) isn't
> optimal, but at least, it's an attempt. More than most of us have done to
> help doing something against the cheat situation.
>
> Anything that can detect cheats, and even if it doesn't work 100%, is a
> welcome means of prevention against cheats. Cheaters must be left in
> uncertainty as to whether they can be detected, so as to at least perhaps
> prevent the more consciencious or timid ones from trying it.
>
> Negative side effects are annoying, but these are not the fault of those
who
> try to write cheat detection programs, they're the fault of those who
write
> and use cheats.
>
> Achim
>
>
> "Tim" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
> news:6%539.45442$[email hidden]...
> > Thats interesting...
> >
> > Jeff's uses a lightpen & pad for artwork that uses those keys F11, and
or
> > F12.
> > You'd think if someone was going to write a hack to detect if certain
keys
> > are enabled they would bother to look into if any other software was
using
> > them, and what software that was.
> >
> > Man, if their only way of detecting a cheat is to see what keys are
avail,
> > man thats lame. Hell I could do that LOL
> >
> > --
> > Tim White
> > www.intracmotorsports.com
>
>
I didn't mean that simply using the F11 & F12 keys could be detected as a
possible cheat. The NR Assistant program contains a KeyboardHook.dll, that
when enabled will cycle through the other keys so you don't have to hunt
for and press them individually.
I don't know that Baker's patch actually detects this particular routine. I
was just make an assumption since it is a hotkey prog running in the
background behind N2K2.
"Tim" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:6%539.45442$[email hidden]...
patch
> to
> > detect possible cheats by somehow reviewing programs running in the
> > background.
> >
> > I think it would probably assume that even the NR Asst option ofenabling
than
Quoted text (19 lines)
> Thats interesting... > > Jeff's uses a lightpen & pad for artwork that uses those keys F11, and or > F12. > You'd think if someone was going to write a hack to detect if certain keys > are enabled they would bother to look into if any other software was using > them, and what software that was. > > Man, if their only way of detecting a cheat is to see what keys are avail, > man thats lame. Hell I could do that LOL > > -- > Tim White > www.intracmotorsports.com > > > "Bob G" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:9n439.16791$[email hidden]... > > There's some info on the Sierra board that Mike Baker has written aQuoted text (18 lines)
> > the F11 & F12 keys would be some sort of cheat, since it is a "hot key" > prog > > running in the background. > > > > > > "Tim" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > > news:Sp139.44965$[email hidden]... > > > Guys, > > > > > > My brother has been accused of using this 'cheat' in some guys' fixed > > setup > > > league. They claim to have some patch that detects that cheat and > others > > > that the papy server.exe cannot catch. > > > > > > Anyone who knows Jeff (who is pretty average at racing online) would > laugh > > > at the idea that Jeff's lap times in fixed setup racing are fasterQuoted text (18 lines)
> > some > > > 'very experienced open setup leagues'. > > > > > > Of course, this league he is in won't mention just who those leagues > might > > > be but I was wondering if anyone else has heard about a patch that is > > > catching cheats Papy cannot? > > > > > > Tim White > > > www.birds-i-view.com/intrac > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > >You're just a regular butt waxer, aren't you. (-:
disclaimer: this post has absolutely no pertinent information or moral
value.
--
Mike Grandy
www.precision-racing.com
"Tim" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:dlc39.50179$[email hidden]...
> Achim,
>
> You know, for awhile I considered your opinions on sim issues valuable but
> what you just said was almost as lame as what happen to Jeff LOL
>
> Jeff, like I said is average at best, and was waxing their butts in their
> league. Jeff asked me to join and I waxed HIS butt and they didnt call me
a
> cheater.
>
> Your points about trying to do the right thing for the community is valid.
> Was is not is making the assumption that decent people who play fair must
> suffer. Jeff isn't bent out of shape over this. It was (IN MY OPNION) a
> lame league, 25% moderate damage, 1/3 of all their racing was under
caution.
>
> But, I'm glad to see that the innocent need to suffer for the greater
good,
> EVEN IN AMERICA LOL !!!
>
> --
> Tim White
> www.intracmotorsports.com
>
>
> "Joachim Trensz" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
> news:aiirc1$14m4r3$[email hidden]...
> > Tim, you shouldn't be so critical of this.
> >
> > Of course this key detection method (if that's really what it is) isn't
> > optimal, but at least, it's an attempt. More than most of us have done
to
> > help doing something against the cheat situation.
> >
> > Anything that can detect cheats, and even if it doesn't work 100%, is a
> > welcome means of prevention against cheats. Cheaters must be left in
> > uncertainty as to whether they can be detected, so as to at least
perhaps
> > prevent the more consciencious or timid ones from trying it.
> >
> > Negative side effects are annoying, but these are not the fault of those
> who
> > try to write cheat detection programs, they're the fault of those who
> write
> > and use cheats.
> >
> > Achim
> >
> >
> > "Tim" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
> > news:6%539.45442$[email hidden]...
> > > Thats interesting...
> > >
> > > Jeff's uses a lightpen & pad for artwork that uses those keys F11, and
> or
> > > F12.
> > > You'd think if someone was going to write a hack to detect if certain
> keys
> > > are enabled they would bother to look into if any other software was
> using
> > > them, and what software that was.
> > >
> > > Man, if their only way of detecting a cheat is to see what keys are
> avail,
> > > man thats lame. Hell I could do that LOL
> > >
> > > --
> > > Tim White
> > > www.intracmotorsports.com
> >
> >
>
>
>"Joachim Trensz" <[email hidden]> wrote
> Negative side effects are annoying, but these are not the fault of thosewho
> try to write cheat detection programs, they're the fault of those whowrite
> and use cheats.
The fault is to Papyrus, for not fixing the holes they left open for
cheaters.
--
-- Fran�ois M�nard <ymenard>
-- http://www.ymenard.8m.com/
-- This announcement is brought to you by the Shimago-Dominguez
Corporation - helping America into the New World...
All butt yours VBG
--
Tim White
www.intracmotorsports.com
"Mike Grandy" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:cve39.80662$[email hidden]...
> You're just a regular butt waxer, aren't you. (-:
>
> disclaimer: this post has absolutely no pertinent information or moral
> value.
>
> --
> Mike Grandy
> www.precision-racing.com
> "Tim" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
> news:dlc39.50179$[email hidden]...
> > Achim,
> >
> > You know, for awhile I considered your opinions on sim issues valuable
but
> > what you just said was almost as lame as what happen to Jeff LOL
> >
> > Jeff, like I said is average at best, and was waxing their butts in
their
> > league. Jeff asked me to join and I waxed HIS butt and they didnt call
me
> a
> > cheater.
> >
> > Your points about trying to do the right thing for the community is
valid.
> > Was is not is making the assumption that decent people who play fair
must
> > suffer. Jeff isn't bent out of shape over this. It was (IN MY OPNION)
a
> > lame league, 25% moderate damage, 1/3 of all their racing was under
> caution.
> >
> > But, I'm glad to see that the innocent need to suffer for the greater
> good,
> > EVEN IN AMERICA LOL !!!
> >
> > --
> > Tim White
> > www.intracmotorsports.com
> >
> >
> > "Joachim Trensz" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
> > news:aiirc1$14m4r3$[email hidden]...
> > > Tim, you shouldn't be so critical of this.
> > >
> > > Of course this key detection method (if that's really what it is)
isn't
> > > optimal, but at least, it's an attempt. More than most of us have done
> to
> > > help doing something against the cheat situation.
> > >
> > > Anything that can detect cheats, and even if it doesn't work 100%, is
a
> > > welcome means of prevention against cheats. Cheaters must be left in
> > > uncertainty as to whether they can be detected, so as to at least
> perhaps
> > > prevent the more consciencious or timid ones from trying it.
> > >
> > > Negative side effects are annoying, but these are not the fault of
those
> > who
> > > try to write cheat detection programs, they're the fault of those who
> > write
> > > and use cheats.
> > >
> > > Achim
> > >
> > >
> > > "Tim" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
> > > news:6%539.45442$[email hidden]...
> > > > Thats interesting...
> > > >
> > > > Jeff's uses a lightpen & pad for artwork that uses those keys F11,
and
> > or
> > > > F12.
> > > > You'd think if someone was going to write a hack to detect if
certain
> > keys
> > > > are enabled they would bother to look into if any other software was
> > using
> > > > them, and what software that was.
> > > >
> > > > Man, if their only way of detecting a cheat is to see what keys are
> > avail,
> > > > man thats lame. Hell I could do that LOL
> > > >
> > > > --
> > > > Tim White
> > > > www.intracmotorsports.com
> > >
> > >
> >
> >
>
>
>"Joachim Trensz" <[email hidden]> wrote
> Considering the nature of this cheat, and considering all the implications
> connected to this form of cheating, I'd think its tremendously difficultto
> prevent that sort of cheat. I don't know any game or sim that successfully
> does so.
You could just block any TSR from running the ports while NR2002 is running,
no?
Yeah, I can see now the difficulties.
--
-- Fran�ois M�nard <ymenard>
-- http://www.ymenard.8m.com/
-- This announcement is brought to you by the Shimago-Dominguez
Corporation - helping America into the New World...
Joachim Trensz wrote:
In that case I'd like to race you at WG, I'll lap you within 10 laps :-)
Beers and cheers
(uncle) Goy
http://www.theuspits.com
"A man is only as old as the woman he feels........"
--Groucho Marx--
Quoted text (14 lines)
> > Considering the nature of this cheat, and considering all the implications > connected to this form of cheating, I'd think its tremendously difficult to > prevent that sort of cheat. I don't know any game or sim that successfully > does so. > > Let's not chop the wrong heads - it's the cheaters that do this to us, > nobody else. > > On a side note, I'm not sure this is really a big issue. I've been racing on > WON the last couple of days and to me, everything looked normal. Although > someone showed me a replay of a car getting its crumpled hood repaired at > 180mph exiting from T2 of an oval in the middle of the track - but that is > certainly not a very intelligent cheat, if it was a cheat at all <g>Quoted text (13 lines)
> Considering the nature of this cheat, and considering all the implications > connected to this form of cheating, I'd think its tremendously difficult to > prevent that sort of cheat. I don't know any game or sim that successfully > does so. > Let's not chop the wrong heads - it's the cheaters that do this to us, > nobody else. > On a side note, I'm not sure this is really a big issue. I've been racing on > WON the last couple of days and to me, everything looked normal. Although > someone showed me a replay of a car getting its crumpled hood repaired at > 180mph exiting from T2 of an oval in the middle of the track - but that is > certainly not a very intelligent cheat, if it was a cheat at all <g>>"Joachim Trensz" <[email hidden]> wrote
> What you mean by 'running the ports', and how would it prevent RAMsniffers
> or little programs from modifying RAM locations?
Point taken.
--
-- Fran�ois M�nard <ymenard>
-- http://www.ymenard.8m.com/
-- This announcement is brought to you by the Shimago-Dominguez
Corporation - helping America into the New World...
Considering the nature of this cheat, and considering all the implications
connected to this form of cheating, I'd think its tremendously difficult to
prevent that sort of cheat. I don't know any game or sim that successfully
does so.
Let's not chop the wrong heads - it's the cheaters that do this to us,
nobody else.
On a side note, I'm not sure this is really a big issue. I've been racing on
WON the last couple of days and to me, everything looked normal. Although
someone showed me a replay of a car getting its crumpled hood repaired at
180mph exiting from T2 of an oval in the middle of the track - but that is
certainly not a very intelligent cheat, if it was a cheat at all <g>
Achim
"ymenard" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:qBe39.167$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (22 lines)
> >"Joachim Trensz" <[email hidden]> wrote > > Negative side effects are annoying, but these are not the fault of those > who > > try to write cheat detection programs, they're the fault of those who > write > > and use cheats. > > > The fault is to Papyrus, for not fixing the holes they left open for > cheaters. > > > > > -- > -- Fran�ois M�nard <ymenard> > -- http://www.ymenard.8m.com/ > -- This announcement is brought to you by the Shimago-Dominguez > Corporation - helping America into the New World... > > >Rather than using "set" areas of memory each time the program (N2002) is
run, it should use random areas. That wouldn't entirely prevent the current
cheat, but make it much more difficult. Of course that would require
someone to WORK on the program. Considering what kind of BS I have seen,
this lack of cheat detection doesn't surprise me at all. Heck, they
couldn't/can't even fix the darn wall bugs, improper drafting and the arcade
physics. This is all about what SELLS, not what is GOOD.
Bill / Amish on Team Brickyard
www.iracingfx.com
"Joachim Trensz" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:aik7qq$14i1am$[email hidden]...
> What you mean by 'running the ports', and how would it prevent RAMsniffers
> or little programs from modifying RAM locations? Do you see a differencein
difficult
Quoted text (12 lines)
> how to prevent this form of cheats under Win9x and W2k/XP? > > Achim > > > > "ymenard" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:6vg39.207$[email hidden]... > > >"Joachim Trensz" <[email hidden]> wrote > > > Considering the nature of this cheat, and considering all the > implications > > > connected to this form of cheating, I'd think its tremendouslyQuoted text (12 lines)
> > to > > > prevent that sort of cheat. I don't know any game or sim that > successfully > > > does so. > > > > You could just block any TSR from running the ports while NR2002 is > running, > > no? > > > > Yeah, I can see now the difficulties. > >:-)
Achim
"Goy Larsen" <"adsales"@get topica.com> wrote in message
news:I8h39.1523$[email hidden]...
...
> In that case I'd like to race you at WG, I'll lap you within 10 laps :-)...
What you mean by 'running the ports', and how would it prevent RAM sniffers
or little programs from modifying RAM locations? Do you see a difference in
how to prevent this form of cheats under Win9x and W2k/XP?
Achim
"ymenard" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:6vg39.207$[email hidden]...
> >"Joachim Trensz" <[email hidden]> wrote
> > Considering the nature of this cheat, and considering all theimplications
> > connected to this form of cheating, I'd think its tremendously difficult
> to
> > prevent that sort of cheat. I don't know any game or sim thatsuccessfully
> > does so.
>
> You could just block any TSR from running the ports while NR2002 isrunning,
> no?
>
> Yeah, I can see now the difficulties.
I can't remember if it was N1 or N2, but when you started the Papy game on
your pc (It may have been the TEN front end), rather then trying to figure
out what TSR's were used, it just checked for anything running that wasn't
default like systray and explorer when you loaded the game. You got a
message telling you to disable them and restart the game.
What concerns me about someone other than Papy creating any cheat detection
code is if they are hacking the N4 server.exe to read a client pc. Once
they do that and you join their servers, it becomes a hack to your system,
like any other trojan.
No matter how you look at it, you might as well be downloading a virus.
The point here is that it is one thing to try catch a cheat, and another to
automatically assume you may be cheating and calling it reason to invade
your computer. Papy, however people see it, chose the high road and just
gave you the benefit of the doubt.
I know that doesn't deter the determined hacker but it was more an issue of
privacy if nothing else. :)
--
Tim White
www.intracmotorsports.com
"ymenard" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:6vg39.207$[email hidden]...
> You could just block any TSR from running the ports while NR2002 is
running,
> no?
>
The "Ram Cheat" in its present form will not work with XP because of the
way its protects the files from being written to. There are ways around it
but
the cheat is only effect on 98 based systems.
For the uninitiated this cheat dates back to the original Nascar in fact
the
original one was capable of keeping your gas at 1 gallon for the whole race,
repair damage on the fly, allow gear ratios beyond the normal range,
spoilers
beyond the normal range plus the tires. You were also able to do setups in
Indy Car One (as the code was still in Nascar) and use harder or softer
compound tires etc and then copy them over to Nascar and get the benefits.
I will also tell you there are far more sophisticated cheats available
but
no need to go there.
Pete
"Joachim Trensz" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:aik7qq$14i1am$[email hidden]...
> What you mean by 'running the ports', and how would it prevent RAMsniffers
> or little programs from modifying RAM locations? Do you see a differencein
> how to prevent this form of cheats under Win9x and W2k/XP?
>
> Achim
Pete... Windows 98 and dont forget 95 and ME... Probably work with
Windows 3.0 and 3.11...... Oh yes and the DOS stuff before.. DW
--
Donald Wilshe
888 588-9207
Martel Brothers Performance, Worlds Largest On-Line Auto Parts Mfg Catalog
Library
www.martelbros.com
Other Interest:
www.ivga.com
www.games-advertising.com
www.whra.com
"Pete" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:pan39.1514$[email hidden]...
> The "Ram Cheat" in its present form will not work with XP because of
the
> way its protects the files from being written to. There are ways around it
> but
> the cheat is only effect on 98 based systems.
> For the uninitiated this cheat dates back to the original Nascar in
fact
> the
> original one was capable of keeping your gas at 1 gallon for the whole
race,
> repair damage on the fly, allow gear ratios beyond the normal range,
> spoilers
> beyond the normal range plus the tires. You were also able to do setups in
> Indy Car One (as the code was still in Nascar) and use harder or softer
> compound tires etc and then copy them over to Nascar and get the benefits.
> I will also tell you there are far more sophisticated cheats available
> but
> no need to go there.
>
> Pete
>
> "Joachim Trensz" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
> news:aik7qq$14i1am$[email hidden]...
> > What you mean by 'running the ports', and how would it prevent RAM
> sniffers
> > or little programs from modifying RAM locations? Do you see a difference
> in
> > how to prevent this form of cheats under Win9x and W2k/XP?
> >
> > Achim
>
>
>
>
Good idea about the random RAM areas. You'd also have to change the layout
of that RAM area else the pattern is too easily recognisable and the offsets
could be used into that area.
Do you know a game that uses such a cheat protection scheme?
Achim
"Bill Bollinger" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
> Rather than using "set" areas of memory each time the program (N2002) is
> run, it should use random areas. That wouldn't entirely prevent thecurrent
> cheat, but make it much more difficult. Of course that would require
> someone to WORK on the program. Considering what kind of BS I have seen,
> this lack of cheat detection doesn't surprise me at all. Heck, they
> couldn't/can't even fix the darn wall bugs, improper drafting and thearcade
Quoted text (14 lines)
> physics. This is all about what SELLS, not what is GOOD. > > > Bill / Amish on Team Brickyard > www.iracingfx.com > > > "Joachim Trensz" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:aik7qq$14i1am$[email hidden]... > > What you mean by 'running the ports', and how would it prevent RAM > sniffers > > or little programs from modifying RAM locations? Do you see a difference > in > > how to prevent this form of cheats under Win9x and W2k/XP?In article <Jlj39.46037$[email hidden]>, jwhite15
@carolina.rr.com says...
> What concerns me about someone other than Papy creating any cheat detection
> code is if they are hacking the N4 server.exe to read a client pc. Once
> they do that and you join their servers, it becomes a hack to your system,
> like any other trojan.
I don't agree. If I knew the person, or knew of his/her work as far as
programming was concerned, I would probably trust the code they wrote.
> The point here is that it is one thing to try catch a cheat, and another to
> automatically assume you may be cheating and calling it reason to invade
> your computer.
I don't understand what you mean.
> Papy, however people see it, chose the high road and just
> gave you the benefit of the doubt.
I doubt that. I suspect it was more a case of nobody thought it would
be an issue.
> I know that doesn't deter the determined hacker but it was more an issue of
> privacy if nothing else. :)
I don't see any privacy issues. If the game detects a cheat program it
simply shuts down. No communications with Sierra, or anything like
that. Where is the privacy iviolation?
--
=========================================================
Redneck Techno-Biker & "programming deity"
http://www.paddedwall.org/john
DeMONS/1 for Nascar Racing 3 & Nascar Legends
http://www.paddedwall.org/demons
DeMONS/2 for Nascar Racing 4 and 2002 Season (in development)
http://www.paddedwall.org/demons2
RASCAR Roster
http://www.paddedwall.org/rascar
Barbarian Diecast Collector (490+ cars and counting)
http://www.paddedwall.org/diecast
If you want to send me email, go to the first URL shown
above & click "Send Me Mail" in the contents frame.
=========================================================
Well, they can't really use random areas of memory because you can't
specify where in memory (a "base" address) to start an allocation. You
can however, create randomly sized arrays both before AND after
allocating the real arrays, objects, or structures. I have tested this
and it seems to work fine. The real data's offset from the process's
base address in memory changes each time the program is run.
The beauty of it is that it only has to change by a few bytes each time.
That's all it takes to keep a ram cheat program from working.
In article <[email hidden]>,
[email hidden] says...
--
=========================================================
Redneck Techno-Biker & "programming deity"
http://www.paddedwall.org/john
DeMONS/1 for Nascar Racing 3 & Nascar Legends
http://www.paddedwall.org/demons
DeMONS/2 for Nascar Racing 4 and 2002 Season (in development)
http://www.paddedwall.org/demons2
RASCAR Roster
http://www.paddedwall.org/rascar
Barbarian Diecast Collector (490+ cars and counting)
http://www.paddedwall.org/diecast
If you want to send me email, go to the first URL shown
above & click "Send Me Mail" in the contents frame.
=========================================================
Quoted text (9 lines)
> Rather than using "set" areas of memory each time the program (N2002) is > run, it should use random areas. That wouldn't entirely prevent the current > cheat, but make it much more difficult. Of course that would require > someone to WORK on the program. Considering what kind of BS I have seen, > this lack of cheat detection doesn't surprise me at all. Heck, they > couldn't/can't even fix the darn wall bugs, improper drafting and the arcade > physics. This is all about what SELLS, not what is GOOD. > >This is absolutely the same kind of bullshit that ruined Counterstrike. I
don't know what is worse, cheating or being a whining sore loser that calls
everyone who does better than you a cheater.
Hatin' it,
Gerald.
"Tim" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:Sp139.44965$[email hidden]...
> Guys,
>
> My brother has been accused of using this 'cheat' in some guys' fixedsetup
> league. They claim to have some patch that detects that cheat and others
> that the papy server.exe cannot catch.
>
> Anyone who knows Jeff (who is pretty average at racing online) would laugh
> at the idea that Jeff's lap times in fixed setup racing are faster thansome
Quoted text (12 lines)
> 'very experienced open setup leagues'. > > Of course, this league he is in won't mention just who those leagues might > be but I was wondering if anyone else has heard about a patch that is > catching cheats Papy cannot? > > Tim White > www.birds-i-view.com/intrac > > > >On Sun, 4 Aug 2002 00:52:55 -0400, "ymenard"
<[email hidden]> wrote:
We've been contacted by a few guys about including a checker for this
cheat in the Replay Analyser program. But no-one seems to know how to
cheat, just that it is possible somehow.
This makes it a bit hard to include a check for it as we don't even
know what to start looking for. Does this cheat fix damage/tires etc?
If so, there is a chance that we can include a check for it. No
promises though! And we will probably not include a check unless it is
a reliable one.
Could someone who knows how to activate this cheat please send a mail
about how to do it to: [email hidden]
Cheers,
/Martin
Quoted text (10 lines)
>>"Tim" <[email hidden]> wrote >> Of course, this league he is in won't mention just who those leagues might >> be but I was wondering if anyone else has heard about a patch that is >> catching cheats Papy cannot? > > >It's I hope common knowledge that there is a (true) cheat for NR2002 that >permits tyre wear and other stuff to be restarted to zero, therefore giving >them an obvious advantage. It's a reason why many people have stopped >racing online. I doubt there is a software that can catch cheaters.Bill,
You seem so..... bitter. <VBG> ;)
--
Scott B. Husted
PA-Scott
ICQ# 4395450
http://www.Husted.cc
"Bill Bollinger" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
> Rather than using "set" areas of memory each time the program (N2002) is
> run, it should use random areas. That wouldn't entirely prevent the
current
> cheat, but make it much more difficult. Of course that would require
> someone to WORK on the program. Considering what kind of BS I have seen,
> this lack of cheat detection doesn't surprise me at all. Heck, they
> couldn't/can't even fix the darn wall bugs, improper drafting and the
arcade
> physics. This is all about what SELLS, not what is GOOD.
>
>
> Bill / Amish on Team Brickyard
> www.iracingfx.com
>
>
> "Joachim Trensz" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
> news:aik7qq$14i1am$[email hidden]...
> > What you mean by 'running the ports', and how would it prevent RAM
> sniffers
> > or little programs from modifying RAM locations? Do you see a difference
> in
> > how to prevent this form of cheats under Win9x and W2k/XP?
> >
> > Achim
> >
> >
> >
> > "ymenard" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
> > news:6vg39.207$[email hidden]...
> > > >"Joachim Trensz" <[email hidden]> wrote
> > > > Considering the nature of this cheat, and considering all the
> > implications
> > > > connected to this form of cheating, I'd think its tremendously
> difficult
> > > to
> > > > prevent that sort of cheat. I don't know any game or sim that
> > successfully
> > > > does so.
> > >
> > > You could just block any TSR from running the ports while NR2002 is
> > running,
> > > no?
> > >
> > > Yeah, I can see now the difficulties.
> >
> >
>
>
Hi John,
I am saying this with all due modesty as I am not a professional programmer
and haven't touched a programming language in more than 15 years, and please
nobody mistake this for attempted wisecracking, but AFAI remember when I was
still playing around with programming languages (and that's all I ever did)
you could specify _relative_ addresses (offsets) which the linker would
either resolve at linking time or at program loading time.
Therefor, I had thought Bill was referring to using such within limits
varying random offsets for the respective data / objects / arrays /
structures which the linker would resolve to different actual offsets from
the respective start address of the program or data area.
I don't remember though and therefor have to ask - is it possible to keep
the code and data areas separate, and to give the data area a different
internal layout at each program start in terms of switching the data /
objects / arrays / structures to different positions based on perhaps a
random keycode generated at startup time?
I also wondered whether, if that is possible but the internal structure of
an array is known, a RAM sniffer couldn't re-detect the data pattern no
matter where it is in RAM? If that's the case, the above relative offsets
wouldn't suffice and one would have to actually change the internal
structures of the data objects / structures / arrays to prevent a RAM
sniffer from redetecting the pattern - one would have to morph the data
containers themselves into different shapes to prevent such sniffers from
redetecting the patterns?
Sorry if I'm talking nonsense, the topic is interesting and I'd really like
to know, so despite being a non-expert, I'm bringing the question up...
Achim
"John Simmons" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
current
> > cheat, but make it much more difficult. Of course that would require
> > someone to WORK on the program. Considering what kind of BS I haveseen,
> > this lack of cheat detection doesn't surprise me at all. Heck, they
> > couldn't/can't even fix the darn wall bugs, improper drafting and thearcade
Quoted text (14 lines)
> Well, they can't really use random areas of memory because you can't > specify where in memory (a "base" address) to start an allocation. You > can however, create randomly sized arrays both before AND after > allocating the real arrays, objects, or structures. I have tested this > and it seems to work fine. The real data's offset from the process's > base address in memory changes each time the program is run. > > The beauty of it is that it only has to change by a few bytes each time. > That's all it takes to keep a ram cheat program from working. > > In article <[email hidden]>, > [email hidden] says... > > Rather than using "set" areas of memory each time the program (N2002) is > > run, it should use random areas. That wouldn't entirely prevent theQuoted text (21 lines)
> > physics. This is all about what SELLS, not what is GOOD. > > > > > > > -- > ========================================================= > Redneck Techno-Biker & "programming deity" > http://www.paddedwall.org/john > DeMONS/1 for Nascar Racing 3 & Nascar Legends > http://www.paddedwall.org/demons > DeMONS/2 for Nascar Racing 4 and 2002 Season (in development) > http://www.paddedwall.org/demons2 > RASCAR Roster > http://www.paddedwall.org/rascar > Barbarian Diecast Collector (490+ cars and counting) > http://www.paddedwall.org/diecast > > If you want to send me email, go to the first URL shown > above & click "Send Me Mail" in the contents frame. > =========================================================Done
Achim
"Martin Granberg" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
...
> Could someone who knows how to activate this cheat please send a mail
> about how to do it to: [email hidden]
Done
Achim
...
> Could someone who knows how to activate this cheat please send a mail
John,
My point, however misguided lol, was IF they are hacking the server.exe to
check for cheaters, and I don't know if thats how they do it, then what is
to stop them from adding anything else to the server.exe that they choose?
I don't know who is wrting the cheat protection programs. And I wouldn't
knowingly race on any server that used it if someone from Sierra or Papyrus
hadn't said something positive about it. If I have access to a cheat
protection program that somehow requires users to keep software that didn't
come with the install I would anoumce that you were using it to race on my
server and send the code to Papy asking for an opinion.
However, if all it is is a replay analyzier then my brother got railroaded
because of a false sense of security created by the guy who wrote the cheat
detection program. It does not matter how nice a guy he is. League admins
will use it wrong, or to just plain kick someone out they don't like. Either
way, programming that starts with good intentions must carry that
responsibility, otherwise it ultimately does as much harm as good.
I know, I'm making some leaps here but coming from a programming background
I take the responsibility of users depending on the accuracy and intent of
my software very serious. I'm not trying to stop people from helping but
IMHO I don't think a program that arbitraily looks for hot keys only and
assumes, or lets the admins assume you are cheating, is responsible coding.
While I agree that it may be okay for you or me if you trust the guy and you
are pretty sure he/they would never invade your pc for any other reason
(such as modifying the server.exe on YOUR pc so that his/their cheat
protection gets passed along to every other server.exe) I still think a
company, like Papyrus, holds the responsibility to maintain integrity versus
giving it to users.
Papyrus always knew about the cheats. They chose not to deal with many of
them for a variety of reasons. But your asking every single online player
to trust the same people you or I trust, thats all I was saying.
--
Tim White
www.intracmotorsports.com
"John Simmons" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
> In article <Jlj39.46037$[email hidden]>, jwhite15
> @carolina.rr.com says...
> > What concerns me about someone other than Papy creating any cheat
detection
> > code is if they are hacking the N4 server.exe to read a client pc. Once
> > they do that and you join their servers, it becomes a hack to your
system,
> > like any other trojan.
>
> I don't agree. If I knew the person, or knew of his/her work as far as
> programming was concerned, I would probably trust the code they wrote.
>
> > The point here is that it is one thing to try catch a cheat, and another
to
> > automatically assume you may be cheating and calling it reason to invade
> > your computer.
>
> I don't understand what you mean.
>
> > Papy, however people see it, chose the high road and just
> > gave you the benefit of the doubt.
>
> I doubt that. I suspect it was more a case of nobody thought it would
> be an issue.
>
> > I know that doesn't deter the determined hacker but it was more an issue
of
> > privacy if nothing else. :)
>
> I don't see any privacy issues. If the game detects a cheat program it
> simply shuts down. No communications with Sierra, or anything like
> that. Where is the privacy iviolation?
>
>"Pete" <[email hidden]> wrote
>You were also able to do setups in
> Indy Car One (as the code was still in Nascar) and use harder or softer
> compound tires etc and then copy them over to Nascar and get the benefits.
Doesn't everybody know about this? No really, I remember back on the NROS
it was discussed in private. It's not fixed yet? I thought it was all
forgotten after N3.
In article <ailo6f$14veap$[email hidden]>, [email hidden]
says...
That was back in the DOS days (and 16-bit programming).
Code and data are already separate. The only way you can realistically
change the "layout" of data allocations is to make random-sized
allocations of basically garbage objects (structures), before and during
allocation of "real" data. You can't really start moving big chunks of
memory around because a) it would eat up a LOT of time, b) it would not
change the offsets to the data segment (or the data within the segment),
and c) would be highly unreliable.
The way the ram cheat programs work is by the cheater specifying a
memory offset to change (and sometimes to keep changing on a specified
timie interval). If the offset isn't the same from one execution of the
program to the next, they can't use that particular approach. The key
is to not only change the first offset, but to allocate random-sized
objects BETWEEN all of the real data as well. This might introduce a
speed penalty while the program starts up, but once allocated, the
program would act as it normally does.
> Sorry if I'm talking nonsense, the topic is interesting and I'd really like
> to know, so despite being a non-expert, I'm bringing the question up...
The whole objecvt is not to make cheating impossible (because that task,
in and of itself is impossible), but to make it so annoying and
convoluted to do, that by the time the cheater finally (if ever) gets
around to figuring it out, his parents have hung a new shiney thing over
his crib, and his attention drifts away to the new shiney object.
--
=========================================================
Redneck Techno-Biker & "programming deity"
http://www.paddedwall.org/john
DeMONS/1 for Nascar Racing 3 & Nascar Legends
http://www.paddedwall.org/demons
DeMONS/2 for Nascar Racing 4 and 2002 Season (in development)
http://www.paddedwall.org/demons2
RASCAR Roster
http://www.paddedwall.org/rascar
Barbarian Diecast Collector (490+ cars and counting)
http://www.paddedwall.org/diecast
If you want to send me email, go to the first URL shown
above & click "Send Me Mail" in the contents frame.
=========================================================
Quoted text (8 lines)
> Hi John, > > I am saying this with all due modesty as I am not a professional programmer > and haven't touched a programming language in more than 15 years, and please > nobody mistake this for attempted wisecracking, but AFAI remember when I was > still playing around with programming languages (and that's all I ever did) > you could specify _relative_ addresses (offsets) which the linker would > either resolve at linking time or at program loading time.Quoted text (10 lines)
> Therefor, I had thought Bill was referring to using such within limits > varying random offsets for the respective data / objects / arrays / > structures which the linker would resolve to different actual offsets from > the respective start address of the program or data area. > > I don't remember though and therefor have to ask - is it possible to keep > the code and data areas separate, and to give the data area a different > internal layout at each program start in terms of switching the data / > objects / arrays / structures to different positions based on perhaps a > random keycode generated at startup time?Quoted text (8 lines)
> I also wondered whether, if that is possible but the internal structure of > an array is known, a RAM sniffer couldn't re-detect the data pattern no > matter where it is in RAM? If that's the case, the above relative offsets > wouldn't suffice and one would have to actually change the internal > structures of the data objects / structures / arrays to prevent a RAM > sniffer from redetecting the pattern - one would have to morph the data > containers themselves into different shapes to prevent such sniffers from > redetecting the patterns?In article <Gey39.39552$[email hidden]>, jwhite15
@carolina.rr.com says...
> John,
>
> My point, however misguided lol, was IF they are hacking the server.exe to
> check for cheaters, and I don't know if thats how they do it, then what is
> to stop them from adding anything else to the server.exe that they choose?
I think you're misunderstanding how raceservers implements the cheat
detection code. He doesn't hack any of the NR2K2 files. His servers
requires the use of a client program in order to race (just like OLR has
it's own client software). The client program simply enumerates the
list of running processes and if it finds a cheat program, it either
tells the user he can't play until he turns the cheat program off, or it
communicates to raceservers that the player was attempting to cheat (I
don't know which it does because I don't race on raceservers).
Either way, there is *no* violation of privacy. If you're running the
cheat program when you start the rsclient app, you won't be able to
race.
> I don't know who is wrting the cheat protection programs. And I wouldn't
> knowingly race on any server that used it if someone from Sierra or Papyrus
> hadn't said something positive about it. If I have access to a cheat
> protection program that somehow requires users to keep software that didn't
> come with the install I would anoumce that you were using it to race on my
> server and send the code to Papy asking for an opinion.
At this time (and I don't see how this statement could possibly change),
the rsclient software will ONLY work if you try to connect to the
raceservers server, and will not affect your ability to connect directly
to Sierra (or any other server or matching service, like OLR).
> However, if all it is is a replay analyzier then my brother got railroaded
> because of a false sense of security created by the guy who wrote the cheat
> detection program. It does not matter how nice a guy he is. League admins
> will use it wrong, or to just plain kick someone out they don't like. Either
> way, programming that starts with good intentions must carry that
> responsibility, otherwise it ultimately does as much harm as good.
Well, you have to evaluate Mike Baker's intentions yourself. As someone
who has dealt with Mike in the past (albeit on a somewhat limited
basis), I have absolutely no reason to believe that he has some
nefarious plan up his sleeve. We don't see eye-to-eye on alot of stuff,
but that doesn't mean he's out to steal your porn site passwords. :)
> I know, I'm making some leaps here but coming from a programming background
> I take the responsibility of users depending on the accuracy and intent of
> my software very serious. I'm not trying to stop people from helping but
> IMHO I don't think a program that arbitraily looks for hot keys only and
> assumes, or lets the admins assume you are cheating, is responsible coding.
I don't think his program looks for hotkeys.
> While I agree that it may be okay for you or me if you trust the guy and you
> are pretty sure he/they would never invade your pc for any other reason
> (such as modifying the server.exe on YOUR pc so that his/their cheat
> protection gets passed along to every other server.exe) I still think a
> company, like Papyrus, holds the responsibility to maintain integrity versus
> giving it to users.
Well, I don't think Papy gives a rat's ass about what we want/feel/need
as far as multiplayer goes.
> Papyrus always knew about the cheats. They chose not to deal with many of
> them for a variety of reasons. But your asking every single online player
> to trust the same people you or I trust, thats all I was saying.
I wasn't asking anyone to trust anyone, I was just pointing out that a)
the guy's giving it a shot, and b) it's only for his servers. If you
don't race on raceservers, you have nothing to be concerned about.
--
=========================================================
Redneck Techno-Biker & "programming deity"
http://www.paddedwall.org/john
DeMONS/1 for Nascar Racing 3 & Nascar Legends
http://www.paddedwall.org/demons
DeMONS/2 for Nascar Racing 4 and 2002 Season (in development)
http://www.paddedwall.org/demons2
RASCAR Roster
http://www.paddedwall.org/rascar
Barbarian Diecast Collector (490+ cars and counting)
http://www.paddedwall.org/diecast
If you want to send me email, go to the first URL shown
above & click "Send Me Mail" in the contents frame.
=========================================================
"John Simmons" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
I'm not an experienced programmer, but what is stopping the hackers from
doing the same thing to the cheat detection programs? You have to remember
that the reason cheating is possible is because all of the game's processing
is done on the client. Well, the same goes for any cheat detection program
that resides on the client.
Like you said, you can only make it inconvenient to cheat, you can never
make it impossible. But based on my limited gaming experience, it seems the
desire and creativity of the cheating community will *always* overcome even
the most elaborate cheat prevention schemes. Exact same situation as the
piracy issue IMO.
The bigger a Game's community is, the more likely it will include someone
who has the desire and ability to cheat. Once a reliable cheat is made, all
that is needed is for it to be distributed across the Net and then every
Tom, Dick and Harry can use it. So I guess the thing to do is to find a game
that sucks so bad that nobody plays it. ;-).
Dave Boyle
Quoted text (9 lines)
> I think you're misunderstanding how raceservers implements the cheat > detection code. He doesn't hack any of the NR2K2 files. His servers > requires the use of a client program in order to race (just like OLR has > it's own client software). The client program simply enumerates the > list of running processes and if it finds a cheat program, it either > tells the user he can't play until he turns the cheat program off, or it > communicates to raceservers that the player was attempting to cheat (I > don't know which it does because I don't race on raceservers). >John,
I should point out the experience with my brother had nothing to do with
raceservers, olr, etc. and did not require any downloads. Simply, these
guys said they got their cheat detection abilities from someone in the
Sierra boards. I never said or meant to imply it was Mike.
Most likely it has to do with the replay analyzer but who knows. Since they
didn't kick me out and Jeff never raced the way they implied it was
basically bogus on their part.
In any case I agree with you that if I as a user must dl something in order
to race somewhere, only I am responsibile for that choice.
--
Tim White
www.intracmotorsports.com
"John Simmons" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
> In article <Gey39.39552$[email hidden]>, jwhite15
> @carolina.rr.com says...
> > John,
> >
> > My point, however misguided lol, was IF they are hacking the server.exe
to
> > check for cheaters, and I don't know if thats how they do it, then what
is
> > to stop them from adding anything else to the server.exe that they
choose?
>
> I think you're misunderstanding how raceservers implements the cheat
> detection code. He doesn't hack any of the NR2K2 files. His servers
> requires the use of a client program in order to race (just like OLR has
> it's own client software). The client program simply enumerates the
> list of running processes and if it finds a cheat program, it either
> tells the user he can't play until he turns the cheat program off, or it
> communicates to raceservers that the player was attempting to cheat (I
> don't know which it does because I don't race on raceservers).
>
> Either way, there is *no* violation of privacy. If you're running the
> cheat program when you start the rsclient app, you won't be able to
> race.
>
> > I don't know who is wrting the cheat protection programs. And I
wouldn't
> > knowingly race on any server that used it if someone from Sierra or
Papyrus
> > hadn't said something positive about it. If I have access to a cheat
> > protection program that somehow requires users to keep software that
didn't
> > come with the install I would anoumce that you were using it to race on
my
> > server and send the code to Papy asking for an opinion.
>
> At this time (and I don't see how this statement could possibly change),
> the rsclient software will ONLY work if you try to connect to the
> raceservers server, and will not affect your ability to connect directly
> to Sierra (or any other server or matching service, like OLR).
>
> > However, if all it is is a replay analyzier then my brother got
railroaded
> > because of a false sense of security created by the guy who wrote the
cheat
> > detection program. It does not matter how nice a guy he is. League
admins
> > will use it wrong, or to just plain kick someone out they don't like.
Either
> > way, programming that starts with good intentions must carry that
> > responsibility, otherwise it ultimately does as much harm as good.
>
> Well, you have to evaluate Mike Baker's intentions yourself. As someone
> who has dealt with Mike in the past (albeit on a somewhat limited
> basis), I have absolutely no reason to believe that he has some
> nefarious plan up his sleeve. We don't see eye-to-eye on alot of stuff,
> but that doesn't mean he's out to steal your porn site passwords. :)
>
>
> > I know, I'm making some leaps here but coming from a programming
background
> > I take the responsibility of users depending on the accuracy and intent
of
> > my software very serious. I'm not trying to stop people from helping
but
> > IMHO I don't think a program that arbitraily looks for hot keys only and
> > assumes, or lets the admins assume you are cheating, is responsible
coding.
>
> I don't think his program looks for hotkeys.
>
> > While I agree that it may be okay for you or me if you trust the guy and
you
> > are pretty sure he/they would never invade your pc for any other reason
> > (such as modifying the server.exe on YOUR pc so that his/their cheat
> > protection gets passed along to every other server.exe) I still think a
> > company, like Papyrus, holds the responsibility to maintain integrity
versus
> > giving it to users.
>
> Well, I don't think Papy gives a rat's ass about what we want/feel/need
> as far as multiplayer goes.
>
> > Papyrus always knew about the cheats. They chose not to deal with many
of
> > them for a variety of reasons. But your asking every single online
player
> > to trust the same people you or I trust, thats all I was saying.
>
> I wasn't asking anyone to trust anyone, I was just pointing out that a)
> the guy's giving it a shot, and b) it's only for his servers. If you
> don't race on raceservers, you have nothing to be concerned about.
>
>
> --
> =========================================================
> Redneck Techno-Biker & "programming deity"
> http://www.paddedwall.org/john
> DeMONS/1 for Nascar Racing 3 & Nascar Legends
> http://www.paddedwall.org/demons
> DeMONS/2 for Nascar Racing 4 and 2002 Season (in development)
> http://www.paddedwall.org/demons2
> RASCAR Roster
> http://www.paddedwall.org/rascar
> Barbarian Diecast Collector (490+ cars and counting)
> http://www.paddedwall.org/diecast
>
> If you want to send me email, go to the first URL shown
> above & click "Send Me Mail" in the contents frame.
> =========================================================
Just curious, but don't you think that there all ready are random
arrays of objects/structures in N2002?
Brian Oster
On Mon, 05 Aug 2002 10:30:05 GMT, John Simmons <[email hidden]> wrote:
Quoted text (22 lines)
>Well, they can't really use random areas of memory because you can't >specify where in memory (a "base" address) to start an allocation. You >can however, create randomly sized arrays both before AND after >allocating the real arrays, objects, or structures. I have tested this >and it seems to work fine. The real data's offset from the process's >base address in memory changes each time the program is run. > >The beauty of it is that it only has to change by a few bytes each time. >That's all it takes to keep a ram cheat program from working. > >In article <[email hidden]>, >[email hidden] says... >> Rather than using "set" areas of memory each time the program (N2002) is >> run, it should use random areas. That wouldn't entirely prevent the current >> cheat, but make it much more difficult. Of course that would require >> someone to WORK on the program. Considering what kind of BS I have seen, >> this lack of cheat detection doesn't surprise me at all. Heck, they >> couldn't/can't even fix the darn wall bugs, improper drafting and the arcade >> physics. This is all about what SELLS, not what is GOOD. >> >> >ok if there is a 2002 cheat what is it?
"ymenard" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:hAY49.4430$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (25 lines)
> >"Mitch_A" <[email hidden]> wrote... > > The bopsy twins have spoken. Any ego left for anyone else? Self > > appointments are meaningless right Pres? God please bring back MHO.. > > > > Mitch ----> shakes head > > > If you want to bash on me, do it in another thread. I'll be happy to show > you what you are made of. > > "It's hard to be humble, when you're as great as I am." > > > > > -- > -- Fran�ois M�nard <ymenard> > -- http://www.ymenard.8m.com/ > -- This announcement is brought to you by the Shimago-Dominguez > Corporation - helping America into the New World... > > > > >>"lemans" <[email hidden]> wrote
> ok if there is a 2002 cheat what is it?
:-|
--
-- Fran�ois M�nard <ymenard>
-- http://www.ymenard.8m.com/
-- This announcement is brought to you by the Shimago-Dominguez
Corporation - helping America into the New World...
Goy Larsen <"adsales"@get topica.com> wrote in message news:<7Iz49.3371$[email hidden]>...
I see your point.
> I'm not going to post which files I *know* isn't checked properly as
> that would only give people ideas,
I was mainly a rhetorical question, but, that sort of information
really needs to be made publicly available if we really wan't anything
to get done about the problem. That's a whole other side debate...
> I haven't got a clue if it's possible to burn these files to a CD and
> connect to to Sierra with them
Ughh...
Well, personally, I am spending a lot of time building my home
theater/game room and comparitively little time racing. By the time I
get back on the track, it won't matter if my opponents are cheating or
not... <sigh>
Gerald
Quoted text (8 lines)
> Gerald Moore wrote: > > > > And these would be? I am wondering because it seems that as a League > > admin, one could do some simple PTP file sharing to verify that > > everyone's "important" files are legit. > > What would prevent someone from sharing a "dummy" directory with the > appropriate files and launch the game from another directory ?Gerald Moore wrote:
>
> I was mainly a rhetorical question, but, that sort of information
> really needs to be made publicly available if we really wan't anything
> to get done about the problem. That's a whole other side debate...
I agree, do you tell and open up a whole new area for cheating, or do
you keep quiet and hope that not too many others have found the same
hole as you have, people who don't mind using *any* advantage to win
> Well, personally, I am spending a lot of time building my home
> theater/game room and comparitively little time racing. By the time I
> get back on the track, it won't matter if my opponents are cheating or
> not... <sigh>
Personally I don't care about cheating much, I hate cheaters, but I
don't let it get to me, and since I usually only race with people I
respect and trust and whom I'd never even consider to be cheaters, then
it's of no importance to me personally, I'm just enjoying it for what it
is
Beers and cheers
(uncle) Goy
http://www.theuspits.com
"A man is only as old as the woman he feels........"
--Groucho Marx--
> I was mainly a rhetorical question, but, that sort of information
> really needs to be made publicly available if we really wan't anything
> to get done about the problem. That's a whole other side debate...
I agree, do you tell and open up a whole new area for cheating, or do
you keep quiet and hope that not too many others have found the same
hole as you have, people who don't mind using *any* advantage to win
Personally I don't care about cheating much, I hate cheaters, but I
don't let it get to me, and since I usually only race with people I
respect and trust and whom I'd never even consider to be cheaters, then
it's of no importance to me personally, I'm just enjoying it for what it
is
Beers and cheers
(uncle) Goy
http://www.theuspits.com
"A man is only as old as the woman he feels........"
--Groucho Marx--
"Scott B. Husted" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:udy49.5103$[email hidden]...
I'm sure this number is what they are tracking through Sierra's matching
service, what about all the IP-only league servers out there. We haven't
used the arena method to connect in any of the leagues I have run since N3.
Surely that would bump the number up some....probably to at least double.
The smart leagues KNOW that there will surely be a night or two when the
arena will have crashed or be otherwise unreachable. That and the flawed
online stats keeping they use is enough to drive the serious leagues OFF the
public arena and into private IP-only situations. I don't think they can
calculate the number of users online that don't go through the open arena
fiasco, double negative aside ;-)
Quoted text (14 lines)
> I doubt it would be worth the effort or cost, in business/finance terms, > considering the low % of sales that have resulted in online racing. (From > my understanding, less than roughly 6% of CD serial numbers sold are used > online). > > I wouldn't rule out an offline only title from them in the future though. > :-\ > > -- > Scott B. Husted > PA-Scott > ICQ# 4395450 > http://www.Husted.cc >In article <5iA59.4600$[email hidden]>, "SimRacer"
<[email hidden]> writes:
>That and the flawed
>online stats keeping they use is enough to drive the serious leagues OFF the
>public arena and into private IP-only situations.
Maybe, but the leagues are still passworded, right? What's the difference if
they run on Sierra.com? Non-members still can't ge in to muck things up...
Eldred
--
Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett
GPLRank:+8.09
N2002 Rank:+22.329
Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.
Even if you race IP, I'm sure a majority of those drivers have at least
created a login for Sierra.. thus they are included in the number of serial
numbers registered for WON.
Although I don't disagree with your reasoning of why you would race IP only.
=)
--
Scott B. Husted
PA-Scott
ICQ# 4395450
http://www.Husted.cc
"SimRacer" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:5iA59.4600$[email hidden]...
>
> I'm sure this number is what they are tracking through Sierra's matching
> service, what about all the IP-only league servers out there. We haven't
> used the arena method to connect in any of the leagues I have run since
N3.
> Surely that would bump the number up some....probably to at least double.
> The smart leagues KNOW that there will surely be a night or two when the
> arena will have crashed or be otherwise unreachable. That and the flawed
> online stats keeping they use is enough to drive the serious leagues OFF
the
> public arena and into private IP-only situations. I don't think they can
> calculate the number of users online that don't go through the open arena
> fiasco, double negative aside ;-)
>
>


































